The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #356: Making Direct Contracting More . . . Direct - with Doug Geinzer
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week’s episode features a conversation with Doug Geinzer, Founder and President at High Performance Providers. Bundled plans provide cost benefits to providers while also connecting patients to quality healthcare. Direct contracting gives patients lower costs which are transparent upfront and provides options for destination medicine too. For an even more attractive offer, patients also get safety guarantees in high performance networks with proven reliability.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- 01:51 Direct contracting: Benefits for both purchasers and providers
- 09:06 Bundled plans for destination medicine
- 12:04 Tailored bundles, hospital transfer agreement, and superior service
- 16:04 Connecting patients to quality healthcare
Quotes:
04:32 “In a bundled arrangement, the terms are negotiated before the surgery even occurs. So there is a flat amount. It’s transparent and that purchaser writes one check rather than multiple checks.”
05:52 “The purchasers want it to be easy. The providers want to earn more money. And this satisfies both of their needs.”
07:43 “From the provider side, you’re eliminating your administrative department that is doing the billing, the coding, the appeals, the collections, everything that comes with it. They’re spending about 27% of what they’re billing collecting what they charged.”
08:52 “Patient doesn’t have any patient obligations, so the plan will waive the co-pay and the deductibles for the patient because they’re saving so much money and they know they’re going to be able to get that patient back to work sooner.”
19:23 “With all of the providers that I work with personally, they have to publish their outcomes every year. So now their outcomes are out there because we need to guarantee that we are in the upper 5 percentile of the practitioners in the United States.”
Plans often want to do direct contracting, but how do you get the providers on board? And who does that work? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. And now, here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidWith self-funded plans, there's an awful lot of plug-in type activity going on and a lot of new things coming to market. And the best ones, and there aren't a lot of those yet, but they're coming. The best ones help every part of the constituency and they save money. And one of those, if done properly, is something called direct contracting. Now, we've talked about direct contracting on the program a couple of times, and we've danced around it, but I don't think that we've ever found anyone who has implemented a complete end-to-end model that's actually working until today. And that's why we asked Doug Geinzer, who is founder and president at High Performance Providers, to join us. Welcome, Doug. Hey, I appreciate being on the show, David. Thanks. So let's level set for the audience. What is direct contracting?
SPEAKER_02So basically it's getting the two parties that are involved in the healthcare transaction better aligned. So if you think about it, you have a purchaser and you have a seller. So you have a provider and you have a payer. And many times it's all of those folks that are in the middle that create the distance and then also create the margin where that is not being passed along to the person delivering the care, which is the provider.
DavidSo let's look at a couple of different pieces of this. Why would a provider want to do this?
SPEAKER_02So at the end of the day, providers want to be just that providers. They have a desire to deliver their services. They don't necessarily want to be in the administrative business. And what they find is about 27% of their gross billings are spent in the collection phase. So they need to code, they need to submit, that typically gets denied, then they need to appeal, and then they also need to get into the collections business. They don't want to do that. They want to do exactly what they were trained to do, and that's deliver high-quality health care to the patients that they're seeing. Plus, when you do direct contracting, it many times will lead to a steady flow of patients to that provider, and it gives them access to larger patient population. So it's exactly what that provider wants, and it just eliminates the need to have, you know, seven administrative types for every provider that you have on staff.
DavidSo are payment terms part of the agreement with the physician?
SPEAKER_02Oh, absolutely. And for the payer, there's a lot of benefits there because they're able to buy those services for much cheaper than they could typically. And so in the world of uh surgery where I spend most of my time, typically the purchaser is able to get access to bundled surgeries for, you know, somewhere between 40 to 60 percent less than they would if they were hitting the PPO network.
DavidOkay, so you you hit another term called bundled surgeries. Again, let's level set. Some of the folks in our audience will know about this, but some won't. When you say bundled surgeries, what does that mean?
