The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #359: In Pursuit of the Elusive Health Care Double - with Suzanne Delbanco
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week’s episode features a conversation with Suzanne Delbanco, Executive Director at Catalyst for Payment Reform. Consolidation in the provider marketplace has detrimental effects on patients, such as provider unwillingness to change in favor of improved patient experience. In policy reform, the central issue is price transparency remains a battleground where Suzanne is very active. She also comments on the recent uptick in direct contracting solutions and the incoming changes ushered by the pandemic.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- 01:43 Suzanne’s background: Changing the healthcare system for 10 years
- 05:34 Payment reform: The state of provider marketplace consolidation today
- 13:34 Advising policy reform on price transparency
- 17:46 Direct contracting is not a broadscale solution
- 20:17 Near future changes triggered by COVID-19
Quotes:
03:40 “Employers, states, Medicaid agencies, unions, universities who have lots of staff who have to buy healthcare for big populations, I’m trying to help them create a shared agenda for pushing the marketplace to be more responsive to the needs of those who buy and use healthcare.”
08:02 “We might come up with a perfect method of payment but if the price is too high, it doesn’t exactly bring better value.”
09:45 “When you have an increasingly consolidated healthcare provider marketplace, which means that providers have the market power and they are essentially calling the shots, it’s not only price that suffers but it can even be willingness to experiment.”
16:25 “The health policy commission, the data analysis institute that they’ve established and their sort of partnership and work with the attorney general’s office, has given Massachusetts insight into the working of their market that’s unparalleled.”
18:22 “I don’t think it will ever be a broadscale solution and it’s for very simple reasons that most employer purchaser organizations do not have the sophistication and the bandwidth to do this on their own.”
In the quest for higher value, better functioning healthcare, one woman stands out. Who is she? And how does she think we can achieve that goal? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaperStrategies.com. And now, here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidThere's been an awful lot of talk in the industry about driving higher value health care and improving the overall functionality of the healthcare marketplace. No one has been, in my understanding, has been a more persistent and more important voice in doing that than our guest today. Suzanne Del Banco is executive director of Catalyst for Payment Reform. And her work is bringing together multiple constituencies to do exactly that, to drive higher value health care and improve functioning in the marketplace. With that, welcome, Suzanne.
SPEAKER_02Thanks for having me, David. I appreciate it.
DavidOh, it's our pleasure. So would you give us a little bit about your background? Because it informs, I think, a lot of the work that you're doing today.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I think one relevant thing is that I am the daughter of a primary care doctor and who is also an academic doctor and who always talked about his work every night at dinner. And so I was aware from a very early age about how messed up our healthcare system is and how much work we need to do, especially to make it from, you know, work work better from the perspective of the patient. And so I've always been drawn to controversial topics and really challenging problems that need to be solved somehow. And so my background over the last 20 years, which I think is the most relevant, has been to work with the power of the employer or other healthcare purchaser behind me to really change the fundamental ways the healthcare marketplace works. You know, I started out working briefly at the Pacific Business Group on Health and then moved to become the founding CEO of the Leapfrog Group, which really pioneered the use of standard measures of healthcare performance and public reporting on those measures. And when we were at Leapfrog, we wanted also to start tying payment to the performance of providers. And we got some work done on that. But, you know, the board over time, you know, really wanted to focus primarily on hospitals and safety and getting that information to people, which is of course very important. And so soon after I left Leapfrog after seven years, I was involved with some leaders at GE in conceiving of what the next Leapfrog should be. And we we thought it should focus around payment reform. So the last 10 years, I've been leading this relatively now new organization now, a decade old, a nonprofit 501c3, you know, sort of educational-oriented organization, to try to help purchasers, meaning employers, states, Medicaid agencies, unions, universities who have lots of staff, you know, who have to buy healthcare for big populations. I'm trying to help them create a shared agenda for pushing the marketplace to be more responsive to the needs of those who buy and use healthcare. And of course, given our name Catalyst for payment reform, payment reform is at the heart of that. But as soon as you start thinking about how to align incentives for healthcare providers, you also need to think about how to align incentives for all the other stakeholders, from the patient to the providers to the healthcare payers and health plans to, you know, the whole healthcare ecosystem. So I'll stop there and see if there's anything else you want to know about my background before we move on.
