The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #311: Disrupting Your Own Disruption - With Eric Silverman
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This episode of The ShiftShapers Podcast is called "Disrupting Your Own Disruption" with Eric Silverman, Founder of Voluntary Disruption. Today, host and Chief Transformation Strategist David Saltzman and Eric discuss some major changes to voluntary benefits aka enhanced benefits.
They explore the reasons why enhanced benefits are a practical idea, the improvements in the tech that serves this group, and the strategies to drive engagement among employees and keep benefits attractive.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- 02:38 Brokers still ignore enhanced benefits
- 09:52 Introducing technology to streamline access to voluntary benefits
- 15:09 Secret to engagement: Help people understand their exposures
- 18:45 The most attractive benefits
Quotes:
07:36 “It’s not exactly the employer that loses as much as it’s the employees. Again, I can’t stress enough, the end-user. Why should an employee be relegated to spend more money for less robust coverage on things that they’re going to buy anyway?”
12:49 “They needed to get into the technological world so we helped streamline and implement our technology completely, again, using that term, the ‘Amazon of Benefits.'”
14:52 “You can still get the participation, engagement, and results even if you don’t have in-person, one-on-one enrollment.”
17:11 “When we implement these things with small to large groups alike, that’s where you truly have the engagement, when they know that you’re only a phone call away, they have a scheduler link.”
19:13 “The most popular plans, still to this day, it happens to be the accident plan, the hospital plan; for any carriers getting really big, medical bridge-type hospital plans, indemnity programs.”
Our guest on this episode is so good at being disruptive that he's even disrupted his own practice. How and why has he done that? And how can the lessons that he learned help you? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. And now, here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidOn this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Eric Silverman. Eric is the founder of Voluntary Disruption. And if his name sounds familiar, it's because not only is he a force in the industry, but we interviewed him back in September 2017. He talked about the growing need back then for what he calls enhanced benefits, which is a phrase that I've picked up and I really like, and enrollment methodology. And we thought we'd check back in because a lot has changed. And with that, welcome, Eric.
SPEAKER_01Hey, thanks for having me back. I'm excited to be here.
DavidIt's our pleasure. So where were you? I mean, kind of a big question, but where were you back in 2017 and what's changed?
SPEAKER_01Oh man, great question. So I feel like 2017 was ages ago, back when we were allowed to social with each other, not social distance. The uh in 2017, right when I was chatting with you, I was I was very fortunate enough to have just been named the 2017 Voluntary Advisor of the Year by Employee Benefit Advisor Magazine. And we were living the dream, man. We had a lot of fun, we were getting a lot of notoriety because of that, and it opened up a lot of doors. So I'm not gonna lie, it was incredible. And it was right at the same time when our collective uh book, my partners and I wrote a book that became an Amazon best-selling book, Breaking Through the Status Quo of Healthcare, and couple that with the with the prestigious industry award I'm grateful for. And boy, did we have an incredible last couple years. But you know it's interesting, Dave, because a lot's the same, but a lot has changed. So, you know, with respect to to what's the same, as sad as I I hate to admit this, brokers or advisors or consultants in the insurance space still, by and large, treat enhanced benefits as I've termed them, as I and I love hearing that you've adopted that. But in the industry, it's still known as voluntary benefits. And brokers and advisors and consultants all over the country from small to large are still, to this day, it's been a few years since I've talked about it, they're still treating it like the uh redheaded stepchild that that I spoke about um in 2017. They still ignore it, the first methodology, they don't want to deal with it, or they bring it in reluctantly using uh some type of local carrier rep, and they just dump in the product and hope for the best and hope that the person they're working with does what they're supposed to do, but they don't really pay much attention to it. Very rarely, but still, every now and then I hear of a brokerage that will will hire an internal quote unquote vice president of voluntary and uh hope and pray that works out because they can keep it all in-house. But as I've said to folks many times, that's the hardest of the hard because for a brokerage to to get a return on investment in a reasonable amount of time really just doesn't exist. So it that that methodology typically fails. And then you have uh method four, which is working with somebody like myself, and I'm not the only one, Dave, you know that, but somebody like myself around the country that is carrier agnostic and uh truly works in the best interest of the broker as well as their employer group clients. So I wish I could say that that those four scenarios aren't still the same, that maybe the first one being that brokers ignore our side of the business. I wish I could say that didn't exist, but sadly it still does exist. I literally today, I'm not making a joke, I had a conversation with a broker partner who admitted on the phone that you know dumping in product through some local random carrier wrap is absolutely the worst of the worst ways to do it. He totally agrees, and when push comes to shove, he was the first to admit that he still does it because quote unquote it's easier. And no matter what I could say and what I could do and what I could explain, it just didn't matter, was falling on deaf ears. Uh and this is sadly a broker, and we hear this a lot, it's not just this person, I hear this often, but this was a broker that says the right things uh publicly to clients and when marketing, that they do what's in the best interest for the client, they shop the market, they'll do fully insured if it's needed, but they'll shop the market. They love to do self-funded and level funded for health insurance, but yet when it comes to the industry I call enhanced benefits, they don't really give a crap, to be honest with you, and they're the first to admit it. And and to me, you know, very bluntly, I I think it's tragic, but I'll I'll use an even harsher word. I I think it's criminal because at the end of the day, the employee is the end user. So yeah, you want to save your employer group money and you want to do its best for your employer group, but what about the employees? That's the end user, the actual consumer who is using the benefits daily throughout the year. And if they're um if they're stuck paying more money for less robust coverages just because the broker and the uh or the broker simply throws in a carrier and a product mix that really doesn't make any sense, again, I I just I know it's harsh, so hopefully you're okay with me saying it, Dave, but I I I just think it's criminal.
