The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
EP #404: In and Out of Medicine, via The Netherlands — with Frank Sutter
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this week's episode, Frank Sutter, a chiropractor and Associate Director of the Harvard Business School's Health Care Initiative, explains why he left medicine and how the medical system in the Netherlands inspired him to go back and change the healthcare in the United States.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- 1:54 Why he sold his practice to a physician group and moved to the Netherlands.
- 8:32 The goal of the healthcare initiative at Harvard and the many different avenues for students.
- 13:14 Direct primary care versus the healthcare initiative.
- 16:45 The difference between the healthcare system in the Netherlands and the US.
Quotes:
3:42 “In my experience, the greatest aspect of that is just spending time listening to patients, we don’t get a lot of that with most of our health care practitioners. So I really relish the time I was able to spend with each patient.”
16:13 “If the doctor is stressed, that’s going to impact the outcomes of the patient.”
19:22 “They [doctors in the Netherlands] don’t have the same fear of defensive medicine, which is testing everybody for everything all the time, always, so they don’t get sued for missing a diagnosis. That’s defensive medicine, which is, of course, very expensive for insurance companies and that’s not the right approach either. So, they are quite mindful of that here.”
What's the story with a U.S. chiropractor who got so fed up with how medicine is practiced that he got out of medicine, went to Harvard, ended up in the Netherlands, and is now back into medicine? We'll find out more on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaperStrategies.com. And now, here's your host, Storybrand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidAnd my answer to that is no, it's not. It's basically working exactly the way it was designed by the people who designed it. Now that may not be great for us as patients, or for some physicians, or many physicians as practitioners, but that's the system we've got right now. And we thought it would be interesting to talk to someone who's been kind of through that gamut and come out the other side in a very different place in the world, but in a different way. And so we invited Frank Sutter to join us today. Frank, for the last eight years, has been the Associate Director of Healthcare Initiative at Harvard Business School. He's also a chiropractor and a wonderfully nice fellow, and he's agreed to share his story with us. So welcome, Frank.
SPEAKER_02Great. Thank you for having me.
DavidIt's my pleasure. Talk a little bit about, and I think it's worthwhile, your journey and kind of how you ended up where you are.
SPEAKER_02Sure, I'm always happy to talk about my story. I, as you acknowledge, I spent the past eight years at Harvard Business School in what we call the Healthcare Initiative. And that department is really looking to find the best ways to innovate in healthcare management. And what can we do to close the gap on the health outcomes in the U.S., how do we increase access to care, and how do we decrease costs? And you know, this the mission of the healthcare initiative really resonated with me because prior to that, I spent about eight years running an integrative clinical practice in Chicago. I had gone to a chiropractic medical school outside of Chicago and was excited to launch my clinic. You know, as you can imagine, you know, launching your own business. It's like launching it's like having a baby. You know, it's it takes a lot of blood, sweat, and tears to nurture it and grow it. And I had a lot of challenges, as all entrepreneurs do, starting a business and scaling it, growing it, and all the growing pains that go with it. So for me, one of the greatest aspects of it was working with patients one-on-one. And being able to run my own clinic, I was able to work with patients in a way that I didn't have to answer to anybody. I didn't have shareholders, I didn't have a large medical oversight looking down on me. I could spend as much time as I needed to with each patient to make a change in the trajectory of their health and well-being. And in my experience, the the greatest aspect of that is just spending time listening to patients. We don't get a lot of that, you know, with most of our healthcare practitioners. So I really relish the time I was able to spend with each patient, and it could be anywhere from a half hour to an hour depending on uh their need, really. And the challenge was insurance companies don't necessarily love to reimburse based on time, and this was a sort of a growing problem that I had with a lot of the insurance companies I worked with. And with being a chiropractor, I was also practicing in a way that wasn't typical. So I was people were presenting with all sorts of constitutional problems from digestive issues, chronic skin conditions, menstrual issues, chronic migraines. And so I would take a what we call a functional medical approach, which would be looking at their diet, their sleep habits, their hobbies, their work, the way they manage stress. All of that factors in. And you know, we've got great results with the patients, but again, over time the insurance companies were reimbursing less and less. And you know, one interesting thing I noticed, you know, when I first started my practice in 2008, the collections were about 90% were insurance reimbursements, and about 10% was out-of-pocket payments from the patients themselves, whether that was their copay or their coinsurance or deductibles. By the time I sold my practice to a physician group about seven years later, that had almost completely reversed. And it was 90% patient paying out-of-pocket and ten percent insurance reimbursement. And that happened because of the introduction of high deductible health plans, people having upwards of $5,000, $7,500 deductibles. And it became challenging to treat the patients that really needed the kind of care that I was looking to provide and that my team was looking to provide. So it became an ethical rub for me over time that we were targeting wealthier people. We were targeting the companies that had insurance plans with very small deductibles. And I was like, this is wrong. Like, this is not what healthcare should be about, and I don't feel good about this. You know, we had very real expenses to pay, from overhead of running a clinic on Michigan Avenue in Chicago to paying staff. And