SPEAKER_02So when you look at a surgical event, there are typically four to five components to the billing process. So you have the facility that you're paying, then you have the provider or what we call the professional fee, who is the surgeon, you have the anesthesiologist, you have the implant if you're using some type of implant, whether that's orthopedic, cardiovascular, what have you, and then you have the other administrative fees. So in a traditional sense, a fee-for-service model, you're the purchaser is getting a bill from all of those. And many times something may happen, such as the anesthesiologist is out of network, so you're getting an extremely high bill. In a bundled arrangement, the terms are negotiated before the surgery even occurs. So there is a flat amount, it's transparent, and that purchaser writes one check rather than multiple checks. And so then it's up to the person that's receiving the bundle to pay the supply chain downstream. So they write a check that goes directly to the anesthesiologist, to the surgeon, to the facility, and then to the implant. And where the biggest savings are typically found is in that facility fee. And so there's a lot of things. Actually, CMS just announced yesterday that they're going to start allowing more procedures to be done in ambulatory surgery centers. Why is that? Because the hospital facility fee is many times a multiple, many times higher than what it is in an ambulatory surgery center. And so they're doing cases that could really be done in an ASC for a lower amount, and that's where the greatest savings are found in a bundled case arrangement.
DavidSo many years ago in a far-off land, I was a TPA. And I remembered that a lot of facilities and some surgeons and whatnot liked unbundled pricing because it ended up with a higher net cost for them. Is that still the case? And do you save money just by virtue of the fact that you bundle a procedure?
SPEAKER_02Well, so the purchasers want it to be easy. The providers want to earn more money, and this satisfies both of their needs. So when you're able to go to a purchaser, and let's just use orthopedics as an example, and you're able to go to a purchaser and say, hey, you know what? We're able to do a knee replacement for a $21,000 bundle. And in that, we're going to cover the surgery itself, and then we're going to cover nine days post-operative care, which includes the physical therapy, the home health. Now that purchaser knows exactly what that's going to cost, and many times that bundle comes with a guarantee as well. So it's good for the purchaser, and the provider knows that they're going to get paid the same exact amount every time, and they're not going to need to chase their money. And in many arrangements, that provider is getting paid either the day of service or within 15 days of delivering the service, as we're in a fee-for-service environment, that provider may not get paid for 60, 90 days.
DavidThat's interesting. Does the guarantee cover such things like post-surgical infection or re-admin or other things?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Of course, because again, it's in their best interest to deliver valuable health care where those complications go away, because if that patient were to come back, that's now on the provider's dollar. And so in a fee-for-service arrangement, if there's a complication, if there's an infection, guess what? That facility, that provider gets to bill additional money. So they make more money that way. In a bundled arrangement, they provide a guarantee. So the provider is guaranteeing that they're going to deliver a better health outcome for a lower bundled price.
DavidAnd so when you look at the overall savings, obviously some of it comes from bundling. Does the rest of it come from volume and the fact that the providers, especially the surgeons, don't have to treat and chase?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Again, you from the provider side, you're eliminating the your administrative department that is doing the billing, the coding, the appeals, the collections, everything that comes with it. They're spending about 27% of all of their the what they're billing collecting what they charged. And providers are tired of that. They just they want to be providers. So what's in it for the plan? What do these kinds of savings look like? Aaron Powell So typically a plan can expect to save 30 to 60% on that, and then they're going to give visibility to the validated health outcomes. So it's a bit different. So we always hear, you know, the PPO say, well, we have 93% of the providers in our network. Well, sometimes that's not a good thing, because some of those providers may not be high value or quality providers. So when you build a high performance network with providers that you have validated their outcomes and you know that they could deliver a better health outcome for a lower price, the purchaser wins, the provider wins, and frankly, the one that matters the most, the patient wins. Because that patient is able to get better coordinated care. And many times in these types of arrangements, patient is doesn't have any patient obligations. So the plan will waive the copay and the deductibles for the patient because they're saving so much money and they know they're going to be able to get that patient back to work sooner.
DavidDo you find that some plans also go another mile and kind of incentivize patients?
SPEAKER_02Of course, yeah. We we hear that a lot. So they will pay, and with a lot of the providers that I work with, the plan will pay for the patient and the companion to travel to the destination where they're going to receive care. And sometimes at upon completion of the surgery, they'll give that patient some type of incentive. Sometimes it's in the form of a fund to the HSA account. Sometimes it's a prepaid card. I've seen it a bunch of different ways, but for the purchaser, they're able to save a tremendous amount of money.
