The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #265: Overcoming Small Market Challenges With Today’s Plans – with Josh Butler
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Deconstructing health plans is a challenge – especially so in small markets. What are those conversations like, and is it possible to achieve success with new health plan strategies outside of large markets? Josh Baker, President of Butler Benefits in Amarillo, Texas, shares his experience and success secrets with us.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- How did he end up opening an agency with his wife?
- What are some of the small marketplace challenges?
- Special hurdles to overcome in a state with an average 18% renewal last year.
- What a DPC model looks like when applied to pharmacy.
- Why much of the change is fundamental.
Deconstructing health plans is a challenge, especially in smaller markets. What are those conversations like, and is it possible to achieve success outside of big metropolitan areas? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzmith.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at CaptivatedHealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. We've talked a lot on the program about marketing deconstructed health plans, and it's kind of a paradigm shift both for employers and advisors, and it brings with it its own set of challenges and triumphs and all of those things that happen when you start moving in a different direction. It's even more interesting when you try to do it in a smaller market or a smaller set of markets. And we've invited Josh Butler, president of Butler Benefits, who actually does this in a smaller market and is having some success. And we thought it'd be interesting to chat a little bit about what Josh has learned and how he's gotten to where he is today. With that, welcome, Josh. Good morning, David. Thank you for having me. It's our pleasure. So let's start a little bit with the backstory. You operate an agency with your wife, which could be fun or could be perilous.
SPEAKER_00How do you guys end up where you are? Well, it's an interesting story, and you're right. It is fun, and it sometimes it is perilous. So but no, my wife is a unique story. I'll just start with her. Her name's Allison, and she was the odd duck. She's the only person I know that works in our industry that actually set out out of high school and went to college and gained a degree and knew that she wanted to go into insurance and benefits and employee benefits. And she interned with Willis Towers Watson throughout college and everything and got interested in the business. And then after college, she went to work for Willis Watson, and then her producers had broke off and started an independent agency where she went to work. I've had 12 years of experience in the industry, so we met through some mutual friends. We got introduced by a couple of our best friends. Long story short, we ended up getting married, and shortly after we were married, we still had jobs with other I worked for a large ancillary carrier, and my wife still worked for an independent agency and brokerage. We had always talked about starting our own agency, and one evening both my parents and her parents were in town and we were doing what we do out here in West Texas and having a barbecue, and and my dad and her and her dad, my father-in-law, were just kind of really reading me the right saying, you know, when are you guys going to start your business? And because we had always talked about it. And I went to bed that night and I just said, you know, I think this is something that I'd like to do. What do you think? And we started to get the ball rolling, and that was four years ago, and it's been great. God's blessed us, and we are having a lot of fun, and we love our clients and we love our community. And but you're right, this paradigm shift and de deconstructing these health plans and doing things a little bit more in an innovative fashion is difficult. Amarillo is it's not like Dallas or Houston. It's a pretty rural market still. I call it the the largest small town I've ever lived in, has its advantages. But it is difficult because most of our demographic for employers is small, it's under 50. And so a lot of times scaling some of these more innovative, out-of-the-box solutions are a little more difficult for small employers, but we have discovered that no matter what size a company is, there are things that employers can be doing to deliver better care, better quality, and lower costs within their healthcare spin.
DavidDo you find as you talk to prospects that the under-50 market is as eager as the large market is for some of these new ideas, or are they more resistant?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, in our experience, it's a great question. They're more eager because we have two things that have kind of happened out here, especially in West Texas. It's one of the places of the country that has the highest uninsured population. So there's about 20% of our market here is completely uninsured, which is fairly high. And the second thing is in our geographic region, we have some of the highest deductibles, average deductibles in the country. And it's not uncommon to see almost every single company offer at least one high deductible health plan, and usually it's attached with an HSA, and they are still receiving double-digit increases. And so a lot of times we use the phrase that they're out of runway, you know. So a lot of times we see that even though maybe a small employer, they've already implemented, they've tried to do the traditional cost-saving measures, you know, like going to a high deductible plan or offering an HMO network, and those just haven't been able to solve their problem. They're still receiving these increases. And so I find personally that they're just as eager or possibly even more eager than the large, large companies.
DavidAaron Powell, one of the components of these increases is place of service. Is part of the issue the fact that Amarillo is a relatively small market and there isn't a lot of competition on the, especially on the facility side, and therefore costs are higher? Or do you have a generally speaking sicker population to what what do you attribute those big rate increases to?
SPEAKER_00You know, when I look at utilization rates here in the Texas panhandle, they're not any higher. Actually, they're lower than national averages. So people aren't. I wouldn't say that we're a sicker demographic or anything like that, but some of the strategies that are being deployed out there with value-based insurance design, whether it be reference-based pricing or direct contracting or strategies like that, it is more difficult in a rural community where there's less competition, at least to my experience. But we are still, Amaril is a very unique place. And even our providers and our physicians, they understand that the status quo is unsustainable. It's not just brokers and consultants and employers who are, you know, thinking that way. We're finding many, many doctors and surgeons and healthcare professionals that agree with us, and we've we've gained a lot of success by being able to negotiate direct contracting for surgeries or imaging centers or surgical centers or labs. We have a very unique little economy and culture here in the Texas Panhandle, and it's been great for our business.