you know, of course, my initial investment to become a doctor, you know, that was upwards of almost 200,000 in student loans. So But I was like, this doesn't feel good. You know, and I've shared with a lot of people over the years that nothing felt better than making money, helping people, and at the same time, nothing felt ickier than making money helping people, and I never could reconcile that. So some part of me was always envious of those that could just, you know, get the patients in, get them in, get them out, get them in, get them out. And it was a numbers game, and I just I just couldn't do it. I just couldn't do it. So I had the opportunity to sell my practice, as I said, and saw that what the opportunity was at Harvard Business School's Healthcare Initiative and the amazing team of faculty there, and thought I could help people in a better way, you know, by addressing that that healthcare triad of improving outcomes, reducing costs, and increasing access to care. So and then, you know, more recently I've moved to the Netherlands and now live in Amsterdam, and interestingly, the healthcare system is just set up very differently here. And, you know, everybody it's a hundred percent insurance here. Everybody has to have insurance, uh, so it's a little I think Obamacare was a little bit tied to the way that the Netherlands has it, where everybody has to pay a certain amount. It's not a hundred percent free, but there's not a lot of the challenging aspects of being a provider, such as HIPAA and the insurance reimbursement system is extremely different here. So it feels much more welcoming to be a provider in the Netherlands than it was for me, and I can only speak for myself, but what than it was for me in the U.S. So that's where I'm at now, sort of exploring clinical practice here and getting that off the ground while still working with the healthcare initiative at Harvard Business School.
DavidAaron Powell It's a great story. Talk to me a little bit about some of the work that you guys were doing at Harvard and kind of what goes on in in that healthcare initiative.
SPEAKER_02Sure. So we look at our constituents in the healthcare initiative, and those are students who are looking to go into a healthcare management career, and that's anywhere in the healthcare sector. So that could be anything in life sciences, pharma, biotech, medical devices, diagnostics, digital health, of course, payers, and various types of insurance models. So there's and of and healthcare entrepreneurship. So there's many different avenues for students to explore when they're looking to go into, again, a management role. And so we also support our alumni. We know we have over 8,000 alumni around the world who have a healthcare focus in their career. So we create opportunities to connect alumni with students, to connect alumni with, you know, potentially if they're investors, or trying to they're trying to commercialize some sort of an innovation in healthcare. Can we introduce them to venture capital? Can we make introductions to investors and whatnot? And then, of course, we have faculty. So there's about 280 faculty at Harvard Business School. About 80 of them have a relatively solid interest in healthcare, and 20 of them, it's like almost they're really their focus. They really just focus a lot of their research around healthcare. So our role was to how do we communicate the research that the faculty are conducting, and how do we get it out there to the operators in healthcare, to other educational institutions to help make a difference, to truly make a difference in healthcare. So that's a chunk of it with you know, some of the faculty, you know, a lot of people know Regina Herzlinger. She's been dubbed by Money Magazine, the godmother of consumer-driven healthcare. You know, she's a force of you know, the consumer needs to be in the driver's seat of their health care and not simply do as the doctor tells you to do and just accept it. So that's an area that she's made a lot of strides in. And you know, she's worked very closely with a lot of with I think almost several of the most recent presidential administrations on health policy and what can we do to really improve what's going on in the American healthcare system. Other faculty, such as Lee Moore Daphne, she has done a lot of research in consolidation in healthcare. You know, we see a lot of mergers and acquisitions, and there's this notion that, oh, it's going to drive down costs. And what her research is showing actually is that if there are any cost savings, it is not passed down to the consumer, which in this case is often the patient, of course. So that's fascinating. You know, so we have other faculty looking at impacts on global health, digital health, innovation in all of these areas. So again, our role is what can we do to boil that message down and get it in front of the right people to help, again, improve health care across the diaspora in the US system.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaperStrategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at ShiftShaperstrategies.com. That's Shiftshaperstrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidI don't think that there are too many examples of places where fewer players in a market means lower costs. And I think you'd be hard pressed to find that. And as far as as Reggie is concerned, she is indeed the godmother of consumer-directed health care, and she is a force of nature and just a wonderfully nice person besides that.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, she's brilliant.
DavidFor an accountant, she does a lot of really interesting work. One of the things that you said I thought was intriguing, and I it's kind of juxtaposed, is you weren't really comfortable in that cash practice kind of medicine. And yet in the United States, what's starting to take root is a concept I think the American Academy of Pediatrics came up with maybe 15 years ago, called it then it was called medical home. Now it's called primary direct primary care. And those are, by and large, cash practices because they're not considered, at least at this moment, insurance in the States. That's growing. And it does seem to provide for those folks who are in it, those physicians who are in it, a kind of practice life like the one to which you aspired, what you had in your head. So it's interesting. How do you juggle those two constructs? The idea of having a cash-based practice, but yet that freeing you up to be able to practice the way you had envisioned when you were in medical school.
