The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #295: Smart. Fast. Reliable. How about all three? – with Ryan Sachtjen
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the ShiftShapers Podcast, host and Chief Transformation Strategist David Saltzman chats with Ryan Sachtjen, Co-Founder at WatchTower to discuss some 21st-century technological innovations that help advisors use more of their time facing clients and selling.
Ryan goes into intricate detail on common RFP issues today and how automating workflows of companies can positively affect the bottom line. He also discusses what the future holds for brokerage firms that could lead to significant shifts in industry.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- 02:03 Figure out scalability issue to maintain levels of customization
- 05:18 Looking for the right technological solutions (SMB vs mid to large market)
- 06:57 Brokerage firms: Investigating workflow problems
- 08:52 RFP issues and automating workflows of larger companies
- 13:39 Finding technology that fits the firm
- 17:30 Technology to sell more and affect the bottom line
- 22:10 The future of brokerage firms
Quotes:
05:17 “And what we see brokers doing, at least initially, is trying to figure out alignment within their own organization which has been very key of driving a level of success of specializing in different areas. And then looking for, once you’ve done that effectively, looking for the right technology solutions that fit their needs, right? And so they can be different.”
06:24 “Because at the end of the day, the solutions that they want to be using are the ones that allow for them to spend the most amount of their time advising. That is the purpose. That is utilities which they serve. That is what they’re really good at. And so for them to be able to offload some of this other stuff and use technology to help leverage that, I think is a real difference. And you’re seeing a real shift in the market.”
09:30 “The pain points that we’re hearing from them really correlate to helping solve sort of their RFP problem. I have this obligation to my customer at some frequency of cadence which typically is in a renewal cycle of ‘I need to go make sure that what we have in place with the current insurance carrier is the right fit.’ And so my core function at this moment is to make sure that is true. And that typically results in RFP event, in RFP activity for these firms.”
15:52 “The challenge is, like you said, you don’t have necessarily the revenue to be as loose with our spent as you maybe could 10 or 15 years ago. And so, what I think those firms need to do is figure out what are those big impact technology items that they can implement reasonably speaking within their firm that really helps drive those efficiencies. And that’s a key and it’s a very sort of north star element that we have here is how do we help build technology that helps facilitate and be helpful to all of the parties because when that occurs, again, the outcome for the customer is improved.”
20:13 “I’m seeing there is a lot more urgency on actually the carrier side because a big issue here of what needs to happen is, there needs to be some investment on the carrier side to help optimize for this outcome of having things be sort of shared and communicated in more of a digital environment. And I would bet that, if you went to the leadership conference of a number of these carriers, one of the pillars of the four pillars of success for 2020 would be something along the lines of digital fill in the blank.”
When you boil it down, the most precious commodity salespeople have is time. What are the 21st century innovations that will help them use more of their time to working with prospects and clients? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman. Hey Shift Shapers.
DavidFollowing on the heels of our highly successful Pitching from the Stage webinar series, Andy and I are really excited to announce the Major League Mindset 90-day live online mastermind. Starting January 8th, we're going to give you all of the tools you need to make 2020 the best year you've ever had. Stay tuned for more details later in the podcast. And yet a lot of those tools don't actually help advisors create more time in their day work more effectively and more efficiently. And today, with commission compression and with clients expecting an awful lot of things that you used to be able to charge for or that were value ads, they're now expecting them as table stakes. It's ever more important to be operating in an effective and efficient manner. And so we asked Ryan Sockchin to come on the podcast. He's the co-founder at Watchtower to talk about some of the 21st century technologies and tools that are out there that can be helpful to advisors to make the most of their day and to spend more time client-facing and selling facing. And with that, welcome, Ryan.
SPEAKER_03Thanks, David. Pleasure being here.
