The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #222: The Status Quo Just Won’t Cut It - with Julien Emery
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Employers are beginning to move the needle on healthcare, and advisors have their ear. There is a lot of debris from old models that needs to be cleared, and on this episode we explore how that is happening and what is coming in its place. New and innovative models of care delivery and payment models are being incorporated into health plans. More importantly, many employers and employees are beginning to realize that they are the ones who are really in charge.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Why HDHPs have not delivered as hoped.
- How misaligned incentives have driven irrational markets.
- Why the entrenched bureaucracies keep getting more entrenched.
- ASOs with the BUCAs is not the solution most are looking for.
- How to serve customers and get EBIDTA.
In a system with misaligned incentives, HTHPs that haven't delivered on their promises, and carriers that are resistant to change, is there a way to serve customers and get EBITA? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Julian Emery. Julian is CEO and co-founder at LA, which is a really amazing platform for making it simple to quote partially self-funded plans. But of course, that's not exactly what we're going to talk about. In the course of his business, Julian's had occasion to study the progression of insurance models, what works, what doesn't. Ultimately, how to think about adding value for clients and adding EBITDA to your practice. Even if you're not thinking in those terms today, as we progress and as agencies get more like businesses than they've been before, you that's something that's very important and will become of increasing importance. So with that in mind, welcome, Julian.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, David. Really, really thrilled and just filled pleasure and excited to be here.
DavidWell, thanks. We're glad you have some time to share with us. So let's go all the way back to what is the modern beginning. We all thought for a while that high deductible health plans would equal consumers and consumerism. It doesn't quite seem like that's happened. What have you learned about that and and why hasn't it happened?
SPEAKER_02I think high deductible health plans and creating some amount of skin in the game from a consumer standpoint and creating consumerism, I think was and still is a good idea. It's just that if we look at it over time, if we track this out over the last, you know, eight years, 10 years, 12 years, what has happened is we've ended up in this situation now where the average out-of-pocket expenses on an employer plan, uh, employer-sponsored plan, is not out-of-pocket expense, out-of-pocket liability. So full out-of-pocket max is just under $4,000. And on individual plans, it's just under $7,000. And when you contrast that with the savings in our country and you look at how that stacks up, for the average American under 35 years old, they have less than $2,000 savings in their bank account. And about 57% of all Americans have less than $1,000 in their savings account. So unless you have the actual savings and cash to use that skin of the game, I think it's it it's causing more deferred care than it is actually creating consumerism. I think another side of the problem is there isn't a strong cash-based market that allows you to assess both quality and price. And so even if you did have the savings to go out shopping, it's difficult to know where the highest value is for a given procedure that you have. And if if you think about kind of how people, how this has resulted in deferred care, there's actually a really interesting study that I looked at where they looked at tax refunds. And the tax refund, average tax refund in America is about $3,000. And for 40% of people who get this refund, it's actually the largest influx of cash they receive each year. And when spending behavior was observed, what was noticed is that there was actually a 60% increase in healthcare spending immediately after that tax refund was received compared to the 100 days prior. And a lot of this spending, the JP Morgan Institute is actually the institute that did this research. And since they have access to where people actually spend their money because it's tied to the card, they noticed that about 62% of that increased spending was actually done in person. So it wasn't paying bills that were passed due from a long time ago. It was finally going to see some healthcare provider that they likely hadn't seen before, because that was an in-person expense. And so I think consumerism is a good thing. I think the implementation of it hasn't worked the way that we wanted it to. And I think it's putting a lot of people in a very difficult place because they don't have the savings to be a consumer, and we don't have the resources to help people, even if they do have the savings, to actually be an educated consumer. And so I don't I don't think it's played out the way we'd like. And I think it's been used as an employer cost saving method while shifting more risk onto employees. And I think there's strategies that can be used that can help control costs, other than just cost shifting, that I don't think have been used enough. But we kind of find ourselves in this situation as as it's played out. I don't think it was ill intent. It's just this is how this is this is where we find ourselves, and I think we have to address that.