DavidSo in your model, at least, this isn't your friendly neighborhood hospital. This is a medical travel model?
SPEAKER_02A lot of what I do is medical travel, but at the same time, those same providers that I work with have similar bundled case arrangements with the local purchasing community. So we'll treat the local community as well. But a lot of it is for destination medicine.
DavidSo if I'm a benefit advisor and I want to bring this to a partially self-funded client and I want to work with you guys, what we're talking about is this sounds just too good to be true, but it's flying people to Las Vegas where you're located and getting care there.
SPEAKER_02So yes, and that's just for high-cost steerable events, is when you're going to put patients on a plane to travel or have them drive, you know, 100, 200 miles. So you're not going to do that for your smaller procedures. But when you're looking at joint replacement, spine surgery, bariatric surgery, some cardiovascular events, you will put a patient on a plane to travel. But if you're just looking at something as gallbladder removal, hernia repair, many times that could be done in the local market, and there are providers in that market that probably have some type of bundled case arrangement or you know transparent pricing.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaper Strategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. That's ShiftShaperStrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidSo can we talk for a little bit about what the patient experience is like? Because we all know that getting people to participate in these kinds of programs, even sometimes with incentives, is difficult. And, you know, you have to, I think, paint a really great picture of what the experience is going to be like, both in terms of the surgery itself and the rehab, if there is rehab, and also just in terms of how it flows. I mean, do I have to worry about hotel arrangements and travel arrangements and all of that nonsense? Or what does a really great patient experience look like in your world?
SPEAKER_02So there's varying degrees of that. So some of the providers that are more sophisticated in the process handle everything from what we call wheels down to wheels up. And so I'll give an example of that. So we have a bariatric surgery program where the plan is responsible for getting the patient to Las Vegas. That's their total responsibility. We then pick that patient up from the airport in a limousine. We take them to the hotel, of which we have three contracted hotels, and all of that is included in that five-day episode of care or that five-day bundle. So we handle everything from the wheels down until the wheels up. And so that just makes for a great patient experience. So that's these providers have net promoter scores in the 98-99 percentile, which is unheard of in healthcare. There are other providers that are maybe not as sophisticated, but they will contract with a facilitation company. And there's a couple of those around the country that are, they handle all of the everything from the flight arrangements to the hotel arrangements. They provide the prepaid card for any meals and entertainment when the patient's traveling. So again, you could contract that part out if the provider is not that sophisticated.
DavidAnd I know one of the questions that a lot of members have when they when they start exploring these kinds of services is well, what if something goes wrong? I mean, is there is there a hospital nearby? Do you guys have privileges at hospitals? How does that work? How do you allay those concerns?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so they all have what's called a transfer agreement with a hospital. And that is if there were a major complication, they could transfer that patient to the hospital and they're able to treat the patient there. And that the provider has privileges at that hospital. Now, the unique part is that doesn't happen very often. The clear difference, and I'm gonna beat up on the hospitals a little bit here, the clear difference between a provider that owns his or her own ASC and is managing that entire bundle compared to a hospital is night and day. When that same provider, and this comes down to the quality measures, when that same provider walks into the hospital, they many times do not know the surgical team that they're going to be working with. So they walk in and they don't know the anesthesiologist, the surgical first assist, the OR techs, the OR nurses, and so the time that it takes to do the procedure is lengthened. So that patient is under anesthesia a little bit longer. And then when that surgeon is done with the procedure, they're done because the patient then gets handed off to the hospital staff many times with a morphine drip and sent up to the second floor, and maybe is not ambulatory right away to start walking. So the recovery period takes a little bit longer. Sticking with like a joint replacement, when you bring that patient into an ambulatory surgery center that's a controlled environment, that surgical team has been together, working together for 10 plus years. So the patient's under anesthesia less time, they get up and they're literally walking an hour and a half, two hours after surgery. So they're well on their way to rehab. What does that do? It eliminates the complications, it eliminates the infections, it's just a better environment because the other thing is many of the surgery centers are single specialty surgery centers. So they don't have a GI case in there at nine in the morning and then another call it an orthopedic or a different case in there two hours later. So they're it's a controlled environment, and that benefits the the patient, it benefits the provider, and it benefits the plan.
