The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
EP #416: Catch Them a Fish AND Teach Them to Fish — with Daniel Corliss
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week's episode is about the drive to change the way businesses acquire and access healthcare for their employees. Daniel Corliss talks about the difficulties associated with receiving medical care under an insurance policy and how DC Advisory is resolving these issues.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- 1:33 The difficulties in obtaining healthcare through insurance policies.
- 3:44 DC Advisory’s client acquisition methods.
- 8:07 Three ways they get compensated for their services.
- 11:17 Creating and modifying health-care plans to meet the needs of both employers and employees.
- 13:30 Starting the discussion with brokers and TPAs about self-funding.
- 16:30 Using data analytics to make informed long-term planning decisions.
- 18:36 Boosting health-care consumerism.
Quotes:
12:20 “There is no one size fits all in self-funding, at least I don’t think there is. I think everything should be built from soup to nuts and from scratch for each client.”
13:03 “We have great technology today that allows us to do things more streamlined and efficiently, but guys, we’ve got to get back to doing the work. That’s the only way that we’re going to change this industry, change how we access health care, and change the way that we’re building these health plans for our clients.”
We've all heard the old saying about catching somebody a fish versus teaching them a fish. But what happens to advisors when you can do both? We'll find out on this episode of Just Food. And that's kind of an interesting metaphor for what we're going to talk about today because there is an interesting argument that helps advisors by giving them both a fish and a fishing pulse. And that kind of motif was designed by our guest today, Daniel Corlett, who's the principal at DC Advisory. And he's going to tell us all about it. Hi, Daniel. Hey David, thanks for having me. It's my pleasure. So let's start with a level set. From your vantage point, what's the problem that needs to be solved?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so great analogy on the fish in the fishing pole. I think the problem is that we're still living in a very status quo world when it comes to how we're purchasing healthcare services, you know, how we're financing those purchases. And obviously the most, you know, the popular way to do that is through an insurance policy. The problem with that is it's there's a lot of waste, a lot of fraud and abuse that happens in those environments. And we work with brokers, other agencies, and other consultants to help them understand that the vehicle that they can use to finance those services for healthcare can look much different and be much more efficient. And so what we've done is basically kind of thrown the box away and said, look, we're going to help you build health plans rather than purchase insurance or place insurance policies for your clients.
DavidSo does that make you kind of a broker's broker?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. That's a term that we use a lot as the broker's broker or managing general consultants. We used to say that we're a quasi-GA or general agency. That doesn't really fit because we're not just selling financial products or services or policies and then kind of disappearing after the sale. We're we're staying very hands-on after the implementation of the plan that we help build and design. And we're helping manage risk, we're helping manage expectations, we're helping manage the vendor relationships. And just, you know, the whole ecosystem needs management after the sale. And there's a lot of agents and agencies out there that don't understand that part of this business.
DavidSo are you working predominantly in the self-funded plan universe?
SPEAKER_01Yes, 100% in the self-funded universe. I have never written a fully insured policy in my life, in my career, ever.
DavidWell, congratulations. The rest of us who have can show you the scars someday over a an adult beverage, I guess. So I'm a broker and I don't know what I don't know. I want to get into partially self-funded plans or self-funded plans, pick your nomenclature. And do I just call you guys up and say, hey, I need help? And you kind of ride shotgun? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01How does that work? Yeah, that's that's pretty much it. Usually you we find people through referrals and you know, just kind of through being a part of this community, the group health insurance and self-funded community. So we get a lot of referrals and names passed to us. We don't do a ton of marketing, so we're still very boutique. But yes, we have brokers, producers, agencies reach out to us via you know, phone call or an email. And our approach is very bespoke every time. You know, we start with you know, what are you currently doing? What does your current book of business look like? What markets are you in? What kind of products and services are you currently selling? How do you picture us working together and seeing us help you with that business? And then we just kind of go from there. So it's never one size fits all, or it's never the same approach. It's really what problems are you currently experiencing and where do you want to be in two, three, four, five years? And we're usually explaining the value of building a more self-funded, sustainable book of business. And usually that conversation is anchored heavily on less attrition, you know, less turnover in your book of business. You know, the small group fully insured market has traditionally been very unstable. You know, you got your big broker houses, you know, constantly swapping clients year over year, and it's it's just very much a who can get us the lowest premium conversation. But once you start looking at self-funding and implementing those self-funded strategies, it becomes very close. You know, rather than talking to that client, you know, maybe four times a year, you know, each quarter with quarterly reports and just kind of checking in every once in a while for coffee. We're talking to our clients and our producers' clients on a weekly basis, if not daily, if there's a bunch of you know issues arising and things like that. We're there constantly. We're in constant communication throughout the year, constantly adjusting things to make them better, streamlining our approach. And that keeps relationships very close. Even if something goes wrong, terribly wrong within the health plan, the fact that your client knows that you are there immediately to pick up the ball and tackle those problems and you know get things done, they see that and they feel that. It's much different than just spreadsheeting and negotiating for lower renewal rates every year. It's much different.
