The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #315: The $500 Tipping Point - With Amy Chambers
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This episode of The ShiftShapers Podcast is called "The $500 Tipping Point" with Amy Chambers, Founder and COO of HealthBridge. Today, David and Amy discuss the complex problem of providing for the healthcare of the functionally uninsured.
Amy explains their program's benefits to providers such as infusing cash into the system and reducing difficulties in collecting. On the member side, she further shares how this restores their dignity around the issue of money and their faith into value-based care.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- 01:55 Amy’s background & observations on average American financial capacity
- 08:52 Designing a program for the functionally uninsured
- 13:49 Advantages to providers
- 17:02 Benefits to employee members
Quotes:
04:54 “The average plan out of pocket these days is $8,000 but the average American has about $400 in times of emergency.”
05:42 “64% of people report to have avoided medical care due to these out of pockets. That’s meaningful and it impacts outcomes. It erodes what we’re trying to do in value-based care.”
11:49 “What we’ve created is a first of its kind employee benefit program. It’s going to help the member regardless of their financial status because we talk about a lot of people who are lower income.”
14:23 “We cover all the co-payments, co-insurance, and deductibles for them, all the way up to their out of pocket and beyond if they happen to have any co-pays.”
17:08 “It certainly insulates them against financial crisis. It should arguably improve their access to care. About 25% of those members that you’re sitting knee to knee with in open enrollment actually have no access to credit.”
Recent events have highlighted Americans' low rate of savings. How does this affect ever larger personal responsibility amounts on our health care plans? And how can we help cushion the blow for employees? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at Chip ShaperStrategies.com. And now, here's your host, Storybrand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist. At Chip Shaper Strategies, David Salt Smith.
DavidOn this episode of Chip Shapers, we're speaking with Amy Chambers. Amy is the founder and COO of HealthBridge. We've talked an awful lot about people who are functionally uninsured, and certainly the COVID crisis pointed out, if anybody needed, pointed out, indeed, the COVID crisis certainly pointed out very clearly the fact that Americans have little or no savings. And so this problem is exacerbated right along by people who we believe are functionally uninsured. That is to say they have a huge deductible, but they don't have a huge salary. And so they defer care or do other things like that. And Amy has come up with a solution for that, but we'd like to talk about a little bit about her background. But first, welcome, Amy.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for having me.
DavidIt's our pleasure. So talk a little bit about your background because I think that does a good job of informing your story.
SPEAKER_01Sure. I have been an employee benefits attorney for going on 25 years now. And most of my time as an EB attorney was spent in-house at a community health plan in Michigan, the second largest, as a matter of fact. And I was in-house at probably the best time for a regulatory junkie like myself. I was there when all the HIPAA regulations came out. So I was the first HIPAA privacy officer. So I learned kind of how to translate regulations into process and procedure. But then all the regulations started coming out in and around consumer-driven health care plans. So the HSAs, the HRAs, the FSAs. And I wound up going from being associate general counsel and privacy officer over to running product development. So that's how I spent most of my career there. And it was an exceptional journey. I was on the front line translating the regulations as they were coming hot off the presses into products. I was sending them over to the IT department to change the claim system. I was teaching our employers and members how to use these programs. And it was a community health plan that was owned by a provider. So I sat across the table from a lot of providers from the very beginning who had their own opinions on these programs. So I had a great opportunity to get in from the very beginning. I would say I'm one of the grandmothers of consumerism. And I would say that from the very beginning, I had some ideas around how these programs may translate one day to financial insecurity for providers and for members. But there were a lot of questions at the time as to whether or not these programs would even survive. So there wasn't a lot done around it. And here we are, flash forward all these years, and there's no doubt about it. And you said it in the intro that the financial insecurity is making people functionally uninsured in many instances.
DavidWell, and that's the problem. I mean, be besides that, and we'll define that very simply. I mean, if you've got a $5,000 personal responsibility amount and you're, you know, making $36,000 a year working on the loading dock, and you've got a uh a spouse, two kids, a mortgage, or an apartment rent or whatever, you're gonna defer care. And I I suspect that that you started seeing an awful lot of that, didn't you?
