The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #303: Finding The Right Stop-Loss Partner – with Mehb Khoja
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This episode of The ShiftShapers Podcast is called "Finding The Right Stop-Loss Partner" and today, host and Chief Transformation Strategist David Saltzman is joined by Mehb Khoja, President of Medical Risk Managers, Inc. to discuss the topic from the perspectives of both employers and MGU's.
Mehb explains the lag times experienced between incurring and paying claims, shares his insights on why it is not advisable to swing back and forth from fully-insured to self-insured, and defines what lasering is and its significance in this industry.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- 01:56 Mehb’s position in the industry
- 08:41 Advisers chasing the lowest stop-loss cost
- 11:51 Lag times between incurring and paying claims
- 16:18 Advising clients and switching back to fully-insured
- 19:07 Lasering defined and predictions of growth
Quotes:
08:48 “I would, in any situation like this, advocate for a long-term partnership whether it’s with us or with another carrier, another MGU, simply because stop-loss claims are going to be volatile by nature and you’re looking to the stop-loss carrier or the MGU to help you with some volatility protection. And sometimes, the stop-loss carrier’s going to win, and sometimes the employer is going to win. And all in all, you want to make sure that you’re purchasing coverage at the right level and that you’re building a long-term partnership as you would with any other benefit carrier.”
12:03 “There’s really no downside in that very first year of self-insurance. The downside is in the subsequent year if you still have the same type of contract. So, for example, if ten employers select 12-12 coverage in the first year, and renews with a 12-12 coverage in the second year, there is a significant gap in coverage and that gap comes from claims that are incurred in the first year of self-funding but paid in the subsequent year.”
14:03 “When you’re thinking about large claims though, these are more complicated situations. This is somebody having gone to a surgical center or a hospital to have a catastrophic condition evaluated treatment on… so let’s take, for example, a transplant. And so, in that situation, the transplant claim, because of the size of the claim, it may go through various levels of scrutiny and review before the employer or the administrator is ultimately billed for the charges. And so, because of that, it is common to see lag time on larger claims be somewhere between 4 to 12 months.”
17:56 “Absolutely. I would say though, more importantly is, an employer shouldn’t be going back and forth between self-insured and fully-insured. I think if you’re of an appropriate size and you’re thinking about moving towards this direction of self-insured, you’re really going to evaluate the philosophical decision to go that way. And once you’ve made that decision that you want to be self-insured, you really don’t want to be hopping back and forth, back to fully-insured carriers.”
19:25 “Lasering is the ability for the stop-loss carrier to identify known claimants, known exposures, and to either exclude them from coverage or include them at a higher rate. And so, what does that mean? Let’s say the employer wants to select coverage at $100,000 per person per year. And during the medical underwriting and clinical underwriting process, it’s discovered that there’s an individual who is going to need a transplant next year. From the carrier’s perspective, that’s a claimant that’s already known and from their perspective, insurance coverage is to protect from the unknown.”
21:54 “I think the stop-loss industry is going to grow. It has been growing significantly. The current market is about $25 billion. And that’s up from about 10 to 12 billion just 6 years ago. And really, the driver of that has been the ACA and now what we’re starting to see is a lot of interest in self-funding from smaller employers who
Who are the different players in stop loss? And how do you find the right one for your practice? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change you want to see. This episode is brought to you by Shift Shaper Strategies. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. Clarify your message so you win more clients, crush your sales goals, and build your practice. Learn more at ShiftShaper Strategies.com. And now, here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist at Shift Shaper Strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidThere's an awful lot of interest about self-funding, and we've talked a lot about it. And there are some entities like NEHU that's doing a really great self-funding course. And yet, the amount of folks that I run into who have an interest but don't have the level of knowledge that they'd necessarily like is immense. So we thought it would be good to kind of touch on a couple of different aspects of self-funding, some areas that we haven't necessarily gotten into before. And our guest today, Mabe Koja, is president at Medical Risk Managers. Now he's an actuary, a student of the business, an educator, a thought leader, and he works with both carriers and advisors. So he's got a great perspective. And with that, welcome, Maebe.
