The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #252: This Agency Is Designed To Flip The Industry On Its Head – with Braden Monaco
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Can you create an agency that is focused more on relationships and results than on the traditional sales-driven mentality? That’s what Braden Monaco, Co-founder and Managing Partner at Blue Horizon Benefits, set out to learn. Along the way, he and his team created a concept they call the “Total Concierge Approach,” which creates true results-driven partnerships. Braden shares his firm’s journey and what they learned – good and bad – along the way.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- What does it mean to “flip the industry on its head”?
- Where do smaller firms find opportunities today?
- How to clearly separate strategy from tactics – and which matters most.
- What his firm’s “light bulb” moment was.
- What he believes the future looks like for smaller, independent firms.
Can you create an agency that focuses less on the traditional sales-driven mentality and more on relationship, results, and true partnerships? And what exactly is a total concierge approach? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Braden Monaco. Braden is co-founder and managing partner at Blue Horizon Benefits. And he's had kind of an interesting journey into where they are now and a business model that's based on helping employers redefine the way they think about employee benefits. And we all talk about that a lot, especially these days. But it's it's going to be instructive to chat with somebody who's actually been doing that successfully and learn kind of some tips and secrets and things that that Braden uses to approach the marketplace. With that, welcome, Braden. Good morning, David. Glad you're here. Let's start at the beginning. Talk about your journey because I thought it was a little bit interesting about, you know, kind of how you got into this area and what you learned and what you found in the process.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. No, I first of all I want to appreciate you having me on. I'm I've been a longtime listener and I'm excited to share what my journey has been and and where we look to go as a firm. You know, so I started the industry just over 10 years ago at another smaller boutique benefits firm here in New England. But one of the things that I learned quickly in my kind of my journey in the beginning was that I don't like the idea of being an industry that is sales driven. You know, I look at myself as a consultant. I look at myself as someone who I got into this industry to genuinely help others and find solutions for with issues they're having. With that being said, you know, I'm looking at trying to find ways to take our industry and kind of flip it's flip it on its head a little bit and go away from that, you know, that sales-driven mentality, which I think so many firms these days have. There's so much conversation around revenue. So when we started our firm, we looked at each other and coming into creating Blue Horizon and saying, what can we do differently? What is it about this industry that we think could be done differently and in a way that other firms out there are not focusing so much on driving that true partnership approach? So when we started again, you know, I was I was driven as a producer, I was driven as someone that just went out there and sold, and relationship wasn't as important. But for me, the relationship is the number one piece in what I enjoy in this. Obviously, after relationship comes results. Without results, the relationship doesn't mean a whole lot. We all understand that. But when we first got started, it was really around the idea of this industry is missing something that we saw was a huge gap, and that piece was that that true partnership on a day-to-day basis.
DavidSo, I mean, for listeners who aren't familiar with the New England area, and both Braden and I are located up here, it's kind of its own ecosystem. And there are some quirks in this market that I mean, every market has its own unique characteristics, but there's some quirks in this market that make it very different. And we have kind of a very interesting mix of a lot of big firms, and especially with the roll-ups and the buyouts and things that have been happening. But we also have some really interesting boutique firms like Braden's and and others, like ours. And so I think has that provided opportunity for you, the fact that the big firms seem to be getting bigger and gobbling up, the small firms and those firms that can afford to be more nimble, for lack of a better word, just aren't proliferating out there right now?
