The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #221: Where the Heck IS Everybody? - With Dawn McFarland
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Relatively new to the benefits arena, Dawn McFarland, President of M&M Benefit Solutions began to look around and realized that there weren’t many OTHER new folks coming into the business. Worse, many older practitioners are aging out of the business with no succession plans. Coupled with her involvement with the California Association of Health Underwriters, she has started one of the few intern and mentorship programs in the business. Now, she wants to scale it.
Coupled with her involvement with the California Association of Health Underwriters, she has started one of the few intern and mentorship programs in the business. Now, she wants to scale it.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- What the scope of the problem is.
- Is there a natural influx of new practitioners equal to those leaving the business?
- How to formalize a program.
- Finding strategic partners is just like prospecting.
- The success story so far.
Large numbers of older practitioners without succession plans for their agencies are aging out of the business. But younger people are still not coming in in sufficient numbers. Is there anything those of us still in the benefits arena can do to help? One agency owner thinks she has an answer. What's her plan? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Dawn McFarland. Besides being an old friend, Dawn is president of MM Benefit Solutions in the Los Angeles area and vice president of communications for the California Association of Health Underwriters. We're not going to talk about any of that stuff. One of her passions is a much more fundamental piece of our industry than claims or discounts or renewals or open enrollment meetings. It's a problem that we're all dealing with. We've touched on it in the podcast, but we're starting to look around for solutions. And it's the problem of attrition in our industry and how we go about getting new folks, younger folks, into the business. And so with that, welcome, Dawn.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much, David. Thank you for having me on your podcast. I'm excited for our topic.
DavidSo exactly how big is this problem that we're dealing with?
SPEAKER_00I believe it is 50% of our industry big in that the more than 50% of our industry is at or over retirement age. And people are hanging on in our industry or they're, they're, they don't, there is no transition plan necessarily. People are just writing it out rather than having a succession plan and having someone to take over their agencies or or grow in the business.
DavidDo you attribute that to the fact that there's been so much change that in order to really grow, you kind of have to reinvent yourself at this point?
SPEAKER_00Very much so. I I think that that people do either they're burnt out because the all a lot of this change and transition is happening at the end of many agents' careers and developing a whole new business model to fit in what would be required in our industry now, giving technology ACA or who knows what's going to happen in that arena. And the constant daily change, I believe, is a has a big impact on people not wanting to put effort into a future of their business.
DavidAnd you're not seeing a lot of people who've done a a significant amount of succession planning.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, hardly it it's it's kind of typical to the industry where the the most succession planning I'm seeing are the people whose children want to go into the industry. Beyond that, I uh there's very few that I've seen that have actually given consideration to where where's my business going to go and is there a future, a five-year future even in my business.
DavidAre we getting any natural influx of folks, or is it just too small, or is it just not happening at all?
SPEAKER_00I think that we definitely got an influx when the ACA first came for the first open enrollment because there were a lot of funded people, enrollers and assistors seeing this as a job opportunity. I think, though, that once they came in, they realized how complicated and complex the industry is. And without the experienced agents giving mentorship to these people, many of them have fallen off.
DavidSo how did you become keenly interested in this particular problem? And there's there are lots of parts of our business that are being transformed and reinvented. How did how did you get on top of this one?
SPEAKER_00Part of it was my involvement with actually I would say the biggest part of it was my involvement with the Los Angeles Association of Health Underwriters chapter, always trying to figure out how you get new membership. And when I started looking at the audience that we were targeting, we're our our target membership is typically in that we're about to retire age group. We weren't we aren't looking for advertising to I'll call it the younger blood that could possibly be interested in our industry. So that it was basically to try to encourage membership that I was trying to think of ways that we could make that happen. And then realizing that when I in when I was in college, I I had a teller job at at a bank, and I it was not my intention to have banking be my career, but it ended up being a good career, and I was able to progress into management. And I think it's similar for our industry. If if if students knew that there were so many entrepreneurship opportunities in our industry, I think we'd have a lot more interest, but we also need to mentor them.
DavidDo you create a formalized mentoring program and invite people in? I mean, we'll use the the NAHU meeting kind of a construct since that's where you started working on this. If if a new member comes to a meeting, do you assign them a mentor? I mean, uh where where is that kind of a program at?
