The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
EP #395: Leadership In The Hybrid Workplace - with Gleb Tsipursky
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week's episode of the ShiftShapers Podcast talks about how companies are shifting the way they do business. According to Gleb Tsipursky, an internationally-recognized thought leader and the CEO of Disaster Avoidance Experts, this shift has begun even before COVID-19 and will continue even after the pandemic ends. In this episode, we talk about the challenges of managing the workplace, more specifically, what leaders need to know in terms of adapting their corporate culture?
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- 2:14 How technology influenced the shift to the hybrid workplace.
- 3:13 Why some leaders prefer to go back in the office.
- 7:56 Reasons why a hybrid workplace will maintain the best morale and employee engagement.
- 10:36 Strategies that companies can use to start creating a hybrid workplace.
- 14:20 Creating new performance indicators and metrics.
- 18:02 The potential of hiring people globally.
- 20:20 What leaders need to know in terms of adapting their corporate culture.
- 23:24 The normalcy bias.
Quotes:
3:03 “People are much more productive on their individual tasks at home. Even before the pandemic, more and more are doing their individual tasks at home.”
4:32 “The key dangerous judgment error here is called the status quo bias. We tend to go toward what we’re comfortable with. The status quo – what we know, where we’re successful, and the leaders who have been successful in their career 20, 30, 40 years in the office, they feel they can manage people best that way. They feel they can control their environment. Of course, that’s a little bit diluted, but they feel that they have more control, more authority. They feel good about seeing people around them. And that’s the status quo bias. They’re orienting towards their personal gut reactions and what’s comfortable for them, rather than what’s best for the bottom line.”
16:23 “Companies need to fundamentally change their performance evaluation. Right now, performance evaluation for the large majority of companies is based on presence, how much time you work, and generally your presence in the office, that’s obviously not going to work. It has not worked well during the pandemic, which is one of the reasons managers want to come back Monday through Friday, 9 to 5. But that is not what you should do. You should change to make sure that performance is based on deliverables, accomplishments, not time-based.”
We're now experiencing the hybrid workplace. Some of us are returning to the workplace, and some are remote, and some are a mix of the two. What do we need to learn about leading hybrid and remote teams? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. And now, here's your host, Storybrand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidYou know, a lot of us are dealing with, especially business owners, are dealing with this new hybrid workplace, and all of us have heard a lot about it. But I don't think there are a lot of us who really understand it, at least in depth yet. And there are some folks who are trying to help us. Gleb Tzaperski is one of those. Now, you will remember that we had Dr. Tzapersky back with us on episode 297 in a previous book that he wrote called Do Not Ever Trust Your Gut. And it's a great listen. So if you haven't heard it yet, go to the Shift Shapers online website and search for the episode or search for Gleb G-L E B and you'll find it. But today we're here to talk about a new book that he's written that's really interesting. It's called Returning to the Office and Leading Hybrid and Remote Teams. That in itself is interesting, but the subtitle, which I didn't write down, but I will read to you, is a manual on benchmarking to best practices for competitive advantage. And I think that's really a part of the key. So with that long preamble, welcome back, Gleb. Good to have you.
SPEAKER_00Pleasure to be back on, David. Thank you for inviting me.
DavidSo let's level set. A lot of people think that the hybrid workplace came about as a result of COVID, but it was actually kind of out there a little bit before, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. It was out there. People were increasingly already. If you look at the number of people who were working remotely, that was growing. I think it was about 2% before the pandemic. And of course, it grew a lot because of new virtual collaboration tools and hybrid. People were increasingly coming in, not every day, maybe spending half their time at home and doing their individual tasks at home. Because if you look at the research on this topic, and that's what the book is about, how do you actually collaborate effectively in a hybrid environment and as well as virtual, you see that individual tasks are much better done in the home. So they're better done. People are much more productive on their individual tasks at home. So even before the pandemic, people were individual more and more doing their individual tasks at home.
