The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #258: Can a 4th Generation Agency Go Value Based? – with Taylor Lindsey
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Taylor Lindsey is a partner at Employee Benefit Consultants, but he is also the fourth-generation member of the firm and he is working to morph this highly-respected old-line agency into a totally modern value-based, data-driven firm. Listen in and learn some of the tools and techniques he has employed to overcome that challenge.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- How the agency originally formed.
- What geographical challenges added to the mix.
- How to help very traditional employers make the transition.
- How the sales cycle has changed dramatically.
- Why starting with the financing is a bad idea.
How do you take a fourth-generation firm into today's crazy and complicated benefits universe? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. As we all know, there's a lot of change happening, especially in old lingencies. The questions that often come to mind is how do you overcome those challenges that are inherent in moving an online agency into a value-based practice? And I suspect that they are especially challenging when you're in a fourth generation agency. And that's why we've asked Taylor Lindsay, who's a partner and employee benefits consultant, and the fourth generation, to share his story. And with that, welcome, Taylor. Thanks, David. Thanks for having me. We appreciate it. So talk a little bit about the history of the agency because it's a fascinating story and it sets up the rest of our conversation very nicely. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_02Funny enough, fourth generation, I wasn't entered into the business accidentally, kind of born into it. My great-grandfather started the firm for his son, so my grandfather, to ensure his lines of credit at the bank that he was running the president of back in those days. I think you could get by with things like that. My grandfather was very deep into the life insurance business. And as that progressed, pension plans and benefits, my father became into the business in the early 80s. And here we are today. I think I've been here for seven and a half years.
DavidSo there's a lot of change going on. Does your father kind of is he still involved? He is still involved.
SPEAKER_02I was very fortunate when entering to the business. I kind of got to do everything from the ground up. So from service work to working with clients all the way up to now pretty much heading up to business development and running the agency. So he's given me a lot of ground, a lot of reins to be able to make my own decisions. He's here to support me and he supports a lot of his clients that are on the books and allowed me to do what really is necessary to evolve our agency. It's been very, very refreshing to be able to have that kind of control. You know, I think we saw the writing on the wall. About the time I came in, things were the this landscape was very much shifting. So, you know, right before ACA, actually I was studying for series six and seven, and here comes ACA, I dropped those books and quickly picked up the ACA legislation and ran with it.
DavidWell, if you were just if you were studying for your series six or series seven, then you certainly understand complexity, which means that you're well suited for what ACA has has brought us. What are some of the major challenges that you faced early on?
SPEAKER_02So early on, you know, I think the what we noticed was what I saw was the direction that things were going. I knew how quickly things were going to shift. And when a firm's been around since the 40s and benefits really haven't changed since my father started, you know, practically 30 years ago, that's a massive disruption. In an industry that's been so stagnant and to change to compound change over 30, 35 years into, you know, a 24, 36, 48-month time frame, we knew that we had a long way to go. And frankly, we didn't know where to start. Funny story, David. Actually, I got kind of down my personal journey. And one of the first things, so about four years ago, I became a little frustrated with this, and I needed some help. And so actually, I ended up listening to Shift Shaper's podcast and kind of got down that journey. Found some people, Kevin Trocke, and got introduced to the power of networking, the power of collaboration, power of coaches, and that really got us started into this new direction.
DavidDid you find that the the sales cycle was getting longer? And did that trouble you?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it was very frightening. I think in our industry today, I would say a sales cycle's north of 12 months. You know, you may luck up a couple here and there, but to really educate somebody on the direction that the industry is going and to really gain the trust and to be able to break a current relationship is incredibly difficult.
DavidYou're in Western Virginia. Does does that challenge you in terms of finding prospects? Does it do you have a great prospect pool, or are you dealing with other smaller old school businesses that might be a little slower to come along?
SPEAKER_02I would say that our legacy book of business is well established, but finding new clients is very difficult. You know, my office is 60 miles from the house, and it takes about 60 minutes. So finding the clients, we may start with a great prospecting pool or suspect pool, but by the time they get to the prospect stage to understand them a little bit better, it definitely narrows. So it's forced us to travel a lot further, to look for the employers that are wanting to help themselves and really have a need or a desire to do that and to think about change, whether they take action on that today, the mindset shift that it takes in order to make change is really the biggest hurdle that we have to come over.
DavidSo if you go and talk to some of your legacy clients in that legacy book, what's that conversation like? Because they trust you guys already. They've been doing business with you for a long time, and now you're coming in and saying, hey, the industry's changed and you better change with it. And this is a big old change. Well, how does that conversation go and how is it received?
