The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #305 Part 1: Reading the Political Tea Leaves - with Jessica Waltman
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This is part 1 of The ShiftShapers Podcast episode called "Reading the Political Tea Leaves - with Jessica Waltman" and today, host and Chief Transformation Strategist David Saltzman and Jessica discuss health insurance and health-related matters in today's political climate.
Jessica, who is Principal at Forward Health Consulting, provides easy to understand insights about what is happening with the Affordable Care Act or ACA and how scrapping it affects much more than just Obamacare. She also provides a fearless forecast on the future of the ACA under a Sanders, Biden, and second Trump administration.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- 02:21 Supreme Court to rule on the ACA
- 10:57 Separating Obamacare from ACA
- 14:22 Predicting healthcare in the next administration
Quotes:
07:08 “So we’re going to hear one hour of arguments and you’re going to have to bring these issues to us. One, is this challenge to the ACA even legal at all?”
08:07 “And then three, if it is true, and the mandate’s invalid, then can it be separated from the rest of the ACA or should the entire law be struck down?”
11:16 “The part that everybody talks about, things about as Obamacare, is really about 50 pages in the front. So it’s not really that big.”
16:01 “Bernie Sanders wants to have a single-payer system in the United States. He wants everyone to have free healthcare with no co-pays, no premiums.”
20:34 “My guess is that Joe Biden, having his very long legislative history and then also serving as vice president, is a little more flexible than perhaps Bernie Sanders.”
When we want to understand what's happening on the political or regulatory front, we ask our regular contributor, Jessica Wallman, for explanations. How does Jessica read the tea leaves? And how will that affect your clients and your practice? We'll find out on part one of this two-part episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. And now, here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidOn this episode of Shift Shapers, we're welcoming back one of our favorite people. And part of the reason that she's one of our favorite people is that she can take really complicated stuff that's happening in DC and on the campaign trail and elsewhere and put it into terms that we mere mortals can understand because she is, as we say in the Boston area, wicked smot. With that, please welcome back Jessica Waltman, principal at Forward Health Consulting. Jessica, glad to have you back again.
SPEAKER_02David, thank you so much for having me back on Shift Shapers. This is always one of my favorite things to do, although I'm now trying really hard not to crack up at your wicked smot.
DavidWell, you you are, so own it. It's okay. You want to start on the regulatory side of the universe or on the political side? I'll leave it to your choice.
SPEAKER_02Let's talk about the political stuff first because it's more interesting. So we'll throw people in with the fun stuff, and then I'll tell you about the regulatory, boring stuff that you need to know about later.
DavidSounds like a plan. Sounds like a plan. All right. So let's start with the Supreme Court is now getting their third bite at ACA that that was just announced that they were going to hear that case as we record this last week. Where's it coming from? What does it mean? What possible scenarios are there for them to decide? And at the end of the day, is there a likelihood that this would completely kill ACA? Lots of questions I'll I'll hush up and let you answer.