DavidYou know, it's interesting because you know, McKinsey's done some research on this, and they found that not only to your point do individuals work better, but that collaboration is often better. And that's something I think employers are concerned about is you know, we're used to all huddling up in the conference room. How do we replicate that? How do we get that result? But there have been some mixed calls from leadership, you know, between COVID-1 and variant one. Now we're in, you know, the first variant, but there were a lot of mixed messages going back and forth. Every corporation was a little bit different. Some said, you must be back in the office. Others said, you know, we're going to be more hybrid. Others said, work from wherever you want. We're closing the physical plant down. We don't need it. Where are we in that continuum, or is that going to continue to be a moving target?
SPEAKER_00I think it's going to be the case that leaders are increasingly going to be seeing that Monday for Friday, 9 to 5 is unworkable. Unfortunately, there are still plenty of leaders who have that mentality that they're stuck back in January 2020. They really feel that that's the right way to collaborate. Monday for Friday, 9 to 5. And when you look at why, so my expertise in cognitive biases, the dangerous judgment errors that cause us to make disastrous decisions that are wired in our brain. And the book talks much more about that. But the key dangerous judgment error here is called the status quo bias. We tend to go toward what we're comfortable with, the status quo, what we know, where we're successful. And the leaders who have been successful for their whole career, 20, 30, 40 years in the office, they feel they can manage people best that way. They feel they can control the environment. Of course, that's a little bit deluded, but they feel that they have more control, more authority, they feel good about seeing people around them. And that's the status quo bias. They are orienting toward their personal gut reactions and what's comfortable for them rather than what's best for the bottom line. And we see that a lot where companies are reversing their decisions even before variant one. So for example, Google was for many months saying, we'll go back to the office, back to the office, back to the office. And my internal sources of Google tell me that people were increasingly rebelling and upset with this, leaving Google, low morale. And so eventually on May 5th, so before Delta, Google announced, you know, we screwed up, sorry, we're gonna allow up to 20% of our workforce to work fully remotely, and 20% other work from other offices, whatever you're closest to, not necessarily your home office. That's Google, you know, it doesn't get much better, bigger than that. But around the same level, Amazon was saying the same thing. Go back to the office, back to the office, back. And again, same problems. And then June 10th, they announced the same thing. So this is before variant. This is before the Delta Search. Companies were making bad decisions already. And now the variant is showing that they fell into another cognitive bias called the normalcy bias. So the normalcy bias is about us perceiving that the future will be normal, that it will be much like today. So after people got vaccination, mass vaccination, leaders perceived, okay, you know, the pandemic is over, we're going back to the office, everything is fine. They greatly underestimated the likelihood of major disruptors. And that's what the normalcy bias is about, where leaders failed to plan for the long tail risks. Now that is an insurance disaster, right? When you think about insurance, long tail risks, ones that are huge risks and they are not that high in probability, but you need to insure for them. And so many leaders did not. And so they said, go back to the office. I mean, a number of companies still want to go back to the office. They've said there's, you know, go back to the office in September. It's September. This is bad. This is bad decision making by these companies. They do not really have good perspective because the Delta variant combined with vaccine effectiveness waning, goes after six months of vaccine effectiveness. Pfizer and Moderna similarly go down to around only 39% effectiveness against Delta. That's not good. You should not be going back to the office Monday through Friday, 9 to 5, with that sort of situation. But that's what we see leaders doing. They're underestimating both Delta and future variants that are coming down the road. We're talking about Delta Plus, Lambda, there are other variants that seem equally or more dangerous compared to Delta. So this is something leaders aren't planning for very well at all.
DavidYou know, it's interesting. Years ago, Joel Barker in his book Future Edge wrote about paradigms and how paradigms inevitably shift at an inflection point. Is the inflection point, do you feel, going to be where we move hybrid workplace into the normalcy spot? Is that going to be more individual driven at some point rather than being driven by the virus and its variants? In other words, are folks just going to go, wow, I really like working at home. I'm more productive. You know, I can work whatever hours or days I want and go for a walk in the middle of the day and that helps me. Is that ultimately going to be the tipping point? Is human beings?