DavidThanks. Now I know that you believe that there's a fundamental need to update and elevate the way brokers and carriers alike work. It's not just a broker issue. What's the problem? What's the scope of it? How do you guys see it?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's a great question. The problem is significant. It's very broad. It extends, you know, pretty much throughout the entire sort of infrastructure of how sort of the employer-sponsored insurance brokerage and community work together. I think one of the big challenges that the industry has as a general statement is the level of sort of manual effort that's required. And it's largely due to the if you sort of get into the root causes here, a big piece of it is due to the level of customization that you see uh companies have for their insurance programs, whether that be on the the medical side or uh their dental, their vision, their life, their disability all the way through. And I think it's caused a real problem in terms of scalability of process for a lot of the brokerage firms, even when the interest is aligned in that effort, because this hyper-customization has caused a real issue of, well, how do you do that more effectively at a better pace? And so what we see in terms of the pathway forward is companies and entities and organizations that figure out how to operate at that sort of scale level while still maintaining that ability for their clients to maintain that high level of customization is really going to separate what we would think broker A from broker B and make them very successful.
DavidWell, and and that's key, I think, because especially in today's market, the advisors who are have survived kind of the last few years and who are doing things in new ways, some of them call themselves next generation advisors, are all about listening and customizing, which arguably they should always have been about. But you're right, it it does it does create a problem. And and you kind of match the every client is a snowflake thought process with the holy cow, there's a zillion carriers with 4,892 different options. And heaven forbid you start self-funding or partially self-funding, then you bring in all those other options. So how do you start balancing those? Where do you begin?
SPEAKER_03So I think you have to begin by understanding A, what could be optimized for, you know, for your firm. And let's just even remove technology for a moment in terms of how your teams are structured, what's the composition of your associates? And we're seeing a lot of firms try to figure out how do I optimize for different outcomes. And really at the end of the day here, the effort, in our opinion, as well as the opinion of brokers and carriers alike, is driving the best outcomes for employers. And then by extension, employees, right? If this is all done well, then employers are offering to their employees the best coverage, the most appropriate coverage for them to take care of them and their families. And what we see brokers doing, at least initially, is uh trying to figure out alignment within their own organization, which has been very key of driving a level of success, of specializing in different areas, and then looking for, once you've done that effectively, looking for the right technology solutions that fit their needs, right? And so they can be different if you're a firm and the primary proportion of your business are companies that are smaller, maybe under 100 lives. Boy, there's a lot of really interesting tech out there that is serving the SMB market. If you are conversely a firm that you tend to work mid to large market, your needs are different in terms of what you're trying to optimize for and how you're trying to be more efficient in terms of putting together the more comprehensive programs for a mid to large customer. And so I think what firms, in my opinion, need to do is try to identify that first, structure themselves first, and then figure out what that technology solution should be to supplement it. Because at the end of the day, the solutions that they want to be using are the ones that allow for them to spend the most amount of their time advising, right? That is that is the purpose, that is the utility to which they serve. That is what they're really good at. And so for them to be able to offload some of this other stuff and use technology to help leverage that, I think is a real, a real difference. And you're seeing a real shift in the market, in uh real investment and interrogation of these different offerings in the market.
DavidAre you finding now, especially over the last five, six, seven years, that advisors who never really thought, I mean, they thought workflow was dial more, sell more, that they're now starting to actually look at, investigate, dissect, and diagram their workflows before they even get to talking to you?
SPEAKER_03I think they're trying. I think they're trying. I think some are doing much better than others. I think they're feeling it too. They're feeling you we hear things like, we just can't get above, we we're just underwater, right? We just can't come up for air because we are we're getting absolutely slammed here in the fourth quarter. You know, whether that for you as a firm is in September or you're working on larger cases, and that for you is in the firm is in August. And so for us, you know, what we need to make sure that we're aligning with in terms of the brokers is how they ultimately have that fit in for their organization. And I don't see like a ton of putting pen to paper and doing lucid chart diagramming out in terms of the process, but I I feel like they are investing some time and attention to it. And those that I think will be successful in the future are really devoting a fair amount of time and considering does a COE structure, a centers of excellence structure, work for us in terms of a way in which we can be really efficient for this role or that role? Do we have a team structure where the client team is also doing the marketing effort, or do we have a financial analyst team within? You're starting to see that happen more in the brokerage community. And I also see that that is accelerating as a result of the MA activity that is obviously very active in the market right now because they're trying to acquire new firms and then as quickly as possible roll in their own systems and operations to make those firms that they just acquired that much more operationally efficient.