SPEAKER_02I I complet I absolutely agree. You know, at the end of the day, what we've we're we're finding is with all the acquisitions going on in the marketplace, it's it's opening up a huge opportunity and gap in the market for firms like ours, David, in the fact that, you know, we're have the freedom on a daily basis to make decisions that are in the best interest of our clients. You know, choose solutions and strategies that may be outside of the norm, that may deliver lower revenue, that may be not something that larger box shops or larger brokerage firms are looking at because it's not a revenue driver. Again, the way that we try to look at it, and I'm sure you guys do as well, is that we have a lot of control in the solutions and the strategies we deliver, the way that we work with our clients on a proactive basis daily. You know, we we are in contact with the majority of our clients on a daily, if not more weekly, depending on uh on how much we get involved with that specific client. But I think that that approach of that proactive and nimble is something that we we use frequently and in that we we are able to bring about solutions, change, creativity that otherwise may take longer in a larger shop to deliver. We can look at our client and say, you might be the first one doing this, but we have we've researched it, we understand it. Is it something you're willing to do versus having to run it through a chain of command that has to approve of everything going through the process? And I think that in a marketplace like today, with with all the complexities in healthcare and the cost drivers, that being proactive and nimble is something that is allowing us to really set ourselves apart from those from those larger brokerage houses.
DavidSo you find that if the relationship comes first and the relationship is deep and sticky, the revenue will follow?
SPEAKER_02I completely agree. That's the way that we've built our organization. At the end of the day, I've always believed, and I'll have to say that was the way I was raised, you do good work, you treat others well, you look out for those around you, and and whatever it may be will follow. Obviously, in this case, it's revenue, it's building an organization, but you know, it's it's just in daily life, and I think a lot of that comes down to the morals, the culture, and the mission of the organization that we run.
DavidNow, I know there's one question that's that's kind of unique to the way you approach prospects and clients. And it has to do with the word that we don't talk about. We talk about in in our own shops when we're building our businesses, but we don't spend a lot of time, at least most of us don't, talking about it with clients, and that's culture. And and when we talked off air, you said that that's kind of the light bulb moment. Would would you tell us about that question and why it's so keenly important?
SPEAKER_02You know, it's it's interesting. The word culture, like you said, is something that we all, when we set out to set up our organizations or we work in an organization, the culture's plastered all over the walls, and we've got, you know, we've got these holiday parties and these things that build culture and these outings and dress code that makes it more relaxed, and bean bags and food and all these fun things to create these cultures in these organizations. And one of the things that that we found is that we're, you know, for years we're going into these organizations and delivering, you know, benefits packages to their employees and in a manner of which that is, you know, obviously we're we're is cost effective, is is providing a benefit that ownership or leadership feels as though is a high level of benefit to recruit and retain employees. But one of the questions I started to have as I looked around a lot of our clients' organizations and and all the things they invest their money in and building their culture. And, you know, you go into different clients and they're rolling around on razor scooters and you know, all these fun things to build this culture. But I also think back to what we do and how we deliver benefits and say, you know, and one of the key questions I started asking in the light bulb moment was you're building culture in all these different areas, but every year we keep diminishing the benefits based on cost, and you're not willing to think outside the box from a creative perspective in a lot of instances to deliver cost savings for, you know, the way the clients look at it. So I said, do your benefits match up with your culture? And it was a light bulb moment for me. And it's honestly a light bulb moment that I'm having with a lot of our prospective clients and our clients now is that understanding that just because you offer 80% of the healthcare or you offer medical, dental, vision voluntary, and you offer company-paid benefits doesn't mean those benefits line up with your culture. So you've got to look at your overall personnel, what your organization is founded upon, the core values and the mission of the business, and say, do our benefits match up with our culture? Because a lot of times they don't. A high deductible health plan and a manufacturing firm that says we're family-owned and operated, and we care about you like your family, but you've got a $2,500 HSA and you make $45,000 a year. That doesn't line up in my eyes. So obviously we've got to be cost conscious, but at the end of the day, trying to find a way to deliver benefits that match up with your your corporate culture is something that we've really taken pride in.