SPEAKER_00I think when we're talking about the tipping point, it was actually back in March 2020. So the tipping point is behind, it's not in front of us. When people stayed at home for over a year, they got new habits, they understood that they can actually do their work full-time remotely. When we look at major surveys and indicating what people want, we see that about 25 to 35% of all workers want to work full-time remotely. About 50, 60% want to work hybrid. Only 15 to 20% want Monday for Friday back in the office. Now, that's going to be hard to staff a company with only 20%, right? So if right now in this current employee market, there's a time of the great resignation. More and more people are voluntarily leaving. Google, Amazon, same thing happened at Uber, same thing is happening at Apple, and so many other companies that I can name, that are middle market companies that I've helped consult for to address this sort of situation. Where companies see workers leaving and they need to appeal to these employees, and they need to understand that they are going to increase productivity, engagement, morale, retention, and recruitment into the future, not simply now, but you know, into the foreseeable future if they allow what is the best practice. So what my book talks about having a team-led model where most people are hybrid, something like 70 to 90% of your workforce, depending on the kind of workforce you have. So I'm working with a Fortune 200 manufacturing company, where of course some people have to be on site. So their workforce is going to be closer to the 85% working hybrid, and then 15% working full-time remotely. And other companies should do closer to maybe 25-30% working full-time remotely, because that's how you'll retain your people, recruit new people, have the best morale and engagement.
DavidBut yet that same McKinsey research says that three-quarters of employers don't have any plan in place. So if you're an employer, and you're directly to your book, if you're an employer and you're going to start thinking this through, what's that process? Where do you start? Where do you go? How do you implement?
SPEAKER_00Right. So what the research by McKinse suggests is that there's no concrete plan. But McKinsey and others show that when you poll CEOs on their general plans, something like 65 to 75% indicate that they do want some kind of hybrid model long-term. That's kind of their long-term plans. So what leaders need to do is realize so I talked about the best practice, you need to not direct from the top down what people are doing. You need to give them guidelines and have lower-level supervisors make these calls. Unlike Apple, Apple has a very bad approach to this. They said you need to come back to the office Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday. That is really not something that will work well for most people. And that's why you see people rebellion at Apple, people publicly complaining, which is very rare at Apple, and leaving the company. So this is something that you don't want. You want the supervisors to make the call. So it's a team-led hybrid model. And then they should allow some of their staff to work full-time remotely, whether it's a whole team or individuals on a hybrid team. And so that is the general best practice 30,000-foot. Now you also need to integrate best practices for collaborating and innovating virtually. And that's something that leaders have not done very well. That is cognitive bias called functional fixedness. Functional fixedness. When you have one way of working, one way of collaborating, one tool set, then you tend to apply the tool set to everything else. It's kind of like the hammer and nail syndrome. When you have a hammer, everything looks like a nail. When you're used to working in the office, the methods of innovating and collaborating and leading and managing are all adapted to that. Leaders during the lockdowns, kind of it's kind of silly to say this, but it's absolutely true. They have not researched best practices of collaborating virtually, of innovating virtually, of adapting their culture to a virtual format. That's why Zoom happy hours came about. Nobody likes Zoom happy hours. Zoom happy hours are an artificial structure that managers try to impose on their team because they want people to collaborate and then formally socialize. It works very poorly. But managers have not researched what are the best practices for actually getting people to connect virtually and collaborate. And all of these things is what my book talks about.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaper Strategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at Shiftshaperstrategies.com. That's Shiftshaperstrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidSo in addition to letting the lower or middle-level managers make those kinds of decisions, what are the other things that long-term employers need to change in their thinking so that they can be successful and have a great workforce in this new hybrid workplace? What are some of the other things and performance indicators and metrics that they need to be looking at?