DavidWhich begs the question that I know everybody's asking, and then we'll get back into the kind of how this all works, which is whose client is it anyway? Does this become your client now? Or do if I'm a broker, do I lose a client? What's that part of the mechanic and the relationship like?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's part of the beauty of it. It never becomes our client. We put that in writing. You know, we never become the AOR, BOR of those relationships. And so we're just kind of working on the back end at a higher level, helping the producer team, the account management team, or the agency as a whole better manage, again, the health plan, the expectations, and the risk. We even have some of our agency partners assign us, you know, emails under their domain so that we look and feel like we're part of their team. So, and we we very much are a part of their team. You know, we're working with their account management and you know, the TPA and all the other vendors on a daily basis, and they know us just like we just like we know them and and uh they know their client. So we're we're very heavily involved. But no, we don't take the relationship, we don't put the relationship at risk. We never bid against uh one of our partners' relationships, and we put that in writing. We also put in writing that we disclose every dollar that we make, whether it's from the client, whether it's from stop loss or any vendor relationships, which we don't really make anything on vendor relationships where everything is very transparent, but we put that in writing. So if one of our broker partners wants to audit how we're being paid, we fully disclose everything. Well, it's pretty much the law now, anyways, but we happily do it.
DavidSo that begs the next question, which is okay, how do you guys get compensated?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so we there's three ways that we get compensated, and one of them is just uh your very straightforward traditional PEPM. So depending on the size of the group and the level of complexity that it might be to manage that group based on network design and the potential risks that are in that group. So we look at everything from you know the census to any claims data if we have it. So we kind of know what we're probably getting into as far as workload, and we set a very what I think is reasonable PEPM somewhere usually between five and fifteen dollars, depending on the size of the group. And then I think this is kind of funny that we're I'm fully disclosing my fees on this podcast, which is great. I don't think um too many people do that, but so that's our PEPM model, somewhere between five and fifteen. We rarely stray outside of that, but um we actually have gone lower and we've gone higher in some very few instances where we have like a really small group.
DavidBefore you get to number two, that so that just becomes part of the fixed cost of the plan?
SPEAKER_01Yes. Okay. Yep. And then depending on how we're placing stop loss, you know, the type of contract or what what the best fit for the client is, we might take up to 2.5% commission on the stop loss contract, but we never go over 2.5. And sometimes we'll just waive it completely, because as you know, when you set override commissions on stop loss, it can actually be adverse to the client when you could just say, well, we'll just take a little bit more PEPM on the fixed costs to kind of balance that out. And it actually is way more advantageous for the client, it's much better for them as far as uh their risk. And sometimes on the pharmacy benefit management relationship, we'll take a per script fee, and that's $2, and that's it. So we've never gone above or below that. It's a it's a $2 per script fee. We've waived that probably 50% of the time. So those are the three ways we get paid, and that's how much we get paid.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message, it should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients that you want to as a certified story brand guide, we use the SP7 processor or that story or websites and collateral that deliver it, or if your message is a certain voice or visit at the com or to learn how we can help you find or clarify and deliver a message that a win clients or sales goals and build your process if you can lose or you'll lose to learn more and schedule that call today at ShiftPaperstrategies.com. That's shiftpaperstrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidSo if I'm an advisor and I I don't have expertise under the roof about self-funding, you guys essentially become my self-funding department.
SPEAKER_01Correct. Yeah. Uh we consider ourselves subject matter experts on self-funding. Self-funding is a is a big ball of wax. Again, it's um we're not doing ASO or we're not selling into some pre-existing program where there's already a TPA and there's already a PBM and medical management, and all the other vendor relationships are just ready to go. Everything that we build is bespoke for that client, for that broker relationship based on their needs, based on their budget, based on their membership, based on their geographical location, has a lot to do with the network arrangements that we set up, and sometimes just culture. Sometimes we know that a certain culture of a health plan, an employer group, is best suited for that. You know, you want a similar culture in that administrator partner to kind of match the way they do business. And so there is no one size fits all in self-funding, at least I don't think there is. I think everything should be built soup to nuts and from scratch for each client. And so that's what we do. We have various administrative partners, various vendor partners, various stop loss partners, everything under the sun, because it has to be that way. It has to be bespoke, it has to be custom every single time. And a lot of people kind of snap at me or yell at me and say that, well, that's just so inefficient. Like, how are you guys managing all that? You know, it just seems like a lot of work. Yes, it is a lot of work. It should be. That's how we should be managing these health plans by doing a lot of work. And there's we have great technology today that allows us to do things more streamlined and efficiently, but guys, we got to get back to doing the work. That's the only way that we're gonna change this this industry, change how we access health care, and change the way that we're building these health plans for our clients. So that's the way we do it. And I think we're gonna stay boutique for quite a while because of that.
DavidIn your experience, let's go back to kind of how this works. Do brokers approach you with, hey, I've got a case that I need to handle, or is the relationship different in that they bring you in and let you kind of go through their book and try to identify clients who might be candidates for self-funded plans?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so it's it's a little bit of a both, but that you're correct in that usually what we hear is, hey, I have a case. I have a group that might be ready for self-funding. And it always starts as, you know, can we get stop loss quotes? So we kind of, when we start with a relationship, they kind of think of us as a quoting mill for stop loss. And that's usually how it starts. And then we have to then we show them that, hey, we have access to markets where we can get competitive stop loss, and we're happy to, you know, show that to you and prove that to you, but that's not what we do.