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients. And over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now, Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solution, go to our website at www.captivated health.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. I know that one of the things that you folks do that that helps create these deeper and sticky relationships is something that you refer to and you talk to clients about as a total concierge approach. What is I mean, we all have this unnotion of healthcare concierges, but I think you guys take it in a different direction. Could you chat about that a little bit?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, I I think that, you know, everywhere we go, we hear the word concierge, and I I think that, you know, we've heard it in our industry here and there, but I think that for the most part, our industry is is delivered in in a large part on features and benefits, not as much on results in a lot of regards. And those results can come in many different ways, shapes, or forms, right? So when I look at our concierge package, and I think it's kind of like a new breed concierge, we're looking at it, the standard concierge is a hotel, you go, you ask a question, and they help you find your way, right? We're trying to create a platform, and we've we've done a good job thus far in our first three years in business is you know, creating a platform that allows for our clients to work with us and for us to work with them on a daily basis. So whether that's through creative solutions with technology, whether it's custom communications for employees, whether it's designing and implementing video editorials to help employees understand their HSA, or you know, so from a concierge perspective, what we look at is every single client specifically, what are your needs? How do how do your employees learn? What is your demographic? What is the best way to deliver information, to deliver service? Because no one client is the same. And I think, I think that we try to we try to pigeonhole our services as an industry on the client, saying that this is what we do and it would work for you. For us, the the main focus at this point is saying, where is our client today? Where do they want to be tomorrow, two years from now, five years from now, and try to take our concierge style platform and say, what are the services that we provide, being nimble and proactive, like we discussed, and saying, you know, maybe we don't do that today, but maybe that's something else we can do to help our clients achieve their overall, overall goal. One of the main focuses for us is, you know, making sure that our HR partners are not focused on paper and process and compliance and all the things that tie them down. I know it sounds like something that everybody does, and I'm sure other firms do it as well, but you know, we want our HR partners to make sure that they are part of the strategic mission and and and organizational goals and objectives because their role is so integral in our organization, our clients' organizations succeeding, oftentimes they're not looked at that way. So we want to help them understand that if we can take over through our concierge platform, the the majority of the I call it the minutiae of HR, right? If we can take that over, then they can become more strategic in their organization. It's a win-win for everybody.
DavidI mean, one of the interesting quotes that is attributed to Peter Drucker that apparently he never said, but it's still a great quote, is that culture eats strategy for breakfast. I think what I hear you saying is that once you understand the client's culture, then you can move into a discussion of strategy versus tactics. And the old way was to kind of work tactically first, and maybe you touched on strategy, but it seems as though your approach is to work on strategy first and then let the tactics kind of support that. Would that be a fair assessment?
SPEAKER_02I I couldn't, yeah, absolutely. You know, I I look at it and and I really think through that, and that's a good that's a great line. And I I just think at the end of the day, tactics are a way, this is how we we how we find the solutions. But if we don't know the problem, we don't know what we're working with, we don't know, you know, it's like going into every organization and saying, we've got a reference-based pricing model, or we've got a, you know, we can go to a self-funded platform with an independent medical manager, we can do all these fun things and and find ways to save money, but not know that that's if that's even something they're looking to do. And in this environment today, everyone wants to offer a high level of benefit at a low cost. I mean, that's just, you know, that's value, right? So, but for me, it's understanding what their goals and objectives are. And without understanding their goals and objectives, then the tactics and the the things that follow don't have a direct correlation to what they're trying to accomplish.