SPEAKER_02Okay. So where we are, just to kind of set the stage, if you're not following this, you know, all the time, like some weird people like me might be, is that over two years ago, when the Trump administration and Congress knocked the individual mandate penalty down to zero dollars, the state of Texas, some individual people, and then a bunch of other states that Texas gathered up decided to sue the Department of Health and Human Services and the Trump administration over the individual mandate, saying that the ACA was found constitutional because the individual mandate penalty was a tax penalty. And if the tax penalty was zero dollars starting in 2019, then it wasn't valid anymore. And that could not be considered constitutional based on Congress's power of taxation. So the whole law should be struck down. There was some back and forth going on. At first, uh the United States, the federal government decided to defend the law, then they quickly backed out of that. Then they kind of decided to partially say that the whole law shouldn't be struck down. They've changed their position a bunch of times. And what wound up happening was the Trump administration said basically we can't defend this. And that happens sometimes because administrations change. It's not completely uncommon. And so the courts let another group of states led by California, Democratic attorneys general mostly take over the defense in the case. And the case is called Texas versus the United States. But in for our purposes, Texas is Texas and a group of individual people that they feel like have been harmed by the individual mandate. And then the United States is really California and a whole bunch of other states. So this lawsuit's been going through the federal court process for a while. And last year, a U.S. district court judge in Texas struck down the whole law and said the whole thing is not constitutional. So California and immediately appealed. And in December, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit upheld part of what that Texas judge did. And they said, okay, the individual mandate itself is not constitutional, but that doesn't mean that you strike down all 10 titles of the ACA, the vast majority of which have nothing to do with the individual mandate. And in a lot of cases, don't even really have anything to do with insurance reform. You know, it does things like authorize the Native American health services. It creates medical student loans, things like that that would be struck down. So they said, you know, we're not canceling a bunch of loans for doctors right away. Go back, figure out how to sort this out. Go back to the first judge. Well, neither Texas nor California like that idea too much. So California said, you know what, we're gonna skip that step and we're gonna go right to the Supreme Court. And we know that the Supreme Court's gonna hash us out eventually, as they've done two other times before. And so we are going to ask them to look at it right now. And they came up with the list of questions they wanted the Supreme Court to look at. And then Texas came back and said, Hey, if you're gonna if California's gonna ask you to do that, we want you to do it too. And we want to know if the law can stand us well. So they asked the Supreme Court to consider it. The Supreme Court, they asked them to consider it immediately. The Supreme Court basically said, We're not going to do it this term, which means that they would have to act by the end of June. They said we do not have enough time. But next year we'll hear this case. And so in the fall, and the Supreme Court starts up its fall term in October. So sometime after October, we don't know what the day is yet, but sometime after October, we will hear one hour of oral arguments, which sounds like nothing, but in Supreme Court terms it's actually a lot. Usually they give you half an hour. So we're gonna hear one hour of arguments, and you're gonna have to bring these issues to us. One, is this challenge to the ACA even legal at all? Because you have to have standing, you have to be harmed by it. And there's some question about whether or not those individual people that Texas rounded up actually have been harmed by that. So there's one question. And the Supreme Court could just throw out the whole case based on that one little simple thing. Two, if the individual mandate even is unconstitutional, now that the penalty for noncompliance is zero, because there still is a tax penalty on the books, and a different Congress could raise that penalty up to a million dollars if they wanted to. That zero is not gone. It's just temporar right now a zero. It could be changed. So does that is that enough to strike the whole law as being unconstitutional based on the power of taxation? And then three, if it is true and the mandate's invalid, then can it be separated from the rest of the ACA or should the entire law be struck down? So those are the three main things that they are going to talk about during that hour. And then the justices have to go back and consider that. And so we'll have that sometime in the fall. It's very possible it'll happen before the presidential election, those oral arguments, but they don't mean anything. I mean, Clarence Thomas doesn't even ever speak during oral arguments. Like you don't know what's going to happen. They're just going to present their case. Then the justices go back and they make their decision. And I actually looked into this, and Duke University School of Law did a little study on how long it takes on average the justices to rule on things in high profile cases. And they had criteria about what makes high profile cases, but I would say that this one definitely qualifies. And in general, it takes an average of 83.6 days for the justices to rule, but then in high profile cases, it takes them much, much longer. And so what they usually do is hold those rulings till the end of their term in June. So just based on timing, if they had heard this case early in October and then it took them their average of 83.6 days to rule, it's going to be after the presidential election that it will be decided. In all likelihood, not only will they rule after the election, but they will rule after either President Trump's second term commences or a new president's term begins.
DavidNot to get too fine in the weeds, but uh a question comes to mind. And I I know the court has kind of had a lot of latitude on this recently, but doesn't severability require that is the ability of the law to stand if one part of it is severed, doesn't that require a severability clause in the actual language? And as I recall, ACA doesn't include a severability clause. Am I wrong on that?
SPEAKER_02No, the ACA doesn't include a provision that says something like if part of this law is struck down, the rest of it stands, which is pretty common in big pieces of legislation, but there are other big pieces of legislation that didn't have a severability clause where the Supreme Court has allowed certain portions of it to be struck and then the rest of the law to stand. So it doesn't have to be that way. There's precedented to precedent to let it stand. And the AC is an interesting law. You know, we talk about how long it is and complain about how long it is a lot, and we're like, it was over a thousand pages, and you know, Nancy Pelosi famously said, you know, we have to pass it before we can finish reading it. Well, that is all true. It's really long, but it's 10 titles, and the part that everybody talks about and thinks about as, you know, Obamacare is really about 50 pages in the front. So it's not really that big. The rest of the law deals with lots of other things. You know, it's what lets us have those handy calorie counts on restaurant menus now. There's just all this other stuff in there that doesn't have anything to do with it. It's redone the whole structure of the Medicare program that's not controversial. There's a lot of non-controversial stuff. So there is precedent in laws like that where there's a lot of things stuck together to allow those things to stand. And honestly, I think that on principle, some people would like to see the whole ACA go down. But the economic impact that it could have and just the chaos that it would create and questions it would raise if you lost all of those unrelated parts of the law, you know, overnight is something to consider. Also, there's congressional intent to look at relative to the specific mandate. Congress knocked this tax penalty down to zero dollars in legislation. They could have made other changes via legislation if it was their intent to get rid of the whole thing. They had a clear congressional majority. They had a Republican House, a Republican Senate, a Republican president. They could have done that if they wanted to. They have repealed parts of the ACA that they wanted to get rid of. Look, we just got rid of the Cadillac tax and the HIT tax. So that can be done. The fact that Congress left it this way and the president signed it this way does the Supreme Court and the courts will weigh that to reflect congressional intent.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaper Strategies dot com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at Shiftshaper Strategies.com. That's ShiftShaper Strategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidSo you made the mistake of using the word chaos, and that is a nice segue into where we might stand at the end of the election when the dust settles. Now, as we're talking, the two democratic contenders who are still viable, there's still a couple of other people in the in the primary race, are Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders. What would we likely to see under a Bernie Sanders regime, assuming that he could get Congress to go along with his ideas? And then similarly, what would we see from Biden? And then when we get done with that, we can talk about what you expect the Trump administration would do if they're granted a second term.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Okay. So, first of all, when we talk about elections and we talk about presidential elections, this really is a universal piece of Jessica's thoughts and advice. But it's very true in this particular case, too. But don't it's not just specific to their views on universal health care or Medicare for all or public options or whatever. When presidential candidates talk about their plans and they lay out their vision and what they want to get done, that's just them talking. And so we should pay attention to what they say because it provides a window into their soul. It provides an idea of who they are as a person, what they would like in an ideal world. But just like every single person has a vision of how they'd ideally like their day or their life to go if it was perfect and no one else was involved and everything just broke their way, we all know that that never happens. And so it's more about how do you lead your life and get things done when regular obstacles are thrown in there and other people's points of view come into play. So Bernie Sanders wants to have a single payer system in the United States. He wants everyone to have free health care with no copays, no premiums. He just wants to give it to everybody. And that's his vision and his dream. But that does not mean if he is elected president, that is going to happen. I would like to not do any of my work this afternoon and get a big cup of tea and reread Harry Potter all day. That is not going to happen. And the likelihood that Bernie Sanders is going to get single payer for everyone and cost us $60 trillion is just as likely as I'm going to spend the whole, you know, it's much more likely that I'm going to spend the whole afternoon reading, and everyone knows that's not going to happen. So when you hear these things on TV and these things come out of the candidate's mouth, always, always, always keep that in mind. That being said, if we have Bernie Sanders, that's the person that we have. He that's what he wants. That's his dream. So he's going to use his power if he were the president, you know, to use that power to the presidency to try and get what he wants. Now, there's a couple of problems with that. One, just doing the math, the money isn't there. Two, he will have to work with Congress to get that done. Bernie Sanders is an interesting figure, I think it's safe to say, polarizing in a way. So there's a question. Right now we have a Republican Senate and a Democratic majority in the House. So divided government. If Bernie Sanders was elected with the current Congress, he could not get what he wants passed at all. They don't want to do it. It would never get through the Republican Senate. But even on the House side, I don't think he has a broad enough coalition of Democrats to get that done. So he would have to either abandon his plan or make substantial changes and look at the reality. And the thing is with Bernie Sanders, we're we're not just electing a president in 20, you know, in November of 2020. We're re-electing all of our House members and then one third of the Senate. So the makeup of the Senate and the House will very likely change. And if Bernie Sanders is at the top of the ticket, whether or not there will be a Democratically controlled House is in question, and certainly whether or not Democrats would be able to gain seats in the Senate. So in all likelihood, Bernie Sanders would be dealing with even more divided government than exists now, which makes his ideas, his pure ideas, even less likely to happen.
DavidAnd where does Joe Biden stand if there is a way to understand today where he stands on health insurance and health-related matters?
SPEAKER_02Right. So Joe Biden has a much, you know, Verney Sanders has a very clear vision in a perfect world of what he wants. Joe Biden's vision is that he is very proud of his role in getting the ACA passed. And he knows now that the ACA is about 10 years old. Everybody have a little party, double digits. But, you know, as we get into that double digits, he recognizes that times have changed a little bit. Things haven't always worked out exactly the way they thought it would. It needs some tweaks. And then his public stance is that he supports a public option, Medicare for All You Wanted, or some variation. They say Medicare for All You Wanted, they really wouldn't just open up the regular Medicare program for everyone. They would have to create a new Medicare Part E, I guess, or something else, but another section to Medicare to have a public program. Or I mean they could really call it something else, but they keep saying they're going to base it on the Medicare framework and have it run through CMS. So it would be called some version of Medicare for All Wanted. You know, Joe Biden has some nuances on his website of how his plan for Medicare for everyone that won it differs from, you know, say what Pete Buttig had lined up, even though Pete Buttigieg isn't in the race. Like he had to put some details down. So when there was all those people in the race, he had something to talk about.
DavidSure.
SPEAKER_02My guess is that Joe Biden, having his very long legislative history and then also serving as vice president, is a little more flexible than perhaps Bernie Sanders and recognizes whatever he's got on his website relative to his details for Medicare Folly 1 it, that those are just details and that he would have to go to Congress to work with them. And I think what was most important to notice about Joe Biden is his main refrain is, I'm proud of Obamacare and I want to make it better. I want to make changes now that we've had the experience to it and I want to make tweaks to it. Now, if you do not like the ACA or you don't like portions of the ACA, that's scary, but it's it is an infinitely more practical thing to get done, making small changes to the ACA. And honestly, that's what's been happening with the ACA over the course of the last 10 years. You know, the Cadillac tax was just repealed. The HIT tax will end beginning with the 2021 plan year. There have been numerous other changes made to the ACA over the course of the past 10 years. So if we had a Biden um administration, I think that the obviously the defense of the ACA and the tone of the changes to the ACA, you know, maybe we would be expanding some things rather than peeling things back, would be very different than what is going on now in the Trump administration. But I think it would be very similar to what happened in the rest of the, you know, the later parts of the Obama and Biden administration, where they just worked on maintaining a law as it is and then making changes to it where they thought improvements needed to be made. And that's what the Trump administration is doing. They've got the ACA on the books. They haven't been able to successfully repeal it. And so they've been working on making changes to what they think needs to be changed, either through regulations or through legislative action. It's just, you know, how those, you know, what those changes should be are very different, I think, depending on whether or not you have a second term for President Trump or, you know, potentially a new presidency with Joe Biden at the helm. But I actually think with either of those two candidates, we're much more likely to have actions that impact brokers and employer-sponsored plans on a day-to-day basis, as opposed to a Bernie Sanders administration where there may be a lot of drama, but I'm not sure that any of his goals are truly achievable.
DavidAnd that's a great place to pause and end the part one of our two-part conversation with Jessica. In part two, we're going to talk about all things regulatory. So get some notos or some caffeine. But it, you know, at the end of the day, we say often on the podcast that the regulatory stuff is the stuff that really impacts us on a day-to-day basis and how we interact with our clients. So come back for part two next week.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020. All rights reserved.