The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #267: Better Communication and Plan Branding Yields Happy Clients - with Ellen Anreder
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
It doesn’t do a lot of good if a firm has the best benefit plans in the world, but the employees don’t really know about them or understand how they work. What are some of the key tools and techniques you should use to make sure your client’s message is getting through? Ellen Anreder, Owner of Bleiweiss Communications, has spent her career helping Taft/Hartley Plans and others do just that.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- How a picket line became a transformative event.
- The 5 key components of an effective communication plan.
- How to set measurable goals to assess your communication success.
- Why it is important to brand your benefits plan.
- Email and text messages alone fall short of getting the job done.
What good is having great benefits if employees don't know about them and don't understand how to operate them? And what are the best tools and techniques to help solve that problem? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Ship Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzmith.
DavidThis episode of the Ship Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. Obviously, a subject near and dear to my heart as a marketing director is communicating and communicating well. And I've invited Ellen Ann Redder, who's the owner of Blywise Communications, to the program. We're going to focus on not only the how, and Ellen's got some really interesting steps that I think will be instructive for everyone, whether you're an old pro or a new pro at doing this, but also the where. And some of that where may surprise you. So stay tuned because we'll probably talk about the where last. And with that, welcome, Ellen.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. It's great to be chatting with you.
DavidIt's our pleasure. Could we start a little bit with your background and then talk about what your company focuses on? Because while it's an allied field and some of it is similar, there are some differences as well.
SPEAKER_02Sure. Well, my background specifically is in communications. And I've been working for the firm for Blywise Communications for more than 35 years. The company has been serving labor unions and working people since 1946. And we focused specifically on educating union members and the people associated with unions to teach them the value of their benefits and to educate them as to why it's beneficial to work under a union contract and to inform them as to what sort of advantages and benefits they have by having a union contract. And that's what we've been doing for we're in our eighth decade.
DavidWow. That's certainly a resume. You got me beat on the eighth decades thing, although I'm closing in. Our listeners, as I mentioned to you off-air, are in the benefits industry, and it's always a challenge communicating benefits and helping employers do the same thing. You wrote a story a long time ago, almost 20 years ago, about a PR fiasco that kind of crystallized your thinking. That'd be a good jumping-off point for our conversation. Can you share that with the audience?
SPEAKER_02Sure. It was a wonderful life lesson for myself, for our firm, as well as for the client involved. If you can picture, it was a snowy day in Chicago, and there was a union hall and a trust fund administration office. And in front of this building were a group of workers with picket signs, and they were smart enough to invite the media to their protest, and they were protesting the very trust fund that administered their benefits because they simply did not understand the value of their benefits, the specifics of their benefits, and there had been, as a result of a new contract, there had been an increase in their premium. But they were not informed, they were not educated, and they had no idea that this premium increase was coming. So when they were hit with the increased monthly bill, they were very angry. And the organization failed at keeping the workers, keeping the union members informed as to what their benefits were, how expensive the benefits were to maintain, and how to utilize those benefits so that they'd be there in the future. Accordingly, the benefits were abused, the costs spiraled in connection with rising healthcare costs around the country, and this higher premium was put in place. So the spokesperson for the workers who was speaking to the media explained all of this, and the person in charge of the administration of the benefits learned the hard way that it was necessary to communicate to the workers not only at the time of change, not only when there was an increase in cost, but it was quite clear that if the communication and the education process was ongoing and developing, that the members would be much better consumers of their health benefits, of their pension benefits, and would understand if and when it would be necessary to make a change to the benefits or to increase the cost. There are two words that are used in benefit communications, information and communication. And very often those two words are used interchangeably, but in my opinion, those those words signify very different things. Information is giving out, just sending out federally mandated notices, just distributing words on a page. Communication is quite different. And communication means your message is penetrating, your message is getting through. And that's what's necessary in this day and age of spiraling health care costs and benefits that have to change in order to keep up.
DavidSo you you actually developed what I'm going to call the five steps of communicating and having a good communication plan. We've talked a little bit about the first one, which is informing. So informing, as you said, is just basically sending out required information, kind of the bland stuff that you're required to do, whether it's an ERISA plan or even not. Maybe it's just a summary of plan benefits or or something less than that. But then there's also instructing. And what do you mean when you say instructing?
SPEAKER_02Well, it's key to inform participants as to how to use their benefits. For example, if if there's a procedure, you know, a non-emergency procedure that's necessary, perhaps a plan might require preauthorization of a particular procedure. Or instead of going to an emergency room for something, an urgent care facility might be better indicated, much less cost to both the participant and the fund itself. So instructing would be also educating the members or the participants as to how to use their benefits wisely and the procedures and policies to follow.
DavidAnd that goes into the next point, which is explaining to folks how to use their benefits efficiently. Are there more things than just what's kind of listed in the plan of benefits? Are there other things that they need to know?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Oh, absolutely. Examples of how to how to use your benefits efficiently. To be a proactive consumer of healthcare, if you go to the doctor and it's necessary for the doctor to prescribe some medication, for example, a proactive healthcare consumer might mention to the doctor or inquire as to whether there's a generic equivalent for a medication that might be prescribed. Or as I mentioned before, if you have the sniffles or if your child has the sniffles, it'd be a lot more efficient to go to urgent care or even to call the primary care physician before just running to the emergency room. It's about being prepared as a healthcare consumer and being proactive and not just blindly following what a practitioner might advise because that practitioner doesn't necessarily have the participants' best interest at heart.
DavidWell, and then the last two items in your list are probably the most difficult because, as we all know, changing human behavior and indeed how people think about things is probably the most difficult thing you can do. And the the next to the last one is educating folks about a smarter lifestyle. How key is that?
SPEAKER_02It's critical. It's critical to the life of healthcare plans. One thing that I think many people could agree on is when we're driving our automobiles, we drive and are cognizant of the fact that our behavior could affect the cost of our insurance to insure our ourselves and our automobiles. If you're driving in the middle of the night and you get to a stop sign and there's no car in sight and there's no pedestrian in sight, many people will think, well, I I there's no real practical reason for me to stop at the stop sign. I might as well just drive right through it. But most people will stop. Why? Because they know if there is a police officer hidden somewhere and sees them driving through a stop sign, they'll get a ticket. And if they get enough tickets, then that will affect the cost of their premium and the cost of their health care. Many people, as it when it relates to the health insurance, they don't see a direct connection between their behavior and the actual cost of their health care plan. And that is something that can save a fund so much money if the participants really feel a connection to their behavior and their usage of their benefits and the cost of those benefits, both to the plan and to the participants themselves.
DavidSo making sure that they understand that the process is 360 degrees, it just isn't a one-way road where the money flows.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. And our firm works very closely with a segment of the population known to have some of the richest benefits of any segment of our population in this country, and that is union members. And for a long time, because the benefits that, the healthcare benefits that union members enjoyed were so rich, there was really a disconnect between the usage of the benefits and the cost of the benefits. But even this segment of the population is not immune to the spiraling costs of healthcare. And so it is critical for everyone to be educated as to the cost of their benefits and how to use them wisely so that they're there in the future.
DavidAnd that tags right into the fifth piece, which is promoting early detection.
SPEAKER_02Correct. It also goes towards a goal that we have with the workers who we communicate with, and that is teaching them to be proactive in their own health care, to pay attention to symptoms and what they experience in their day-to-day life, taking notes, being thorough, and going to the doctor and communicating from their perspective what is going on in their bodies, and not just blindly or deafly listening to what the practitioner might say and without asking any questions or being involved at all, doing what the practitioner might advise. It's a two-way street.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients. And over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now, Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solutions, go to our website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. One of the things that I think is fascinating that I know you talk to clients about is what you call establishing a brand for your plan. Now, listeners will think about establishing a brand for their agency or for some marketing for some particular marketing effort, but I don't think many have thought about establishing a brand for their benefits plan. How does that work? What do you mean by that?
SPEAKER_02Well, as it relates to, let's just say, union members and their earning of their health care benefits through their employer or or a group of employees at a particular corporation who may be part of a corporation's healthcare plan. Sometimes that's one of the most valuable aspects of a compensation package. So when information arrives in whatever medium it may be, when information arrives from the corporation or from the union healthcare plan, right there, that's a message to the worker, to the recipient of the health care of healthcare in general, that there is something, there is a message for me from my healthcare plan, and I need to pay attention to it. We get so many messages on a daily, even hourly basis that in order to stay sane, our brains just automatically have a delete button just to keep us sane so we can make it from one end of the day to the next with all of these various organizations and methods fighting for our attention. So when we talk about a brand for a healthcare plan, it can be a tagline, it can be a color scheme, it can be a logo, and the best brands will incorporate all of those so that when a message arrives in whatever medium it may be, the participant sees it and says, oh, okay, without even reading anything, they know that there is a message about their healthcare benefits, and more than likely they'll take a peek at it or pass it on to, let's say, somebody in the household who is in charge of managing the health care benefits in a particular household. It reminds me a little bit, in the 1970s, there was a book written by Marshall McClellan called The Medium is the Massage. And some people say the medium is the message, but it's the medium is the massage. And what's meant by that is just receiving communication is a message in and of itself.
DavidInteresting. And so one of the things that you also talk about an awful lot, and we we had a great conversation offline. There's more than we're going to be able to get to in 20 minutes. So we hope you'll you'll come back at some point. But one of the things that you talk about is measurable goals. And now we all talk about measurable goals a lot, but only from the health plan standpoint, not so much from the communication standpoint. How do those two mesh? What's that and what's the importance of that?
SPEAKER_02Well, one measurable goal would be the number of phone calls that come into a TPA's office or if it's a self-insured plan, the administration office, a decrease in the number of phone calls is a measurable, is a way to measure a successful communications plan, a reduction in the number of appeals that are dealt with, claims that perhaps were not dealt with properly. If a group is educated to use their benefits properly to follow the protocol and procedures in place, phone calls are down, appeals are down, and abuse is down.
DavidSo is that something that you actively track? Do you set up matrices with the TPA or whoever is handling those calls, the customer call center, to keep track of those on a regular basis so that you gain history over time?
SPEAKER_02Our firm specifically doesn't, although we do work with administrations and encourage them to do that, but our firm specifically doesn't. But it's a it is a great tool to be able to measure the success, and not just measure the success, but to measure the failure, because you can really get a sense of where the communication breakdown is. Is it with a particular segment of the population? Are you having difficulty getting the message to retirees, for example? Stop me if this is going too far afield, but one of the things that we notice increasingly with the advent of email and text messages and even voice blasts is there's a temptation to avoid printing benefits communication, whether it's information about changes in benefits or whatever the message may be. There are multiple messages that need to get out to participants. And the temptation is to save money on printing and save money on postage and send out the message via email, for example. Well, not everybody has email, and there is a specific segment of the population that is hard to penetrate with just email, and that's the retiree demographic. So that's an example of tracking communication and finding out a weakness in the link. There is no silver bullet. There is no one particular method of communicating that is going to reach all segments and get the message across in all ways. A successful communications campaign will include any number of methods. And we can elaborate on that if you'd like. But that's one way, tracking the communication is one way to find out where the weaknesses are.
DavidSo yeah, I would like to elaborate on it because it's, you know, 2019, and we all think that Twitter and Facebook and text messaging is just exactly what we need to do. And I don't think a lot of people think about print anymore as being effective. Is it still as relevant as it once was as part of a good communication strategy?
SPEAKER_02The power of print is as effective and critical as it has ever been. It is the focal point and the flagship of any successful communications program. Increasingly, workers are on the go. They are not necessarily in the same place at the same time. And that is what's great about text messaging and emailing and such. But there also are many examples where the worker themselves, the participant who earns the health care, may not be the member of the family who actually manages the health care. Let's use a traditional example of a male worker. He's the one who's earning the health care on behalf of the whole family, the spouse and the children. But perhaps it's the mom in a more traditional role who is in charge of making the doctor's appointments, taking the kids to the doctors, and making sure that the entire family does what they need to do in order to stay healthy. If we send our messages exclusively by email and text messaging to the worker, to the man, then the spouse won't get that messaging. If we have a newsletter or a magazine or even letters and postcards that are mailed to the home directly, everybody within the family has the opportunity to read whether it's a magazine with comprehensive information about benefits or a quick update that's critical and time-sensitive that might arrive on a postcard. It goes into the house, it stays in the kitchen, it goes to the living room, maybe it even goes into the bathroom with some people. It can stay around as a reference tool for everyone within the household to learn from. Whereas one text, one email, if it even gets to the recipient, is only seen by that one participant and not the entire family who may enjoy the healthcare benefits from the plan.
DavidThere have been campaigns that have worked very well with visual impact because you need to convey a strong message. And I, you know, I don't know if you do you think print's ever going to go away.
SPEAKER_02I don't. I think our brains are hardwired to remember things and to retain things much better when we hear them and when we see them. Just a quick example. If any of the listeners participate in conferences or seminars or educational settings where they may be given a name tag, think about how many times you maybe have been introduced to a colleague or somebody who you're sitting next to and they tell you their name, but they're not wearing a name tag, how many times do you have to ask someone what their name is before you actually retain it? Whereas if you are introduced to somebody and they're wearing a name tag, your brain has two senses from which to retain that information. And it's just a scientifically proven fact that if you read something and you hear something, your brain will hang on to that information even more. That's just a name. Multiply that by all of the information that may be in print. And it's just scientifically proven that when you are actually reading something in black and white, your brain will retain it longer and deeper.
DavidSo you should not only listen to the podcast, you should go to the ShiftShapersOnline.com website and read the show notes as well. And I'm I'm I'm attributing the source of that to you, Ellen.
SPEAKER_02That's what I meant to say. Thank you for reading my mind.
DavidI knew that. Alan Ann Redder, owner of Blywise Communications. Ellen, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with our audience.
SPEAKER_02It's been a pleasure, and if you could indulge me, could I end it with one of my favorite quotes?
DavidAbsolutely.
SPEAKER_02One of my favorite quotes is by George Bernard Shaw, and he said, The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place.
DavidAmen to that. Thanks again.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, David.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.