SPEAKER_01Oh, absolutely. So around the shop, we talk a lot about statistics that have led us to this point and the creation of Health Bridge. And, you know, I think a lot of the listeners probably know them, but I'll just I'll cite the ones that are the most meaningful for us. We say we talk about how the average plan out of pocket these days is $8,000, but the average American has about $400 in times of emergency, and who knows what's going to happen after this COVID crisis. We can only assume that it's going to get worse. Let's talk about the employers for a second, too. These employers are paying about $20,000 for family coverage with the $8,000 out of pocket. They're impacted too when their employees come in for the first time after a big episode of care with an $8,000 out of pocket and the bills start coming in and they're standing around in the coffee room and they say, you know what, guys, our benefits stink. And they don't stink. It's just it's the first time they've ever had to deal with such a huge expense all at once that was unanticipated. We also talk a lot about how 64% of people report to have avoided medical care due to these out-of-pockets. That's meaningful and it impacts outcomes. It impacts and it erodes what we're trying to do in value-based care from an employer's standpoint. When people skip care, if you're self-funded, when they finally go in for care, it's about 300% more expensive. There's absenteeism and presenteism. And then we talk a lot about how providers struggle. I mean, a lot of the risk has been pushed to them because now they have to collect. And, you know, if you look at your average health system, they collect about 40 cents on the dollar. It takes about 180 days to do it. And there's a huge cost to that. It's about 8 to 12%. And I've seen it even higher than that. So all the stakeholders have been impacted over time. And that has been the basis for the creation of our program.
DavidWell, and you know, one of the things that, and you touched on it just a moment ago, one of the things that we don't think about an awful lot as advisors, because we think about that example I gave of somebody being functionally uninsured, but we don't think about the impact that providers not being paid timely has or not being paid at all, and the amount of friction that that creates in the system at an employee level, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_01Oh, absolutely. Providers do not want money to stand between them and good care. These high deductible plans have increased the care avoidance and decreased care acceptance. So they are troubled by these programs on many levels. It's not just financial, it's the patient care that they care most about. You know, payers are impacted by this as well. And we don't forget about them when we design, because if you think about the payer, the insurer relationship with these providers, they have very tight relationships and how hard it must be when they go in to negotiate a fair provider contract when the provider comes rightly so to the table and says, look at all my bad debt. Look at what you want me to go on into these value-based programs, but people aren't accepting care like they used to. It is, it has created a lot of hardships, and even the payers are struggling with some of these programs. Not to say that high deductibles aren't a necessity. Again, I am a big fan of consumer-driven healthcare plans. I was around during those years when we didn't have these programs and we were handing out 20 and 30% increases to our employer-sponsored programs. We had to do something. We had to relieve some of the pressure that was in the system. But now we are all these years into this and we do have to do some course corrections.
DavidWell, it was Professor Reinhardt at I think he was at Princeton who was to who wrote that thesis about hydraulic medical economics. And and what he said essentially was, because I was around at the same time that you were, and we were, you know, both engaged in the early years of consumerism. What he said was that, you know, when the level goes down on one side of the tube, it the the whole thing is like a U-shaped tube. And when the level goes down on one side, it goes up on the other. So the insurers did what they had to do, and for a while that provided some rate relief. But then ultimately it leveled off again, it became the new normal, and we ended up with 20% rate increases again. Because we really the consumer part of it hadn't really taken hold as we might have wanted to. So again, we're back to that situation where we have folks who are functionally uninsured. How do you solve that problem?
SPEAKER_01So one of the things that we thought about when we were addressing this issue is how do we create something on a go forward basis where all votes rise? A lot of the programs that are out there are zero-sum games. If I win, you lose. And we really have four stakeholders in all this. You have clearly the patient, or you know, for our listeners, it would be the members in these programs. You've got the employers who pay the lion's share of healthcare today. You've got to keep them at the table. And we can't forget them. You've got the providers and you have the payers. So, given all the pain in the system right now, we were trying to design something that would help all of them. Um, and that's the only way that you can create a platform that's scalable and sustainable. So, what we decided to do was build something. I'll back up and I'll just say I think that it's time for a new benefit category, and it's around financial security of members today. But the way we designed this program, we wanted to make sure that not only were we providing financial security for the employee, but we also had to have something in there for the employer. Providers had to benefit from this, and the payers would have to have a win. It had to drive value for all the stakeholders. We also said we've been around healthcare long enough to know that we had to construct our program in a way that would optimize current technology and operations in order to minimize disruption. I have been inside the house long enough to know that when you're asking a provider or payer to do something radically different, rip that out and put this in. It's not going to happen. There's just not enough money and time to do all the things that would be radically different. So we thought, yeah, we got to build it on what is currently available. We also said to ourselves, whatever we do, we cannot add to the cost of healthcare. You got to remove the waste. And then last but not least, one of our other thoughts is this has got to be patient-centered. Obviously, we want to help people get access to excellent and affordable health care. And it's got to be about the patient. It's that whole, you know, the patient will see you now. So we're continuing on that path. What we've created is a first of its kind employee benefit program. It's going to help the member regardless of their financial status, because we talk about a lot of people who are lower income. We've got to make sure that we've got a program for them, not just people who have high FICO scores. We've got to have an employee benefit that helps members, regardless of their financial status, both manage and pay for those out-of-pocket medical costs. And what we're really trying to do is get people access to credit they may not otherwise have access to. So we can help all the stakeholders promote right care at the right time. When people, it's the 64% that we talked about up front. When people feel like they don't have access to credit, they don't have access to money to go into the provider, forget about all that talk about right care at the right time at the right level.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaper Strategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at Shiftshaper Strategies.com. That's ShiftShaperstrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidSo let's talk about the different constituencies in real practical terms. What's the win for the provider?