DavidSo how how does that conversation start, especially if you're in a relatively small market?
SPEAKER_00With the providers or with the employers?
DavidNo, let's start with the providers. I mean, if you're having success doing direct contracting and bundle pricing and such, how do you initiate that conversation? In a larger market, that those conversations have been going on in one form or another for a while, but in some of the smaller communities, they probably haven't. So what's that conversation like? You just knock on the door and say, hey, we need to change stuff?
SPEAKER_00Sometimes, yeah. But I think if you think about the effect that high deductibles have had on the insured, I mean, that's obvious. We we talk frequently, and I hear on your podcast in the past where you've frequently talked about the functionally uninsured. And to us in our industry, that is, you know, if you have a $7,000 deductible on your health plan and you've got $500 in savings in the bank, you're pretty much functionally uninsured at that point. But we also need to think about the impact that it's had on providers. And you know, if people don't have $7,000 to saved up for their deductible, how difficult has it been for providers to collect that money from those patients? And it really impacts their business as well. So if we come with some sort of solution to say, hey, look, maybe you can get paid in full, but you can get paid a whole lot quicker, and you're not going to have to basically relegate yourself to a collection agency. How can we come to terms or how can we come to an agreement? We're finding a lot of agreement in that space. So that's the lever that you use.
DavidThat's interesting. So let let's let's switch over to the employer side. Now, Texas in general, the renewals were about 18% last year, and that I guess also opens the door for a lot of conversations and employers who are feeling as though the their employee benefits, especially their health and welfare plans, are something they want to do in order to take care of their employees and in this labor market attract and retain employees. I guess that also opens a door for communication. How do those conversations start?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, I think that there's just a lot of frustration in the employer market when, and it was not last year, but maybe the year before that was about the average was about 18 percent. Last year wasn't horrible, but it was still they got pretty significant increases. But the year before was the one that was really tough for the especially the small employers here. I think that it's a double whammy when the employer gets a 19 or a 20 or a 30 percent rate increase and they're staring down the gun barrel of, oh, well, I've got to raise my deductible through the roof again, and plus I'm still only gonna get it down to about a 15% increase. They're taking it both ways. And I think that's when I really started to have a personal, not just the year before last, but this it was three consecutive years here where the renewals were very, very ugly. And that's really when I started to have a personal paradigm shift in the way we operate in our agency is, you know, we just it was a year that we were experiencing those really high renewals, and just every day we were delivering bad news to our employees of, hey, your rates are going up, and there's nothing that, you know, there's not much that we can really do about it, so we thought at the time. And I just went home and Allison and I talked, and I said, you know, I I don't know if I can do this. And she's like, What? You know, we just started this business, you can't so I said, no, no, not I'm I mean, I can't continue to do it the status quo way. I don't feel like we're bringing enough value to our clients. And so that's what put me on a mission to just kind of, you know, I'm a reader and I'm a researcher, and I just said, you know, I'm gonna I'm gonna find out if there's something else. And, you know, it kind of led me into the Health Rosetta. I stumbled across Dave Chase. He's the founder, I'm sure you know who Dave is, and he's the founder of the Health Rosetta, and I stumbled across his TED Talk that he delivered, and it's about a 15 or 13-minute TED talk, and I to this day I go back and I frequently watch it because it's so inspiring. And when I got done watching it, I watched it again, and I was just like, I've got to figure out who this guy is. I've and so I just started to consume content. He had a lot of content out there on LinkedIn and he had it out on the internet, which and that's what led me to the Health Rosetta, which has led me to Q4 intelligence with those folks. And it's an ecosystem out there of just some of the most brilliant consultants in our industry, and I've been able and very, very fortunate to learn from them and to be mentored by some of those folks. And it's been it's been a great blessing to me personally. It's helped my business and it's helped my clients. And now a word from our sponsor.
DavidCaptivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now, Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solution, go to our website at www.captivated health.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. Yeah, Kevin and Wendy at Q4 do a great job. I have a lot of respect for the work they do. And and you know, Kevin's got a unique take on the industry and how to go about doing stuff, and and he is, as you know, he's not shy about expressing his opinions. And you know, I I generally think that Kevin's got the got the right answer and the right the right wavelength. So back to your story. You you so you went through this education process, and what was the first thing that you guys found that you could do once your your thinking changed to try to ease the burden on some of these employers?
