The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #276: Employees Need Deeper Guidance For Their Health Care Journey - with Shannon Skaggs
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Shannon Skaggs, President at Quantum Health, knows that the average significant health event lasts 11 months, involves 5-7 providers and requires the patient to make 41 decisions. On this episode, Shannon explores how a patient can deal with all of that and discusses the tools and techniques that are available to help them.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Do patients need tech guidance or empathy and compassion or “all of the above?”
- How can digital tools help?
- The on-the-ground level services patients need.
- How to keep people from feeling like a number on an ID card.
- Does AI have a role to play going forward?
What lasts 11 months involves five to seven providers, 50 claims, and 41 decisions. And how do we help deal with all of that? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of Shift Shapers is brought to you by Major League Mindset, dedicated to helping you play bigger. Do you watch those other advisors grab the large accounts and wonder, what do they know that I don't? Do you think about being the recognized authority on health plans and other benefits in your market, but just aren't sure how to get there? The good news is those other advisors know a few secrets that we can help you learn to turn you into that advisor that everyone else points to as the one-to-be. We've been there and done that, and we can help you get there too. Play bigger, play major league. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Shannon Skaggs. Shannon is president at Quantum Health. And you may remember, for those of you with really good memories, you may remember that back in March of 2016 on episode 114, and we'll link to it if you'd like in the show notes, we spoke to an associate of Shannon's Kara Trot, and that was a very interesting interview, but very different than what we're discussing today with Shannon. What we're talking about is that as the system gets more complex, it's important for employees to have guidance in their healthcare journey. And we're not just talking about at the 10,000 foot level, but I'll let Shannon define that in a minute. With that, welcome, Shannon. Thanks for having me. It's our pleasure. So let's talk about this whole business of providing guidance. It's easy to say, it's hard to do. Would you outline what you see as the scope of the challenge?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, guidance can mean a lot of things to a lot of people. So in healthcare, guidance can mean everything from, you know, hey, I need to know transactionally where to go, or if I can afford that. So if we step back and think about healthcare, the average person that goes through a healthcare journey, they're on that journey for on on average 11 months. They see five to seven providers. They have about 50 claims filed on their behalf, and they make 41 decisions. So you can imagine those decisions are everything from where the heck's my ID card and what do I do with it, to more lifestyle things like what does this diagnosis mean to my family, to my way of life, and all the way down to more, you know, trivial things like how do I how do I get to my appointment? Those are all the things that people need guidance on. And to be able to switch from what's my deductible to what's my life going to be like after this procedure, that's a broad scope of things. That spectrum, you know, goes from emotional to transactional and back and forth very quickly. So when we when we talk about guidance, it's that idea of being w with a person alongside with them, you know, helping them make decisions, telling them what's next, giving them expert advice to say, we've seen this a couple times, and here's what you might want to consider during the process, and how can I help along the way?
DavidSo I think a lot of advisors, when they think of guidance, they think solely of technical guidance, the kind of, as you said, what's my deductible, what's my copay, what tier is this drug in? But it it sounds to me that what you're saying is that it also includes equal parts of empathy and compassion.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you're right. So, you know, empathy and compassion in our world equals trust. And for you to have a conversation about that gets past ID card, past deductible, past coverage levels, you have to have some trust, right? So you're just not gonna reveal things. We we talk about it as the available conversation. The available conversation will not be there unless there's trust, and we firmly believe that empathy and compassion lead to that. So, you know, things like instead of taking someone down a more clinical path around a checklist, which we all know, whether it's care paths or care gaps, protocols that people should be doing, you know, you're a diabetic, you should be looking at your A1C. If that's not where I, you know, the member or the consumer want to start my conversation, you have to be empathetic and compassionate to that and say, we're gonna talk through that stack of bills that's on your table right now. And I'm gonna do my best to solve every single problem and every question you have. And if I do that in a way that earns trust with you, then you may allow me to have the conversation to say, have you had an eye exam? Have you had a foot exam? Some of those more intimate things that unfortunately our industry sometimes leads with, and people, you know, and we know that via net promoter scores of you know other services, they're just low. People don't want to be treated as a body part or a disease state. We're all human beings and we want that empathy and compassion. So that's really when we talk about guidance without empathy and compassion, all you're doing is, you know, tech technical expertise, which is valuable in some cases. But we see on the more complex side where people are really getting stuck and tangled in their kind of care journey, they need that you know human being that's gonna not only have the expertise, but have the compassion and take some stuff off their plate to say, I'll go do that. I'll call that provider and have that conversation for you so you can just feel better. So that that's that idea of empathy and compassion. We we honestly look as we you know, as we run our business, we hire empat empathetic and compassionate people. We firmly believe we can teach them health care. We can't teach them empathy and compassion. So we even go through our hiring process with an empathy test to actually measure that. So I think that's that's how important it is for us in this space, because as you know, healthcare issues are very personal to people. It's not just yet another state or a checklist or a condition, it's their life. So, you know, you have you have to take that human approach.
