The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #318: Direct Primary Care in the Employer Market: How to Get There - With John Collier
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This episode of The ShiftShapers Podcast is called "Direct Primary Care In the Employer Market: How To Get There" with John Collier, President and CEO at Proactive MD, a direct primary care (DPC) organization.
John explains the possibilities of DPC that integrates administrative processes, delivers clinically effective healthcare while still remaining financially viable for stakeholders, and promotes patient empowerment through a "patient advocate".
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- 03:58 How to make DPC widely accepted by employers
- 07:33 Creating a system that streamlines administrative processes
- 10:46 Making DPC attractive to physicians & employers alike
- 16:47 The role of the Patient Advocate to engage & empower
Quotes:
04:59 “Truthfully, while they’re great phenomenal physicians that I’m sure they have incredible clinical outcomes in their DPC practice, they don’t fully understand the business case for what a self-funded employer is facing.”
07:51 “At its core, direct primary care was invented and built to reunite a patient and a physician relationship, in a partnership.”
08:22 “If we’re solely focused on the patient and what is right for that patient, let’s leverage that data to help them take this patient by the hand and walk through the care continuum as primary care was designed to do.”
15:41 “When direct primary care physicians and these groups are working with employers, the care doesn’t stop at that on-site clinic.”
18:15 “The care team would consist, and they would be partners with that physician, is a licensed clinical social worker that’s going to work with the physician to engage a population.”
What are the challenges and opportunities in bringing direct primary care to the employer market? And how can we help our DPC docs understand and plan for that opportunity? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaperStrategies.com. And now, here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidOn this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with John Collier. John is president and CEO of ProactiveMD, which is a direct primary care organization. And they're working in some areas that I think the audience is really interested in and is very critical. And a direct primary care, as those of you who are long-term listeners know, is a particular passion of mine. As one of our guests said a number of episodes ago, we are slowly and inadvertently creating folks who are functionally uninsured. They have an ID card, but they've got huge deductibles and not enough income to really cover it. And DPC, while it's been pretty widely adopted by the individual population, has yet to really make significant inroads in most places in the United States into the employer population. And we thought we'd bring John on and get his insight into what it is and how it's going to have to be configured so that it can meet the needs and penetrate finally that practice and help those folks with big deductibles and smaller paychecks. So with that, welcome to the podcast, John. Thanks, Dave. It was a pleasure to be here. We appreciate you spending time with us. So as you see it from your vantage point, somebody who specializes in the DPC area, what's the challenge?
SPEAKER_02Oh, I think there's there's a multitude of challenges, but you know, the exciting thing is I as I see the the challenges getting less and less. And I've been in this at this for a long time and been very passionate about DPC since about 2010. And I see um this world evolving and getting, you know, more and more attention. And employers are really looking to solutions like this, and it's really about education and really, you know, educating employers, educating physicians, and letting them know that there's other options and other care models out there. I'm actually very, very optimistic for the future of direct primary care and for primary care in general.
DavidSo the direct primary care model, as I said, is has been fairly well accepted and is gaining more steam. And it I know it's geographically diverse too, isn't it? I mean, some areas have have grabbed onto it more than others.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean you look at some areas like Denver, and it it's a hotbed of direct primary care, and it is definitely geographically spread out. But if you look on there's a website, dpcfrontier.com, that has a mapper on there, it really is, and it's exciting to see the direct primary care movement spreading all over the country.
DavidSo how does DPC? I know, I know, I mean, as you do, I know an awful lot of DPC docs, and I know that they've gone into the DPC model because it's how they really wanted to practice. It's kind of the practice model that they envisioned when they were in medical school. And it it's really a relationship business and a time business. So it's working well, I think, for individuals, but it hasn't really made the leap to a product that is widely accepted by employers. Why do you think that is? What are the hurdles?
SPEAKER_02So, David, you're exactly right. This is a um, and again, I'm probably pretty biased, but this is a such a perfect model for physicians. Looking at the philosophy of internal medicine, family medicine, DPC really fits in that mold. And you know, I talk to physicians all the time that are practicing in DPC that say, this is exactly if you look at the essay that I wrote to get into medical school, this is exactly it. I'm practicing like I always wanted to. I think on the employer side, it really goes back to it's kind of twofold. One, educating employers, making sure that they know that there's a solution out there. And then two, I do believe that there's there's a lot of DPC providers, you know, that are great physicians, but they don't fully understand how to access and how to market into the employer space. And truthfully, while they're great, phenomenal physicians, and I'm sure they have incredible clinical outcomes in their DPC practice, they don't fully understand the business case for what an employer, particularly a self-funded employer, is facing. And so an important thing is bringing a lot of education to the DPC world on what the employer world is going through.
DavidIs it also a case of being able to deliver a repeatable, demonstrable ROI? I mean, I know there's loads of anecdotal evidence, but how do we get the DPC physicians to operate within a system that allows them to get empirical evidence on the financial side?
