The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #220: Changing The Care Path - with Scott Schoenvogel
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The current health care environment is complicated, convoluted and fraught with misaligned incentives, care decisions that focus on a single price point and doesn’t help consumers plan based on a desired final outcome. Scott Schoenvogel, CEO at Compass Professional Health Services, believes that healthcare navigation programs that account for benefits, consumer decision making and clinical decision points is the way through.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- How we got into such a confusing mess of a system.
- What kind of help consumers really need.
- How to help employees understand the often-inverse relationship between cost and quality in healthcare.
- Why bundled pricing coupled with appropriate advisement helps employees and plans.
- How and why patients need to take control of their care.
Is there help out there for consumers trying to deal with the complicated, convoluted, and confusing healthcare system? And will that help finally get us to change the healthcare path we're on? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultan.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Scott Shane Vogel. Scott is CEO at Compass Professional Health Services, and we're going to talk about a relatively new, or at least new to some of you, perhaps, but a very growing benefit, a very necessary benefit, called healthcare navigation programs. With that, welcome, Scott. Thank you, David. I appreciate you having me this morning. Thank you. Thanks for sharing your expertise with us. So let's start with the fact I mean, we we will presume that if we need a navigation system, we've got a completely bizarre system that needs to be navigated. How'd the system get to this level of complexity? In the old days, it used to be simple. We'd go to the doctor, we pay the doctor, we'd come home. That's not the case anymore. How do we get there and what are the elements that are gumming up the mix?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, historically, as you described, you know, the relationship was direct between the patient and the provider. And over time, what we've done is we've inserted all kinds of things in between those two, primarily insurance and employers and different companies and so on and so forth. And so what's happened is that the ability to understand cost, understand quality, value, each of those lenses has become very disconnected for both the provider and the patient. And that's allowed kind of the creation of many different instruments and structures that are difficult for a patient to navigate. And on top of that, you know, healthcare is just one of those unusual kind of industries where the frequency with which you might experience a healthcare event is very low, which is a good thing for most people. But as such, that dynamic breeds a lack of familiarity, which makes it very difficult to jump in, be an engaged consumer, and have a positive, constructive relationship with a provider.
DavidSo what are the kind of things that most consumers seem to need help with?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, most consumers are primarily struggling to find high-quality providers that they can expect to treat them in a responsible fashion that ultimately is good for them, that's good for their wallet, and creates that kind of empathetic healing outcome that they're looking for. And the challenge is that the impetus for care is not a typical consumer interaction. You know, this is a typically a situation where a a patient, you know, effectively a consumer, all of a sudden is is hurt or they have a disease or they're in some type of pain, and that's often very scary, it's very traumatic. And most of us, we have a strong kind of emotional response to that that is one of, I just need to understand what's wrong with me and how to make that go away as quickly as possible. And so that first stage in that consumer journey is not really a rational one, it's a very emotional one. I'm scared, I want to know what I can do to make this pain go away. And really, you know, once we get past that moment, you know, we're like, okay, I just need to trust, I need to find someone I can trust to help me solve these problems. And then when I go through that experience, I want to be cared for and have empathy and know that my needs are important. And then really it's not till the very end of that experience where what we typically think of consumer behaviors come back into focus. And that's really around well, what was my overall experience? How much did this cost? Did I feel like I got value? Did I feel like the quality was good? Because we haven't had that experience before, you know, it's hard to assess as we go through the process. And so really it's at the end where that comes up. And that's really the focus of navigation companies. We're trying to anticipate all those things that you might kind of want and feel at the end of an episode of care so that at the beginning, when you're hurt and scared and afraid, we can get you kind of to the right doctor, the right place, make sure you have the kind of a care experience that you expect, so that when you feel better, you know, that's all still says in alignment with your values.
DavidHow do some of the misaligned incentives in the system exacerbate that problem? Or do they? Do you find that they do?
SPEAKER_00You know, the systems is not directly aligned with meeting the patient's needs fundamentally. You know, incentives in the system are designed so that you know you get paid and rewarded for doing work. And the work that's out there in the healthcare system today is not really focused on keeping patients healthy. And there's just massive pressures to do that work because healthcare is very expensive. I mean, if you build a large hospital, that's a massive amount of fixed structure and cost. And so, in order to be able to pay for that fixed cost, you have to run a lot of volume through those types of buildings and organizations to cover those costs. And to do that, you know, you have an immense amount of pressure to find things that are wrong with people and make those go away in the most profitable way possible. And and ultimately, you know, you can argue that having those facilities and those resources available is an incredibly good thing, very positive thing for society, but yet the ability to kind of keep those available and the amount of costs that it requires to maintain that infrastructure puts a lot of pressure on the system to treat patients kind of on a per episode of care, per use type of environment, which just is, once again, does not lead us down a track to kind of holistic, total patient focused care. You know, which is why it is so important for the patient to be able to can take control of their own care and be able to make rational decisions around what's best for them through that process, because without a partnership between them and their provider on what's appropriate and what's rational, a lot of times those just inherent needs and behaviors in terms of what it means to keep the lights on and the doors open take over.
DavidWe just talked about that a little bit. How does that differ from total episode of care and why is that important to consumers?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you know, we have diseases, you know, we have illnesses or we have traumatic events that cause injury. You know, each of those are reflective of a care scenario that is not addressed by taking a single pill or having a single procedure. You know, most care is a function of preventive behaviors, even before the episode comes up, as in many cases related to chronic conditions or just being safe to not put yourself in the way of injury. And then once you do get into the care system, there's a process of diagnosis, there's a process of treatment, and then there's often a process of recovery, and then you have prevention activities to keep healthy going forward. And so, really, you know, as we think about the healthcare system and episodes of care, you know, what we're trying to do is to elevate ourselves above, you know, kind of the individual services that might be performed along that journey and really create focus with the provider and the patient on how to optimize that overall path, that overall care journey so that we get the right care at the right time in the most efficient way possible. And the way the system is set up today is that there are a lot of different people, you know, it's kind of like specialization. There are a lot of different people that do their own little pieces and parts, but really very few people are focused on how to manage that overall episode of care. That's an important concept or navigation, is why you hear concepts in the market around a medical home. Medicare itself is trying to reward on overall value-based care and the total efficiency across an entire episode of care. There's just a lot of forces in the market that are trying to elevate the healthcare system to get out of that kind of per unit specialization focus and move into this how do we deliver value across an entire episode.
DavidAnd now, a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients. And over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now, Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solutions, go to our website at www.captivated health.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. So when we talk about value, it leads to the question of how challenging it is to help employees understand the cost quality equation. A, because so much of what we've looked at in years past has been focused solely on cost, at least if an employer is sponsoring a plan, that's what they're looking at. And also because of the almost inverse relationship as opposed to other consumer markets between cost and value or cost and quality. How challenging is it for you guys to help take employees through that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, your insight there about the inverse relationship between cost and quality is so important. You know, as we all have come to expect in our other buying behaviors and consumer habits, you know, the more you pay, you know, and generally the higher the quality you expect. And in healthcare, as you said, it's it's almost just the opposite. It's very typical that the more that you pay, either the lower the quality, or effectively the quality is the same. You know, there is no quality differential for that increase in payment. And as you mentioned, that's very counterintuitive for the patient and the consumer. And so the way that we really try to address that, particularly on serious illnesses or emergent care or these places of high emotion, is that the focus is really on quality first. You know, you're building trust, you're focusing on that quality of care and the ability to heal. And that's really where the emphasis is with the consumer. The trick is that when they're using trusted services like navigation platforms or medical homes or whatever that might be, you know, the expectation is that those platforms can actually anticipate cost alongside that so that once again, when you get to the end of that episode of care and the patient's able to kind of feel better and pay attention to what's what's happened to them, you know, they see that the cost has been rationalized as well. The only difference in that is really around elective care procedures where there can be some type of planning. And what we see is that when patients need some type of service or treatment, but they have an opportunity to plan for that, and it's not an immediate thing, you will see costs start to move into the beginning of the care decision-making process. And so quality never goes away, but what it allows for us to do in those moments is actually include cost up front in that process.