SPEAKER_02Thank you for having me.
DavidOur pleasure. Now, talk a little bit about your background and the kind of work you do, in particular with advisors.
SPEAKER_02Sure. So I work for medical risk managers. We are a stop loss MGU, which means we underwrite stop loss on behalf of various carriers. I've been with the company for the past two years. And prior to that, I did some actuarial work at Milliman focused around employer stop loss. And prior to that, I was with Mercer for 15 years consulting directly to employers regarding employer stop loss.
DavidNow, one of the things that you mentioned is that you guys are an MGU. There's lots of different new folks for people who aren't used to the self-funded side of the business. And they have different titles and they talk about having pens and all kinds of stuff. Can you take us through that hierarchy of kind of a who's who?
SPEAKER_02Sure. So you have what we'll call regional health plans, and then you have what's called third-party stop loss carriers. And both of those entities may provide employer stop loss coverage, and they may choose to underwrite the product themselves, develop product, any changes that they want to think about. They may choose to do all of that themselves, or they may choose to work with a third-party entity like us and other MGUs who provide those services on their behalf. And those entities may take some of the risk, all of the risk. And in the cases where they take some of the risk, they will also work with a reinsurer. And the MGU's role is to underwrite on behalf of the carrier and the reinsurer. It's to underwrite, to pay claims, to issue policies, basically soup to nuts what any other stop loss carrier would do.
DavidIs that the normal entry point where an advisor would come into the process?
SPEAKER_02Well, advisors that are advising to employers could choose to work with MGUs who place coverage on behalf of different carriers and reinsurers, or they can choose to go direct to the large carriers who work on this product directly by themselves, or they could go to a specialty firm like a wholesaler who provides that type of knowledge to the advisor.
DavidIs there a better place for the advisor, especially for somebody who's a little bit green?
SPEAKER_02Well, typically the MGUs will work with smaller brokers, smaller entities, and it's a little bit more of a hands-on approach. And the MGU can bring some problem solving applicability to the process. Many MGUs work with more than one carrier, and so we can bring some additional solutions to the provider or to the advisor. And so yeah, I guess when you come to the MGUs, you should expect to get some more service than you might get from some of the direct carriers.
DavidIs it also a place for advisors to become better educated?
SPEAKER_02It depends which MGUs you're working with. I guess I'll be a little bit biased in that. Fair enough. You know, I'll speak on behalf of our company, Medical Risk Managers, where you know, we do all of our services in-house. So from underwriting to actuarial to policy issuance and to ultimately paying claims on behalf of the carrier and on behalf of the re-insurer. And so when you're working with an entity that can kind of bring all those services in-house, you're absolutely right. You're going to get some more service and you're going to get the ability to work with experts in the space. Again, there's some of our competitors who do exactly the same services we do. And there's some competitors in the space who will tend to outsource some of these items to other third parties.
DavidNow you also mentioned wholesalers. Are wholesalers in their part of the industry, are they driving value, either tangible in terms of the dollars of the stop loss and what services you get, or just in terms of educating advisors, or are they just driving more cost? That's a great question.
SPEAKER_02I think the wholesalers, depending on who you ask, I think if you're on the employer side of the equation, you would probably hear that they're driving a lot of value. And if you were on the carrier side, you might disagree with that. Essentially, wholesalers are working with several carriers, and they are bringing additional services to the brokers who choose to outsource to them. And they're also able to drive pretty good rates because the number of carriers that they work with. Now, I think the flip side to that is if you talk to the carriers that are working with some wholesalers, they may question the ability to be profitable in their stop loss coverage. Because again, if an employer is getting a really good price, that could mean that some carriers are writing the coverage at a loss. I know that sounds hard to believe, but it happens in this business where some carriers will choose to write at a loss in order to gain some traction in a segment or with a certain producer. And in that situation, that's a great deal for the employer because they're getting a good rate and a good value, and it might not be such a good deal for the carrier.
