The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #351: Independent Imaging Centers Expose Savings and More - With Dr. Cristin Dickerson
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week’s episode features a conversation with Dr. Cristin Dickerson, Founding Partner of Green Imaging. There is a stigma that scanners in hospitals are better than freestanding facilities. However, there is no difference in hardware and professional skill in handling these machines. Knowing this can help patients and employers cut their medical spend for these services by two-thirds and enjoy greater satisfaction with their dedicated concierge.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- 03:22 Why doctor’s do NOT refer to freestanding imaging
- 06:06 How Green Imaging saves money and utilizes existing structures
- 08:18 There is no diagnostic advantage of using hospital scanners
- 13:23 Guaranteeing patient satisfaction with lower costs and better service
- 17:58 Future-proofing imaging centers
Quotes:
05:22 “The hospital price of an exam is somewhere, except for the specialty hospitals, is going to be somewhere around $1,300 to $1,600 and we’re about a third of that. And sometimes we’re lower here.”
06:46 “We’re Green for two reasons. We’re green because we save you money and we’re green because we also are using existing brick and mortar, not just adding more brick and mortar to the system.”
08:32 “Typically, the scanners are the same. Maybe the hospitals change them out a little more regularly because they’re incentivized to do so by the vendors, but there is really no diagnostic difference in scanners really within the last 20 years.”
13:06 “If it’s an employer sending the patient our way, there’s an invoicing process. But it’s really a much-simplified process. There’s not a two-day wait for an auth and all the complicating factors that happen when you’re in a hospital.”
How can unique imaging networks save everyone money while delivering a great user experience? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. And now here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidOn this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Dr. Kristen Dickerson. She is the founding partner of Green Imaging, and it's an interesting model for providing lower cost, but still high quality and most importantly, maybe patient convenient imaging. It's a kind of a different model, as I said, so I thought we'd invite Dr. Dickerson on to talk about what her background was and how she kind of got to where she's getting and what the business model is. And with that, welcome, Kristen.
SPEAKER_02Thanks for having me. Excited to be here.
DavidIt's a pleasure. Talk a little bit about your background because I think that kind of sets the story of kind of how you went forward from there.
SPEAKER_02Sure. I'm a traditional radiologist, general radiologist, although I trained at MD Anderson. And so really I have a sub-specialty which is oncologic imaging, cancer imaging. And I started my practice with a 50 doctor multi-specialty group in the heart of the Texas Medical Center. And I went there because I'd never wanted to get involved with the business of medicine. And about five years in, we had a new business office manager who brought a box of yellow tickets into my office. And these were the tickets, these were the procedures that took me away from my family at night and weekends that I was doing over at the hospital. And she said, we can't bill for any of these because the hospital isn't giving us enough demographic information. And suddenly I got interested in the business of medicine. It was literally millions of dollars sitting there in that box. And so I, within a couple of years, I was the president of this multi-specialty group. I had a CEO and CFO under me and learned the business of medicine. But more importantly, we were a self-funded healthcare provider. We had a Blue Cross Blue Shield network, but we were self-funding. So we were paying for the medical care for our employees. And I had a brilliant CEO who had the idea to start pulling as much care out. This is when deductibles were skyrocketing, premiums were skyrocketing. And she had the brilliant idea to pull as much care as we could out of that Blue Cross Blue Shield plan, do it ourselves, have some strategic partners do it more affordably, and hold our premiums down. And we were able to do that. And so that was really the beginning of the company that I now own and run.
DavidYou know, it's interesting because when you talk about imaging in particular, oftentimes I've had this happen. I know lots of people have had it happen. I ran a TPA for nine years, so I saw the claims come in. Lots of people end up being referred by doctors to hospitals. Is there a reason why doctors, at least in some locales, haven't quite embraced the notion of local or freestanding imaging? There absolutely is.