DavidSo another patient-centered question, I guess, when you're talking about getting people to engage with these kinds of programs, I guess the natural response for some members would be to see to say, hey, this is this is just saving the plan a whole ton of money, and I'm glad I don't have any out of pocket, but what about quality? I mean, that's kind of the industry's catch-22, where people wrongly, in my opinion, equate quality with cost. How do you message that to members?
SPEAKER_02So that's where you many times hear skinny the network. We would prefer to call them high-performing networks. So a lot of the groups that I work with, you go through a very rigid screening process to be able to identify those centers of excellence. So I will call one out, Edison Healthcare. Tom Emmerich, who built Walmart's program, commercialized that into Edison Healthcare. If you are a provider within the Edison Healthcare Network, you are one of just a few because not every provider could just reach over and say, hey, I'd like to get credentialed with you. You go through a rigid screening process and you are one of just a few. So with the bariatric program that I work with, for example, it's just the Blossom Bariatrics and the Mayo Clinic. That's it. It's not every bariatric surgeon in the country that wants to participate, can participate. So from the patient experience perspective, they know that their employer, the plan, went to great length to find a partner that's going to highly select the best providers in the country to deliver them high quality care.
DavidAnd that's communicated to the to the members. Is there a middle person in all of these transactions? Is there kind of like a concierge that that sees them through from beginning to end and kind of makes sure that they don't have any questions and gives them a contact point?
SPEAKER_02Again, every contract's a little bit different. So in and using Edison Healthcare, yes, they have a very sophisticated team there that navigates the is in constant communication with the patient, constant communication with the plan and with the provider. So they handle that navigation. Now, going back to uh direct direct contract, sometimes our bariatric program is directly contracted with the plan itself, and they may not utilize an Edison or they may not utilize that concierge service. So we have over there, we have eight medical concierge. It's literally like a call center environment, and they're communicating back and forth. So it's highly coordinated care.
DavidI presume with the kind of savings that you're talking about, that this travel, this kind of high performance network, you try to reserve for high-cost procedures or frequent procedures.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So things think things that are steerable. So if somebody needs to get a knee replacement, a hip replacement, lower spine surgery, a lumbar surgery, or bariatric surgery, they know that they're going to need that. And so you're able to coordinate and plan that care out. Emergent, it doesn't quite work that way. But keep in mind, in when you're talking about direct contracting, there are direct contracts and markets for everything from imaging to laboratory to you name the procedure. And again, it's works the same way, but the patient's not necessarily traveling for that.
DavidWell, and and this is also a great move towards transparency for plans and patients, isn't it?
SPEAKER_02Oh, absolutely. Because a lot of times, like with all of the providers that I work with personally, they have to publish their outcomes every year. So now all of a sudden their outcomes are out there because we need to guarantee that we are in the upper five percentile of the practitioners in the United States in order to be able to earn those contracts. So everything is transparent and every everything is well communicated across the continuum of care.
DavidWhat kind of growth are you and your peers seeing in this kind of arrangement for these surgeries?
SPEAKER_02Right now, significant. Believe it or not, COVID has really accelerated the business. And it's because during the early onset of the pandemic, all of the uh elective surgeries were shut down. And so when they were bringing those back up, there was a protocol of what is, you know, phase one, phase two, phase three, and uh a lot of the procedures that are were being done in a hospital can now be done in an ambulatory surgery center. And during the COVID crisis, the last place a patient mentally wants to be is in a hospital. So the plans are going, okay, does that bariatric surgery does it really need to be in a hospital? Does that patient need, you know, a 48, 72 hour stay in a hospital, or can it be done safely in an ambulatory surgery center where they may not be exposed to the COVID cases that are being brought into that hospital? So we're seeing a lot of steerage cases that were once being done in a hospital environment are now being done in an ambulatory surgery center.
DavidCertainly lots to consider and a great place to end our discussion for today. Doug Geinzer, founder and president at High Performance Providers. Doug, thanks so much for sharing your expertise in this very exciting developing area with our audience.
SPEAKER_02David, I appreciate the opportunity to uh be on the show and thank you for all that you do. Thanks.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.