SPEAKER_02And that is, and that's what we're seeing with some of these concierge models, you know, concierge medicine, people paying a subscription to have access to their care provider. And that subscription allows the provider to put a cap on how many patients are in their Rolodex. That I can't speak intelligently about the numbers, but the it allows the physician to greatly reduce. And therefore, you know, if your child is sick, you can call your doctor and get a same-day appointment, or even a next day appointment. Or at least have a phone call with your doctor that day, and possibly even an email exchange. And it's all part of that subscription. So it's you know, I think there's it's not necessarily the right option for everybody, and it's going to exclude people of a certain socioeconomic status. So it's not I don't think it's the perfect solution across the board, but for a significant portion of the population that can afford it, it is a great way to, I really think, improve health outcomes and keep providers in care delivery. Because we see a huge exodus of primary care physicians leaving health care because they're tired. You know, I was one of them. You know, when I and tired of dealing with insurance, tired of dealing with all of the red tape, all of the documentation needed, you know, then the amount of sleep I lost about, you know, from all the ways I could get sued, you know, is our documentation does it support clinical care for that CPT code used in the insurance claim? You know, it's like, oh gosh, I don't know. Did we violate HIPAA? I don't know. So it was all these fears that that weigh on providers. And so this that's this sort of concierge model, I think, if if I understood you correctly, if that's where you're going with this, I think that's one way to, again, improve the the everyday sense of well-being by the doctor. Because if the doctor is stressed, that's it's going to impact the outcomes of the patient.
DavidYou know, so I think you know, I'm familiar with well familiar with three direct primary care docs, and the way they get around to use your highfalutin Harvard medical term, the ickiness of it, which is a great term. Because it is kind of icky, or it can be, is they price their practice so that they take a certain amount of pro bono patients as well. And I guess that makes them feel that they're being a little more egalitarian in their intake and whatnot. Question for you, kind of zooming around a little bit, but you talked a little bit about health insurance in the Netherlands. How is that funded and how is that paid? And what does insurance look like there? Do you have out-of-pockets and deductibles and co-pays and whatnot to kind of put a break on utilization, or is it just y'all come?
SPEAKER_02So I'm still wrapping my head around it, so I'm not the expert on it, but everybody has to have it, and everybody pays a monthly premium into their plan. Most of the time insurance, you uh your employers will provide insurance similar to the U.S. But there's also a lot of self-employed individuals here. So that creates, you know, or independent contractors. So that creates another challenge. You know, in the U.S. it was it was actually, you know, before the Affordable Care Act, you just you really couldn't buy insurance. You just if you didn't have a job with an employer, you didn't have health insurance. I was one of those people. I didn't have insurance for over ten years.
DavidAaron Powell Well, there was an individual market, but it was expensive. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_02It was unattainable because who are the ones that don't have insurance? It's people who don't have jobs. And it's people who are underemployed. You have a couple part-time jobs. You know, you can't put out eight, eight hundred thousand dollars a month at that, you know, with that. So it was a real challenge, and which is why there were so many unemployed or uninsured individuals. Uh here it's much more accessible. And you know, I've actually had to go to the emergency room. I cut my hand open, putting an IKEA cabinet together, and you know, we wound up getting, I guess we had a small deductible, and we had to pay about a hundred euro out of pocket. But it was pretty minimal. And so it is different here. I I see a difference in preventive medicine. You know, here you hear I hear a lot of the Dutch talk, and they'll say, you know, the doctors all say the same thing, you know, you know, whatever your problem is, take some paracetamol, which is basically acetaminivin, the Tylenol. Take some paracetamol and give it a week and you know, let us see what happens. So I've witnessed that too, and I was like, huh, you know. So I had to beg my doctor to test my cholesterol. And I was like, I've got a history of high cholesterol. Please, please, please. And you know, he was like, You're not over fifty. I can't, you know, I can't do it. But after begging and begging.
DavidIs that government mandated or is that just standard practice there?
SPEAKER_02It's really standard practice. I I don't think it's government mandated, because I if it were, I imagine he wouldn't have been able to budge. But it was I just I had to like really like advocate for myself. And so those are some of the differences I see where they they don't they don't have the same fear of defensive medicine, which is testing everybody for everything all the time, always, so they don't get sued for missing it, you know, missing a diagnosis. So that's the sort of defensive medicine, which is of course very expensive for insurance companies, and you know, that's not the right approach either. So they they have they are very quite mindful of that here.
DavidInteresting and a great place to end our conversation for today. We I do hope you'll come back after you've if you set up your practice and you get going and whatnot. We'd love to talk to you and learn more about you know your impressions of that system versus what's going on here in uh the lower 48 or the eastern 48.
SPEAKER_02Sure, that'd be great. I'd love to.
DavidAnyway, Frank Sutter, Associate Director of the Healthcare Initiative at Harvard Business School, and a chiropractor, and someone who's gaining experience in yet another area. Frank, thanks so much for sharing your expertise with the audience. I appreciate it.
SPEAKER_02And thank you for having me. Have a wonderful day.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper Strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.