SPEAKER_02Around 70% of doctors are either employed by or subsidized by healthcare systems. And in those formulas, even though it's not supposed to be that way, are the formulas for what they're reimbursed, are the number of referrals to that hospital system. And so, yes, it's a dirty game, but there is a definite reason for that.
DavidYou know, between that comment and the fact that I just got off another interview talking about pharmacy, I'm going to need to take a shower when we're done. Yeah. It's just it's so non-patient-centric. And yet today, as we finally started to build consumers, at least a little bit, it's all about user experience and removing friction. And it seems to me that all that does is introduce friction, especially if you're self-funded and you start seeing those claims.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. The variation we we find that it is market specific. The price of an exam, you know, is almost always three times greater in a hospital system than it is in a self-funded healthcare plan because it's largely in hospital systems, those claims, three times greater than the typical outpatient imaging center. And that varies from market to market, whereas in Boston, you've got, you know, 90% of the imaging happening at Mass General and Boston Children's, you know, very hospital dominant and they have very high pricing. You know, it's like MD Anderson, you know, $9,000 for your MRI. In that setting, you know, the typical outpatient imaging center is only going to be about a, is still going to be about a third of that. So it's going to be higher. We had a very hard time finding independent imaging centers there that would work with us. But in Houston, where we've been doing this for almost eight years now, you know, the hospital price of an exam is somewhere, except for the specialty hospitals, is going to be somewhere around 60, 1,300 to $1,600. And we're about a third of that. And sometimes we're lower here just because we happen to the only imaging center in our network that we own is in Houston. And we have a $250 MRI there.
DavidWell, I mean, I had some medical care a couple of years ago. I'm in New England and I ended up at Mass General. And if you had told me that the Mass General price for imaging was $1,300 to $1,600, I would have applauded. Right. Because it's, I mean, that's unheard of. So let's let's talk a little bit about kind of how how your business built out. Because you so you you recognize this need and you recognize that, especially for self-funded employers, but for patients as well, you needed to get them out of that hospital setting. How did you start acquiring centers or buying time or whatever it is you're doing? You you had alluded in the pre-interview to kind of using a travelosity model. What's that all about?
SPEAKER_02Well, radiologists are considered consultants in the Stark laws. And so radiologists are able to do lease arrangements that others could not do with imaging centers. So, you know, when I looked at building my own centers, you know, there were so many centers around town that were at 50% capacity. Why would I do that? Why wouldn't I lease the extra time at a discount from these scanners that were sitting, you know, empty half the day? And so that's what enables us to pass along, you know, those savings. So we're we're green for two reasons. We're green because we save you money, and we're green because we also are using existing brick and mortar, not just, you know, adding more brick and mortar to the system.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaperStrategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at Shiftshaperstrategies.com. That's Shiftshaperstrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidSo I want to delve back into the business model a little bit, but let's talk about the concern that, again, as I said, we're just starting to build baby consumers, even after all of these years. I mean, it was 15 years ago that I was Southeast Director of Consumerism at Humana, and we were just kind of embarking on our on our visit. And some of our folks, some of my friends at Definity and other companies, were trying to push the consumer thing. But there's still this notion among some people that if you don't go to a hospital, you're not getting a quality image and that you're not getting a quality read. Can you talk about both of those things?