DavidWell, I mean, the the joke used to be with some name brands that we won't name is that if you've seen one of their offices, you've seen one of their offices. And for a while, I guess that was great, but that's the antithesis of being able to scale. So, I mean, weird, not to mention the fact that if you have a whole bunch of different offices telling different stories different ways, it doesn't really lend much to be able to be able to market and extend your brand and do those kinds of you know basic blocking and tackling stuff. So once a firm has figured those things out, where's the part in the workflow that they start thinking about automating? What's the biggest bang for the buck or the place that most advisors ask you about?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, the pain points that we're hearing from them really correlate to helping solve their sort of their RFP problem. I have this obligation to my customer at some frequency of cadence, which typically is in a renewal cycle of I need to go make sure that what we have in place with the current insurance carrier is the right fit. Right. And so my core function at this moment is to make sure that is true. And that typically results in an RFP event and RFP activity for these firms. And for those that are working in sort of the maybe the mid to larger space in terms of employer size, those become real projects. I mean, some of the some of the stats that we've heard are, you know, 40 to 60 hours, you know, per per RFP to just go through some of the the steps of all of the pulling information together, packaging it up, sending it out to the market, going through QA loops with carriers, wrangling all the documents back, reading them, spreadsheeting them, going through the negotiation loops. And ultimately, when you think about, again, what is the key objective here? The key objective is getting the best outcome for the employer possible. You're not driving and optimizing for that outcome by spending all of this time and energy on this manual process. And so where we have seen in our experience and the firms that we work with is that is a really big opportunity in terms of not only being more efficient, but then how do we use technology to leverage the use of information and data so that we can, again, focus on driving those better outcomes. So we can find the best fits of carrier to client, and we can make sure that pricing is fair and aligned, and we can make sure that we've done a responsible job in terms of the level of detail of analysis to ensure that if a transition of carrier occurs, we're doing it with confidence. And so for us, we're hearing we're hearing that very loudly as what brokers are trying to figure out a way to optimize. Because previous to having a technology solution, you sort of just had to staff up for it or maybe go full outsource and go down, you know, maybe a general agent route. And so that is what we're hearing most commonly and most loudly from the brokerage market.
DavidAndy and I are excited to let you know that enrollment in the major league mindset, 90-day online mastermind, is now open. What is it? And why are we doing it? I'll let Andy answer.
SPEAKER_00Well, if you are an insurance advisor or a partner of the industry, you face a lot of noise today. You're a commodity. We all are. But to win out in today's market, you have got to stand out. But here's your problem: you don't have a clear message that's directed at your target audience. You don't have an effective marketing plan to get that message to your target audience. And you're letting your calendar control you. You're not setting effective goals. You're not planning to be productive every day and every week. If this sounds like some of the challenges you have, this mastermind is probably a fit for you because here's what we're gonna work on. Starting January 8th and running to the end of the first quarter, we're gonna help you make 2020 the best year you've ever had. We're gonna make the first 90 days the best 90 you've ever had. So the full 365 are the greatest you've ever had. It's like baseball. You wanna score a run? You gotta get the first 90 feet to first base first. That's what this is about because we're gonna help you craft a clearer message, a more concise message for your audience. We're gonna help you create a simple but effective marketing plan to get your message out, and we're gonna help you set good goals, reverse engineer the goals all the way down to what you need to be doing every day. And then we're gonna work on your productivity every day and every week.