DavidBut partially self-funded plans are not a one year in a cloud of dust proposition. They're a long-term proposition. And so the appropriately, at least in my opinion, the appropriately placed client needs to have a three to five year minimum horizon. It's not like buying a fully insured plan where you shop rates and those things are interchangeable, and maybe every 12 months you shop again, is it? I mean, it if you get a great price this year, what's the likelihood that once claims start hitting and you get, say, 18 months into the plan, so you get all that that first three months claims tailing on in, what's the likelihood that those cheap rates are going to hold?
SPEAKER_02It's a good point. I would say stop loss and self-funding is a long-term proposition. And that, you know, really, when you think about the total cost that an employer is paying, the lion's share of their expense is going to be the variable portion. So the actual medical and pharmacy claims. And then on top of that, they may pay an administrator's fee, and then on top of that, they're going to pay the stop loss carrier's fee. That stop loss carrier's fee is typically somewhere between three to fifteen percent of the total expense. And so if an employer is thinking about going self-funding, the real core that they need to look at is their claims expense, and there's various TPAs and carriers that can model what the claim expense will be based on the type of network that the employer wants to select. That's going to be the lion's share of the expense.
DavidSo it's not a good idea though, is it, for advisors to chase the lowest stop loss cost?
SPEAKER_02I would in any situation like this advocate for a long-term partnership, whether it's with us or with another carrier or another MGU, simply because stop loss claims are going to be volatile by nature, and you're looking to the stop loss carrier or the MGU to help you with some volatility protection. And sometimes the stop loss carrier is going to win, and sometimes the employer is going to win. And all in all, you want to make sure that you're purchasing coverage at the right level and that you're building a long-term partnership, as you would with any other employee benefit carrier and any other product that you need for your employees.
DavidLet's talk about some nuts and bolts, and we'll do some educating here along the way, hopefully. If I'm an advisor and I'm bringing in a case that has never been self-funded before, we've got good data. Um, you all can make good decisions about what you want to do. What kind of coverage, like in terms of different types of terms, do I want to show that client and what do those different numbers mean?
SPEAKER_02Sure. So I think where you're going with the question is there's a different type of product for a first-year self-insured client. And typically that first year self-insured client is going to purchase 1212 or incurred and paid coverage. Some clients who move from fully insured to self-insured will purchase 1224 coverage, which is claims that are incurred in the next 12 months and either paid in the next 12 months or the 12 months right after. The reason why this matters is because the cost of coverage can be significantly different from a paid contract or a 24-12 contract to a 1212 contract, which is typically the first year contract that most newly self-insured clients purchase. So absolutely looking at the contract basis is extremely important to new self-insured employers.
AnnouncerAnd now, a word from our sponsor. It's a fact. Salespeople and organizations lose opportunities because they don't clearly communicate their value. In today's market, your story is your message. It should be crystal clear, perfectly arranged, and precisely targeted to attract the clients you want. As a certified story brand guide, we use the exclusive SB7 process to create that story and the websites and collateral that deliver it. If your message isn't cutting through the noise, we can help. Visit us at ShiftShaper Strategies.com to learn how we can help you find, clarify, and deliver a message that wins clients, crushes sales goals, and builds your practice. In sales, if you confuse, you lose. So learn more and schedule that call today at Shiftshaper Strategies.com. That's Shiftshaper Strategies.com. And now back to our discussion.
DavidWhat's the downside of not getting that right? I mean, when you talk about a shorter length contract, like a 1212 and a claim comes in in the 15th or 16th or 17th month, how does that get paid?
SPEAKER_02There's really no downside in that very first year of self-insurance. The downside is in the subsequent year, if you still have the same type of contract. So for example, if that employer selects 1212 coverage in the first year and renews with the 1212 coverage in the second year, there is a significant gap in coverage. And that gap comes from claims that are incurred in the first year of self-funding but paid in the subsequent year. And really, when you're talking about large claims, there's a there could be some long lag time between when that claim is incurred and ultimately when the claim is paid.
DavidYeah, I want to talk about lag time a little bit because especially in the first year, can you talk about the significance of that? And then in calculations going forward, can you explain what IBNR is and why that's important?