SPEAKER_02I can. The quality of the image, you know, typically the scanners are the same. Maybe the hospitals change them out a little more regularly because they're incentivized to do so by the vendors. But there is really no diagnostic difference in scanners, really, within the last 20 years. You know, 3T magnets, there's a lot of glory around those. Really, in my personal opinion, I think breast and prostate imaging and imaging for endometriosis are the things that it really there is a significant difference if the magnet is tuned that way. 3T scanners can be either tuned for better image quality or tuned for uh quicker turnaround time, you know, less time on the scanner. Well, what are hospitals doing? They want to get as many patients through the door as they can. So they're they're just using the the speed differential, not so much the image quality differential on a 3T. If you look at what orthopedists are putting in their own MRI centers, they put in 1.5 Tesla magnets. As much as, you know, all the glam we hear about a 3T, there are some issues with some, you know, it's a little more motion sensitive, it's a little more artifact, you know, there's some artifacts that emerge. So really that's not such a big deal. And the really cool thing that's happening, the place I see AI really impacting imaging the most quickly is software. The imaging center that we have, we're um beta testing some software that actually can turn a 1.5 Tesla magnet to the image quality that a 3T can achieve if it's tuned that way. And so, and it also decreases scan time. So, one of the really, I think, amazing things AI can do is resurrect some of this uh older equipment and you know make sure that this equipment hits the same standards that the hospital systems have. The other thing is ACR accreditation, it is standard across the industry, and you know, we're held to very high standards in our protocols, in our continuing education, and this starts getting into the radiologist piece of it. You know, in we have to send test cases across to make sure that our image quality is great and there aren't artifacts. And the fallacy about the radiologists is typically you're gonna have the same, the same radiologists reading in hospitals and outpatient centers. There are some radiologists, you know, that only read in outpatient centers, but that that doesn't mean that you know they haven't been hospital radiologists for years as well. So, you know, it's really and and our standards are very high, and you know, we have to be board certified, and most radiologists now are fellowship trained as well.
DavidWasn't there a move a few years ago to offshore some of the reading of some of these scans?
SPEAKER_02There was, and uh, that proved not to work out well. We we have such excellent training here, and I think Medicare first, you know, outlawed it, and then I think a lot of most of the major payers followed suit. So I don't know of much of that happening at this point in time.
DavidSo let's talk a little bit about the patient experience, because so much of what's going on today that's being that's driving good healthcare is removing friction from the patient experience. And it sounds like that's part of what your business model is. From a patient perspective, what does this look like?
SPEAKER_02From a patient perspective, you know, it really took us about six years to figure it out and for the technology to come along far enough that we can actually say now that we offer easy, affordable medical imaging. And what we do now is a patient can take a snapshot with their phone of their doctor's order and their benefits card if that's applicable. If they're self-pay, you know, they just let us know that. And they take that snapshot and they can securely text it to our main phone number. And that gets pulled up into a messaging system that's part of our enterprise-wide referral management system. And so that patient, we can message back and forth with that patient. About 85% of our patients are completely scheduled using that messaging system. And so, you know, they get a few screening questions, they get some questions about, you know, zip code and prefers days and times for the exam. And in about, you know, 20 to 30 minute exchange, we can frequently have them, you know, the imaging center has a voucher, they have the patient's order, they have all the information they need, and the patient has, you know, their voucher that tells them where to go, when, what the prep is, you know, what to expect. And that referral is complete from our end. You know, we do have to close out the referral. We do make sure that the patient completed the exam. You know, if it's a an employer sending the patient our way, you know, there's an invoicing process, but it's really a much simplified process. They're not, there's not the you know, two-day wait for an auth and all the complicating factors that happen when you're at a hospital.
DavidThat's great. Do you also find that there's higher patient satisfaction with the staff interactions in a smaller standalone setting than in a hospital?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. And, you know, my company's Google reviews almost every time the person who they interacted with, the concierge uh staff members called out by name. And I think that speaks to really, you know, I believe in consumerism, but it this is complicated. Even referring doctors, about 40% of orders are incomplete or incorrect. And so, you know, not only do we have radiologists on that platform in the background reviewing the orders and making sure the appropriate exam is ordered and that if it if it needs contrast, it has it. If it doesn't need contrast, that we remove that. There's a lot that goes into this. And when patients are under healthcare stress, you know, that's not when they really want to be uh exhibiting consumerism. They really want somebody to help them. And um, you know, that's really become evident to us that having that, you know, world-class concierge service makes such a difference to the patients.
DavidOne of the things that often comes up with patient populations is discounting for cash for cash payers. How do you feel about that? Do you guys have a policy on it, or is it one price fits all and that's the price?