DavidYeah, I mean, I think we've we've talked a lot on the podcast about some of the new digital tools that are available. From what I'm hearing you say, those are really an adjunct. You still need the personal care. I mean, when when we first talked about compliance and other issues like that, we talked about trust, but we didn't talk about ways of building it. We were kind of focused on the other end of the pyramid. We were focused on learning about the ProChasca protocols and some of those other modular things that that we learn. But it sounds to me as though you're saying we need to keep and even enhance the human part of what we're doing if we're going to help folks.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Uh and there are digital, I mean, we we have digital tools and we use them every single day as a business. And they're the right tool at the right time for you know a multitude of consumers. What you can't miss in that, you can still have empathy and compassion through a chat window if you need to, or by you know, sending a follow-up email or you know, through a video chat. That that's still available and that that's still accessible. But what our research has shown is that you know, as you get more complex in your care, the more human interaction, not only with you, the consumer that's going through this, but with your provider. If you think about the provider side of this, which sometimes I think we forget that they're just as confused sometimes with benefit plans. They don't have you know a stack of everyone's SPDs laying around their office just to read between you know appointments. So they also have the providers, also have tons of questions. They need guidance. There's a ton of tools out there that we use. Think of transparency, think of you know, second opinion, any of those tools that are commonplace for consumers, providers need those too. So we've found that, you know, in the case of transparency, you know, just helping a provider as they're referring a uh a patient on, just to quickly check in and say with them, hey, did you know you're sending that patient to the most expensive place in town? And I have three options right here for you that you could send this member to because they're on a high deductible health plan. And it would save them out of pocket money, they still get the great care. Forty-four percent of the time, the provider says, Wow, I just didn't know that. I'm in a habit of always referring to the MRI shop down the street or the post-it note I have on my screen. So even supercharging, you know, those digital tools, if you will, and using them with providers is a great example of where I think all of this comes together.
DavidThis episode of Shift Shapers is brought to you by Major League Mindset dedicated to helping you play bigger. Do you watch those other advisors grab the large accounts and wonder, what do they know that I don't? Do you think about being the recognized authority on health plans and other benefits in your market, but just aren't sure how to get there? The good news is those other advisors know a few secrets that we can help you learn to turn you into that advisor that everyone else points to as the one-to-be. We've been there and done that, and we can help you get there too. Play bigger, play major league. Well, and and what a lot of consumers and providers as well are unaware of, that you and I know because we we study such things, and certainly TPAs who pay claims know, is that more often than not, in this industry, there's an inverse relationship between cost and quality. That a shop that does dozens of knee replacements is likely to have a lower cost and higher quality and higher metrics, post-surgical infection rates, recidivism rates, all of those things. And is that a conversation that you have when you talk to doctors like that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, so to be honest with you, if you think, you know, and in how we founded the company, right, is we did research to figure out how people actually go through healthcare, right? Not only consumers, but providers. If you think about what really happens when someone's either referring on or doing uh authorization, it is classically front desk person from a provider's office. You're not speaking to a physician themselves, right? And they've got a stack of files that they're trying to get through for the next day of care, right? So anything that you can do to help them, when it be a recommendation to the the three other providers that are still of great quality but lower cost, we find, like I said, you know, 44% of the time, they're open to that. They're actually very thankful to say, oh my goodness, that is so much better because now my my patient's more likely to go there because there's no longer a financial barrier to them to go. So, yes, we you know, we see that real that inverse kind of relationship. We rarely have to have that conversation with the providers just because it's the nature of how work gets done. But when we do, they're very aware of that. I think that's that's well known in our industry, but you know, think about the consumer. If as you're going through the process, we we th people like you and I that think about this all day long. We love the the theory and the the idea behind these great tools. The reality is as you're going through a healthcare journey, the