DavidWell, no, I think that's great. I'm thinking as you're chatting, so you're 10 years into this. Are things better, worse, the same, or just different than they were 10 years ago?
SPEAKER_02You know, trying to change the healthcare system sometimes feels pretty thankless. But I will say, you know, let's go back 20 years ago. Do we as a nation now agree that we should have standard ways for measuring the performance of healthcare? Yes. Do we agree there should be transparency on quality performance? Yes. Do we also agree that the traditional fee-for-service payment system is fraught with problems and we need to fix it? Yes. So in that way, I feel like we have been successful in our work in changing the way changing the way people think about the healthcare system and how it fundamentally needs to be built. Have we hit the nail on the head when it comes to the perfect mode and method of payment to drive to perfect outcomes for all patients? No. We still have a long way to go with that.
DavidSo are all the different constituencies, even though everybody's agreed on the problem set, are they any closer to working together as a cohesive group, or are they still disparate constituencies that are each coming at it from their own perspective?
SPEAKER_02Well, let me start by saying, just to be clear, that, you know, Catalyst for Payment Form is an employer purchaser-led organization. So we are not multi-stakeholder in that sense, but we do work very regularly, as you can imagine, with the major health insurance companies. We've just started working with some of the PBMs. We work a little bit less directly with healthcare providers because most employers lean on their health plans or TPAs as their agents, you know, when it comes to buying healthcare directly from healthcare providers. So I can share the perspective of the constituencies that I interact with. You know, I also, you know, interact with the vast array of stakeholders out there, including policymakers and journalists and researchers and others. So when I think about where we are, I think there is a lot of consensus about what needs to change. I think in the payment reform arena, there is growing consensus about what things don't work, which is very important when you're at the beginning of an experiment. And there is some coalescing around some of the things that are starting to seem as though they do work consistently, you know, or somewhat consistently across provider settings and in different marketplaces.
DavidAre you focusing mainly on then the mechanics of payment?
SPEAKER_02That is one piece of what we do. As I was talking about in describing my background, if we only thought about the mechanics of payment with providers, I suppose that would be a useful service. But given that we're working with employers and other healthcare purchasers who also need to think about what providers do they want to have in their network and what benefit designs do they want to offer to their planned participants. We really try to run the gamut when it comes to how do we align the incentives across all the parties. So, you know, we we really think about all those things. And then frankly, all of this is taking place in the context of a rapidly changing provider landscape. And we can't ignore that either, because we might come up with a perfect method of payment, but if the price is too high, you know, it doesn't exactly bring better value.
DavidAre you still folding in quality as part of the equation, especially going back to your leapfrog days?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I mean, there's I don't think there's an employer out there who is interested in changing the method of payment at the detriment of quality. I think we're all willing to change the method of payment if we at a minimum keep quality where it is and can make healthcare more affordable. I think that is still an improvement in value, but I don't think there's anyone out there who isn't interested in improving quality. And there's some areas where we need to work on that more drastically than others.
DavidSo you talk about the environment and the current environment today. If we fast forward into today's marketplace, there's been a ton of consolidation in a lot of different ways, both hospitals buying up physician practices and ancillary services, and also a lot of roll-ups on the employer's side. Is that changing how you deal with the problems you're trying to solve?
SPEAKER_02It is. You know, again, it doesn't really have much bearing on, you know, which method of payment reform we think works or doesn't work. But what it does have bearing on is whether or not a provider is willing to accept a new form of payment. What price are they willing to take for the service or uh procedure or care that they're going to deliver? Are they willing to enhance access and patient experience? Are they willing to play ball at all? And when you have an increasingly consolidated healthcare provider marketplace, which means that providers have the power, have the market power, and they are essentially calling the shots, it's not only price that suffers, but it can even be willingness to experiment and try new things that ultimately benefit those who use and pay for healthcare.