SPEAKER_02It's a long conversation, David. You know, everyone else that we talk to, new prospective clients, it's it's actually not a whole lot different. The journey that we have to take with them starts 30 years ago, you know, whether when they started on with our firm and talking about the trust and what it is that makes them comfortable. But then we've got to get to the point of the direction that they're looking to go to make meaningful improvements to their organization. And whether that's through communication or education with the leadership team, the HR, or the employees, it's a conversation that continues to come back to knowing that the partners that they work with, which is us, are continuing to evolve for their best interest to exceed the expectations of their needs.
DavidWell, your choice of words interests me because you said meaningful improvements to their organization. In the past, we talked about meaningful improvements to their health insurance benefits. How does that differ? Have we gotten to the point now where the things that you and other advisors like you do transcend just the benefits plan and actually affect corporate culture and employee involvement and employee satisfaction and all of those other soft metrics?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely, David. You know, no longer is this insurance sales. We're really problem solvers. While insurance is a big focal point of that, you know, with the number two, number three largest expense, of course, that holds a heavy, heavy burden on employers and their employees. I mean, you think about that 25, 30 years ago, it was 5% of total compensation. Today it's 30, even upwards of 50% of comp. So that conversation is obvious obviously shifted, but it's everything else that we can do that surrounds the insurance piece to help support it, the communication and the education, the complexities of the law and the legislation, the forecasting of it, the technology that we can bring to help improve their overall strategies. It's all those pieces that are working together that give this employee benefits package the pulse that it needs.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years experience working with healthcare and benefit clients. And over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solution, go to our website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. So is is the conversation, is the starting point of the conversation the financing, the difference between moving from fully insured to partially self-insured and what opportunities that gives the prospect, or do you start at a different entry point?
SPEAKER_02We really do try to start at a different entry point. Of course, when a particular client or prospect has needs that are very, very urgent, we may jump into that a little quicker. In an ideal world, we'll start earlier, we'll find those pain points that they have. And many times it is budget. It is finding that equilibrium of benefits and expense, and then the shifting that conversation from an expense more back into the investment of the organization and their employees. It's become incredibly more popular to talk about that transition from the fully insured world, stair-stepping into self-insurance or some level of that and the control and the capabilities within those plans. It's exciting to me, but it more importantly, it's exciting to the outcomes and the benefits for our clients. And I think that's when the conversation starts to, those wheels start to spin in their head. Meeting those pain points, finding those open wounds, and then bringing those solutions that we can, then we have a lot more capabilities of helping with in the partially self-insured world. That's when they start to understand it, but it all goes back to the education. And many times employers don't have a need or a desire to make any forward progress, but it's on us to talk about it. It's on us to educate them on what's out there and available.
DavidSo do you ID good prospects by virtue of that conversation and the responses that come back and then determining that folks are more willing to change or less willing to change, or do you have other metrics that you look at?
SPEAKER_02You know, David, that's that's a pretty interesting question because the prospecting side of this business is becoming ever cumbersome, really. Many people are are say that they're happy with their current situation, but when you go down and you and you challenge that question, exactly what they are happy with, the conversation tends to turn. You know, we're we're in this evolution of an industry in which Ben is fairly transactional and fairly stagnant. And I say that from you know eight years in the industry. So I'm not one to point fingers, but I am one here to make continue to make those improvements. You know, going back to our agency when I start when I started with with my father, was you know, what he did, he greatly supported his clients, but but the marketplace shifted. And so we had to shift very quickly. So it's really just that journey of being able to identify those employers earlier on. They're at least willing to have that conversation.
DavidSo what are some of the value-based tools and techniques that you talk to employers about? What what resonates in your area? And do you suspect from from your conversations with Kevin and other folks, maybe in Kevin's mastermind group, that that it's different regionally, or is it pretty much the same across the country?
SPEAKER_02I think, you know, we we'll talk about public and private employers and large and small, and we all think that we're so different. But if you look across the country, Tita, those pain points are pretty unilateral all the way across the country. We're all facing the same struggles. We're all faced against the same challenges of the healthcare industry, not just the insurance piece. So, you know, the solutions that we're bringing to the table are everything from a fully insured package from some of our smaller employers, or even larger ones that aren't ready to make that journey to direct contracting, pharmacy programs, which helps the international pharmacy labs and imaging, reference-based pricing many times comes to conversation. It's all those little pieces that are under the hood of what we'll call value-based insurance or a high-performing health plan. Those pieces are where the opportunities lie, but it doesn't all have to be done in a day.
DavidNo, and I I I presume that in many cases it would be best if it weren't done all in a day, because it's a lot to swallow. Look, it's been it's been a lot for all of us in the industry to educate ourselves about. So it you've got to imagine that for a prospect who's making rubber baby buggy bumpers or cardboard boxes or whatever industry they're in, it's a lot to wrap your head around because it's very different than, as you say, we've things we've been doing for the last 30 years or that your dad or even your granddad did.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. And let's not forget this. I mean, change is painful. It was painful for us to change as an agency, but you've got to, you everybody's doing what's necessary to be competitive in today's marketplace. We're operating on smaller margins. Our clients are operating on smaller margins, and that's why we've got to help them get their hands dirty and take some of these things back into their control. And I think that that's where people get, you know, a little bit of a challenge. They're not used to managing these benefits on their own. It's been a pretty turnkey solution, and that's been nice. And it's put people in a comfort zone, but now the pain is outweighing the change. When that pain becomes so great, they will get their hands dirty.
DavidAre you guys having conversations or have you already gotten there where you're talking about fees in lieu of commissions or an amalgam of the two? What's your structure look like?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. We're very transparent in either whether we're paid through the insurance product, we're transparent in those fees, or if we do charge a fee, we're upfront about that. We are having conversations with prospective clients and current clients about performance-based just because it's such a it puts us on the same side of the table as they are. We're in an industry where we've got to put our money where our mouth is in order for this thing to evolve. And I think employers are enlightened to see that, to see that at least you're willing to do what is necessary and to do what's in their best interest. And honestly, David, we're on a journey to bring transparency to this entire system, insurance and healthcare both.
DavidSo how do you there are a lot of advisors who are facing these same kinds of issues? How do you begin to educate yourself about all of these new modalities and how to have these conversations and and such? You mentioned coaching early on. That might be one component. Are there educational sources? What did you do to kind of get up to speed on all this stuff?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely, yeah. Hired coaches with Q4 Intelligence and have one-off conversations within that network. From there, we we branch to other experts within that area. Um we find out what the problem or what the problem is with these clients, and we just go down that journey. We use the resources that we have. You know, we're a small shop, we're a boutique employee benefits firm, but our org chart is as deep as the big box stores. May not be on retainer, but they're there in our in our benches ready to help support us, whether it's Health Rosetta Tactics or the networking of Q4. You know, we're in this industry, the benefits space is becoming so much more collaborative. People are working for a common mission, and we're working to bring improvement because if we don't do this now, we don't know what the future holds in five years. The single payer, you know, where does that put our space? So we all know that it's the time is now to make that shift. And if you're not investing in yourself, in your education, and then sharing that message back with your clients and prospects, you know, we're all failing in that aspect if we don't take care of it and put it on our own shoulders.
DavidIt is that deep bench conversation something that you bring out when you're talking to clients and prospects as well? That as you said, while you may be a small boutique firm, you have a lot of depth and a lot of expertise available to you?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. We may not start there, but when we identify particular pain points, that deep bench, knowing that we have those resources, whether it's pharmacy, whether it's direct contracting or bundling or imaging DPC, we better have people on our bench because that's how you know the whole story of David versus Goliath. You know, if we're going to be challenged against these books of capabilities, we better be able to support and fill those gaps as well. But we're able to evolve much, much quicker pace. And our clients and prospects deserve to be aware that we have people on our side to support us, and that reaches to them as a client.
DavidYeah, I mean, I think one of the things that we've all learned as we've undergone these changes is how important it is to be able to be nimble because the change happens frequently and we need to digest it and then get it back out to clients. And I think that's a great point. We've got about a minute or so left. Where do you see the future, both in your firm and maybe across the industry? You're you're a thinker, and and you and I had some conversations offline about where you think things are going. Share that if you would.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely, David. I think that this industry is really in the we're at a tipping point, and we're about to move into a spot where instead of just saying we're consumers, we're gonna actually get to a point where each member within a health plan is actually given the data to make the best decision that they possibly can. We're gonna be seeing more free market, I think, in the healthcare space. And I think, and hopefully, things become regional pockets of healthcare. You know, there's nothing more local than going to your doctor, and so we've got to work with our own communities internally to build out the needs. Without the employers, you don't have hospitals, and vice versa. So I think that you know, bringing this all back together, we're solving problems across the country. But we want to be able to do this right here in our own backyard.
DavidA great place to end our conversation for today. Taylor Lindsay, partner at Employee Benefits Consultants. Taylor, thank you for sharing your expertise and for being a shift shaper. Thanks, David. The Shift Shaper Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.