DavidThere's some discussion in the industry now, and it's it seems to be growing over the last year or so. We first heard about it about, I guess, 18 months ago on the podcast, about in non-emergent situations, in elective procedure situations, about doctors actually bidding for the total episode of care. Are you seeing that? How are you explaining that to patients? Because that's a very different thing for patients, employees, if you prefer, to get their head wrapped around.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that is one of the exciting new areas of healthcare. And what you're seeing there is a movement to bring patients and providers closer together. It's very exciting for the market to see providers that want to take responsibility for that overall care and believe that they have designed ways to deliver that more efficiently. That's the kind of attitude and mentality that will make the healthcare system better. You know, the challenge for the market today on that front is that most of the healthcare system is not set up to bundle those services and manage an overall episode of care. And the ability to efficiently handle that exchange is really in its very early days. The technology, the decision making, the timeliness, all those types of things are are still not at a level where they're highly consumer friendly. And so I think we're going to see more and more of that. My sense today is that that's a very small part of the market as it stands, but I think it has great potential to transform what we do today. And as potentially employers, particularly employers, focus more on building those direct provider relationships, those type of discussions where there's an infrastructure and a way for payment and access to be easily exchanged, you have a chance to work out some of those purchasing decisions up front, evaluate kind of that cost and quality, the ability to manage that episode of care, and put in the infrastructure necessary so that when patients do get sick, it's a very streamlined and efficient process.
DavidSo if that grows and we continue to see more reference-based pricing, do you I mean some practitioners think that that kind of is a harbinger of the end of the traditional network/slash mythical discount system? Do you subscribe to that belief?
SPEAKER_00I do. So, and just to clarify, reference-based pricing is a very different model than bundling. You know, reference-based pricing is a platform with which to go to the market without an existing contract or payment arrangement, and then at the time of service, you know, using benchmarks and language that both providers and payers can understand, generally some percent of Medicare, Medicare being kind of a fixed case rate type of payment model, allows people to relatively efficiently come to some type of agreement on what can be paid for service. The ability to do those agreements efficiently in real time effectively negates the need for traditional network services. It's that process, once again, is still very nascent and it's building, but just like bundling, it has incredible potential to change the way providers and purchasers come together, purchasers being generally the employer and the individual patient or consumer in a way that I think is creating an amazing amount of energy in the market right now. We're seeing new health plans, new health plan strategies pop up literally on the belief that those models that have typically been repressed by the typical Blue Cross, United, Signa, Aetna, BUCA carrier relationships now have potential because they're going to be able to tie into one of these flexible payment structures without those traditional network restrictions. And that will give them a way to bring a whole new set of plan strategies and values to both employers and patients in the market.
DavidAre healthcare navigation programs expanding beyond just answering simple questions to kind of incorporating in a more seamless way clinical component? Are you seeing that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, clinical. There are three major components to navigation: benefits, consumer decision making, and clinical decision making. And so clinical is a huge part of the healthcare navigation platform, strategic process. You know, historically, historically, clinical programs and services have been focused on what's called medical necessity. So as a payer, you have to have a check in place to make sure that the services performed for your members and those patients are appropriate. That's you have a fiduciary responsibility as a payer to make those checks. And that model has resulted in the typical pre-certification or authorization process that you should hear about in the market or run by utilization management companies. The challenge with that approach is that pre-certification and authorization generally does not happen until a doctor calls a hospital to schedule a surgery. And that's literally just a day or two before the surgery is expected to take place. And if there is a challenge related to that procedure, you know, the diagnosis and the procedure don't make sense. And yet, here is this doctor that they've trusted, that they've put their life in their hands that are telling them they think that's the right thing to do. And that conversation just does not go well. And so, really, clinical navigation of the future is a process that is connected with clinicians and that understand kind of how to map manage that whole episode of care. It happens very early on in the care process. So, what we're really looking for is we're really looking for a patient to be diagnosed and engage their provider on what the right treatment options are for them. And there's always a wide array of options in many cases that the patient can go down. And in many cases, those options may, they may need all of them, but they may be able to step through them. And if one of them is particularly more effective, it could preclude the need for a more expensive downstream option. And so applying, you know, kind of these expert clinicians to kind of stand by the patient as they're working with their specialist and they're making these more complex care decisions, you have a tremendous opportunity to change the care path and get to a very different outcome, both in terms of health and cost. So clinical services and their importance to navigation is critical.
DavidScott Shanevogel, CEO at Compass Professional Health Services. Scott, a fascinating interview. We hope as this part of the industry grows that you'll come back and share what's new with us.
SPEAKER_00David, it's been my pleasure.
DavidThank you for having me this morning. The Shift Shapered Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.