SPEAKER_00It's in development and constantly changing to figure out what works. I'll tell you where I started. I just started reaching out to local colleges. In Southern California, there's a a bunch of local colleges and a and a large I started with the college closest to the biggest percentage of our membership. Los Angeles is a huge geographic, our chapter covers a huge geographical area. And as I'm sure you've heard, the California traffic is terrible. So people don't want to travel too far. I worked with the college closest to our membership, which happens to be CSUN. That's where I started. Just start it, it took a while to figure out who's who are the right people, ultimately found out that there are professors who are in charge of the internships that the students get credit for in college. So those teachers ultimately we built a relationship with those teachers. And those teachers now on a on a semester basis reach out and say, Do you have anybody who needs interns in the office? It's no charge to the agent, but there is a commitment. We drew up requirements because there is a commitment on the agency who receives an intern for the semester. It's there's a commitment for them not to just sit them at a desk and have them file or answer calls, but to really show them what our business looks like.
DavidDo you find that you're getting students or you're seeking students from certain particular majors?
SPEAKER_00That's also interesting and a developing process. We started with some of the colleges here, and again, I'm speaking to California, have health majors. And with CSUN, it's health policy and admin people that we're working with. What I am finding, though, is the needs of our agencies, the majority needs, are probably more in the marketing and business management arena. I we just haven't found the right professors to build those internship relationships in those arenas.
DavidWell, how do you get started even doing that with the college? Did you just start knocking on doors and making phone calls? Is it is it just kind of prospecting?
SPEAKER_00Yes, sir. That's that's exactly what it that's exactly what it's been like.
DavidWow. So how how many colleges do you have on board? Now you still just working with CSAN or have you have you developed others?
SPEAKER_00The second one, it what I found, and this is timing based too, one college a year is, and I've only been doing this for a year and a half. So one college a year is about what I'm able to really grow a relationship to get this working. And Long Beach is the other other college that we have so far with Los Angeles. What I what I do have to say though, CSEN has been really successful because, like I said, the majority of our agencies in RSO in our chapter are in that area. Because we also need agencies to be willing to support this and mentor the students. And so and they they have to have the time to do that. And I'm finding that is my next obstacle to figure out how to overcome.
DavidSo what what are what are those conversations like with agency folks?
SPEAKER_00Well, there's it, so I'll give you an example. There's an agency in Long Beach who really wants an intern and has come it would be a fantastic mentor and who's willing to mentor, but every time there's a deadline, right, to get the application, the application into the college to get an intern, and then there's uh an interview process. So there's some time that they have to take at the outset, and they keep missing the deadline.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. But they they they know they need this. There have got to be other agencies that understand that in order to grow, they need qualified staff. In order to get qualified staff, they have to get interested people in the door and teach them. Are they still finding folks they kind of, for lack of a nicer term, poaching folks from other agencies or are they just static and worrying about how they're going to grow?
SPEAKER_00I think that they're, I'll use this same agency as an example. They they are actually hiring, posting jobs and hiring people. I think it's the fact that they know that they need, they know they have the need. So they're they want to make sure they satisfy the need without having to every semester retrain a new student or or have that responsibility. I believe that's a big part of it. And frankly, another part of it is communicating and communicating to agents the other agencies out there. It takes it takes a village to really get the word out on something like this. So I I know that there would be other Long Beach agencies that would be interested if I had one-on-one conversations to explain the process, but we need more people to get that word out.
DavidIs is this something that you've spoken to the national NEHU organization about?
SPEAKER_00Well, I know that the national organization has the that they just did the Vanguard book, the internship book. I'm not sure where that came from. I know that the Texas Ahu, uh, talking with Rusty Rice, he he's told me some information about what the Texas Aahu does. And they have it's a different program, but it is there it they work with colleges frequently. So I I believe that it's out there, but again, you just you need committed people willing to talk about it more.
DavidWhen you go searching for strategic partners for colleges, are you are you limiting it to undergrads or are you also looking at postgraduate programs?
SPEAKER_00I never think there's a limit to anything. I think that if if there's opportunity, you go for it. So I would go for postgrad, but I I'll I'll again go to it's a matter of the because I'm one person. It's a matter of having more people help grow the program than just one person. That's and I'm or even two pe two or three people. There, and I've got people who've volunteered on that that committee, and they're they're very supportive and helpful, but we're not we're not moving forward at a pace that I think we should be.
DavidThat's a lot of work and and everybody's busy, especially you know, as we get towards the the third and fourth quarter of the year. You know, it's it's I think everybody's heart is kind of in the right place. I mean, one of the things that I wonder about is if people really understand how how rewarding a mentorship experience can be. I mean, it it's you know, I've I've been fortunate enough to be in that position a couple of times, and the mentor gains as much or more than the mentee. Have you have you found that?
SPEAKER_00Yes, I I agree wholeheartedly. Again, we go back to the time issue and how much time someone has to invest. And I do believe that you always get way more back than you give in any situation like that. We've even had a couple of the interns so far. I think we've had eight interns in total over the last year and a half at placed in agencies. And out of those eight, two, two were hired. And I think that you're ex and I know that the agencies that help them, it was rewarding on both ends. So, yes, for sure, I think that people need to consider that a little bit more.
DavidSo is is it just a question of getting the word out and and and getting more feet on the street again? That's why I go back to kind of I wonder if so you guys are doing something, Texas is doing something. Do you know of other states that are doing something where maybe there's a an opportunity to bring folks together and have a long-form conference call and kind of figure out a way forward on a broader basis?
SPEAKER_00That's a really good idea. I don't know other states, but I imagine they are, you know. So I and I think that would be a great idea. And maybe going at the national level would be the way to do that.
DavidSo let's let's talk about the success story for a minute. Uh, you've you said you've had eight interns total in the last year, which is pretty awesome for just starting up, and two were hired. Tell me what you can about the two that were hired, kind of what their path was and and how they ended up in into the business and accepting an offer.
SPEAKER_00And I'll say actually, three of them, our our very first intern became very interested in our industry, the entrepreneurship side of it, the fact of building his own business, he was very interested, but he actually did not go into an agency at this point. He's still looking. The two that were hired, one was interning at an agency, and then was through that agency, they knew of a job opening at a local GA, and they were hired. The the student at the end of the semester serving for the agency applied at the GA and was hired. The other student was actually hired in the agency because they did such a good job. It it was so rewarding and helpful to have them assist in their agency. They were hired right at the end of the semester.
DavidAre they working in sales or support or you know, where did where do they start in the agencies?
SPEAKER_00Support. Yeah, for the most part, it's support. Sales and I I will attest to that. I think that that's probably at least a year to a year and a half process before that before you're really ready to do that or and feel feel good about doing that. So yet they're in the support role, managing CRMs, creating the technical skills of these students is pretty amazing. So they're they're able to create a lot of cool-looking documents and those kinds of things.
DavidWell, that's one of the things that you get when when you hire folks who are closer to college age is they come with a different set of skills than folks who've been in the business a long time, generally speaking. I wonder if if you know, do those folks aspire ultimately to be in sales positions?
SPEAKER_00Some of the it I think it's half and half at this point, from what I've seen. Definitely, and again, we're dealing with policy and admin students. So their function, they're what they're attracted to is more on the servicing and admin side. But then you run it once you explain the opportunity, you find those salespeople, this the people with the sales skills that they never even knew they had.
DavidSo we've got a couple of minutes left, and I'm I'm interested in in hearing what your thoughts are because you've been immersed in this. What do you think the future of this is is going to be? Do you really think that this could is something that could scale and be a way to help us bring a significant amount of new blood into the into the industry?
SPEAKER_00I do I think there's huge opportunity with this if we could get the backing of the physical support, the bodies who can build the relationships with the colleges. If we could have some kind of presence, you know, like a box presence, so it's easy. It's not something someone has to create every time. If we could create something nationally that gives us a presence that we could take to colleges, colleges are all there, they want the success rate of having their students hired in jobs right after college. That helps their statistics. If we could provide them with a resource to make that happen, it would be fantastic. And it could go large scale.
DavidPlease come back and keep us posted on how this is and how it's growing. And we'll do whatever we can to help get the word out. Don McFarlane, president of MM Benefit Solutions and Vice President of Communication for the Mighty California Association of Health Underwriters. Don, thanks for sharing your expertise in a very important subject with us.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for getting the word out, David, and thanks for having me.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.