DavidAs you can tell, we're pretty excited about this mastermind and how it can help you shape your 2020 into the best year ever. To schedule a quick call to learn more and see if this major league mindset 90-day mastermind is a right fit for you. Click on our logo at shiftshapersonline.com or go directly to bit.ly. That's bit.ly forward slash major2020. Well, and not too many years ago when the compensation model was quite different than it is today, it was okay to be effective and not efficient. But today you really have to be able to do both. And and to your 60 hours, I mean, I my guess is that that's probably an understatement. I am a longtime filler outer of and hater of RFPs. And uh a lot of the times, you know, if if you're filling out an RFP, let's say it's a piece of business you don't have, but that you're going after, if you're filling out an RFP, you have to wonder is the RFP biased? Is it stacked so that it's really built for one brokerage firm versus another? And then you're going to first plug in 60, 70, 80 hours to hope that maybe on the back end you get this piece of business. And so when you start dividing the number of RFPs to which you respond by the ones you receive, the cost per RFP just goes through the roof.
SPEAKER_03Oh, no doubt. No doubt. And whether it's in the context of you as a brokerage firm responding to a client RFP or you as a brokerage firm going through and producing an RFP out to the carrier market, it is a laborious process. And it is not a high value return to the firm. And so we know that the those firms that optimize and minimize the amount of time that they're going through and spending on these very sort of labor-intensive processes is going to be a real challenge to continue for a long period of time.
DavidBut if you're an advisory firm out there, what whichever side of the RFP flow you're on, how do you automate that? I mean, uh the carriers don't speak to one another, the carriers don't all speak to the advisors, the advisors have different systems. How is that done? How do how do you get there?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and you know, you get there by trying to, in in in our case, the you know, the f the firm that we're trying to build here at Watchtower, you know, we're trying to assist in that in providing and being the supplier of the technology to help facilitate. And for us, we very much believe in this notion of enablement because we believe very deeply that there is a there is a real tremendous value that that advisor provides to that employer client. The challenge is, like you said, you don't have necessarily the revenue to be uh as loose with hours spent as you maybe could 10 or 15 years ago. And so uh what I think those firms need to do is figure out what are those big impact technology items that they can implement, reasonably speaking, within their firm that really help to drive those efficiencies. And that's that's a key, and it's a very sort of North Star element that we have here is how do we help build technology that helps facilitate and be helpful to all of the parties? Because when that occurs, again, the outcome for the customer is improved. And at the end of the day, there's nothing that makes a broker, financial advisor, consultant look better, feel better than when they're confident that what they're bringing to the customer is an improved outcome. And so it is really all about trying to find what is that fit for that firm. And that is what we're trying to build here. And there's, you know, whether that is on the RFP side or whether you're talking about technology on the enrollment side, there's a number of really, really cool solutions out there, and and that is what we're hoping we see the advancement of and are really starting to see that shift occur in a number of the firms that that we talk to at leadership levels. They know that this is happening. They know that this transition into more of a digital environment is going to occur. And sort of the the laying the pipe element right now so that these are all connected is something that a lot of different technology firms are trying to do right now.
DavidWell, and the other side of that challenge coin is equally valid. Um there's a study not too long ago by the Industrial Performance Group that showed that most salespeople spend about 38% of their time actually selling. So let's argue the numbers, if you will, but but you know, let's say that it's 40%. If you could get back half of the other 60% and spend it selling, what would that do to your bottom line?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, this is this is an industry that if you just look at the the close rates, it's just it's very low. And then you don't even, and for a minute, I had spent some time on the carrier side, that close ratio from carrier to broker is you know like five to eight percent. And so it's unbelievably inefficient and unbelievably expensive. And if you could reharness that in a way where the focus is on sort of converting from you know proposal to opportunity in terms of what you're working on and where you're spending your time and attention, boy, everyone could be working way more effectively. And the outcomes for them would be so much better too, because you're closing more business, you're being more effective, you're spending more of your time consulting with your clients and less of your time running around trying to fix all the problems that happen when everything is done manually and by hand.
DavidWell, and and you're also contracting the sales cycle, which is part of that equation as well. It's kind of a multiplier, isn't it?
SPEAKER_03That's exactly correct. You know, and and you know what happens here is when you're just treading water because you're trying to get through the current workflow as it exists, what suffers again is creativity in the market in terms of products and solutions because there just isn't the same amount of time and attention devoted to that. And so it will be interesting to see how that shifts as a new generation comes in and grows up in the workflow in the workforce. And what are the types of employee benefit programs that those individuals want as a generation of workers? And how does that compare and contrast to those that are getting closer to retirement? And when does that turnover shift occur? And those that are well positioned to be consultative and thoughtful in terms of product selection and offering during that process are the are the ones that are going to be overwhelmingly successful, and the ones that are gonna be really challenged are those that are not thinking about it through that lens of how do we think broader here about what are some of the tectonic shifts that are going to occur over the course of the next 10, 15, 20 years.