SPEAKER_02I think we in the DPC world, we need to embrace data. You know, for us, you know, data is such a powerful vehicle that we use. And I think in the DPC world, we need to embrace it and understand going back to that business case of what's going on with the employer and practicing, you know, the employer space, David, you know this. It's such a unique world, looking at all the different ecosystems in healthcare, on the employer space, there's so much readily available data, and particularly on the self-insured side, you know. So if a DPC group can figure out how to leverage that data, empower physicians to leverage that data at point of care, help them, you know, make point of care decisions to help patients and employers navigate the whole continuum of care. It is not hard to replicate that ROI. It's not hard to see a huge impact. It's just about you know knowing that business case and hitting it head on. And it's it really goes back to, again, those principles of primary care of practicing a level of very, very high level of population health.
DavidOkay, but I'm a doc who, as we've said, envisioned practicing a certain way. And besides what they envisioned, what they wanted to avoid was having to deal with all of the billing and coding. Right. And so they are happy as little clams that they're not circling little digits on little pieces of NCR forms when they see patients. Right. They're keeping notes, but they're not keeping the kind of data that they need to integrate with an employer's thinking in terms of how it actually will integrate and then show results with their existing plan. Even if we make it easy and we say it's a partially self-funded plan, so that the data transfer is not an issue. Is it necessary to create a system for those docs to use, or does such a system exist?
SPEAKER_02So I I do believe it's necessary. And taking a step back, there's certainly some philosophical bins in the DPC world and there's some debate in the DPC world. But at its core, direct primary care was invented and built to reunite a patient and a physician relationship and a partnership. And so many times you do feel some pushback from some people in the DPC community that I left a system not to bill and code, I left the system not to have to deal with, you know, this administrative hassle, and many might see data as such. I would say embrace data. I would say that data is empowering, and I would say if we're solely focused on the patient and what is right for that patient, let's leverage that data to help them take this patient by the hand and walk through the care continuum as primary care was designed to do. So does a system like that exist? There are systems out there, and I would say there's no perfect system. At Proactive MD, you know, we've had to build our own system, and it's taken a lot of work. And, you know, I was um, I can say, oh, I'm I'm really proud of this really cool proprietary software, but I realized it's meaningless unless you can build operational processes and build buy-in from your physicians. And it won't and once physicians buy in and they see just how empowering it is to have this readily available data and how they can understand a population before they even start to take care of that population and then get ingrained in a population and really there's so much hand holding that goes on with this data, and and then they can take this data and translate it to their patients. It it really is an empowering thing. And so, yes, I definitely think that there are systems out there, and I definitely believe if you're going to thrive in an employer setting who's investing in a group to take care of their people data and using a systematic approach is certainly a necessity.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaper Strategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. That's ShiftShaperstrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidSo how do we get there? I mean, if we're in a community and we're looking for DPC docs because we think there's an employer opportunity in that particular community, do you find one stock who buys in and then hope that they translate that and translate that excitement to the other docs? Do you do you position it as a business play, which frankly a lot of them just aren't interested in? They're not money driven, they're patient-driven, which is the beauty of DPC. Exactly. But it seems like there's a disconnect there. How do you bridge that gap?
SPEAKER_02So I think it's also kind of understanding this space. And so the employer world is not always going to be a fit with some in the DPC world. And again, it really is about that patient, and it's about having a relationship with that patient and impacting that patient's lives and their family's lives. And some might see an employer relationship as a distraction from that. And so it's finding groups that actually are dedicated and invested in building an employer-based solution. And so looking at the space, we kind of have two parallels here that I think often, and I smile a lot because we sit in these two different worlds that don't really talk with one another, really don't know each other that well, but you have the on-site clinic space that has been around since the late 90s, early 2000s, and that, you know, initially was built more as a you know nurse practitioner-based primary care supplement on-site, but geared towards employers. And then you have the DPC world, which is primarily more physician-based models, starting more on the consumer base, that is now starting to bleed into the employer space. And the funny thing is, I'm seeing these two worlds collide now. And so the DPC world is understanding more about the employer side. And then you look at some of the largest on-site clinic companies in the country, and if you if you look at their market material, they are now starting to call themselves direct primary care. And they are calling themselves direct care organizations. And so, and they've shifted focused on not just being a primary care supplement, but also being overtly primary care. And so the DPC world is evolving. And so there are options out there for employers to consider and to look. And some are that that phenomenal DPC doctor right in the heart of town who is ingrained, who knows that population. And the other option might be working with a um, you know, a vendor that is geared towards specifically employers. Again, I think it all goes back to understanding the business case of that given employer and finding a partnership with the employer, the benefits consultant, and the physician and that clinic team to be focused on, you know, how can we impact the lives of this population uniquely and be willing to be nimble and customizable.
DavidWell, you know, it's interesting that you bring up the on-site clinic space because I remember many years ago when I was working with a carrier, on-site clinics were a thing that was often discussed. And one of the stumbling blocks was that there wasn't data flow between the on-site clinic and especially like the case management and those kinds of DM departments. And they overcame that and they started doing integrated data transfers, which has not kind of yet come to the DPC space. So do you position yourselves as an intermediary and say, hey, we you know, we can partner with you and bring you this technology and you can keep practicing the way you want? Is that how you see this kind of rolling out?