DavidWell, and so for a moment, let's touch on this business of how you actually define results. Because I know that one of your credos is that if you want to have a real true partnership, and you said this earlier, you need to be able to deliver results. And again, results are not having a $2,500 deductible with somebody who makes 40 grand a year because then all you've got is somebody who's functionally uninsured. Yep. When you talk to employers about results, what are the kinds of things that they want to know and the kinds of things that you have to deliver?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, I think I think that that's a great question. And when I when I look at the way that we work with our clients in regards to results, every client looks for different results in different ways. And I think that that's kind of the key to the way that we look at this, the way that we look at our our client partnerships and our relationships is that our our partnership approach is to deliver results at the end of the day, right? Without results, our relationship's great, we can have a beer and move on. Like that doesn't mean much to me, right? Or to them for that matter. But the results is where you build a stronger relationship, a stronger partnership, and a long-term relationship. When it comes to the results and delivering those results, I think that again, with without truly understanding where your client is today, where they want to be, results are are never going to happen in aligned with what they want to see to see happen within their organization. You know, and I I I hope I'm answering the question you're asking there, but I I still look at it as a piece of we have clients that are currently funding 100% of their employee premium. They've got 100% contribution towards an HRA. You know what? At the end of the day, they are delivering benefits that match up with their culture. They can afford to do it today, whether tomorrow that's the case. But if I went into that client and said, well, I have a way we can save you $100,000, we're going to have to change it from a fully insured platform to a self-funded platform. There's going to be a higher exposure of risk potentially, but we may be able to save you some money. Employees are going to have to utilize the plan a little bit differently, et cetera. That's not a result that they're looking for because that may create disruption in the marketplace where in a construction company these days in the Northeast and probably around the country, they don't, they can't afford to have any disruption because losing one employee loses profitability.
DavidWell, and that's that's a great place to kind of wrap up is you told me a story in our pre-discussion about a firm that you've been working with. And I think part of the takeaway, and I'd like you to tell that story if you're comfortable doing it. Part of the takeaway, though, is that sometimes this stuff doesn't happen instantly or overnight. Would would you take us through that line encounter?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I just touched upon it briefly. But you know, here in the Northeast, again, like I said around the country, construction is booming. I started in 2008. Construction was not in that same facet. I mean, obviously we're looking to save money, try to retain talent the same way, knowing that things would eventually turn around. But the way things are looking today with this client, you know, they they're funding 100% of the premium, 100% of the deductible across the board from medical, dental vision, short-term, long-term life. They have, I would argue, top 1% of a benefits package in the country, right? I mean, employees have literally, other than copays, no out-of-pocket exposure. Now, with that being said, there's there's this threshold of change that had to happen. You know, they're they're looking to grow, they're looking to expand their operation, and and they understand that the cost associated with healthcare is one of those things that because they've been so generous for many years now, that they had to make a change. You know, it was interesting they they made a change this year to go to a 10% employee contribution to the benefit plans, which doesn't seem like a lot to every anyone listening to this call or anybody in the general population of that utilizes healthcare, but for their employees, it's uh it's a big change, right? It's it's change. Any change is big change to employees, especially when it comes around healthcare. So, you know, the the idea that for one, it went over really, really well. The employees understood what he was trying to accomplish and what was what was going on. They were still very grateful for the benefits and the offerings that they had. But it was the way it was delivered from the leader of the organization in a way that his decision was not based solely on the financials, but it was based on the ability to grow the organization and in turn create a more fruitful future for the rest of those employees that are currently there today.
DavidOne of the things that became important in that process, and we we don't talk about this enough either, I don't think, is that the ultimately the messaging had to come from the leadership of the organization. It couldn't come from open enrollment meetings or your team going in and talking. How critical is it at the outset to get C-level, C-suite level buy-in?
SPEAKER_02Incredibly important to get the C-suite buy-in. You know, and it's something that we don't normally get. Normally we we deliver the message with HR, but in this case, I often try to recommend that the C suite deliver the messages like this because there is a way to present it that it can turn into a positive as opposed to just that that negative outcome of an employees having to pay more. What was the intent behind the decision other than just a financial decision? So getting C-suite buy-in across the board from new creative solutions to education and delivering a message is hugely important.
DavidWell, and that's a great place to end our conversation today. Braden Monaco, co-founder and managing partner at Blue Horizon Benefits, thank you for sharing your expertise with our audience and thank you for being a Shift Shaper.
SPEAKER_02I appreciate the time and I look forward to many years of listening to the podcast and learning from others around the country.
DavidThank you. You're very kind. We enjoy doing it. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved