The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #287: Nurses Take Back Healthcare – with Jeanne Moore
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of the ShapeShifters Podcast, David welcomes Jeanne Moore. Jeanne is a registered nurse who is now working in the health insurance industry, and providing consulting services. She is the author of Nurses Take Back Health Care One Employer At A Time.
Jeanne talks about the shift in the role of nurses in society today and how this relates to the quality of healthcare as well as the flaws in the business framework inherent in hospital settings. She shares her insights regarding disease management, data analysis and problems with the healthcare industry as a business. David and Jeanne discuss how to empower nurses and the current need to augment their roles in the healthcare system.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- 4:46 The quality of healthcare
- 7:54 The “dark side” of healthcare
- 10:36 How data analytics matter
- 16:05 Healthcare as a business
- 20:15 Getting nurses to understand the whole picture
Quotes:
“I think that nurses are finding their voices in a variety of ways across the country and across the healthcare system as a whole.”
“Most generally when we’re speaking about the quality of care in the insurance realm, it’s not about the quality of care that’s being received in the hospitals. It’s really focused around chronic conditions and ‘are we following the guidelines that are set by all the entities that are out in the world?’”
“There’s a lot of different things — reasons that your data is looking like it is but the assumption that are being made and applied to that aren’t necessarily true.”
“When you have folks in the hospital system, who have never held a patient’s hand, making business decisions, administrative decisions, those decisions are a lot different than if you have those decisions being made by someone who understands the clinical impact.”
“You know, if anybody thinks that the healthcare industry is nothing but a huge business engine, then let’s have a conversation because it is all about the money.”
That's not our opinion. That's the title of this week's guest's new book. What is that all about? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of Shift Shapers is brought to you by Major League Mindset, dedicated to helping you play bigger. You want to become the authority in your market? You like to prospect less and sell more? How can you create those long-lasting relationships with clients who don't change advisors every year? We've been there and done that, and we can help you do that too. Click on our Major League Mindset logo on the ShiftShapers Online.com website for more details about our next Pitching from the Stage program that will help you become the advisor you know you can be. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Jeannie Moore. Jeannie's an old friend, but more importantly than that, she's two things you need to know for today's conversation. First of all, she's a longtime RN and a longtime fixture in the health insurance industry, and we'll talk about that a little bit. But she is the author of a really interesting new book called Nurses Take Back Health Care One Employer at a Time. And we thought that was an interesting perspective and it would be something worth discussing. So with that, welcome, Jeannie.
SPEAKER_00Thank you very much. I'm happy to be here.
DavidThanks. You know, we remember nurses from years and years and years ago as kind of surrogates to the doctors and working really hard, no question about that, but also being overlooked or put upon by docs and other people in the hospital. Is that changing?
SPEAKER_00I do believe it is. I think that nurses are finding their voices in a variety of ways across the country and across the healthcare system as a whole. There are actually a number of nurse organizations that are kind of popping up everywhere that will help nurses become entrepreneurs and ways to start new businesses. And if you think about it, there are thousands of ways nurses can impact many, many different areas. My particular foray is health insurance and the finance and economics of healthcare. And that's so that's where I reside. But nurses are everywhere with startup companies across the nation. Very exciting time.
DavidIt sounds like it. It sounds like so, you know, as I said in the open, you you've been at this for a while. What do you think started the decay of the system and the decline to the point where we are today?
SPEAKER_00Right. Well, uh, you know, I can only share my story, which every nurse that's out there has their own story. But for me, it started about three years after I graduated. I was taught in a nursing school that that taught very idealistically. And when you get out on the floor and you start working in the hospital, you quickly realize that that's just not the way it always works. Yet we adhered to a standard of quality of care. And we were afforded it when I first started because of the patient ratio. I had four patients, cardiac patients, and I could take care of their every need. After about three years, I realized I could no longer do what I wanted to do for my patients because now I had 12. I do believe it was the insurgence of a number of different skill sets into the hospital setting where they administration said that it was because of the nursing shortage. I don't believe there's ever been a nursing shortage. We just decide to move on because of the limitations that are found in the hospital setting. So but that was really the start of the decline because even though the skill sets are numerous, you miss things when you don't have the right nurses paying attention and focused on that individual patient.