SPEAKER_02I think there's some possibilities with that. And, you know, I love the direct primary care world and I believe in the power of, I believe in the power of the primary care physician. I've seen it personally in my own life and how primary care has impacted my life and my family's life, but I see it each and every day in the lives of our patients at Praactive MD. And so I look and I realize that, you know, DPC is far bigger than Pray FM D. So yes, I would love to be, you know, a catalyst to bring some of those solutions. And, you know, there's some great minds out there in the direct primary care space. You've had many of them on your show. I'm a big fan of both of them. And so getting great minds to come together, think alike, and say, how can we support one another? How can we, again, build a solution and offer a solution that is focused on this given employer? And what I believe is such an an amazing, you know, an amazing power that primary care has, and I see it in direct primary care, is care does not stop within the four walls of primary care. Primary care is designed to go well beyond the four walls. And so when direct primary care physicians and these groups are working with employers, the care doesn't stop at that on-site clinic. It doesn't stop at that near site direct primary care clinic. You know, they're holding hands every step of the way. And those cardiologists, nephrologists, you know, them surgeons, they're held accountable by the primary care physician, and that primary care physician and team are bringing things back in. And you see, you know, not just savings happening on the primary care side or savings happening by you know ER visits being deferred or urgent care. You see, you know, catastrophic claims being hit head on, and you see, you know, these outlier anomalies that are still being hit head on. And so again, I think, yes, the employer space needs the power of primary care. And so whatever we have to do to help empower this this movement to continue to grow and and flourish, I think we we need to focus on that.
DavidSo let's move from the physician and the employer side to the place where the rubber actually meets the road. How much work is there to do, assuming that you can get part A and B stitched together in a way that's cohesive and makes sense for everybody? How much work is there to do and how do you go about doing it to educate employees about how to use a DPC practice? Because a lot of times they get very freaked out because it's not integrated with their insurance plan, and so they just don't understand it. It's this new kind of square peg and a round-hole thing. How do you get past that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a great question, David. And I think it again, it's understanding the employer that you're working with and really being ingrained in that culture. And so you look at this and you think, okay, I'm gonna be working with this this um large group and I'm gonna offer them great direct primary care, and the primary care physician is going to provide great primary care, is gonna go out there and engage the the patient, is going to coordinate care through through every aspect of care. And we we put this huge laundry list of things that we expect this physician to do. But you have to we have to realize that while there are some amazing physicians out there, physicians aren't superheroes. I mean, they mean they can do some great things, but they need support. And so models that we embrace, and and something I push for, is building a care team that can support that physician to be such a an empowering doctor. And a model that I like to push is the patient advocate. And this patient advocate that would come alongside, and then the care team would consist, and they would be partners with that physician, is a licensed clinical social worker that's gonna work with the physician to engage a population, to focus on you know some of the social determinants of what's going on, helping empower this care delivery, this direct primary care care delivery team to be nimble and to meet patients where they're at, and work with patients to remove any and all obstacles to that that are getting in their way from care. You know, a story of that would be you know, there's a lot of things that may be going on the home front. And, you know, our patient advocate, one of their primary roles is engagement and and and particularly the engagement of the chronically ill. And we had a patient who, as much outreach as we possibly could do, just would not visit our health center. And this patient advocate was determined. This patient really needed to come in. The patient advocate said, Okay, I'm going to find this guy, and I'm not giving up. And so it was an employer that was a shift worker, and this guy worked on the night shift, and the patient advocate showed up on the factory floor and said, I need to introduce myself. I've called you several times, but I I want to introduce myself. I'm Amber, and it's great to meet you. They started talking, and that and then that patient opened up and said, You know what? I know I need to see a doctor, I've been hearing it, but I'm having some, you know, financial issues. I'm I'm I'm having my own trouble on the home front that that you know that is really taking my focus. And so that patient advocate said, okay, let's talk about that. And they worked on on community resources and they worked on a budget, and they worked on just caring for that patient and you know, putting them at the center, built a trust, and and I really do believe in in direct primary care, trust is our currency. And so when you when you can build that trust, that patient, they didn't feel like it was Big Brother coming down on them and pushing them. It was Amber who held his hand and helped him figure out a really hard situation in his life. And so now he's he's a very compliant patient, he's you know, and one of the biggest evangelists for us. And so engagement is key in really understanding people, meeting meeting them where they're at. If COVID-19 has taught us anything, it's you must be nimble, you must be willing to meet patients where they're at. And primary care doesn't stop with a worldwide pandemic. Primary care must go on. And so that care might be virtual care. We see a lot of that right now. That care might still be in the health center, that care might be in a car or the or um on the front porch of a house, but it's willing to be as nimble and creative as you possibly can. And that's the great power that you have in care delivery models like this.
DavidAnd that's a great place to end our conversation for today. John Coll, your president and CEO at ProActiveMD. John, thank you so much for sharing your expertise. We hope you'll come back.
SPEAKER_02Would love to. Thank you, David, for your time.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.