The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #255: Taft/Hartley Plans May Be The Leading Edge of Change – with Jacques Loveall
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Our guest on this episode, Jacques Loveall, is Chairman of the United Food and Commercial Workers Trust, which, after being buffeted by the system as end users and an (almost) afterthought, has made some long-overdue changes in ownership and control of healthcare delivery. It is has been a fascinating journey, and they are just getting started.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Why Taft/Hartley plans are different from commercial plans.
- The journey from afterthought end user to ownership and control.
- Why Hotel & Restaurant Employees in New York own hospital facilities.
- Is this model analogous to the original Kaiser plans?
- How does our guest envision this as a growing movement?
Half-Hartley plans, long overlooked by most advisors, may be on the forefront of change in large group medical. What are they doing, and how might it be the harbinger of broader change? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzmith.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Jacques Laval. Jacques is the chairman of a very interesting organization, the UFCW Trust. And as as many of you know, Taft Hartley Universe is different than the commercial universe that a lot of us practice in. But he's got a lot of experience with healthcare and the obstacles that they faced, and a kind of unique perspective and a unique decision was made that has kind of helped them take control of what's going on. And we wanted to be sure that you heard their story because I think there are certain applications for it on the commercial side as well, although it might be a little different kind of a reach. But with that kind of a long-winded introduction, welcome, Jacques. Happy to be on. I appreciate your interest in what we're doing. Well, thanks. Um I I don't know how many folks in the listening audience actually know a lot about Taft Hartley plans. Could you give us a kind of quick primer on what those plans are and how they differ from a traditional commercial health insurance plan?
SPEAKER_01Sure. I'd be happy to. Taft Hartley plans are plans that are created by employers and unions. As a result of the contracts that are negotiated, the collective bargaining agreements, we negotiate the benefits, whether they be health care or pensions, and then we create trust funds that are jointly administered, that have employers from the participating employers that are contributing to the funds, and then the unions that represent the participants of those funds. So they're jointly administered by labor and management, and that's essentially the defining characteristic of a Taft Hartley plan is it's a labor management arrangement.
DavidAnd and for folks who might get confused, this is not a multiple employer welfare arrangement, which is a Miwa that you're you're more familiar with. These are multi-employer plans.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. For an example, in the case of the UFCW Trust, uh UFCW is United Food and Commercial Workers. So for example, the participating employers would be for the most part major supermarket employers, major drug store chain employers. So you'd you know from a national basis you recognise recognize names like Safeway or Kroger or Riteaid. Those are the type of uh those are the type of companies you'd be looking at. So so the major supermarket, multi-employer plans, but then the other participants in the trust, the other trustees, are the union officials for the unions that represent the workers in those funds.
DavidTo come back up to where you're located, which is the northern part of California, you guys were seeing pretty exponential cost acceleration, and it caused some serious problems and consequences for the people you represent. Could you talk a little bit about what that environment was like?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I would be happy to. What we've seen in Northern California, first of all, I would I would start by telling you, Northern California has the highest health care costs of anywhere in the country, with some very, you know, with some minor exceptions to very small pockets. But Northern California, as a region of the country, has the highest health care costs in the country. And there's a number of different reasons for that. And they are almost entirely driven by the healthcare industry and the way they do pricing and contracting with our networks and the the notion that they can essentially charge whatever they want. There's a number of reasons why they've been able to get away with it. And I'm not going to get into all the details of that. But I will tell you that there's been Attorney General of California's actually filed suit against different healthcare providers for monopolistic practices in in Northern California, which have effectively raised the prices out of sight for healthcare in Northern California. But to distill down to what you were talking about, what problems specifically was it creating for us? Well, obviously, we negotiate the health care for our members along with their pension contributions and their wage contributions, and a larger and larger amount of the money that was available when we would bargain was required to put into healthcare, which may put a lot of pressure on our ability to get wage increases or pension contributions because so much of our what we were bargaining for was going to health care. That put pressure on our employers to want to try and reduce health care cost. Strikes over health care. And obviously it's not isolated, just the food industry, but there's a lot of pressure on employers in labor because of the rising cost of health care. Well, what occurred to me was this wasn't our employers being draconian, and it certainly wasn't our members being selfish or expecting an unreasonable compensation package. It was a problem that was created and forcing us into conflicts with our employers that was created by something that was outside of our control, and that was the healthcare industry. The idea of going down that path over and over again and having conflicts with our employers over something that they had no control over, or we had no control over, was extremely frustrating. So rather than continue to go down that path, it occurred to us that we needed to take a more active role in the provision of health care and the governance of health care and how the healthcare system was constructed in Northern California. So what we did is we established a fund that we call the Strategic Health Care Fund. And the Strategic Health Care Fund is very simple. It is a fund that was created by labor and or Tap Hartley Markets, and it was initiated, the seed money came from the pension fund from the UFCW Trust. The seed money was $100 million and since we've at this point it the fund has been in existence for just a few months, quite frankly. It is now we have $300 million that's been raised, and with the goal of the first fund being a $500 million fund. And the purpose of the strategic health care fund is to actually take equity positions in healthcare service providers, so that rather than simply being a customer of the healthcare industry, we're actually equity owners. And we have governance, we have some say in how the healthcare is delivered, and quite frankly, we have ownership so that we can uh experience some of the some of the upside in terms of the finances, in terms of funding our pensions. So the the goal is to create a better health care delivery system that we have governance in, ownership in, and is has a majority labor ownership. And there's examples of this that have already been done around the country in a lesser form. For example, the hotel and restaurant employees have done this in the five boroughs of New York. Each of the five boroughs has a major healthcare facility that all of the participants, employees that work in the healthcare industry, whether it it be the hotel and restaurant employees or the operating engineers or the teamsters, but if uh you know any number of different unions that are involved in the hotel and restaurant trades. So they have the hotel and restaurant trades created this network of health care facilities in the five boroughs of New York, and everyone that works in that industry has access to those facilities. Well, the net effect of that is the cost of health health care for the people in the health in the hotel and restaurant industry is 30% lower in New York than it is for your standard healthcare customer, for lack of a better term, in New York. So by taking ownership of it and control of it, they've reduced the the cost uh to the employers in the health in the hotel and restaurant industry by 30 percent. So there's a microcosm of of where this has worked. Uh New York, or I'm sorry, Las Vegas has also done quite a bit of work around this this. The laborers there, the hotel and restaurant employees there have done the same thing where they have ownership of their own primary care clinics. And here again, it helps control the downstream costs of health care. So so it has worked. So the idea, and then we've done it in Northern California to a lesser degree with eye care and dental care, where the where we own a number of facilities where where our members get those services, and now we're we're expanding into the primary primary care arena. And the idea was to not just do this onesie twosie, but to create a significant fund and make a real footprint where labor can participate in having this equity position in the healthcare industry. And it has been profoundly effective in terms of doing a couple of things. One is uh getting the investment community is extremely interested in the model because they see you know, we're kind of capturing lightning in a bottle here because we have the customers, we pay the bills, and we can direct those customers by virtue of them being in our networks, which we which we have the control over. So the ability to direct traffic more or less to the to healthcare providers is something that they see as powerful, and obviously the hundreds of millions of dollars that we spend on healthcare they find interesting. So the investment community loves this. And then as we've uh rolled out the we've rolled out the fund, what we've discovered is we're not the only union that has had trouble with escalating health care costs and being at the mercy of the healthcare industry dictating terms to us. Like I've said uh many times, we're our trust funds have been in existence for 60 years. We pay around $600 million a year just in our industry alone, in a one region of the country. So you can imagine if you extrapolate that, the billions of dollars that labor is spending on uh health care on an annual basis, and all we have to show for it are canceled checks. And when when that's been explained to, you know, kind of outlined to the trustees of other funds, and we say, you know, now it's time for us to take ownership of the health care delivery system and the primary care health care delivery system, which really helps navigate people to the appropriate medical care, it just rings a bell and the lights go off. And and that's why we've been so successful at rapidly raising the money for this fund, is that it just makes all the sense in the world that that since we're the since we're the recipients of the benefit and we are paying the bills, that why wouldn't we have some some ownership in it? My my metaphor is if you own an office building that had 10,000 people working in it and they went out to lunch every day, it might occur to you sooner or later to open a restaurant down in the lobby of your office building. It's kind of that that's the metaphor. It's we're we're paying hundreds of millions of dollars every year for for health care, yet we haven't closed we haven't closed the loop. And the loop is that why wouldn't we own why wouldn't we own the services that are being provided? And it it it seems to really be resonating in the space with the with the uh Taft Hartley trustees, both on the employer side and the labor side, that it just makes sense that this will help us take take more control over the it's a reimagination of the healthcare system.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivated health.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. Well, it's it's it's also kind of back to the future. It's kind of, you know, you go back to the 20s, it's kind of the Kaiser thought process, in some ways brought forward.