SPEAKER_00So what they want to change are a number of things. Your virtual innovation, they need to adapt new innovation practices. This manufacturing company, I helped by now 16 companies adapt strategically to the new post-vaccine environment. And what I'm finding is one of the biggest concerns is innovation. These leaders are saying, well, we need to go back to the office because we need innovation. We're going to lose our innovation edge. And I show them, you know, traditional brainstorming is not something that works well in virtual formats. You need to adopt new strategies. And there's a strategy in the book called virtually synchronous brainstorming, where people individually come up with ideas anonymously, comment on each other's ideas, then create revised ideas, and then just discuss them in a synchronous meeting. That research shows, and my practice shows, that it results in more novel, interesting, and practical ideas than traditional brainstorming. So you have to address that innovation. You also have to address your collaboration. Collaboration is not addressed well. Zoom happy hours don't work well. You need to instead do things like a digital water cooler, where what you do is you have a channel like on Microsoft Teams for each team, where the team, the first thing they do in the morning, they check in by saying, hey, here's how I'm feeling, here's how I'm doing, here's what my life is like, and here's what I'm focusing on this day, and here's a fun fact about the world that you may not know, or about me. And then you respond to three other people. That's what should replace Zoom happy hours. That works much better to keep teams together and keeps teams motivated and engaged well. And the third thing you talked about KPIs, companies need to fundamentally change their performance evaluation. Right now, performance evaluation for the large majority of companies is based on presence, how much time you work, and generally your presence in the office. That's obviously not going to work well. It has not worked well during the pandemic, which is one of the reasons managers want to come back Monday for Friday, 9 to 5. But that is not what you should do. You should change to make sure that your performance is based on deliverables, accomplishments, not time-based. Why do you care how much time people spend working or what specific time they spend working? You want to focus on what they deliver, what they accomplish, what's the bottom line for a business. So you, their objectives. And instead of one large quarterly evaluation or even annual evaluation, you need to have meetings every week, small weekly meetings where you evaluate people's performance. You evaluate, you know, the team lead, the team member sends the team leader a report with saying, hey, here's my top accomplishments for the week. Here's how I solve the problems I faced, and here is what I plan to work on next week, and here's how I would evaluate myself. And then the leader and the person meet and they discuss all of these things. The team leader coaches them on solving their problems better, and then they agree or revise plans for next week. And that fee gets fed into a constant performance evaluation for KPIs. So key performance indicators. And so that is the kind of thing that you need to do. And I'll discuss a lot more and all of these in depth in my book on how do you actually lead effectively in a hybrid and remote setting.
DavidSo there are some, let's call them, benefits that I don't think, at least the employers that I chat with have actually figured out yet. And yet they seem kind of fundamental. For example, if you are in an anywhere, anytime work environment, then your hiring pool just became anytime anywhere as well. Are you seeing with the companies that you work with folks starting to realize that and starting to go, well, I don't just have to hire locally because I don't need people to drive into the office. I can hire from any place in the world and use geofencing, distributed computing, cloud computing to make that happen. Are you starting to hear that or is it too early in the process yet?
SPEAKER_00I'm starting to hear that as a more medium-long-term strategy. What's happening right now is instead the formation of cross-functional collaborative teams that are much more global in scope. Now, previously, it was a much more problematic to have a team that consists of people from India and consists of people from Poland and consists of people from the US. And that is a tough time because of time zone differences, right? Now, what's happening when they're adopting these methods for virtual innovation, virtual collaboration, it becomes much easier. You don't have to schedule a Zoom happy hour where it's really inconvenient for a number of people. You can do the virtual water cooler that I mentioned from any time asynchronously. So you're having a much more effective team. The same thing for virtual intentional brainstorming. It's asynchronous. You don't need to be there at the same time to share your ideas, comment on each other's ideas, generate revised ideas. So this asynchronicity is very, very helpful for global companies that are forming different cross-functional teams. So that's what they're experimenting with right now. How does this work out for the long-term orientation, medium-long-term orientation of bringing on people from anywhere? They want to make sure that these methods work internally so that they don't put in resources into hiring people and then it doesn't work out. But yes, they're generally finding that this is working out well and they're integrating into their medium-term strategy, hiring people from anywhere.