DavidWell, sure. I mean, and does that all go to the quality of care that we've started measuring in? And where does that factor in?
SPEAKER_00Right. It does. Most generally, when we're speaking about the quality of care in the insurance realm, it's not about the quality of care that's being received in the hospital. It's really focused around chronic conditions and are we following the guidelines that are set by all the different entities that are out in the world. Hospitals today, we have a kind of an inside joke. You don't want to, that's the last place you want to go when you're sick. And that it really has to say a lot about the quality of care that hospitals are are providing. They're not all the same, and we don't have a really easy way of measuring the quality of care hospitals are providing. Generally speaking, when we're talking about chronic conditions and the insurance realm, for an example, we use a lot of quality metrics in disease management, for an example. In that realm, we've kind of really done our job. Diabetics, for an example, have we no longer diagnose people when they go to get their eyes checked. That's 20 years ago we did. And we're really, from a closing of gaps in the treatment of chronic conditions, we're really have kind of done our job. And so it's time to move on to what do we do next to improve the situation for employer groups? So qual but quality is a very hot debated topic. There are physicians out there that say quality schmollity. You know, it's something that are we even measuring the right things?
DavidI I mean, I guess it's easy to say quality schmality if it's not your grandma or your spouse or your loved one who's being operated on. But I want to go back to touching on disease management. You don't, there's a whole chapter in the book where you don't speak too kindly about disease management. What troubles you about it?
SPEAKER_00Well, I spent a large chunk of my career in disease management. I was actually a leader of product development. So employers would come to the company and say, we want to create a new program. And then I was in charge of a cross-functional team that would put that program together for folks. And the reality is what you can create on paper is often quite difficult to operationalize. And there's this huge disconnect that happens. Disease management, after 20 years, there's really no more need for it. There's no return on investment by continuing to educate diabetics on the standards of care. You're pouring a lot of money into the nursing staff and the IT systems and the data management systems, etc. And the reality is, I always equate this with Al Lewis, is regression to the mean. If I measure something in the beginning, it's going to change the second time I measure it, regardless of what we do. And that phenomenon, known as regression to the mean, is what's really killed the disease management product, for lack of a better term.
DavidSo you at a certain point in your career, you moved to what you call the dark side. I did. I did. Talk a little bit about that and what you learned while you were there, good, bad, and indifferent.
SPEAKER_00I had been a cardiac nurse for about 10 years. And the move to the dark side was going to the insurance company. I had really gotten to a burnout state in the hospital setting, really kind of learned everything I wanted to learn about the technology and the wizardry of medicine, and started to see the people underneath all the tubes and wires. And I was like, mm, what are we doing here? You know, why do we have this 85-year-old lady on a balloon pump? What are we doing? Why are we inputting a uh pacemaker into a 94-year-old patient from a nursing home? And got to see, you know, uh finally saw the people underneath all of the tubes and wires. And that's why I kind of jumped into this arena I had no idea existed, but absolutely fell in love with it. And the dark side is the insurance company. My whole world just exploded in understanding the finance mechanism and the insurance and the regulations. What I did find out throughout my career, however, is that once you go to the dark side, the clinical side no longer want you. So that's why I call it the dark side. There was a period of time where I wanted to get into the ACO, the accountable care organization realm. And what I heard from the people who interviewed me was you don't have any recent clinical skills. And I'm like, what? What do you mean I don't have recent clinical skills? I'm still a nurse. And the truth of the matter is I learned more about clinical information and medicine while I was at the insurance company than I ever would have learned at the bedside. At the bedside, you're very, very focused on the needs of that patient, where the world of insurance opened everything up to me. And I was able to learn about traumatic brain injury, spinal cord, cancers, neonates, pregnancy. It just you learned everything. And that's the wonder. That's probably the reason why I loved it so much.