The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #339: Paying the Claim After Paying the Claim - with Jordan Hersh
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week’s episode features a conversation with Jordan Hersh, Vice President, Enterprise Solutions at Vālenz. Renegotiating out-of-network claims can provide cost savings to members. On the plans side, Jordan also explains how offering discounts can help ensure timely payments. If insurers communicate the benefits of staying in-network and offering incentives, this can avoid confusion with the EOB and arm members with the knowledge of how post-claims adjudication works.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- 02:01 Reference-based pricing: Finding the right fit for self-funded plans
- 04:26 Defining narrow networks and high-performance networks
- 08:31 Saving money: Renegotiating out-of-network claims and offering discounts
- 13:42 Communicating costs to members and incentivizing in-network claims
- 15:44 Transparency in out-of-network claims
- 18:42 How much savings can a self-funded plan expect?
Quotes:
05:10 “Readmission rates, complication rates, mortality rates, we’re taking that into account and making sure that when people do people stay in-network or go to the panel of those high-performance network partners, they’re getting top tier coverage.”
08:46 “Depending on the primary PPO network regardless of broad network or network of concise nature, there’s going to be out-of-network medical claims. And that can cost self-funded plans a lot of money if it’s not managed correctly.”
09:45 “Some plans we’ve seen pay out-of-network claims at full bill charges, some take a usual customary approach. Having a much more direct and aggressive approach can really be a game-changer for self-funded plans and materially impact the bottom line.”
10:38 “So being able to achieve a discount, that can also assure them that they’re going to be paid and have a little bit more clarity on how the member responsibly can be split up. Oftentimes we see self-funded plans offering some type of incentive.”
19:22 “So a plan with a medical spend with a million dollars, implementing these types of tools into the right education training to the members, could reduce their overall medical spend by about 25%.”
What is post-claim adjudication? Why does it matter? And how much savings can it generate? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. And now, here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidOn this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Jordan Hirsch. Jordan is the vice president of Enterprise Solutions at Valence. Now, we've talked a lot, especially in this era of increased interest in self-funded plans, about deconstructing plans and all of the little bits and pieces that happened that used to just be kind of packaged up in one nice package for which you paid way too much money and got oftentimes arguably way too little. But there's a whole world of stuff that most advisors don't see that goes on behind all of that. And as a former TPA, I saw some of how that sausage was made. And that's where Jordan's company works. They kind of are trying to figure out ways to do things after claims hit and some stuff before claims hit, but it's mostly behind-the-scenes stuff. It's not stuff that might be obvious to a client. So with that long-winded introduction, welcome, Jordan. Thank you, David. I appreciate it. Thanks for having me. My pleasure. So so how much work actually does go on post-claim? I mean, most a lot of people think, well, I, you know, I go to the doctor, they circle a little code on their pad, the insurance company gets the bill, I pay my portion, they pay their portion, life is good.
SPEAKER_02Right. Yeah. I mean, and and really there's a lot. There's a lot that happens behind the scenes, like you mentioned in introduction. Everything needs to go on with really understanding, you know, the best network to even choose from, you know, I think from an advisor perspective as well, about how to make the best decision for that, for that self-funded plan. So, you know, there's a lot of work that goes into really before the TPA or the administrator needs to receive that claim to adjudicate and pay it. And that that's really where our organization valence comes in and really provides a lot of value.
DavidSo a lot of people have talked about reference-based pricing. I mean, that guy, I think they would fit that into this bucket. And the the questions that I always get is A, is reference-based pricing a sledgehammer when you need a scalpel? And B, is it sustainable? Is it a is a sustainable model? What's your position on those things?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think in the right regions, reference-based pricing can be a sustainable model and the right fit for a self-funded plant. The route that we've taken, we've seen a lot of uh adoption in the in the in the self-funding community, has been instead of you know really taking that reference-based pricing approach and going full bore with it, you know, let's understand if we can achieve strong and advantageous reimbursement amounts at a percent of Medicare or at a reference-based price, but that's agreed to with specific health systems and really build those client-centric networks that are agreed upon and really members aren't putting any type of harm's way when it comes to the payment and reimbursement.
DavidYou know, it's it's funny. If you talk to proponents of RBP, they say, well, that hardly ever happens. Client uh patients almost never get calls for balanced bills. But I I I tend to hear about it more often than not. Do you think that they're minimizing that problem or that it's still a real problem?
SPEAKER_02Again, I I you know, not to be political, but I do think it it's regional in nature. I think Northern California, let's say Monterey County, the amount of provider appeals based on a reference-based rate compared to, let's say, uh Houston, Texas, I do think there is there is a significant delta between that. But I, you know, from what I've seen as well, David, I would agree with you that what I've seen in practice usually is is much there's more volume of appeals and balance bills than than some of the data suggests coming out from some vendors.
DavidThat's interesting. So another technique that a lot of people play around with is either narrow networks or high performance networks. Some people conflate the two of those. I think they're different things. Can you give us some some background on those two things?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think you know, from a high performance network, I think narrow network, my the connotation for me is more again, just a narrow, narrow or concise panel of providers that, you know, with without really looking at uh quality. I think quality is kind of the big X factor there. And when we look at high performance networks, um it's really combining both cost and the reimburs the reimbursement piece and also the quality aspect as well. And so how can we route, steer, and incentivize using the plan design members to see those providers or facilities that are in network? But how can we make sure that key metrics like readmission rates, complication rates, mortality rates, we're taking that into account and making sure that when people do stay in network or go to the panel of those high performance network partners, they're getting uh top-tier coverage and top two care.
DavidHow often are people wowed by the fact or amazed by the fact that uh that you and I have known and a lot of other practitioners know that there's this inverse relationship in medical care between cost and quality. And you know, you sell them quality and then they all of a sudden realize holy cow, it's actually cheaper.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, all the time. And I think probably a lot, you know, you and maybe a lot of listeners, you know, I saw the RAN study that came out uh a week or two ago. It also came, it had that was one part of their executive summary. It said uh that there is really no correlation between cost and quality. And I think there's uh, you know, from the data we see in the how we, you know, uh build and power some of these high performance networks, there are some what we would consider low quality facilities with some great and high performing physicians and providers there, and vice versa. There's you know, the some really high, high characteristic facilities out there with some very low, low performing providers there too. So you're gonna get a mix regardless of of where you go seek care. But again, from what we've seen, I think from what other sources have seen, there's really no correlation between cost and quality out there.
DavidAre you seeing any let up in the uh medical groups trying to stop the creation of specialty hospitals? I think if if we had had specialty hospitals and generalist hospitals a long time ago, this notion of cost and quality might have been settled. But I know that a lot of the big hospitals, especially the chains, don't really want the specialty hospitals because they feel that they're taking away their one and duns.
SPEAKER_02Agreed. Agreed. I mean, we're we're seeing that. We see, you know, we partner, I guess, transparently with with some of the larger health systems out there as well. But I'll agree with you, David. I I think for them, having kind of your more general acute care facilities out there in the market, that it it makes things a little bit more ambiguous. And if we had more specialty facilities, we would be able to probably derive, you know, at least have a better shot at saying cost and quality, there there's a there's a stronger correlation.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaperStrategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at ShiftShaperstrategies.com. That's Shiftshaperstrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidAll right, so let's jump over a little bit and talk about an area that a lot of people may not be aware of if they haven't been on that side of the Wizard of Oz curtain, as I call it. This this ability to renegotiate out-of-network claims after the fact. How big uh an opportunity is that for plans to save money and what's that like? How does that process work?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no good question. So, yeah, I mean, really depending on the primary network, the primary PPO network, regardless of it's a broad network or a network in Dice and Nature, there's going to be out-a-network medical claims. And that can cost plans, self-funded plans, you know, a a lot of money if it's not managed correctly and there's not the right cost containment pieces uh in in place. And so that's something we've been doing for a while. And typically we see maybe, depending on your standard plan, maybe 10 to 15% of medical claims do fall in that that out of network bucket. Um, so really what you know the flow would be is to really understand, you know, the claims would would flow into an organization and they would be deemed out of network. And then it would be really using you know bill review tactics, even some supplemental medical networks that can achieve a discount, or through negotiation to be able to achieve a discount on those medical claims. And is that not only benefiting the plan, but it's also benefiting the member as well when it comes to you know having a better economic outcome to those claims. So, you know, not either paying some plans we've seen pay out of network claims at full bill charges, some take like a usual and customer approach, having a much more direct and aggressive approach can can really be a game changer for self-funded plans and materially impact the bottom line.
DavidWell, for advisors to understand though, what's what's the incentive for the provider or the facility in actually granting a lower rate?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a good question. I mean, a lot of the times uh they're they're looking for the a cell-funded plan to actually utilize something that's in place. So that could be using a supplemental network discount. They just they're looking to actually being paid. And many of the facilities that we deal with or providers that are at a network, when they're at a network, they they know that a large portion of the payment may fall back on the member, so a large member responsibility, or they're they're curious about when they would actually get paid by uh the self-funded plan, you know, via via their administrator. So being able to achieve a discount, that can also assure them that they're going to be paid and have a little bit more clarity on how the member responsibility can be split up. Oftentimes we self see self-funded plans offering some type of incentive in terms of how either uh the timely payment or how quick or the breakdown on payment from the plan to the member based on if they will negotiate and accept a discount.
DavidThat's interesting. So as you start looking, or a TPA in with your help, as you start looking at these this bushel of out-of-network claims, this 10 to 15%. How do you select those claims to go after? Is it solely dollar value based, or are there other considerations like condition or other selectors?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, you know, I think, you know, for a self-funded plan, you know, typically they they look at the dollar base. You know, there's some other factors that we take in, but I think from a peer to be able to prioritize, be able to achieve the best type of discount, the plan obviously has the most liability for those larger dollar claims. So those kind of come to the front of the queue to be able to negotiate, again, you know, use clinicians to be able to evaluate the how the medical claim was billed, look at supplemental notes about exactly what happened with that episode of care. You know, we do also and others out there look at uh you know what exactly occurred. So CPT codes, the other type of diagnosis codes to be able to prioritize that. But transparently, you know, from a planned perspective, they want to do the best they can to minimize their their liability. So typically we prioritize that, typically by bill charges.
DavidAnd does the plan set a dollar threshold?
SPEAKER_02Typically, no. I mean, typically when when plans come to us and other folks out in the market, they they look to see, hey, you know, we if if you can't do anything to an added network medical claim, we're probably gonna again use, you know, usual and customer amount or maybe even put pay the claim at full bill charges. So really the expectation for many of our clients are saying, hey, how many, you know, a big KPI or big metric they look at is saying, how many claims can you achieve a discount on? We send you 100 claims, can you achieve uh 95, 95% of those claims we sent to you? You achieved a discount that were on a at a network claim. So really at the end of the day, you know, the expectation, what they're looking for is us to again prioritize and and and spend most of the time on those larger dollar claims. But if they send us a $250 dermatologist bill, the hope is that we can at least achieve a discount on that and and save the plan some money.
DavidSo from what you from what you said, I would assume then that plans are looking at this as a long-term proposition rather than a holy cow, we just got a $400,000 facility bill.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I mean, I think again, it's you know, we want to do the best we can to steer out, incentivize members to stay in network. But again, if they do go out of networking, it will happen regardless of the plan, regardless of where the location is. The plan wants uh to be able to achieve a discount on those medical claims. And, you know, I think that's that's again a long-term view and a you know really, really important cost of payment strategy to make sure that the plan can be sustainable in the long term.
DavidDoes any of this repricing ever, I mean it must get messaged to the member? And how do you mem how do you message that? And do they just find it totally confusing?
SPEAKER_02It is confusing. I mean, I I think you know, every everything we probably in, I'm sure in past interviews and and conversations, a lot of this is confusing. In terms of how it's communicated to the member, you know, that that's something we work typically with the administrator on is passing the right type of uh EOB messages across to the administrator. So members, when they get the actual EOB, they're able to understand that the claim was at a network, but also that Valens or whatever uh organization is achieving uh uh an at-a-network discount on the claim, applied a 50% off-build charges or 175% of Medicare uh type of reimbursement structure to the medical claim. But typically, again, what self-funded plans you know usually do, you know, do apply much leaner benefits if they do stray from the primary network.
