The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #240: Schedule It. Bundle It. Save On It! - with Stan Schwartz, M.D.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
There is a fast-growing movement toward bundled, all-in one-price medical services that save money, provides less complexity for members, and may make networks (as we know them today) obsolete. Our guest on this episode is Stan Schwartz, M.D., the Chief Medical Officer of The Zero Card, a company which is in the forefront of making this dramatic change.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- What is the scenario when rates are unbundled?
- How rates get bundled.
- Is this a region-by-region or a nationwide play?
- How to gain employee engagement.
- What advisors need to know to have an effective client conversation.
Do 100% transparent bundled charges have the potential to dramatically change healthcare costs while delivering less complexity for members and helping them save on personal responsibility? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to succeed. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Salt Smith.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Stan Schwartz. Stan is the chief medical officer of the Zero Card. And we've talked an awful lot about new techniques that are coming to the fore, especially kind of fitting in with the new rekindled interest in partially self-funded plans. And what Stan's company does, what the Zero Card does, is they provide 100% transparent bundled case rates. And bundling and its impact in short and long-term plans and also for the industry is something that we haven't really delved into too much. And so we're very pleased that Stan has taken some time to share his expertise with the Shift Shabers audience. With that, welcome, Stan. Glad to talk with you, David. So today, what's a typical scenario? What does it look like when rates are not bundled? Let's start there.
SPEAKER_00When rates are not bundled, you're buying everything basically a la carte. So let's say you go into the hospital and you have a gallbladder operation. Pretty simple operation, usually done as an outpatient, may stay overnight, done with a laparoscope. Pretty much, I hate to use the term a commodity, but low complication risk, pretty s pretty safe operation. So you go in the hospital, and when you come out of the hospital after your gallbladder surgery, you'll typically get a bill from the facility, you'll get a bill from the surgeon, you'll get a bill from the anesthesiologist. That facility bill may include charge for your drugs, charge for your stay in the hospital bed, charge for your IV fluids, charge for your lab, etc. And it's not uncommon to get a bill from a doctor you've never met, for example, like the pathologist. So at the end of all of this, you've got five or six hospital bills. Some of them may be a lot higher than you expect. You don't know what the cost was ahead of time. So you've actually bought something that's a la carte. You bought something that you had no control over the price, and you bought something that you don't know what it costs until it's done. I mean, you don't buy anything else like that. So in the bundled world, all these things are bundled, as we say, into a single price. Typically here in Oklahoma, the cost of a bundled gallbladder surgery for an employer may be about fifty, six hundred dollars. And what that means is that you know the price ahead of time. There's no surprises, you don't get multiple bills, there's just one bill. The price is set ahead of time, and you can actually shop around. Now that you know what it's going to cost, you could actually compare the price at one provider to another provider. So bundling is taking the entire package of an episode of care and putting one price on it and cutting out all the multiple bills, all the vexation that patients get after surgery when these bills come rolling in that you don't understand, you can't interpret. Remember, the most confusing document on earth is the so-called explanation of benefits that you get after any kind of medical encounter. People who have bundling, who undergo bundled procedures, never see these documents. They become irrelevant, David.
DavidSo how do rates get bundled and why would a facility want to bundle a rate?
SPEAKER_00Typically, a hospital, a facility, a surgery center determines prices based on what they can negotiate. You know, they'll set what they call a charge master price. That's the so-called list price, and list price, nobody pays list prices. So an insurance company will always get a discount, for example, off of a list price. They'll call it a network discount. So the list prices are just there to begin to set the stage, so to speak, for a negotiation. So most facilities base their charge master on, you know, how much money do they want to make, what do they think they can negotiate, and so forth. Somebody, a facility that bundles needs to truly understand what the cost of a procedure is. They need to know what does it cost for me to do a gallbladder removal surgery, then how much money do I want to make as a margin, and then the sum of those two becomes the price that I charge. What it becomes is a market-based price. So now the facility is setting a price that covers their cost, covers their margin. But if somebody is able to shop that price, they may want to go to someone that has a lower price. So the market is actually working in that situation where if you don't know prices ahead of time, the market can't there's no market forces that come to bear.
DavidBut I mean, there's been a lot in the press. There was an article in the Wall Street Journal a couple of weeks ago that facilities really don't know the answer to the what does it actually cost question. Is that something that's starting to pick up and they're starting to study that?