DavidWell, beyond beyond being criminal, I mean I think it's just really bad business. We're in the business of helping people transfer risk. Right. And if you don't transfer all of the employer and employees' risk, you're leaving a door open for somebody to come in. But I'm I'm I'm curious, though, on a more basic level, I mean, personal responsibility amounts on core medical have not decreased. And so we're creating what one podcast guest a couple of years called functionally uninsured folks. Absolutely. And it would seem to me that that would highlight even more the need for enhanced benefits and the desire for advisors who really want to help their clients to engage in layering those on top of the core plan. Why do you think it isn't happening?
SPEAKER_01To be candid and very blunt, you know, I always am with you and everybody, it's not happening out of sheer laziness and and lack of care. So the amount of advisors and brokers, and you know, I I run the risk. I know you have thousands of downloads a month. I run the risk of having advisors or brokers get irritated with my message here, but you know, I'm not one to mix words, and it's oftentimes, more often than not, it's a broker or advisor who's just sheer lazy. They admit it. They spend 100% or 99% of their time on crafting the most perfect innovative health plan that the world has ever seen for every single one of their clients, small to large. And when it comes to this stuff, it just kind of takes a back seat and nobody thinks about it. And then by the time it gets brought up, if it gets brought up, and that's a big if, the owner and HR department of the employer group just kind of says, Yeah, no, we'll look at it next year, and that never happens. And I don't blame the owner of the HR department. I blame their advisor, I blame their broker, their consultant, because they didn't prioritize and make it something that that needed to be on the forefront of the conversation. And again, it's not the employer. Well, I could argue the employer loses, but it's not exactly the employer that loses as much as it's the employees. Again, I can't stress enough, the end user. You know, why should an employee be relegated to spend more money for less robust coverage on things that they're gonna buy anyway? I mean, the the employer's offering these types of plans. Why do these plans not deserve to be shopped around every couple of years, uh, if not every year? Why do they oftentimes, too oftentimes, get dumped in and then just forgotten about? You know, again, I go back to the word, it's criminal. So I try, you know, here's the thing, David. I try to run my business on the enhanced side for our broker partner clients across the country and their employer groups. I try to run it the same way that they're running their health benefits business, or at least what they say they're how they're running their health benefits business. And by doing it that way, we typically have a really good fit. But but I do, I I see it more often than not, and this is another harsh word, so somebody's gonna get upset, but I find that a terrible amount of brokers and advisors and consultants in the marketplace are very two-faced when it comes to it. Again, they spend all their time on health benefits, major medical that is, and they just ignore and uh don't really care about the end user when it's all said and done. And they can argue till the cows come home that that's not true, but actions very much speak louder than words, as my mom would say.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaperStrategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at ShiftShaperstrategies.com. That's Shiftshaperstrategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidWell, I mean, there was a perception for a long time that voluntary benefits required a tremendous amount of manpower, that it was a manual crank 'em out kind of a process, that you couldn't really bring any kind of technology or electronics to it. Has that changed since you and I spoke last?
SPEAKER_01Sure, sure. Great question. And you know you're 100% right. You know, I've been in the business now, gosh, it's crazy, but almost 21 years, only on this side of the house. I've never done anything else. No health insurance, major medical, no property and casualty. And you're you're you're spot on for years and years. And I would even say when we first chatted in 2017, that was still the case, where it had to be it was a very manual process, very laborious. Businesses and the executives, human resource executives, brokers alike all had to um have a little lift in involved. But no, I'm excited and proud to say that it doesn't have to be that way anymore. I knew it'd be a there'd be a day that we didn't have to do it that way. And that day really started, uh I would say for my for my firm, and I think other firms like me as well. Again, I'm not the only one, but for us it started at the um, I would say early mid-2018, so the last couple years, whereby, you know, it's interesting, more than 80% of our new group revenue, just speaking of last year alone, 2019, came in through self-serve and or with the assistance of call center support, whereby I dub it, I dub this term, it's nothing creative or amazing, but I explain it to brokers, advisors, consultants, and employers in HR departments as we have the ability to give their employees the Amazon of benefits. So when people think of Amazon, they think of quick and easy. You you make a couple flicks of your finger on your smartphone and you buy whatever it is you're interested in. You watch a product video, you read a brochure, you read some uh reviews. So we have systems where we have the ability to give employees the Amazon of benefits where they log in, completely self-serve on their own, they uh watch some uh videos that are you know 30 seconds to two minutes long, tops, they can download brochures, they can look at comparisons, they can um see all the rates and and everything accordingly. Give you a perfect example. We did a case uh last year, a new case, and we started talking to them early 2019. The enrollment was August for an effective date of 9-1. This group had um more than 1,200 benefit eligible lives. And this is a totally paper group for health insurance, major medical, you name it. The broker had just taken over the group um a few months earlier, and they he was brought in so that he could take over and bring them to the digital age, uh, as crazy as that may sound for a group this size that was already that was still doing paper. I mean, for heaven's sakes, you ready for this, David? For health insurance open enrollment, they would send all 1,000 plus employees a postcard in the mail, and they would say on the postcard, if we don't hear from you, we assume you want to continue your benefits and they'll just roll over. So whether that's good, bad, or indifferent doesn't matter. They knew they needed to be techno-sabvy, they needed to get into the technological world. So we helped uh streamline and implement our technology uh completely. Again, using that term, the Amazon of benefits. You know, the genesis of it that most brokers and advisors, and particularly people in my industry, are worried about, is the engagement level. How will the employees be engaged? Will the employees be engaged? Will the communication resonate? This is a group that I'm speaking of in my story that is in 14 or 15 different states scattered around the country. Some of the employees work from their home. And couple that, you know, this this makes it even worse if you think about it. The it's the it the industry is in the um, it's actually the health care industry with respect to the like a hospital nursing type facilities, and the average employees very low wage and very, very, very low education level. Most of their employees are actually on the spectrum. And I don't say that in a bad way, I just try to paint the picture of the employees' education as very slim. So the CFO, HR, COO, and COO of the and CEO of the company was nervous that this wouldn't resonate because they he was they were unsure about the techno ability of all the staff. Well, bottom line, when we were all said and done, we had all 1,200 and something employees go through the technology with ease. And here's the crazy part we thought that more than 80 or 90% of the employees would utilize our call center, but it was actually quite the opposite. It was 60%, roughly 60% did 100% self-serve, and the other roughly 40% decided to use the call center in aid with the self-serve technology, and it blew our minds. And by the way, from a you know, let's be honest, we're all for-profit agencies. So from a revenue perspective, my firm and the brokerage uh that brought us in, we did quite well. We ended up having more than 55% employee participation in the entire um company. So we had hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of people voluntarily decide to spend their own hard-earned money after looking at it on their own through self-serve and or speaking to a call center representative, which therein lives proves that you can still get the participation, engagement, and results, even if you don't have in-person one-on-one enrollment. So we've done that quite a bit, to say the least. And uh, it doesn't just have to be a big group. We we do it for a 5, 10, 20-man group, we'll do it for a multi-thousand-man group.
DavidWell, I know there are a lot of people who think that if the the system, the enrollment system, just forces you to go through the enhanced benefits portion, you know, in other words, you can't just do your core enrollment and then log off and let it complete, that that will do it by itself. But isn't the secret to engagement still helping people understand that they have exposures and and that it's really very easy for individual employees to cover those exposures?
SPEAKER_01Oh, oh yeah, 100%. Absolutely. So to continue that example, you're right. If you have an employee population that is, I don't like the word mandatory, forced or required, but for lack of better terms, if they're forced to go through the system as part of the process, whether they want insurance or not, even if they want to waive, if they're forced to go through the system to click waive at the end, that's by and large going to naturally generate more participation just because people go through the system and they start to see things that they that they thought they weren't interested in. But for us, it comes down to the communication and the strategy. So we um, you know, David, I think you remember uh I've said it before, I I'm a marketing guy by trade. So I really enjoy doing the marketing and communication campaigns myself. So my my staff helps me and we have marketing people that help, but I love spearheading that more, believe it or not, more than I love the insurance industry because it brings me back to my roots and what I get excited about uh to be fun or have fun and be creative. So, from a uh communication perspective, you know, we have to go where the client is. I.e. when I say client, I don't mean the employer, I mean the employees, all the way from the management down to the supervisor foreman level, all the way down to the end user, the actual employee. You know, that can consist of everything from social media on their intranet to social media in general, to text messaging technology, to voicemail technology, to email technology, to landing pages and custom websites and uh ultimately uh even decision support tool communication technology. Uh so when we implement all of these things, particularly with a larger group, by all means we probably can't afford to do all of that for a 20-man group. But when we implement these things with small to large groups alike, that's where you truly have the engagement. When they know that you're only a phone call away, they have a scheduler link where they can schedule to talk to a call center representative anytime during the open enrollment. By the way, in order to get all that set up, it's quite the lift. I promise you, any advisor partner that I've been fortunate enough to work with will tell you it works incredibly well, my goodness, but it's quite the lift that they just don't have the bandwidth as a brokerage or the capacity or wherewithal to do. So that's where we come in. But with respect to um to general engagement, that's the key. It it really has to be a partnership between uh our firm and the brokerage as well as the executive C-suite at any company USA. Without that partnership, to be honest, uh David, we've walked away from deals. Uh just last year we had a 250-person company supported by the broker, and the employer group wanted everything we talked about, but they were not at all willing to come where they needed to come with respect to the the partnering that we needed for their support. We call it the top-down support. And I just politely told the broker it wasn't going to be a good fit, and um I couldn't be involved. So most folks in my industry don't walk away from a couple hundred person group. The they usually, particularly carrier reps, will usually take it, hope for the best, and if it if it uh you know, if it fails, they'll just chalk it up to uh at least we sold something and it was a it it was a try. I just don't have the time and the bandwidth to to waste my time on that.
DavidWe've only got a couple of minutes left. A couple of questions, um, kind of in quick order. Sure. The first is in in terms of overall benefits, what do you find being the most attractive benefits? What what are employees most drawn to?
SPEAKER_01I think it really depends on what's already in there. You know, uh uh human resource professionals will are starting by and large to be really excited about non-insurance programs like pet programs, pet discount insurance programs, prepaid legal student loans, ID theft, fraud protection, stuff like that. Those are really exciting to human resource professionals. But from an employee perspective, the most popular plan still to this day, it happens to be the accident plan, the hospital plan for any carrier is getting really big medical bridge type hospital plans, indemnity programs that that truly fill in where the healthcare leaves off. Those are big ones. Critical illness, cancer type plans are always popular. And then, of course, I can't forget disability. But again, I don't step on the toes of my broker partner. So when they bring us in, just like any company just like me, the last thing I want to do is try to change what they're already doing. So if they're already doing disability in life and dental and vision, I'm not gonna touch that. So those are always the most popular, but not always the ones I'm brought in for.
DavidSo if we touch base again on the podcast in a couple of years, what do you expect your end of the industry to look like?
SPEAKER_01That's a great question, and I hope we do. I I think that it's gonna, you know, a couple years from now, uh all my colleagues and and friendly competitors and even not so friendly competitors, I believe they're gonna have a long adopted what I just spoke about today with respect to technology. And, you know, be it that we're we're chatting today in the age of coronavirus and we're sitting at our houses, I think it's gonna be more and more important. And um, you know, right now brokers, advisors, and groups are scrambling to figure out how on earth to do an employer open enrollment for benefits when they've always done it one-on-one, in-person, a group meeting setting. So we've actually gotten very busy with our broker partners to help them figure out how to do that because they're just it's not something they've ever been accustomed to. So that's where it's gonna be a couple of years from now. People are are gonna be doing this more and more, and the age of doing group meetings in person and one-on-ones is gonna continue to die, in my opinion.
DavidInteresting. Well, we look forward to that conversation a couple of years ahead, and hence Eric Silverman, founder of Voluntary Disruption. Eric, thanks for coming back and sharing your update with us. Absolutely. Thanks again for having me, David.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.