first thing that isn't popping out to your mind is, oh, I think I remember during open enrollment, there was this tool that could tell me what things cost. I think I'll stop my care right now, go log into that, go look some things up, and then continue on my care. Some people may do that, don't get me wrong. But depending on the severity of what you're going through, that is the last thing that's on your mind. So when we talk about guidance in the space, you know, we take that as our our job to make sure those tools get used in the most meaningful times. It's it's the equivalent, you know, I'm no I'm no physician, so a scalpel in my hand is a weapon, really. And a scalpel in a surgeon's hand is, you know, i i is a paintbrush, if you will. That's our job is to make sure that these, you know, as we call them point solutions, whether it be transparency or anything, get used at the most appropriate time as close to decision time as possible. Telling somebody about it 30 days, 60 days, 90 days later when a claim or some artifact hits a predictive modeler is not helpful. I think we all know that as an industry. To Monday morning quarterback someone's care and tell them what they should have done isn't exactly helpful. So I think that's, you know, as we think through things like transparency or any other tools, our whole goal is to make sure that those tools see the light of day and get to the right people at the exact moment when when people are making decisions.
DavidYeah, I mean, I I I think, you know, we we're all veterans of many open enrollment meetings and employees just aren't focused on anything generally, except, okay, what's my deductible going to be? What's my total out of pocket going to be, and what's my premium going to change too? Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_02And uh it's it's that idea that you don't think about healthcare. I mean, you you don't wake up in the morning and think about those things unless there's something going on, right? You don't wake up in the morning and say, boy, I'm gonna go get an MRI for fun today. So it's just I think it sounds simple. I think we all are you know reasonable adults and you know are are smart people, but at the same time, I think we forget that people are just living their lives trying to get through whatever they're going through, and they're they're not benefit experts, but they need they need people that that are in their corner that can kind of do that heavy lifting for them, whether that's digitally, telephonically, you know, any of those tools.
DavidYou know, we've we've asked the question to a number of guests over the years. I'd be interested in your opinion. We we've talked a lot for years now about consumerism and transparency, and there's some new transparency laws in some states coming forward. And the president's talked about it recently and the no surprise billing, which is kind of the other side of that coin. Do you think that this whole ability to grasp some of these things we're talking about is going to be a generational tool? Is it gonna take that long for it to really be part of our DNA, or will it ever be a part of our DNA?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I would hope, you know, we become better consumers. I think I I can I can follow that line at the end of the day, you know, if you just think of the frequency at which you do things. So if I, you know, if I'm not in healthcare, I mean we know for a fact that people that become very savvy of the healthcare system or have either been in it, worked in it, like you know, ourselves, or have had a lot of care. And unfortunately, those people don't have great survival rates. So that knowledge transfer doesn't happen. Like anything that you don't do very often, you're not that great at it, right? You know, you know, I used to you know run track in in uh high school, and I guarantee you I couldn't do that today. I couldn't jump a hurdle. It'd be entertaining to watch, but I couldn't do that. So I think we'll get better. I think technology obviously gets better year over year, transparency will get there. At the same time, this isn't a healthcare is an event where you're not at your best from a mindset standpoint. Just think of the primal nature of our brains. When you're under stress or your health is at jeopardy, you don't have all of your executive functions. Your limbic system is is changed. You lose some of those reasoning skills that you normally have on your sharpest days, fear, flight, freeze, all of those things kick in. That's just the primal reaction of human beings to stress. So I would offer up that yes, it would get better and people will have tools and they can get to it. But in the moment, in the more complex cases, that all goes out the window. You're really thinking about you know survival in some cases, some more extreme cases, or you're just really frustrated and you don't you throw your hands up and you don't honestly care. And you just want someone to take care of it. So I would say I think it'll help. I think there's is always, I would always push us to get better and more transparent and you know educate people more often. But education during some of these events, the more complex ones, I honestly just don't think that you know we'll have the mental capacity to weigh all of those things at once when you when you're not at your best.