DavidWell, it's also the wrong place to start a conversation about a client being self-funded.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So that's usually where it starts. And so then we have to, you know, once we get some quotes and some competitive underwriting, which typically we're pretty good there, we'll say, hey, here's a stop loss quote, but here's also a plan proposal of you know what we might recommend, how this might look for this client, you know, with all the administrators and vendor partners and and kind of what this ecosystem might look like. And then they usually it's like, oh, that this is great, you know, I think this might work. Thank you. And then the discussion becomes great. Well, now we can help you implement it. We can help you with the vendor management, making sure that the onboarding calls and open enrollment and everything like that goes smoothly. Then we'll help you after that for the next year or two. So once they see that it's much more of a long-term hand-holding approach, I think they feel a lot more comfortable that they didn't just pay us five to fifteen dollars PEPM just to get a quote. Yeah, yeah, that's what we do.
DavidWhat about TPAs? Do you also help them shop for an appropriate TPA for a case?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. We'll help them. There's always new TPAs and new vendor partners popping up all the time, you know, and they they get bought and sold all the time. So a TPA that you really liked a year ago or two years ago might be completely different now. And they the ones that you like now might be completely different in two years. And so we're always talking about not putting all of your eggs in one basket. And uh for those reasons, this is a very fast-developing, heavily evolving industry that we're in. But yes, we will evaluate new TPA relationships with our partners all the time if we haven't already been introduced, or maybe it's a TPA that we've known about for years, but we haven't been back in touch with them for a while. And so, hey, maybe we need to revisit where they're at today. Because, again, the solutions that some of these uh vendor partners administrators are are developing and innovating on a monthly, yearly basis, it's incredible. The rate and the speed at which we're developing this industry is so fast. And so there's a lot of work that has to go into just evaluating partnerships.
DavidTalk about data analytics. What do you guys bring to the table? How do you help the advisor understand what that data looks like and what it means and how to make intelligent plan decisions based on that on a going forward basis?
SPEAKER_01So important to have access to data, to timely data, accurate data, and then know what to do with that data. Depending on like the administrator partner, they all have different uh solutions as far as ways to access that data. So it might be like a, you know, there's there's like Deerwalk and Springbuck and, you know, everything in between. And some TPAs have their own proprietary data management warehouse or system. And no matter what the case, it doesn't really matter who's giving us the data, right? It just has to be accurate and we have to be able to get it timely. And if we have that, then yes, very important to be able to dig into that data and interpret it. So getting the data is just the first step, and you barely scratch the surface. Once you have the data, knowing what to do with it, you know, pharmacy data. Which one of these tier two or tier three drugs could be sourced through like an international 90-day program where you're saving 50, 70% on tier two and tier three drugs? You know, on the specialty and infusion side, you know, J-codes and J-code blocking. I just helped a TPA, I think it was last week, set up a program, a brand new program that they didn't have before on how to set up J-code blocking for various PBMs and network arrangements where they could be steering the ship and providing those savings for their whole book of business for all their clients. And the way that stuff like that has to be handled, very carefully, that's very important to look at the data first to know how you need to handle it as far as risk mitigation goes. But yes, we're on top of that every week, David. Most people get up in the morning and get their coffee and they read the newspaper. I'm reading trigger reports, pre-certs, and case management reports every morning with my coffee. So I'm always looking at data.
DavidAre you also providing tools that help some of the employees become better consumers, whether it's um a concierge service or access to lower cost, higher quality, outpatient medical testing, et cetera? Do you also build those things into most of your plans?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, again, that has to be bespoke for that member population. But yes, we definitely have to drive consumerism and healthcare. You know, it's it's going to take all of us to do that. But there's yeah, various ways, shapes, and forms that we do it. We have a great domestic medical tourism program that we've set up for anybody who needs anything from orthopedics to general surgery to cardiac surgery. We work with some really great partners on that end. I mean, we we're we're saving tens of millions of dollars a year on those surgeries alone. And everything else. I mean, it's members don't know what they don't know. So you really have to put in front of them, whether it's using your mobile apps, you know, sending them push notifications, sending them emails, even making phone calls. If you have a medical management team that can even make phone calls and take a look at chronic conditions and you know the cases and the diseases that some of these folks are dealing with and kind of have a proactive outreach campaign, that works really well in some environments too. So everything under the sun, David. It it really depends on the group. But yes, we have those as well.
DavidAnd that's a great place to end our conversation today, but we do hope you'll come back because I think this is going to be a growth industry. There are so many advisors trying to do partially self-funded plans who've never done them before, who don't really understand them, who don't understand ERISA, who don't understand plan documents, and they need somebody to kind of help them along. Daniel Corlettes, principal at DC Advisory. Daniel, thanks so much for sharing your expertise with us today.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, David.
AnnouncerWithout our code. Copyright 2020, all right, for the first time.