DavidSo do you advise employers to do any communication of this fact to members up front, or would doing that lead them to be more lax about whether they stay in or out of network?
SPEAKER_02So we we do advise that they do communicate by saying if you do go out of network, one, you'll have benefits. And two, we do work with an organization to be able to achieve a discount or you know, work on your behalf to get to get a DS out on out-of-network claim. But I think again, between using plan design, it's it's a very, very strong incentivizer to ensure that members become healthcare consumers and and do stay in networks. So it is communicated as a benefit to the member, but again, during open enrollment meetings, during ongoing communication education sessions, it's it's strongly it's there's a big answer to the why you want to stay in the primary network or in that high-performance network.
DavidI mean, have you seen uh a significant effort at transparency? I mean, you know, you we all hear the phrase that medical care is one of the few things in life that you always get before you know what the price is. Because, you know, especially if somebody gets a dread diagnosis, they go where the doctor tells them to go. They don't really think about whether it's in network or out of network, oftentimes. It's a dire situation. Are there any efforts at transparency that are helping that? Either transparency on cost or on quality?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, we we try both. I mean, with with our high performance networks, when I'm seeing it more and more in the market, you know, you you see tools, Castlight Health out there and many other transparency tools. But what we try to, especially again with with our high performance networks, is allow, you know, through some of our uh a program when when uh it's NAVACE, it's more of kind of care concierge, allow our members to interact directly with those folks and understand what type of reimbursement, if I'm gonna go in and I'm gonna have a colonoscopy in Northern California, what are my you know in network options? And then also based on you know derivative of Medicare and those types of reimbursement models, what should I expect for being the total allowable and how that would affect me as a member? So I think from a cost perspective, it's it's absolutely crucial and something that uh we're gonna see more and more of as an industry from a transparency perspective. And then also on quality, I mean, same thing again, like I spoke about earlier, you know, some very, very high quality uh facilities and uh surgery centers do have some low performing physicians. So we try to dive a little bit deeper too through some of the tools that we have about saying not only are we do we gonna want to route you to a high quality facility, but we also want to ensure that surgeon is a high performing surgeon on there. So we dive a little bit deeper than just routing someone to a facility that that gets well marks. We want to ensure that that their physician or their surgeon also is very well performing.
DavidAre you seeing any plans mandate interaction with a care coordinator for certain conditions?
SPEAKER_02I guess out of our book of business, I haven't seen any plans mandate that. I've seen incentives though. I've seen plans incentivize through you know additional contribution, through, you know, it could be just even external gift cards if there's interaction with that care coordinator or with that, that, that care navigator. And really, you know, what what again, it can really ensure that not only are they going to an end network provider and help coordinate that visit, but also it's ensuring that they're going to and getting quality care from a high, high performance surgeon. So I haven't seen any mandate, but I have seen a decent amount of plans actually provide incentives to be able to utilize this benefit that they offer of a concierge or a navigator.
DavidAnd do you have any idea what kind of engagement that gets?
SPEAKER_02Not off the top of my head, you know, just uh a swag or just off the, you know, a guess would be about maybe 50-50 of members for either in-or-outpatient type of care engaging with with a navigator, but I haven't actually run those numbers in terms of pure engagement.
DavidSo we've got just about a minute or two left. And I wonder if if we were to wrap all of this up, if a plan were to employ all of these methodologies, what might their average savings be in a plan year, in a treaty year?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, from what we've seen, especially also when you combine the high performance network with uh with the added network type of containment. And also you put you know uh a strong care management solution on the front end. We you've seen a lot of stop-loss cares also rate and evaluate, you know, networks that are uh high performance in scope and be able to pass that savings on the self-funded plan. So what we're seeing is you know, really 15 to sometimes 25% yield when it comes to better overall health care spend. So, you know, a plan with a uh a medical spend of a million dollars, implementing these types of tools and the right education and training to the members, we'll see, you know, we'll could could uh reduce their overall medical spend about 25%.
DavidWell, that's a tidy sum, and it's something that everybody ought to think about, especially those advisors who are working with clients who are in this arena. Great time to end our interview. Jordan Hirsch, Vice President of Enterprise Solutions at Valens. Jordan, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with our audience. Yeah, thanks, David. Thanks for having me.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.