DavidDo you see your role as we go forward mixed in with the human element for artificial intelligence? Do you are you starting to see that come along, or is that kind of a way distant future thing?
SPEAKER_02No, I think you know, I've heard people say, you know, AI is kind of more in the lab of in healthcare. In our, you know, in our world, we use it every day. So there's there's different applications of that, and there's varying levels of sophistication. So I think, you know, quantum health has been in business for 20 years. So we have 20 years of health care, consumer grade decision-making data. So AI and machine learning techniques and models and workbenches are really helpful in our world to say, hey, these are things that belong together, similar to all the things that we're used to in consumer shopping experiences, that people that at the simplest terms, people that bought this, bought these things. But in our world, people that you know show up asking these couple questions tend to go down a path like this. Or people that are looking for the easy one would be people that are looking for urgent care tend to need to be reminded of telemedicine if they have it. So whether that's a quick reminder in our system, by no means is that scripting from our people that are actually on the phones or in our digital experience, those are helpful hints that are popping up. I would say, you know, AI, machine learning, grading, whether those are valuable or not, is super impactful to our business. And then more transactional, just running your business. We forecast how many interactions are going to happen in our building today, and we staff accordingly. And those models are really great for just running the business side of the house. And I think I've seen a ton of great work that we're doing in, you know, MSK and other spaces that can, you know, start to predict the chance of having back surgery or issues with care. So I think, you know, I think it's being used. I know we are using it already today, and we're seeing great outcomes. Of course, there's weird, as we call them, insights that that that our algorithms are coming up with. And the great thing is that we have healthcare warriors here that are helping grade those rules, and they're saying that's that's not so great of an insight. I mean, it's not very helpful. So I think that that's where it's become really impactful on our business is to be able to capture that 20 years of learning that we've had with all kinds of consumers and providers over the years and making sure that we can get those fresh insights to those consumers and providers as quick as possible. So I I would very much say it's here and it's valuable. There are some, there are some you know, things around you know how quickly you adopt that, you know, ethics around AI and other things that we could probably talk for, you know, talk about for another 20 minutes. I'm sure that's not what we want to do. But you know, I I'm excited about that. That's the inner geek in me that really loves that side of our business. I mean, I think, you know, at the end of the day, anything around machine learning and artificial intelligence, it's the quality of data that you're running on. If you don't have a full data set, whether that be provider interactions or not just claims, right? A lot of people have claims. You want to you want to know decision making, what people are looking up, what people are clicking on, what they're contemplating, did they make a decision? That's that quality data just makes any AI or a machine learning system better.
DavidWell, we've got a couple of minutes left. So here's a final question that, again, you could probably talk about for 20 minutes, but just in kind of a quick summary, do you see all this data and this machine learning getting us to a point where the old phrase that we used to use was predictive modeling becomes a lot more valuable and we can help consumers get out ahead of some of these problems and be preventive looking out the windshield rather than looking out the rearview mirror?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think to the to the very conversation we just had about the quality of the data, I think predictive modeling in the past has been based on old old data, stuff that happened in the past. And I think as we get closer and closer to the data that at least we look at, real-time data, there's an there's a provider asking for benefits for a member. We know that with 100% certainty that member is getting an MRI today. There's no predictive modeling needed needed there. So taking that data and applying those same modeling techniques at the front end, I think instead of just targeting populations, that's where insights become super valuable to a person in real time as they're making a decision. You mentioned it earlier. You know, all those models that we have in place, all of them say the earlier the better. If you completely Twitter version it down, the earlier you get to that person in the moment when they're making a decision. So I think that, you know, predictive modeling as we know it classically will be more about insights modeling. And I think that's where the future of our services and guidance really are.
DavidShannon Skaggs, president at Quantum Health. Shannon, uh, thank you so much for sharing your time with us, and thank you for being a Shift Shaper.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thanks a lot.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.