SPEAKER_00Actually, that's that there there has been a movement toward bundling surgeries here in Oklahoma for many years. Oklahoma is actually ground zero for this this whole movement. It started with a medium-sized surgery center in Oklahoma City that's that was getting tired of being pushed around by the big boys and being nudged out of out of networks and so forth. That's our buddy Keith Smith. Yeah. And Keith just started posting his prices. And that revolutionized things. People would know what it costs ahead of time. He actually figured out what does it cost for me to do a gallbladder removal? What does it cost for me to do a thyroid surgery? So he understood the cost, and he's able to put a price out there that actually works in a free market.
DavidSo where do you start folding quality in with the price? Because obviously that's a big factor as well.
SPEAKER_00You know, that's a really interesting question. And every time we talk to an employer that's interested in bundled payments, at between 20 and 22 minutes into the discussion, we always get the question Am I getting cut rate care for a cut rate price? We get that question all the time. And what people need to understand is in healthcare, there is no relationship between cost and quality. Often the relationship is inverse. One of the reasons for that is the facilities that decide to bundle a particular procedure, and most facilities don't bundle everything they do. They'll bundle the things they do efficiently, effectively, and they can do predictably well. Those are the three things that have to happen. So they may not bundle a complex surgery where they really are not confident that you know they will use this many gauze pads, this much V fluids, and so forth. So what we see are high quality institutions who do certain things very well are actually bundling. And it's interesting here in Oklahoma, there are two facilities that bundle total joints, total joint replacements, actually three facilities. These are all rated five stars by Medicare, by CMS, on their hospital compare, and they all have excellent ratings from other organizations. One of them is in the top 40 in the nation for joint replacements on one of the most reliable rating systems. So what what we find is the best people are doing the bundling because they know how to do something and they do it really well. You know, another interesting phenomenon that we see is that the centers that do bundling will be very careful in assuring that bundle procedures are done by their most effective surgeons. Because the last thing they want to do is have a surgeon that's very slow, very inexperienced doing a bundle procedure because they've already set the price out. You know, in the unbundled world, if somebody drops a surgical tray and they need to use a new one, they can bill for it. But in the bundled world, you know, the price is set ahead of time. It changes the entire mindset toward quality.
DavidDo they also pay more attention to things like post-surgical infection rates and readmits and those kinds of things?
SPEAKER_00Yes, they do. I mean, although in most bundle payment arrangements, that the the surgery in in the commercial bundle payment arrangements, the surgery center may not be responsible for major complications. It that works a little bit differently than the Medicare bundle payments program. That we just we see a pretty low infection rate because people are doing things, as I said, with experience, they're doing it effectively, they're doing it efficiently. And one of the things that that's characteristic in the bundle world is that most of the folks that do bundling, these are procedures they do very frequently. And as we one thing we can always say in surgery is that high volume is one of the best predictors of good outcomes. In other words, experience really drives quality.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivated health.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. So we've talked an awful lot about Oklahoma kind of being a starting point for a lot of this and having deep penetration in bundle pricing. And of course, we interviewed Keith Smith a couple of years ago and we're very impressed with what he was doing and also with his attitude and kind of flack he was taking and how he was handling it. I mean, he's a great success story, but is this at the moment, is bundled pricing something that's a more regional thing if I'm an advisor and I'm going to look for this for a client, or are there national concerns, or how do I access this?
SPEAKER_00We're seeing the bundle payment movement is is really expanding nationally. You know, in the zero card we started right here in Oklahoma, partly because you know, bundle payment has already existed. We had folks like Keith Smith, you know, already running programs, but we've got bundle payment programs going on now in west of Chicago area and Rockford. We're working in Seattle, we're working in Denver, we've got doing some business in Texas. We'll be opening soon in Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Alabama. I would say that in a few years in the commercial space with self-employed, self-funded employers, we'll be seeing bundle payments being a very common way of accessing healthcare. And one of the mantras at the zero card is if you can schedule it, you can bundle it. We believe that almost anything that can be anything in healthcare that is reasonably predictable can be bundled. For example, you know, our employers that use the zero card, they're getting laboratory bundled, they're getting imaging x-ray CT scans, MRIs bundled, surgical procedures bundled, diagnostic procedures bundled. We've also just started bundling diabetes care. So folks with diabetes can get a year's worth of care for a set price and remove some of the barriers to care that people with diabetes get have because of costs.
DavidOh, that's huge because it's a it's a big, big driver. So here's kind of the 8,000-pound gorilla. Does this make traditional networks less relevant or will it make them irrelevant? What what where's that fit?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell The Bundle Payment Protu exists kind of outside of what we call the insurance sphere. You know, self-funded employers are paying for their own health care, you know, except for catastrophic care for which they have stop loss insurance. Most have stop loss insurance. But for the most part, they're buying their own health care. As a result of that, they just use an insurance carrier to process claims. We exist outside of that universe. In other words, this is really a direct contracting kind of thing where the provider and the employer have a direct contract, you know, through an intermediary like the zero card. So we don't really have a network. We just have providers that that do bundle payment. You could call it a network if you want, but words like network, words like deductibles, co-pays, co-insurance, these just don't exist in our world.
