The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #268: Don’t Forget The Most Important Part – with Tom DiLiegro
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
With all of the focus on deconstructing health plans, the technical aspects of self-funding, advising clients on compliance, and more – it is often hard to remember the amount of good we do as an industry. Advisor Tom DiLiegro’s experience as a young man drove that point home in a very personal and long-lasting way.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- How his personal experience drove his professional choices.
- How to make an impact on a personal level.
- How the Charleston, SC market impacts plans, decisions, advising and more.
- Why small businesses are too often forgotten.
- Discussing and overcoming the challenges of fully insured plans.
With all of the focus on deconstructing health plans, the technical aspects of self-funding, advising clients on compliance, and so much more, it's often hard to remember the amount of good we do as an industry. How can advisors keep that in mind while dealing with all those complexities in today's market? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Ship Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of the Ship Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. We all tend to get wrapped up in the deconstructing of healthcare plans these days and the self-funding and the stop loss and the best-in-class services and how do you look at your data and all that stuff. And I I think we often forget probably the most important part of our business. And I was reminded about that talking with my old friend Tom Delegro down in Charleston, South Carolina the other day. And I asked Tom to come on the podcast, and so we can explore that a little bit. Tom is the owner of Benefit Advisors of Charleston. And if you've never been to Charleston, you really need to go. It's a place that's just neat with great history and great food and very nice people like Tom. So Tom, thank you for spending time with us today.
SPEAKER_00David, great to be with you. Thanks for having me.
DavidI appreciate it. You know, we're always interested in how people get into the business. And for a lot of us, it's accidental, but for a few people, it's circumstantial. And you had a an experience that really drove you in this direction. Would you share that with us?
SPEAKER_00Certainly. Like many of us, who the heck wants to be in the insurance business, right? It's always something that a joke that we tell ourselves in college, well, I'm not going to go out and sell insurance. Or, you know, an athlete might be fearful of failing at his uh ultimate, his or her ultimate goal of uh, you know, achieving whatever they want to achieve for fear that they might have to, quote, sell insurance. So, you know, this is no different for me. I was really not not interested at the beginning of being in the insurance business. But it's funny, it's always kind of clicked for me, and it clicked very early in uh my particular situation. You know, my dad passed away when he when I was 17 at the age of 56. Insurance was always kind of there for us. And you never really knew it, but we were okay because that insurance was there. And it took me several years to look back and say, huh, we we were okay because an employer cared enough to offer insurance benefits. So, you know, reflecting back after years, the reason why we were okay is at a time when my dad was sick and and needed medical care, he had a fantastic group health plan available to him through his employer, which was at the time Star Market out of Massachusetts. And, you know, again, it was just kind of there. And we felt it and we sort of took it for granted that he had access to the best cancer doctors in the world in and around Boston. When he couldn't work anymore, you know, we were able to remain fed and kept a roof over our heads because they had group long-term disability. Now, if they didn't have it, who the heck knows where we would have been? But again, it was always just there and it was felt. Um, and I think that's the point is to have it be there when it's needed. I think often that's why people hate paying for it because they never know if it's gonna happen or not. But we were thankful, again, that we had it available to us. Ultimately, when he passed, it was about the time I was graduating from high school. Total uncertainty, total fear. But he had a group life insurance policy, again, offered by the employer, obviously, of $100,000. And that wasn't a lot of money at the time when you're maintaining a house, especially in Massachusetts, and that was getting ready to go to college. But we stretched it and it kept us, again, fed and clothed and housed through four years of college, and who knows where I would have been if we didn't have that. So all these things uh were available to us. And again, frankly, I took it for granted. And it wasn't until years later where I look back and it's like, wow, where would we have been without those things? Where would we have been if he couldn't earn an income when he could no longer work? Where would we have been if we didn't have that life insurance? Totally up in the air. So as I got into business school and started to get out, and my interest in health care sort of peaked. My biggest concern was, wow, the costs of healthcare are going up. And I was keenly interested in what was going on in Massachusetts in 2006 with Romney Care. But as costs kept going up and caused me to wonder, well, what happens if healthcare takes over an entire employer's budget for benefits? They're either going to have to drop or skimp on the other things that were available to us that made all the difference in the world when we actually needed it at the time. So that kind of prompted me to get into the employee benefit space now functionally, keenly aware of healthcare costs. So it doesn't eat up as much of a budget as it probably should to keep an employer from offering other key benefits that can be as impactful to their employees.
DavidAre you finding lots of instances in your market where that's happening where the cost, obviously for most employers, it's the second highest item on their on their cost list on their balance sheet. Are you finding that that it has in some instances actually crowded out other benefits?
SPEAKER_00If not financially, then mentally, they're just exhausted by the discussions around health care. So it's twofold. One, they see the cost of healthcare and having to keep up to offer those benefits to retain and attract employees, which, yeah, I think limits their ability to offer uh, you know, especially on a mid-sized company with 50 to 100, 150 employees, where they're just tapped out and they say, listen, we're doing all we can to keep a group health plan in place. We'll be happy to introduce you to these other benefits, but we just can't afford to offer them as an employer-sponsored plan. And the joke I I always think of, I heard from a partner of mine out of the mid-Atlantic area, uh, long-term disability is often discussed last. So it's long-term disability is last thing discussed. And by the end of those healthcare discussion meetings that often go for an hour and a half, the employer's just tapped out and they're done. And at least two things I found either laxadasical kind of laziness on behalf of the employer of just getting something in or preserving something that might not be high performing, or something that, you know, they've gone, you know, seeing crossways uh through all the numbers and spreadsheets that, you know, it's just, yeah, we're we're done, we're good, we're we can offer the health and that's about it, or any other you know, voluntary benefit. And so group life or group long-term disability is often maybe not forgotten, but just not paid attention to as much as it probably should be.
DavidHow do you approach that kind of a situation? Do you do you go in with a conversation that says, you know, we can work together to lower the costs of your core health benefits so that we can offer some other things? Or do you go to a different angle? What's your approach to getting employers beyond that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it all links together. What, Mr. Employer, do you want to do? What is the ultimate goal? You want to make an accommodating home, for lack of a better term, for your employees for as long as they're employed by you. And so just offering a health plan for the vast majority of us, what are the stats? I think one out of 10 or 2 out of 10 actually have a catastrophic medical event in a year. And that health plan actually might only help you for that one incident in that one out of five years that you might have a medical claim. When you get into the life insurance and long-term disability and other benefits, those are lifetime changing benefits that you can offer. So, you know, we go in and all credit to my Q4 partners, Kevin Trockey and Wendy Kenneep, who a short time ago said, Tom, it's about a process. And that was the big transformative moment in my career was yeah, you can't just be a health insurance guy or gal. It's the comprehensive approach, it's the holistic approach through a concerted, focused process that helps employers get from point A, where they might be now, to point B to some improved scenario with their HR and benefits down the road. But it's an it's imperative that you have a process that you work through and all the elements of that process work together to ultimately achieve the goal of providing the highest quality benefit plan for the fewest dollars spent without having any gaps in your offering to your employees that could have a huge impact on their financial situation for them and their families. So, you know, it's a holistic approach and everything is connected. So, you know, you have a health event, how do you discuss a health event without discussing what it might mean for that particular employee if that health event prevents them from working for an extended period of time? So, you know, I look at it as an integrated, holistic approach that you have to take when designing a plan to have the impact that it should have, which is a transformative impact for their employees.
DavidDo you find that as costs have gone up and personal responsibility amounts for employees have increased, that employers are more receptive to that kind of a conversation?
SPEAKER_00They are, because the numbers speak for themselves. I mean, when you have in my market, you know, uh canned insurance products on the group health side with maximum limits of approaching now in 2019 $8,000 or $7,900, that jumps out at an employer. The thought of, oh my gosh, what if something catastrophic were to happen for one of my people, they can't afford to pay the health insurance deductible. Right? So, so yeah, I think that's the impact that these high out-of-pocket costs are having when employers are evaluating uh their benefits program. They just a lot of them haven't had the uh proper advisor or given the proper advice on how to mitigate some of those high costs and how to uh integrate it with other benefits that could help their employees.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. They've got a family, and for all intents and purposes, they can't really use that unless they have something catastrophic. So what's the Charleston market like? Are you seeing? I mean, one of the things that some employers are starting to use as a hedge against that kind of situation is folding direct primary care in. Are you seeing that in your market?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. It's not widely adopted here, but it's funny, in the past few days, there's a gentleman who is stepping out from a full-time employed position as a physician to start his own direct primary care clinic in August. You know, virtual primary care solves a need. It solves a need in the marketplace, but it's certainly not any replacement for somebody who can give hands-on care and hands-and-face-to-face consult to an individual. So that's always been there, and I think that's just been something that's been thrown in. Oh, yeah, no, by the way, we have a Teledoc service available for you at no cost. That's all well and good, but that often doesn't have the impact on an employee to really resonate and have them use it to any particular uh substantial benefit for an acute medical condition. But when you have a direct primary care relationship, which uh again is is growing here, you have that impact. You know, it's it's wow, oh my gosh, you're you're Mr. Employer, you're giving me access to a real physician who who I can see at any time. And oh, by the way, it's no cost to me. So, so yeah, I mean, that that appeal is there. Uh, but like many other markets around the country, the scalability is a challenge, not only for the employer, but also for the physician. Uh so for example, the challenge I'm having uh with this physician, we've talked about it at length, is he's gonna have an office in an area of uh Charleston called North Charleston, and he's gonna have clinics that are gonna he's gonna take walk-in and individual clients, but also he wants to have a presence in the insurer in the employer market. The problem is he can't go too far from his home base because he has other clientele. So scalability from a direct primary care perspective is is still an issue as it is in many other places, but it's certainly resonating and it's a message that we're taking to the market uh aggressively here as a as a primary area of focus to provide care. Disregard coverage for a second, but give the care first. Once you give health care first, the insurance piece will take care of itself, especially if you're open to a self-funded arrangement.
DavidSo is that part of the conversation that you have with employers? And when you say, as you said earlier, that one in ten or two in ten will have a catastrophic medical event, but the other eight or nine are dealing with lumps and bumps and sprains and broken bones and flu and that kind of stuff, is that kind of the way you position a DPC practice as as it starts to roll out in your market?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Yeah, and I you I draw the metaphor, Mr. Employer, you're you're doing it already. If you have a paper cut from one of your office workers, you're not gonna send them to the emergency room and file their health insurance claim. You probably have a physician friend or an urgent care center in your market, maybe right across the street, that you'll say, hey, go here, get it sutured or glued, and bring me the bill, and I'll pay for it. You don't use insurance for that. Well, congratulations. You have a self-insured, in in part, work comp plan. And so everybody seems to get scared of that whole self-insurance component because of the phrase and the and the connotation that it might carry from years past. I mean, when you adopt self-insurance as a strategy, then you can do things like involve uh a direct primary care relationship to take care of those bumps and bruises without subjecting them to your insurance plan. And I contend they do that on their work hump. They might do it on their fleet insurance. You know, if you have a fender bender, for example, nobody wants to file a claim against their fleet insurance, they'll take you to a body shop and have it addressed uh on a cash basis. So I position direct primary care as very simply nothing much different than that, something they're already doing with their other commercial insurance lines within their business.
DavidI think that's a great way to think about it. You know, it it's funny because for a lot of employers and a and a lot of advisors now that we have more tools at our disposal, and now that the market has gotten to a point where being partially self-funded is is a really great means to an end, you know, it's almost as though the tables are starting to turn. And being fully insured for the for the right employer, if they've got a suitability and and they're in the right place to do a partially self-funded plan, being fully insured is scarier than being partially self-insured.
SPEAKER_00I I could not agree more. And I do a lot of blending. You know, one of the things that we've seen with the out-of-pockets like we talked about earlier, being upwards of $8,000, you can have a hybrid approach, and I've had a successful strategy with this where if you don't want to be partially self-funded in the classical sense, well, even in your fully insured contract, you may not know it, but you're self-insured. When you have medical expenses that are out of your or your employee's pocket, upwards of $8,000, you're self-insured. You just don't know it. So we look at a small group self-insured plan, the spec deductible on the self-insured plan is $10,000. Well, you're approaching that on a fully funded contract. If you're not uncomfortable with the concept of being self-insured, just by the worst fully funded contract you can save the money where you are and just do a reimbursement arrangement underneath that $7,000 or uh $8,000 out of pocket. Again, congratulations. You might not be classically self-insured, but you're taking part in some of the first dollar benefits that can largely be ameliorated by a direct primary care relationship. And via the premium savings, you're funding your max liability underneath that $8,000 deductible.
DavidAnd that's really a big part of the game, isn't it? It's it's learning how to have that conversation with you know with your prospects and with your clients. I mean, you you said to me in our in our pre-interview, lots of people know what to do, but doing it is the whole game.
SPEAKER_00Right. And it's it's ultimately to me, it comes down to third grade math. And I think as it uh you know I try not to be more than what I am, which is I just show people a different way and show them how I can possibly help them. And if we do the right things and have the right mindset and have our heart in the right place, then the path will show us what to do and the numbers will support it. So I know I don't make it any more complicated than that. I boil it down to third grade math. You're saving X amount, you're taking the risk on Y. Y happens to be less than or uh what you're saving, so you're in a no-lose situation, right? And everybody wants to do it, but they're always fearful of a what if. I say to people, what if is why the CEO of a particular health insurer makes $39 million a year because of that what if. And I think we need to stop being fearful responsibly, not irresponsibly, but responsibly not being fearful of the what if, because typically is not as bad as what people might be uh might fear it actually turns out to be.
DavidAnd I mean, what in your marketplace, what do you do for smaller employers? Are are you looking at minimum funding or level premium, or are you finding a market to be able to bring them a regulation fully insured self-insured plan?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, uh yes, yes, yes, and yes. So I look at all the above. One of the big positives I've incorporated in my portfolio of solutions is uh Sedera Health, which is a cash-based medical cost sharing. Now, uh a lot of employers are scared of that concept, medical cost sharing, and that it's not insurance. Be that as it may, fine. If you have that fear, then it's not a fit for you. But I try to find real medical prices uh for real medical services. And when you actually look at the real cost, I used to work at a local hospital system, and you'd be amazed at what the hospitals will accept and physicians as well, frankly, on a cash basis, and have that uh puncture of an eardrum to relieve your pressure. You know, it's only but not even $200 to have that done. A specialist co-pay is $75. So I let the numbers do the talking and say, listen, the real cash price is X. Look at what you're paying against your insurance contract, and how about we just pay it? And so when you do that, it opens up some of those self-insured options and it really opens people's minds to the fact that, hey, healthcare is really not that expensive. It's what we're charged for healthcare, is what is expensive. And so once they grasp that, a lot of that fear that I mentioned earlier goes away, and they're more open to these alternative arrangements to provide benefits, not insurance, but provide benefits to their employees that actually have an impact.
DavidYeah, and that and that's a huge distinction, and it's a great place to leave our conversation for today. Tom Delegro, owner of Benefit Advisors of Charleston. Tom, thank you for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience, and we hope you'll come back and chat some more.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, David. Hope so too. Thank you.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.