SPEAKER_02You know, we discount ever for everybody. We keep our margins as slim as we can. Actually, patients who are shopping for care take a lot of time and energy. You know, they frequently go back and forth between three or four imaging centers. They don't respond. You know, it's not that we don't want them, but it takes a lot of work to get those patients scheduled. Then on the other hand, you know, in an ERISA plan, you know, we're not gonna have any patient bad debt. We're gonna, you know, that that's gonna be guaranteed payment. Now it's gonna be payment six weeks down the line, but I'm not gonna have a, you know, merchant fee. There are a lot of things about that patient. So we've really gone to one fee schedule. We do sometimes offer specials when we have an imaging center that asks us, hey, if we cut our price here, can you, you know, can you get some more patients our way? And in imaging centers, you know, the viability of these imaging centers is super important to us. I mean, our whole business model is dependent on it. We do contract with a few hospital systems, but the outpatient imaging centers are are really the the meat and potatoes of what we do. And, you know, we don't we let them set their own prices because they know the economics of their practice, and I know the economics of their practice since I own an MRI center. Price of helium has doubled this year, and they're really, you know, and yet the reference, Medicare, is actually cutting imaging reimbursement once again this year. So, you know, there are a lot of market forces out there, and but we feel like typically the work of a direct contract patient and a self-paid patient are about the same overall.
DavidDo you find that you tend to develop relationships and referrals among patients that you treat in this kind of a setting versus a hospital?
SPEAKER_02We do. You know, it definitely we do not advertise. We do no advertising to individual patients. You know, we do support a website that has good information for them about, you know, how to shop for imaging, but we don't do any advertising. So, and we have yet we have, you know, growth year after year. And not as much growth, you know, our our explosion in growth has been in the employer market because employers are really, you know, reaching the breaking point and being able to afford health care for their employees. But certainly, you know, we have a loyal referral base, especially in Houston, where we've been doing this for seven years.
DavidBut you have a network that's beyond Houston.
SPEAKER_02Oh, we do. We're national. We're contracted with 1,400 imaging centers. But if we have an employer who has an employee somewhere where we don't have one, we actually, as the experts, shop for care for that patient and find, you know, an affordable high-quality exam for that patient.
DavidOh, that's that's great. So we've got just a couple minutes left. A broad question: where do you see the future moving? And do you see this model being applicable? I know that you, you know, you've got stark laws and things to deal with, but do you see this model as being applicable to other medical specialties?
SPEAKER_02I do. You know, I think sometimes the ease, you know, if you are an ENT and you're providing direct care, you know, through something like a model like Texas Free Market Surgery, it behooves that entity who's serving that employer to also hold down the cost of imaging for that employer. And that might look something like working with us, or it might look like going down the, you know, going down to the imaging center down the street and seeing if you can, you know, work out great pricing with them.
DavidSo what does the future look like? Are uh, you know, you talked a little bit about 3T machines and and you know, there's technology that always changes and the software that you guys are piloting. Where do you where do you see the future of imaging going in the next three to five years?
SPEAKER_02Well, my hope in the outpatient imaging world is that we can quit replacing all this equipment, you know, every five to ten years and hold down costs that way and also get im scan time down, you know, with by increasing computing power. I think radiologists, I hate what I'm seeing with radiologists, which is, and then this is a, you know, this is a podcast in and of itself, but you know, the mergers and acquisitions in the space of radiology groups is something that's actually going to hurt radiology, but it's gonna help the independent radiologists, you know, stay alive in this outpatient world because the care is so much better if you're not on a dashboard reading an MRI.
DavidYeah, well, that's that's definitely true. And you get to you get to provide more individualized attention, I imagine, as well.
SPEAKER_02We do, definitely.
DavidGreat place to end our chat for today, Dr. Kristen Dickerson, founding partner at Green Imaging. We thank you for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience. Enjoyed it.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.