DavidYeah, I mean, I think we've created a class of people who, for lack of a better term, are functionally uninsured. And those are the folks you're talking about. They've got a card in their wallet, but they they don't feel as though they can afford to use it right, wrong, or indifferent. And by the way, we'll link to that JPMorgan Institute study, so you'll be able to get it in the show notes at shiftchapersonline.com. So moving on, there are other problems that are all mixed in with this. It's not just the high deductibles, it's that for a long time there have been so many misaligned incentives in in our business. And we've talked about that some on the podcast. What's your take on that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so in terms of misaligned incentives, I find it fascinating as someone who is an outsider to the industry looking into it. And it's interesting when you when you dig in and start to just see where the money goes. And there's a there's kind of four different places that I think we all need to look at. One is just how compensation is structured in the industry. Again, I don't think this is unethical or bad in any way. It's just we find ourselves in an environment where healthcare is a massive problem in the country. It is an increasing burden on employers and employees. And the way that we as advisors all get paid for the most part is based on the total cost, the total premium. So if that total premium goes up, there's a lot of times that's beneficial to the advisor. And that that's just been industry standard for a long time. I don't think there's you know been a problem with it. It's just I think now we have to look at that because that that's a misaligned incentive, I think. And I think it'll take us a little while to transition away from that, but I think we need to honestly look at that. I think another big one is if you look at the networks that are being sold to us, you know, there's major carrier PPO networks, and we all look at carrier discounts or network discounts. And as we all know, you've had a lot of fantastic guests on this podcast talk about this. What are we discounting off of? There's these arbitrarily high charge master prices, and these discounts are pretty meaningless when they're coming off this arbitrarily high charge master price. And I think we need to just relook at PPO discounts, because I think that's just we're getting excited, I think, about the wrong thing. And we need to start benchmarking to different costs and to more transparent prices that are actually paid versus charge master prices. And a third one, I think, is is pharmacy benefit managers. It's just been really interesting. A lot of people have dug into this, and I think you've had some people on the podcast talk about this. You've got someone who's negotiating or a company that's negotiating often drug prices on your behalf, and as they're negotiating drug prices on your behalf, they're not necessarily always a fiduciary. And how do you know you're actually getting the breast price and who's getting paid behind the scenes? And there's these misaligned incentives around the pharmacy benefit manager that's supposed to be negotiating on your behalf as an employer. And I think that's just been unchecked for a long period of time and it's coming to a head now. And the fourth one is the carriers. Depending on the type of plan you're on, especially in the fully insured environment, the carriers have a fixed margin that they make. And so if they're trying to drive revenue, whether they want to or not, or intentionally doing it or not, there is an inherent incentive for costs to go up in order for revenue to go up if you have a fixed margin. And even if you kind of go a layer deeper into not a layer deeper, even if you look at self-funding with the carrier, a lot of advisors that I've talked to will do some type of partially self-funded arrangement with a big carrier where the carrier is providing the stop loss and doing the administration. But that also kind of gets into another misaligned incentive because the same person paying the stop loss is also doing the administration. And from a stop loss standpoint, again, there's a loss ratio that stop loss carriers are trying to target. And a reality of insurance is if costs go up, then that loss ratio, if you're targeting, say, a 10% profit margin, if that profit mark or if that margin grows, that that total premium grows and you have 10% of whatever that total premium is, obviously your absolute revenue goes up. And so I think it's misaligned when the administrator of the plan is also the stop loss carrier as well, for the same reason that I think it is misaligned if you have a fixed margin, for example, on a fully insured plan, and the best way to grow revenue is to grow the overall pie, and therefore your 15% goes up higher, or your 20%, depending on group size. I think there's a bunch of these misaligned incentives, those four primarily. It's time that we take a look at that more deeply and look at ways to align those incentives. And I think there's a lot of ways to do it, but I think it we're hitting this point where healthcare is just such a big problem, the cost of healthcare specifically, that I think the time has come to address that.
DavidWell, I mean, employers are definitely interested in gaining control, and the brokers who are right on the cutting edge are trying to find ways to bring that to them. Hence, I think the renewed interest, if you will, in partially self-funded solutions. And for a lot of brokers who are used to being in a carrier-centric universe, their first thought is, well, okay, let me call up the carriers and see what they can do for us. Is that a good idea or a bad idea?
SPEAKER_02I think you have to always look at all options. I just think if you're calling up the big carrier that is that has a misaligned incentives, you're you're doing your employer-customer a disservice by not looking at other options. And I think when you unbundle it, it's much more work generally. There's a lot more things you have to look at. There's a lot more moving parts. I don't think it's a bad thing to call out that carrier, but I don't think that's the best option. I mean, interesting, if you look at the market at especially the partially self-funded plans or the quote unquote level funded plans, a lot of different names for those. But calling out that carrier, that might be the easiest thing to do. That's the least amount of work. But if you look at a lot of these stop loss contracts, as an example, one, the stop loss contract and a lot of these carrier partially self-funded plans don't return all of the funds to the employer. So they might just return 50% of unused claims funds. And that might also only be if you renew. If you don't renew and you go somewhere else a year later, those funds might be withheld. So that that's not an incentive. How does that help you get motivated around reducing the cost of healthcare? And so I think it it's not bad to look at that as an option, but I think that there's a responsibility to look at other options through independent TPAs. I think independent TPAs are a critical part of the mix. And I think to date, it's just been more difficult to actually do a proper evaluation of that unbundled market. But that I think is a responsibility that an advisor has to really help drive cost control for their customers.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. So what size group is it is it that you need in order to both do this unbundling and to have a credible prospect for a partially self-funded plan?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, there's there's you can go down, we've seen a lot of, you know, captives or or Miwas or things of that nature, where I think I've seen some of those go down to uh as low as five employees. And depending on whether that custom that that customer might have a ton of cash flow, maybe it it makes a lot of sense for them to look at an independent level funded plan or an independent partially self-funded plan. It may make sense for them to go into a larger captive, but I think down to around five employees, you should at least be looking. Now you can do a lot more as you go up market. So once you get a little bit larger, I think unbundling and the options available to you grow, but I think there's great solutions for small employers that we've seen from some TPA partners of ours that they go right down to five employees. And I think that makes a ton of sense for some for some groups. I think it's important to at least look at that. It might not be the best option for all of those groups. There's a ton of great options out there that should be looked at. Yeah. So as a stop loss carrier to credibly price a five life group, everything comes down to health questionnaires and really managing what. So you typically you look at an actuarial kind of manual rate and try to understand, okay, if this group kind of fell on this average, what would that look like? But then a deeper thing is you're really underwriting right down to an individual basis, kind of similar to how pre-ACA underwriting worked. And they're really looking at individual health questionnaires and looking at what is that risk relative to just manual rate. And so it's really a one-off writing every single or sorry, underwriting every single individual. And in doing so, they're also thinking about it from a book size and a book risk. And so looking at five people, adding them into the book and underwriting rate down to each of those individuals, a stop loss carrier can manage that. There's there's less stop loss carriers that will that will look at that and it will go down that low, but there are options for groups of that size. Again, I just think there's a lot you can do, a lot more you can do once you're a larger group. And I think there will always be a larger set of employers as group size grows that become self-funded versus down on the smaller end of the market.
DavidSo let's talk about a word as we kind of work towards the conclusion of our chat today. Let's let's talk about a word that brokers don't use too often, which is EBITDA. I mean, it's not a word, it's an acronym, but you know, one man's word is another man's acronym. Why is that important? What let's start start with a level set. What is it and why is it important?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so EBITDA, earnings before income tax amortization. And what that really means is you're just looking at your margins. How it's a good measure of how healthy your business is running and how how what you're doing is what is the cost of your goods that you are delivering? What is the cost of the product you are building? What is your cost of sales, and what are the margins you're making? And I think that in the advisor business, I think that it's not always looked at, but I think it's important to keep an eye on just to think of how you can become more and more efficient. And I think today benefits advisors are being asked that there's so much demand on their time. There's so much demand for them to do so many different things. There's becoming an HR expert, there's looking at 401ks, there's looking at all these different new healthcare options, there's potential association health plans, there's, you know, maybe you want to look at self-funding down to five employees, maybe look at it, you know, at 100 employees and above. This is a lot of moving parts. There's a lot of different things to know. And I think it's important to really kind of pick battles, pick where you want to be the best in the world at and think about your business from an efficiency standpoint. And I mean, customers come first, but also how efficient of a business are you running? And it's interesting. I've I've I've talked to, just out of curiosity, a number of different MA advisory firms specifically that look at brokerages. And it's interesting to look just to think about how they look at the space. And there's a lot of roll-up activity and what sort of EBITDA margins they look for. And I don't think that all brokers or even most brokers are thinking about exit, but keeping an eye on that is important. And when you when you start to look at that, I think what it does is it surfaces opportunities where you can think about repeatable processes that you can create. You can think about where technology and partnerships can automate and take work off your plate, whether that be prospecting, customer service, managing your block, doing enrollments, and really kind of designing your firm around more efficiency. I don't think that comes overnight, but it's kind of picking spots and saying, okay, how do we how do we standardize these operations? How do we make this a repeatable, really quality experience? And then that might iterate over time. But in doing so, I think it makes it easier to run that business. And if down the road there is some point where maybe you are thinking of an exit, I think it's a much more attractable business because all those pieces have been put in place. But at the end of the day, your customers have to love you. And so you have to deliver these things in such a way where your customers are still loving you. And I think if you have that strong, repeatable process and you've also you're also willing to iterate on it and you're also looking at ways to be most efficient, I think it enables you to deliver a lot more to your customers.
DavidWell, and it's a great baseline measurement, isn't it, for the for the ratio between being efficient and being effective? It kind of is a is a light post to tell you kind of what direction you're heading in.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. And it might not be something you want to over-optimize for at the beginning, but I think it absolutely acts as a guide for you. And I think that this industry, our industry just traditionally hasn't focused on that in a lot of ways. There's there's a lot of brokerage firms all over the countries. And I think that advisors in general do a good job at really putting their customers first. But I think you know, we get into these Q4 crunch times and we get into these problems that come up over and over again. I think looking at those when you have downtime and thinking, okay, how do I implement one little thing that can help me get better at that keeps you tracking towards that guidepost around efficiency. And then you can start adding more things that you offer if you start creating efficiencies, and then you have more value to those customers that you're serving.
DavidAbsolutely. So we've we've got about a minute or two left. And you've done a fabulous job of bringing us from the kind of origins and the original thought process of HDHPs through today. What do you see the future is looking like? Where do you think we're going?
SPEAKER_02So I am incredibly excited about where we're going. At a very high level, the reality is our nation has a healthcare problem on its hands. And personally, I don't have a ton of faith on solutions coming from either side of the aisle in Washington. I like to track that closely because obviously it affects our industry, but I'm very kind of nonpartisan on that front, but I like to look at that. But what I do see is a lot of innovation in care delivery, in payment models, and these things getting incorporated into health plans, I think, is really exciting. And I think that advisors are in such an important and impactful position. And I think it's actually under-recognized across the country. I think it's it's under-recognized by everybody. They kind of just see this sort of brokerage world and they don't realize that really employers are in a position to help change how healthcare is delivered. Employers are in a position to move the needle, and advisors have their ear. And I so I think it's an incredibly exciting time. And I'm just really excited to be a part of it because I think there's a lot of solutions out there that advisors can use, and we just want to make it easier for them. And I think it's exciting for I think there's a bright future ahead for how healthcare will look and how quality can continue to improve and opportunities for a lot of players that are in the space.
DavidJulian Emry, CEO and co-founder at LA. Julian, thank you for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience. We appreciate it.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much for having me. I'm really thrilled to be here.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.