DavidWell, yeah. And and you're also starting to populate agencies with digital natives who are looking at this kind of a manual process and look at you as though, you know, you're you're making blue smoke in a fire and conjuring spirits to give you numbers. It's they're gonna demand these kinds of systems, aren't they? Are you seeing any of that yet?
SPEAKER_03I'm seeing it get much faster. I'm seeing there is a lot more urgency on actually the carrier side, because a big issue here of what needs to happen is there needs to be some investment on the carrier side to help optimize for this outcome of having things be sort of shared and communicated in more of a digital environment. And I would bet that if you went to uh the leadership conference of a number of these carriers, one of the pillars of the four pillars of success for 2020 will be something along the lines of digital fill in the blank. And that's good because now there's an incentive that is coming top down. And there is alignment in terms of spending and investing some time and a resource to figure out how do we reshift and reshape our organization in a way to be to be poised for that sort of digital exchange of information. And so we're seeing that, and some of the carriers that we have great relationships with are conveying that, that that is a real priority. And then I think that affords the opportunity on the brokerage side to be able to go and execute on that. Because now you're talking about partners that are able to really change the game in terms of what is the service delivery to the client, what is the experience to the client, and thinking about this in a really new way so that those new generations of workers that are coming in, it meets their expectations because they've grown up in a digital world and it is archaic to them to think that you've got to fill out pieces of paper by hand and you've got to scan and fax them in, and and all of that that has been the reality for a long time, it just won't be true in the next 10 years. And so those that uh are well positioned to optimize for that digital environment are gonna be the big winners.
DavidAnd you get the question, okay, I'm happy to do that. What's a fax? Exactly. You know it is you know it is about a minute left. Where do you see the future? Where do you where do you see things going? You you mentioned that you see the pace of this accelerating. What's next? What are we gonna see?
SPEAKER_03You know, I I think what we're gonna see is there is going to be a continuous shift here in the way in which employers think about offering benefits to their employees that are of high value. And I think you're going to see a real shift into a real focus in driving and pursuing better outcomes in whatever definition that means, whether that's all the way down to the employee level, whether that's at the employer level, and the ability for this industry to start actually being connected and not in just a facade way where people say they've got connectivity, but then it's a batch overnight process for them to get data from point A to point B, is going to be the sort of unlocking moment where you can now actually see information and you're gonna be able to use data to be more predictive in terms of the type of insurance that a company might want to offer to their employees all the way down to the employee level. And so you actually just open the whole thing to how do you have this be a curated experience all the way down to the employee. And so once you start having things connected together, you can use that information in a way where it's just fundamentally different for the entire ecosystem. And I think that is what gets us really excited about it because once you do that, once you connect all these pieces together, you unlock this layer of thinking that is really, really sort of industry shifting. And then you have a just widespread opportunity of new carrier entrants potentially offering new types of products. You've got old carriers that are maybe now have an opportunity to really rethink and reshift what their book of business looks like. A broker can really focus on a curation so much different than they were before, where it's a you're fully insured and you've got four options and we can play around with your deductibles, and maybe you want to go self-funded, but you're not comfortable with that. There isn't just a ton of things that they've historically been able to do in a realistic tactical way that they can execute on. And what we see as the future is once you start connecting these pieces together, you now have the data and information to really make these choices in a much more informed way, based off of objective data that just doesn't exist in the benefits world that exists in a number of other industries.
DavidWell, as this evolves, we hope you'll come back and join us again and give us an update. Ryan Socken, co-founder at Watchtower. Ryan, thanks for being a Shift Shaper and for sharing your information with our audience.
SPEAKER_03Thanks so much, David.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper's strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2019, all rights reserved.