SPEAKER_02Now you're uh talking my actuarial language, which is right up my alley.
DavidWarning everybody, warning.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So when you think about all the claims that an employer incurs, most claims these days are auto-adjudicated, which means, so for example, if you're going to the pharmacy and you're purchasing a script, once you're at that point of service and you complete the transaction, your administrator knows of the claim and they've already billed the employer for the claim. Medical claims are a little bit more legged, but only by a couple of weeks, really. Meaning, so if you go to the doctor to have your annual physical, maybe a week or so goes by and you get the bill in the mail, and that bill is the difference between what you owe and what your employer has paid on your behalf. So since most claims today are auto-adjudicated, on average, you know, employers typically will see about a month to two months of lag in the time between when a claim is incurred and when it's paid. And so it's very typical for employers to set aside reserves for those type of claims. When you're thinking about large claims, though, these are more complicated situations. This is somebody having gone to a surgical center or a hospital to have a catastrophic condition evaluated treatment on. So let's take, for example, a transplant. And so in that situation, uh the transplant claim, because of the size of the claim, it may go through various levels of scrutiny and review before the employer or the administrator is ultimately billed for the charges. And so because of that, it is common to see lag time on larger claims be somewhere between four to twelve months.
DavidThat's pretty amazing. But at the end of the day, those are really the claims you're worried about because at the facility side of the equation, that's where the money is, right?
SPEAKER_02On the stop loss side of the equation, you're absolutely correct. Most of our claims are going to be paid somewhere between four to twelve months after they were incurred. And not to mention, from our perspective, even though the claim may have been incurred and paid by the employer, as a stop loss carrier, we may not be aware of that claim for another month or two after the fact because that employer then needs to file for a stop loss reimbursement. And that could be done by the employer directly, it could be done by their broker, it could be done by the TPA that they work with. And because of that, the lag for a stop loss carrier could be even longer than the four to twelve months that we spoke about before.
DavidHow do you protect against that?
SPEAKER_02Well as an employer, as a employer or as a stop loss carrier.
DavidNo, as the employer.
SPEAKER_02As the employer, you're you're looking to outsource that risk to a stop loss carrier. And depending on the size of employer, you know, smaller employers don't have the ability to see swings in their monthly medical expenses. And so that's why they will buy stop loss coverage. Typically, employers that are 10,000 lives and above will forego the coverage because they're just not seeing a lot of volatility in their monthly expenses. But think about that employer who's 400 lives and is spending, you know, probably $5 million a year in healthcare expenses. Well, they don't want to see one month where they have a million dollar expense, and so they're going to buy stop loss coverage to protect them from that.
DavidUnless they leave the plan, unless they decide that they're going to go back on a fully insured basis, in which case they have some potential liability, don't they?
SPEAKER_02They absolutely do. An employer who is self-insured today and decides you know, as of January 1, 2020, we're going to be fully insured again. Well, that employer who was self-insured in 2019 may have individuals who incur claims in October, November, and December. And those claims could be large claims and they could be paid in 2020. And in that situation, that employer would be on the hook for 100% of those expenses unless they purchased the appropriate stop loss contract in 2019.
DavidAnd that's a very important thing to remember because oftentimes advisors who are a little green in this area will take a client into self-funding and not really explain well enough that the or explain well enough and the client just doesn't hear it because they're fed up with fully insured market that this is a long-term play. And then at the end of the first year, they maybe haven't had a great year, even though they're probably only looking at nine months worth of claims at the end of the 12-month period, and they say, well, this is for the birds, we're getting out of here, we're bailing. So it's really important, isn't it, for for that protection to be set up in advance.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I I would say though, more importantly, is an employer should really shouldn't be going back and forth between self-insured and fully insured. I think uh if you're of an appropriate size and you're thinking about moving towards this direction of self-insured, you really gotta evaluate the the philosophical decision to go that way. And once you've made that decision that you want to be self-insured, you really don't want you don't want to be hopping back and forth, you know, back to fully insured carriers. That going through that process, um, it's painful for the employer, it's painful for their advisors, probably ends up being painful to the employees as well if they're making carrier changes. And it's really painful for their actuaries and accountants who are doing the reserve setting and uh you know the financial part of the business are part of the projections for the employer.