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Let's get serious. Are you tired of watching those other advisors in your market snapping up the primo relationships and wondering what their secret is? Well, time to get your bubble burst. There is no secret. What do they know that you need to know? They know how to create engagement, relationships, and authority, and now you can too. Pitching from the Stage Course has already helped advisors learn how to hone their messaging in a way that resonates with the clients they want. And we can help you do that too. Keith took the class and said, Thanks and kudos to David and Andy. They've been enormously helpful in steering me in the right direction and providing tips, guidelines, and ideas for public speaking. Carol said, I wanted to get myself more at ease with doing presentations, and this course was a great way to build my confidence. This is definitely a course you want to take. Well now you can join Keith, Carol, and all the others who've gained the confidence, confidence, and course of action they need to become the authority who can pitch to many prospects all at the same time. Our next four-week class begins on September 18th, and there's still room for a few more attendees. For more information or to sign up, just click the Major League Mindset logo at shiftchapersonline.com. And now back to our conversation. So as we go down the road now and we're working on trying to make some changes in the system and trying to do some things, one of the things you spend an awful lot of time talking about is data.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
DavidAnd I know that that's a subject near and dear to your heart. So let's go from zero to one thousand in ten seconds on data.
SPEAKER_00On data.
DavidWhat do you watch? Who's watching it? Why is it important? Why does it matter?
SPEAKER_00Right. There are a lot of really super smart people out there who are doing data analytics in some of the major companies that provide the mechanism or provide the tool that is used. And then there's not so much. There's a lot of uh things in the market that really shouldn't be on the market. That being said, it depends on who's looking at your data. Uh, most generally, we have folks who love to look at the data, they think they understand it, and the reality is they don't. To give you an example, and I spent six years at a brokerage firm where we have a lot of wellness folks who like to look at the data, and my response to their output was that's just not how any of this works. We shouldn't be looking at the data this way. It's not really helping your client move the bar. And it's because we're looking at the data completely differently. For an example, uh, I've spent a meeting with a client on ER utilization. We talked about how we're gonna combat this increasing ER utilization for four hours when finally I just couldn't take it anymore. And it's like, wait a minute. Number one, you're assuming that the consumer is the one going to the ER on their own by their choice, and that's just not really what's happening in the healthcare delivery system. They're often referred by their primary care physician. It's typically not an access issue, which a lot of people believe it is. It could be that the ER just doesn't know what they're doing and the patient keeps coming back. So there's a lot of different things, reasons that your data is looking like it is, but the assumptions that are being made and applied to that aren't necessarily true.
DavidWhy would a primary care doc refer somebody to the emergency room?
SPEAKER_00I actually read an article just yesterday. He was so upset with the prior authorization process that he just threw his hands up in the air and he said, Go to the ER, because he couldn't get through the authorization process in the insurance company. I think a lot of it has to do with frustration. It could be that they don't have a certain something in their office that that patient specifically needs. Go to the ER. Could be late in the day. I don't want to deal with this situation, go to the ER. So there's a multitude of reasons.
DavidThat's almost unfathomable and slightly scary, or more than slightly scary.
SPEAKER_00No, what's really scary is when you go to the ER and a patient goes in six times because the treatment is ineffective. That's scary.
DavidHow do you combat that? How do you start fixing all of this stuff?
SPEAKER_00How do you start fixing all of this? I think you put a registered nurse in with every single patient and let them walk through the healthcare system together. You know, how do we fix this system? I think that it will evolve over time. I think that nurses will become more embedded throughout the continuum. And I think we're becoming more vocal. You know, when you have folks in the hospital system who have never held a patient's hand making business decision and administrative decisions, those decisions are a lot different than if you have those decisions being made by someone who understands the clinical impact. That's another reason why you see so many nurses becoming the CEOs of hospitals. Now they're smaller hospitals, albeit, but it is happening. And I'd like to see that continue and promote registered nurses into those larger executive levels.