DavidThis is a nationwide problem, isn't it? It's not, we're not talking about a particular locality.
SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, I mean, market by market it varies, but I think we're at a place where about three-quarters of the healthcare markets, you know, geographic markets in the country, uh, we can say have high concentration of providers. So there aren't that many left where they are competing with each other and have that, you know, motivation, if you will, to continue to improve quality and reduce prices because they don't want to lose out on business, you know, to a facility down the street. Now we're more likely to be in a situation where the facility down the street is owned by the one, you know, in a few blocks away. And that's a very different dynamic.
DavidBut that smaller cohort, does that make it easier or more difficult for you to do the work you do? Or just different?
SPEAKER_02Well, it means that, you know, if if we looked at what CPR's agenda was 10 years ago, we were very focused on what could be done in the marketplace by purchasers in how they buy healthcare, how they, you know, ultimately, you know, design their benefits and their provider networks. That was, you know, let's say eight-tenths of our focus. We were already worried about provider consolidation. And in fact, one of the first things that we did was commission a study on how payments vary within and across markets to different healthcare systems using commercial data. And then within a couple of years of our existence, we held a national conference on provider market power. So we were already worried about it. But I think what's different now as we go into our second decade is that policy is going to take a lot more of our focus, meaning we have already begun examining policies, meaning laws, regulations, other types of policies that states can put into place to try to make their markets work better. There hasn't been as much activity at the federal level, aside from some important suits from the Department of Justice against some healthcare systems that, you know, have allegedly been using their market power to the detriment of the citizens around them. But we are, I think, increasingly going to be looking at how we can help states and even the federal government think through what kind of policies need to be in place if we're going to continue to have a quote unquote healthcare marketplace.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaperStrategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at ShiftShaperstrategies.com. That's ShiftShaperStrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidCould you give us an example of something that you've advised states that that might be an example of kind of the direction you think they should go?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I mean one place to look is you know, we've put out now, I think, seven report cards on state price transparency laws. And what we're looking for there is the availability of data that are accurate and easy to find for the average consumer to know how much a procedure or service is going to cost them before they go get care. And if you think about price transparency as something that every consumer has a right to have, but also as a fundamental building block for other policies that a either policymaker or even a purchaser might want to put into place. You know, you need to know how what prices are being charged in order to monitor whether or not there's anti-competitive behavior going on. Or as a purchaser, you need to know what the prices are to decide. You know, let's say you're interested in doing a direct contract with a health system. You're going to want to know, you know, not just the price, but of course, you know, the total cost of care for given episodes at different facilities to know who you might want to work with. So, you know, price transparency is sort of a fundamental need in many ways. And so some of the things we look at in terms of the laws are has the state mandated an all-pair claims database? Are the data going into the all-pair claims database being used in a way that is publicly available? Is there a website that makes it easy for consumers to look up specific procedures and facilities? Does it actually go so far as to incorporate what the patient's benefit design is when they're looking at that information? So, you know, states can you know be anywhere in the range from having passed no laws at all related to price transparency all the way to a state like New Hampshire that has, you know, a pretty sophisticated website that any anyone can go to to get this kind of information.
DavidWell, since you took us to New England, a state with which both of us are familiar is Massachusetts, and they've had a law on the books for some time now. And yet I don't know that there's anybody in Massachusetts that would necessarily point to it and say that from a consumer standpoint, it's been a rousing success. Are you familiar with Massachusetts? I'm sure you are, and and what's going on there and what the good and the bad of it is and what might be able to be improved, just as an example for other states.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, you know, as a part-time policy wonk, you know, the laws that were passed in Massachusetts are sort of a dream come true. And I've I've I've had the opportunity to present at one of the annual cost trend hearings there, held by their health policy commission, which was established by law. And, you know, the health policy commission, the data analysis institute that they've established and their sort of partnership and work with the Attorney General's office has given Massachusetts insight into the working of their market that's unparalleled in any other state. And it's true that information doesn't lead to a it isn't an instant fix. And that's one of the things that we often talk about is that if a provider has market power, even if there's transparency about, you know, how outrageous their prices are, or, you know, the fact that their prices don't correlate with a decent level of quality, it may not matter because they still have the market power. And so, you know, in Massachusetts, there's all kinds of information that, you know, uh state policymakers now have. But unless, you know, there's a case to be made that, you know, there is behavior that needs to be corrected or et cetera, you know, then it can only be so useful. But, you know, there are some proactive things they are able to do in Massachusetts too, in terms of, you know, looking before mergers happen at information and, you know, things that ACOs want to do and things like that. So I think it's, again, you know, you kind of have to have the right foundation from which to make sound policy. And so Massachusetts at least has created that for itself.