SPEAKER_01But a couple couple of questions about if I could just take one second on that. It is absolutely the Kaiser. Yeah, it's funny you would bring that up. It is absolutely the Kaiser model. You know, Kaiser wanted to take control of their uh, you know, the steel industry wanted to take control of the healthcare cost and start providing them and look at what it grew into. And part of that, the success of Kaiser, and and in an interesting way, you know, they kind of re you know, it's kind of the in that revolution they became out the they became the kind of the the monster they went out to destroy in in some respects. But what I'm seeing out there when we talk about this is what you just said, people say, well, that's that's kind of like creating your own Kaiser. I said, Well, that's exactly what it is.
DavidAnd it kind of worked out pretty well for Kaiser. Sure. And I mean it's as long as you stay true to the model and you know you keep keep your head where it was a couple of questions, if I can go back for a second. For example, these facilities in New York, are those open only to union members? Are those open to the public? And and do the charges change depending on who the patient is?
SPEAKER_01Well, it's interesting. In the case of the New York model, it is it is a closed model. It is it is the culinary workers hotel and restaurant operating engineers, but they have to be affiliated with the hotel and restaurant and trade. So they have a they have a closed model. Strategic health care fund is a different model. The idea is it's it's an open source to anyone to use the healthcare system that we provide, however it is more affordable to the affiliates of the trust funds. So, you know, I don't know if that answers your question.
DavidNo, it does. It does exactly. As you as you look kind of into the future, do you see this starting as a group of segmented regionalized players, or do you think that it will come together as a nationwide concern more rapidly than than these kinds of initiatives might have in other industries?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, it I I love that question because it's the you know, the logical thing would be the broader base, the more effective it would become. But you know, some a lot of times people think labor in general is just this big affinity affinity group that can move on a dime in one direction, but it it doesn't work that way. So I would I think you're gonna see it more regionalized and kind of w you once you demonstrate it works, then I think it you'll get broader buy-in. Our intent, well first of all, Northern California is a great market to do this in because there's there's it's low-hanging fruit. You know, there's such a margin, there's so much margin there that that it's just a logical place to do it. And the necessity for it is so obvious uh because of the strain of the health care costs. Well, I'll give you an an interesting example is our initial investment, the f the very first investment that we did from the strategic health care fund, in fact, it was almost our it was actually our beta investment, was primary care clinic called Solidaritis Health. Solidaritis Health we opened with in coordination with the United Auto Workers in Tulsa, Oklahoma. And we negotiated as part of the United Auto Workers Agreement with Boeing there in Tulsa. We negotiated healthcare clinics, which are owned 100% by labor. So they are they started out with one, just opened our third clinic, and they have been wildly effective and successful and popular with the participants in the in that in that region. Uh and that that's in Tulsa, you know, that's Tulsa Home, Tulsa, Oklahoma, not exactly a union stronghold, and really kind of revolutionized the perception of what labor can do in Tulsa, and it's been very successful in a very rapid period of time. And now there's discussion about moving up into the same operation up into what uh up into Wichita, Kansas. So so it's kind of, you know, you go where your opportunities lie, and in the in that case, it it came out of the bargaining process. But what I to to really answer your question, could this become a national, could this become a national movement? I I hope it does, because I think it's it's always been logical to me that labor, that labor does, you know, that labor takes the the laboring ore on the delivery of affordable health care. That's kind of what our calling card's been, and I think this is just taking it to the next level.
DavidWell, and it all it also helps the the unions and trades that you represent deliver more value to their members. So their their union membership becomes even more valuable and it helps solidify that that back and forth.
SPEAKER_01It's really it's that's really true. I've always said that our health care plans are our calling card, and then if it's you know, we've not only do we have a good healthcare program, but we actually have healthcare facilities that we own and operate, then I I think our value add just becomes so so obvious and apparent, not only to our members, but to employers as well.
DavidSure, absolutely. A fascinating story, Jacques Laval, and thank you for for sharing it with us, Chairman of the UFCW Trust. Jacques, please come back again.
SPEAKER_01I'd be delighted to do it. I really appreciate your interest uh very much. Thank you.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.