SPEAKER_01Well, what we do in our program, and you know, I haven't really gone into detail, but basically what we are doing is we roll out our program, and I will tell you what we do with the provider, but you kind of have to understand the context. We roll out our program alongside their insurance benefit design. And if they have a higher deductible plan, not just an HDHP, HSA compatible, anything that's you know $500 in deductible or above, because that's about the tipping point for most people, we cover all the co-payments, coinsurance, and deductibles for them, all the way up to their out-of-pocket and beyond if they happen to have any co-pays. So what we do for the providers is we make immediate payment to the provider on that member balance. So that balance after insurance, the co-paid co-insurance, or deductible, we actually have that sent to us, electronically sent to us from the payer. So we eliminate all the administrative waste of providers having to send out all those bills and we pay them immediately. So think about it as we're almost like a secondary payer. So your primary payer will pay first, the one that has the high deductible, they'll pay the provider whatever is due and owing. And now the provider doesn't have to collect the balance after insurance. They don't collect the co-payment up front. They don't require, I should say, that co-payment up front. And that co-insurance and that deductible, they never lick a stamp. And within two business days, I send them the remainder. So now that that member or their patient is zero balance. So just think about what that does for the provider, particularly today. We talk every day about how these providers, these poor providers who are either being barraged with COVID patients or there's a lot of them that aren't seeing the volume and they're doing no elective care, right? So everybody needs cash right now. What we're able to do is infuse cash. So cash is king, our program doesn't make them lick six envelopes and stamps and send it out, you know, over six months to collect 40 cents on the dollar. We get them cash on the barrel up front. But even bigger than that, I mean, there's getting that waste out of the system is huge. And it should translate to a lot of good things that we can all surmise. But more than that is we've taken all that financial conversation, all the financial shame, all the financial issues out of that patient provider relationship. And providers can go back to being providers again and not being the, you know, we talked to a hospital system in the very beginning, and I remember the CFO saying, I'm the largest unsecured creditor in this city, and that has stayed with me. They're in the finance game right now, and they shouldn't be. So we need to collectively figure out how you know we can take them out of that role. And we feel like we've we've gone a long way towards that.
DavidAnd what does it look like from the employee perspective, from the member perspective? How does it work from where they sit?
SPEAKER_01Well, it certainly insulates them against financial crisis. It should arguably improve their access to care. About 25% of those members that you're sitting knee to knee with in an open enrollment actually have no access to credit. They don't have a credit card in their wallet or a credit card that works. So when you give them back that financial security, you're giving them access to care. I think it's gonna decrease confusion around billing and repayment because you know, a little portion of our program is so now I'm plugged into the payer and I get balance after insurance fresh after adjudication. So, you know, one of the problems with healthcare billing is that people get the bills asynchronous. They're gonna get them, you know, you get one and then you throw it out because you're anticipating you might get another one. And when did I get this? And some of them sit on it and some of it want it immediately. There's so much confusion around billing. What we're able to do being plugged into the payer is we consolidate everything that's occurred over a month. So I've already paid it off. All those balances are paid off, and then I'm able to collect them over the month, consolidate them into one bill that looks and feels like a credit card. So it's something that they're familiar with. So just decreasing confusion around billing and repayment is pretty huge. I think for members, it's nice also to have increased satisfaction with their employer's health plan choice. They feel in that open enrollment when they're looking at that high deductible, okay, they just gave me a means to manage this. I can do this, reduces care avoidance and delay. And, you know, it r I think it restores a lot of dignity around that provider visit. You know, there's nothing worse than walking in and you're trying to get care, and Mrs. Chambers, you owe us $400. How would you like to pay for that today? A lot of people just don't go back for follow-up. They'll they'll never darken the door of a provider again once they feel like their dignity has been stripped. And there's a lot of shame around money.
DavidAnd those are the people who inevitably end up in emergency departments or intensive care wards for problems that could very easily have been taken care of early on in the disease state.
SPEAKER_01You got it. Exactly.
DavidWell, we it's a very interesting process, and we hope you'll come back as it grows and you learn more and tell us how it's going.
SPEAKER_01Ah, thank you so much.
DavidAmy Chambers, founder and COO of Health Bridge. Amy, thanks for sharing your expertise with our audience today.
AnnouncerThank you. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper Strategy, and it may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.