DavidYeah, there's no question. It goes back to something we said earlier, and we've probably said a couple of times that you have to advise clients that this is a long-term gig. This isn't a one year in a cloud of smoke. I before we go, though, I'd like to touch on one other thing that confounds some advisors because they just don't understand it, and that's lasering. We hear about it and not everybody understands it. What is lasering? Why does it matter?
SPEAKER_02That's a great question. You're right. When we talk to employers who've never gone in this route, they hear about lasering and they're completely confused by the term. Lasering is the ability for the stop loss carrier to identify known claimants, known exposures, and to either exclude them from coverage or include them at a higher rate. And so what does that mean? Let's say the employer wants to select coverage at $100,000 per person per year, and during the medical underwriting and clinical underwriting process, it's discovered that there's an individual who is going to need a transplant next year. From the carrier's perspective, that's a claimant that's already known, and from their perspective, insurance coverage is to protect from the unknown. And so because that transplant claimant is known, and it's known that the expense is probably going to be somewhere between three and four hundred thousand dollars, that what they'll do is they'll either accept coverage on that individual and raise the deductible to three hundred or four hundred thousand, or they'll decide to exclude that person from coverage. Now, in reality, when a member or individuals on the plan are expected to have these high-cost surgeries, typically the stop loss carrier is not looking to exclude them 100%. They're looking to laser them at a higher level or have a have them have their coverage at a higher deductible. The instances where you see a complete laser or a complete exclusion of an individual is typically for some of the really high cost and ongoing claims that we've seen, especially from specialty pharmacy type of claims. So certain two conditions that come to mind are hemophilia and hereditary angiodema. These two conditions have treatments that come with extremely high price tags and they're hereditary, which means there could be another member of that member's family that also has the same condition. And so typically stop loss carriers will look to exclude those types of individuals from coverage.
DavidThat's a great explanation. We've got just about a minute or so left. Where do you see the future? Do you see this kind of hockey stick interest in in a growth chart in self-funding continuing? And what kinds of things are are you seeing and what do you think you'll see in the near term?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I again I might be biased in this, but I think the stop loss industry is going to grow. It has been growing significantly. The current market is about $25 billion, and that's up from about $10 to $12 billion just six years ago. And really the driver of that has been the ACA. And now what we're starting to see is a lot of interest in self-funding from smaller employers who were previously fully insured, and those employers are going to need stop loss coverage. So we're going to see some organic growth coming from that market. Then flipping to the complete other side, you know, it's it was typical that larger employers, usually those over 10,000 employees, were not buying coverage. But now we're seeing some really expensive gene and cell therapy treatments that are two to five million dollars in expense, and that's creating enough volatility for even the largest of employers to think about purchasing stop loss coverage. So you're going to see organic growth from that segment. And then you have everybody in the middle who's already self-insured and buying stop loss. And those employers and their brokers understand that this product goes up every year by leverage trend, which is typically double what regular medical and pharmacy inflation is. So if medical and pharmacy inflation is in the 5-6%, stop loss is typically going up 10 to 15%. So you'll see organic growth in this market from those two segments, the smallest employers and the largest, and those in the middle who are already purchasing coverage are going to see their rates increase by about 10 to 15% per year.
DavidAnd that that's true. But to be fair, and let's we maybe we end it on this point, the premium that you pay for stop loss in the overall scheme of a self-funded plan is really a very small sliver of the plan costs.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Again, for the smallest employers who are buying a lot of stop loss coverage, that coverage is probably somewhere between 12 to 15% of their total expenses. Going all the way to the other end, if you're talking about the 10,000 life employer who's buying coverage, for that employer, they're probably spending about 2% of their total expense on stop loss coverage. It's very small.
DavidExactly. And a lot of really great information. Maebe Koja, president at Medical Risk Managers. Maebe, thanks so much for sharing your expertise with the audience.
SPEAKER_02I'm happy to do it, and thanks for having me.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.