DavidWhat do leaders have to know in terms of adapting their corporate culture? Because this is as much a culture shift as it is a work shift. What are those things that they need to be keen on being mindful of and fomenting so that they end up where they want to be?
SPEAKER_00I think the most important thing they have to think about is addressing the potential problem of some people being more time, spending more time in the office, and some people spending less time in the office, and or maybe no time in the office. And you don't want to create a culture that's like have nots, haves and have nots. You don't want to create that culture. And if you just let it develop, there's a threat that that will happen. So instead, you need to develop deliberately, intentionally, a culture of excellence from anywhere. Excellence from anywhere. What that means is you focus, and that's fundamentally tried to tied to changing your KPIs and your performance evaluation process, because that's all focused on deliverables. So you don't need to be in the office to get your deliverables done, you don't need to be in the office. You need to be in the office to get your deliverables done, you need to be in the office. The manufacturing company with which I'm working right now, they need to have some people in the lab to do innovation. They know they have to use those tools. Then you have to be in the lab. And some of you, much of your other research time you could spend at home doing your individual tasks, right? So that's what you need to focus on. You need to not focus on, oh, I have to go to the office, and why doesn't Bob have to go to the office, right? You want to focus on people being able to do their job and deliver and perform. form for the company according to their role. And so that should be the focus. And you want to make sure that people don't feel kind of deprived because they have to go to the office. Because, you know, when you really think about it, and this is something I've pretty had pretty much all the companies that I worked with integrate as an idea is you don't want your colleague to commute out of spite. You know, you don't want your colleague to commute just because you know you want to ruin his day, right? You want to ruin Bob's day. That's not great. Nobody wants that, right? The commute is the top reason that people cite for not going to the office. You know, and it makes sense, you know, an hour there, an hour back with all the transition that happens, going for security, all of that sort of hassle. That is a lot of time wasted. And when you look at what happened during the pandemic, people on average work 20 hours longer, which is one of the reasons for the average 10 to 14 increase in productivity that comes from remote work, full-time remote work. People work more time, you know, that commute is unpaid labor and people work less because of it. And they work more because they didn't have to do the commute. So this is really good for productivity. And of course people aren't distracted at home. That's why it's better for individual tasks. So you want to create a culture of focusing on excellence from anywhere, not making your colleagues come back to the office and you know having Bob come to the office just out of spite.
DavidWe've got about a minute left, maybe a little bit more and I wonder where you see the not so much the future, because I think we all kind of have a vision of that, but what you see this timeline as being until we move into the this is the normalcy bias against which we measure things. In your opinion, when are we going to be there?
SPEAKER_00Some companies are definitely already there. They're realizing that in order to compete in the future of work, in order to recruit the right people and to retain their people, to actually have good morale, productivity, well-being, good work life balance, they need to allow people a lot of flexibility. And that means that kind of that hybrid first model with some remote options, you know, 10 to 30% fully remote, the rest hybrid. So some companies are already there. Some companies, you know, they're kind of moving there. Like I said about Google and Amazon still kind of kicking and screaming. Apple may to move there. And so I think it's not simply you know we're going to be there and not be there and there's a single timeline. It's going to be that the fact that companies that move there quicker and they're already there, they are going to seize the competitive edge and they're going to seize have more talent and they will have better productivity and better engagement and better morale. And so they will grow in their value cap and the stock market and profits and other companies will suffer. Those who are stuck with high bound managers who really feel you have to be back in the office to get innovation done, to get a collaboration done, which is absolutely not the case. And so that's what I think will happen in the future. You'll see the successful thriving companies having that hybrid first model with some remote options and companies that are backward, well, they're going to be held back.
DavidAnd that's a great place to end our chat for today, Gleb Sapersky, Gleb, great book. It's called Returning to the Office and Leading Hybrid and Remote Teams. It's not a big book, it's an easy read but it is chock full of really great information. So if you're leading a hybrid team, it's well worth picking up the book. Gleb, thanks so much for sharing your expertise again with our audience. We look forward to having you back for a third time. I'd love to be back for a third time. Thank you, David. Thanks.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020 all rights reserved