DavidWell, but playing devil's advocate, I mean, you've still got a huge physical plant that has an equally large price tag attached to running it. How do you achieve that balance between the folks who only want to look at the revenue, the top and the bottom line, and the folks who have actually, as you say, held the patient's hand and have a kind of a different perspective? How do you balance that?
SPEAKER_00Good question, right? I think the same thing applies to our government trying to figure out capitalism. How much does a CEO really need to make? I mean, where where are the profit margins? And let's be transparent about it. That's where we need to be get to is full transparency. I think that most people are generally reasonable and say, we know you work hard, we know that you've taken extra steps in your career, and you need some extra cush so that you continue to work hard. But the egregious amounts of money that our CEOs are receiving, I actually read an article, a couple I'm always reading, but an article that talked about the top 10 billionaires of the United States, they're all in the healthcare industry. You know, if anybody thinks that the healthcare industry is nothing but a huge business engine, then let's have a conversation because it is all about the money.
DavidSo a CEO of a hospital making more than maybe we would be comfortable with them making, do you think is more contributory towards the cost of healthcare than uh an $80 bag of saline?
SPEAKER_00I think both contribute. So that brings up a really good point. When we're looking at all of the data and we're identifying quote unquote cost drivers, what I try to explain to employers and to the broker is that it's not that easy. We can't simply take the data and put them into nice little buckets and say, here, here's the answer for that problem, because that's not how any of it works. Um I always am quoting Geico, that's just not how this works. The cost of healthcare is like a leaky boat, and you have sprouts of water pop popping up all over the boat, and you're desperately trying to stop the leaks, right? And what we need to do is take the boat out of the water, completely seal it on the inside, completely seal it on the outside, and then go back and set sail. And that's what we do as registered nurses. We're the sealant on the boat before you even put it on the water.
DavidSo is it a question of more nurses or a question of rethinking how nurses are deployed or sets of responsibilities? What's what's the change? Because there have been nurses forever.
SPEAKER_00Right. Well, so let's define a nurse, right? And and there are over three million of us out in the United States, and each one of us has a unique story. There are nurses that will never leave the hospital. They don't want to do anything but patient care, and that's great. But we we're not all the ones with the little white hats on. We there are so many of us that have taken the white hat off and gone into the business realm, have gone into the insurance realm, and have mastered that skill set as well. And I think that that piece is most misunderstood, is that I'm not I'm not just a nurse. I happen to have be a nurse by background, but I really can help in all arenas of the insurance company. However, what my skill set is not across the United States. We have to bring on those nurses that have an interest and train them up to understand. Giving uh let's talk a little bit about medical management for just for an example. We have a number of nurses who understand utilization management and they do that job. We have a number of nurses who do case management and a number of nurses that do disease management. It's what's becomes very difficult is finding the nurses that understand all the pieces of the puzzle.
DavidHow do you overcome that? What steps do you suggest that we take first, second, and third?
SPEAKER_00Right. From an employer perspective, the very first thing you need to understand is why you need to have a nurse working with you, right? Whether it's the broker or an employer, why is it so critical for that uh person to help you pull all the pieces together, have a clinical background? Number two, we need to educate our nurses, right? We need to cross-train our nurses. There's a number of different medical management programs out there. The most successful are the ones that cross-train the registered nurses. They handle whatever happens that's in front of them.
DavidSo it's a training issue, at least at the beginning.
SPEAKER_00In the beginning, yes. I think from a brokerage perspective, understanding medical management, we can't teach medical management to brokers. But what's important is for the broker to understand who you're going to trust as your advisor from a medical management perspective.
DavidAnd that's a great place to end our conversation today. But we hope you'll come back. Jeannie Moore, RN, author of an interesting new book called Nurses Take Back Healthcare, One Employer at a Time. We'll link to the book in the show notes on the ShiftShapersOnline.com website. Jeannie, thank you for sharing your expertise with the audience.
SPEAKER_00All right. Thank you so much for having me.
DavidThe Shift Shapers podcast is a production of Shift Shapers strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2019, all rights reserved.