DavidThere's at least a significant cohort in the in my audience that always talks about direct contracting as a solution. Do you have a view on direct contracting and do you think it's a solution, or at least a broader long-term solution?
SPEAKER_02And I assume by direct contracting you mean that let's cut out the health insurance company or the health plan, and the employer or purchaser is directly contracted with a healthcare provider for services. Is that is that what you mean?
DavidYeah, especially with the resurgence of interest in self-funded plans in the small to mid market.
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. So, I mean, I, you know, I don't think we'll ever be a broad-scale solution. And it's for very simple reasons that most employer purchaser organizations do not have the sophistication and the bandwidth to do this on their own. You know, we have noticed, as I'm sure you have, that there's been a real growth in vendors, if you will, who are offering what I would call sort of semi-direct contracting, which is they've established contracts with providers. They might have selected them based on their quality performance. They may have agreed with them to use some kind of alternative payment model, like a bundled payment. Let's say it's for a you know, sort of center of excellence type program. And so the vendor comes with a provider network already established with better customer service and most likely a slightly better price than what the employer has been paying through the health plan. So it becomes relatively easy, although it requires a lot of education and communications with the plan participants, but it's become relatively easy for an employer to pick up a service like that. It's a very different thing if they are, you know, going to do a direct contract with a health system, let's say in an ACO-like format, where the provider is being held to account for quality performance and for their financial performance and they're in some kind of shared risk arrangement. That is a tremendous amount of work. So I just don't think that very many employers or other purchasers have what it takes to put those together. Now, in the rare circumstances that you've got an employer who does in a market where they have choices of providers or where they think they can get a better deal directly than a health insurance company can, you know, I think it can be very successful. And we have examples of that. So I'm not at all against it. I just don't think it'll ever become widespread because of how much work it is and how and how challenging it can be to put it together.
DavidWe've got about a minute left. What do you see in the near-term future in in terms of things that may be significant change?
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, how can we not mention the COVID pandemic, right? So I think the COVID pandemic has brought two very important things to light that are in my area of focus. One is that fee-for-service payment for providers can be very detrimental to them, even though they've liked it for a long time, because the more they do, the more care they provide, uh, the more they get paid. But when your patients stop coming, it can be very detrimental. And so I think we're at a place where there are many providers who are ready to make a jump into alternative models of payment. And I think that's a good thing for primary care. I think it's a good thing generally. So I think that's one big thing that has changed. The other is, of course, the way it laid bare the differences in care that different populations get and the different outcomes that they have. And let's let's give a very specific example. You know, black women are much more likely to die or suffer complications when it comes to childbirth. In a country where we should, you know, be way at the top in terms of our quality outcomes, but instead, we look like a third world country in many ways. So I think, you know, the COVID pandemic showed how different the outcomes can be for different populations. So I think in a good way, there's no turning back now in terms of us being able to ignore, you know, disparities and equity issues related to, you know, patients' race, socioeconomic status, or other factors.
DavidWell, I can't argue. It sure would be nice if something positive came out of all this craziness. And that's a great place to end our conversation today. Suzanne Del Banco, executive director of Catalyst for Payment Reform. Suzanne, thanks so much for sharing your expertise with our audience.
AnnouncerIt was a pleasure talking with you, David. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper Strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.