DavidSo again, the the $6,000 question, if you will, is how do you get engagement from employees? Do self-funded employers rewrite their SPDs to direct that for certain procedures there's a quote-unquote second opinion and they go to a clinician that directs them to these facilities, or how how exactly does that work?
SPEAKER_00We we operate like a bolt-on network, a bolt-on supplemental plan to their underlying health plan. So they just need to have minimal rewrite to their health plan just to include the zero card. Zero in the zero card stands for the fact that when an employee or dependent utilizes the zero card, they will have no copay, no coinsurance, no deductible. In other words, that becomes the incentive for them to use a zero card provider.
DavidSo other than the lack of bill complexity and getting a mailbox full of stuff that makes no sense to mere mortals and sometimes doesn't even make sense to those of us who've been in the business for a long time, what are the what are the kind of savings that a plan might expect?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell We see generally in the neighborhood of 35 to 45 percent overall total savings on things that can be done on the zero card. Now that's going to depend a lot on geography. You know, some areas of the country are just more expensive than others. But the direct contracting cuts a whole lot of middleman expense out, and we get really good prices. So the zero card tends to drive folks to have their procedures or tests done in the most effective and low-cost environment. One example is when we started doing the zero card, you know, we really concentrated on procedures, gallbladders, thyroid surgeries, heart surgeries, and so forth. And then we began to realize as we looked at claims from companies, there's a whole lot of additional savings on low-cost items or what people would consider low-cost items that we could get at a lower price. Here's one example. If you go to a hospital outpatient department for an MRI scan, you're likely to pay two to three thousand dollars. You can get the exact same scan, sometimes even read by the same doctor, by the same radiologist, you can get it in an imaging center for $500. We see a blood chemistry test that you may get a charge of $60, $80, $100, or even more, $200 in a hospital outpatient department, you can get that for $7 in a freestanding laboratory, a good national laboratory with a great reputation. So as we as we bundle things, we find that we can save huge amounts of money on low-cost but high-volume services like lab and imaging.
DavidAre hospitals gouging or are they just inefficient?
SPEAKER_00The whole purpose, the zero card doesn't exist to vilify hospitals or any providers. This is the nature of their business. I don't call it gouging, I don't call it anything else. They're just more expensive environments. If we can direct patients to lower cost environments, we can save employers money.
DavidSo as you talk to benefit advisors and they recommend bundle payments and services such as yours, what's that conversation like with the employer? I know you said the 20 to 22 minutes and you get the quality question. What's the initial open? Is it a cost saving? Is it a patient satisfaction or an employee satisfaction? Is it all of the above? I mean, how how do advisors have that conversation for the first time?
SPEAKER_00You know, once you've had that conversation, you've had one conversation, we find that it varies tremendously from employer to employer. We're generally talking with employers and advisors often at the same time. But we get really very different responses. So we have one company that looked at this program and they realized that, you know, if I can give my employees a large amount of their health care with a zero copay, I've given them a huge benefit. And this one company told us, you know, I don't care if I save as the employer $100. I like this program because I've given my employees and their families this terrific benefit. If in Oklahoma, where so many things are available under bundling, and we we we have a saying we do everything from bunions to babies to bypasses in bundled in a bundled sense here in Oklahoma, it's possible for a family to have all their health care, if they have no major emergencies, they can get all their health care at a zero copay.
DavidWell, you know, it it's a fascinating solution, and we've talked about things like direct primary care and other things because with the huge personal responsibility amounts on a lot of today's plans, for folks who are in the lower to middle socioeconomic strata, we've created people who are basically functionally uninsured. So you're right. If if if a procedure can be provided and there's virtually no out-of-pocket or no out-of-pocket to the member, that's a huge game changer, no question. We've got about a minute or so left. Where do you see the future? How do you see this rolling out?
SPEAKER_00I see this becoming the way most things are going to be paid in the future. Fee for service is going to is going to die. It needs to die for several reasons. One is, you know, it needs to die because it's so unpredictable and it's so unshoppable. You know, as we want people to be good shoppers, we have to be able to give them prices.
DavidStan Schwartz, MD, Chief Medical Officer of the Zero Card. Thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience. Thank you, David. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.