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, a lot of it's just very, very fundamental, and one of the most basic fundamentals is just understanding that health insurance is not health care, and at the end of the day, people don't necessarily want health insurance. What they want is good quality health care, and they want a transparent market and they want a fair price. If you go ask anybody that's maybe scheduled for a surgery or they're looking at some upcoming health care service they're gonna need, and you ask them, you know, what do you want out of your experience? I mean, a common answer we're gonna get from almost everyone is, well, I want quality. They don't want to go to the worst surgeon in the country, and they don't want to go broke getting medical attention. And so everybody wants the same thing. They want value and they want some transparency. So we just set out and just started to try to deliver that to our clients because I believe that the cost of health care is one of the primary drivers of the cost of insurance. Of course, there's a lot of other variables, but having a 20% uninsured population, those people still get sick and they still need to access the health care system. A lot of employees that work in these smaller companies that are strapped with high deductible health plans, they're looking for lower cost alternatives. And so that's kind of where we take the initial approach is that you don't have to have health insurance to gain access to good quality health care. And I think that's making a big difference for a lot of our clients that we're implementing these types of strategies, and their employees are extremely appreciative. We're able to, in some instances, reduce a person's cost exponentially for surgeries or for a prescription medication they're taking and things like that. So we're very proud of that, and it it also makes me feel better that you know we feel like we're bringing more value to our plants and I feel like the same thing.
DavidWell, you mentioned pharmacy, and and as we all know, and all of our listeners know, that's one of the big drivers of healthcare costs today, and it's it's only going up. It's kind of a hockey stick curve. One of the things that you guys have been working on is what you call a direct primary care model for pharmacy. Can you talk a little bit about that?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Sure. And you know, outside the traditional models that everybody pretty much knows about at this point, like Good Rx and and websites like that and mobile apps like that, which and we recommend to all clients just because it's an ad it's a consumerism tool. But there are other people, very, very innovative people that out there that one example would be if you're familiar with the direct primary care model, which is a membership model, you know, there's pharmacies out there that are doing the exact same thing because they're allowed to buy medications at cost directly from the manufacturers or the wholetailers, then they can just pass those costs directly on to the consumer in exchange for a monthly or quarterly or annual membership, and it's usually set up through mail order. And in some instances, it's not a program for every single person, you know, but for many, many people we've been able to help over the last few years dramatically reduce the cost of their medication. You know, for a guy like me, I take a blood pressure medication that's $17 a month. That may not justify a monthly membership program because I just pay $17 a month for one medication. But if I took a medication that's $500 a month, or I take multiple medications, you know, five or six or ten different medications may all add up, then we do that type of analysis in our groups. And so that's part of the conversation as more and more carriers get innovative with things like level premium self-funding or what we call level funding plans. Some companies are going all the way down to 10 lives. Fortunately in Texas, we can pull some claims data. It's called HB 2015, and that's kind of where we start that conversation with employers to see if they may be a candidate to transition away from a fully insured plan over to either a level funded plan or a partially self-funded plan because we have some other non-insurance solutions where we can source medications for cheaper, we can get surgeries for less money, we can get radiology for less money. And so when you're putting the downwards you're on claims, you can start to control the overall spend of your health insurance. And that's where I find that even small employers are able to implement good innovative strategies.
DavidSo what is the process for educating employees? Because you know, the populace has been used to doing business a certain way and maybe not understanding these alternatives, or maybe thinking that these non-insurance alternatives are lower quality or lesser quality. How do you go about the process of educating employees that there's a different way to do stuff and that it's in their interest to kind of look at those and analyze those for themselves and their families?
SPEAKER_00Excellent question. And to me, that's the most important and it's the it's it's the most critical part of the entire thing is uh the education of the employee. And I do it in a couple of different ways. One way is I kind of just retrace my own personal steps, what we talked about a while ago, when we had that, you know, that that moment, that year where we were just delivering bad news and we just go and do some self-reflection and say, hey, maybe we're part of the problem. I mean, we're just contributing to this mess. And that's something that we kind of start with is that we all agree that healthcare has gotten in pretty bad shape, and especially from a cost perspective, but we all own a little bit of the responsibility. It's not one single entity's problem or fault. And so what we focus on is the consumer responsibility, is that we all talk about, oh, you got to build a consumer-driven model. So how do you do that though? And it's not something that we just do at enrollment time, it's something that has to continually be educated and reinforced throughout the year, top-of-mind strategies to remind people to be good consumers. But you also have to help them and get them the resources that they need. So, you know, GoodRX is an example. Everybody should be downloading that app on their phone. But, you know, with our solutions, we have material that we put out both electronically and on paper to keep employees educated and reminded throughout the year that, hey, if you've got a surgery coming up, you know, call us because maybe we can redirect you to a high quality or a higher quality facility at less money where we've, you know, entered into a contract with someone. And it it's that that is the key, though, David. But once you get to see, it's fun to watch the momentum build because once you do it for a couple of employees and they get the experience of direct primary care, or they get the experience of saving a tremendous amount of money on their medications, then they're gonna, it's word of mouth, it's gonna spread pretty quickly, and then other people are gonna inquire and participate.
DavidThat's a great place to end our interview. We hope you'll come back and talk more as your success grows out there in the in the panhandle. Josh Butler, president of Butler Benefits. Josh, thanks so much for sharing your expertise with our audience and for being a shift shaper. David, thank you so much. I appreciate it. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.