The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #219: How To “Retail-ize” Health Care And Free The Unicorns - with Eric Haberichter
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
We have been talking about consumers in healthcare since the turn of the century, but real health care consumers – in the true sense of the word – are still apparently hanging out at the unicorn farm somewhere far away. Eric Haberichter, Co-founder at Access Healthnet knows why – and is working hard at creating a consumer environment in health care that approximates our consumer engagements in every other industry.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Why we must stop focusing on network discounts.
- Why is the typical shopping experience still opaque in healthcare?
- How we create a more normal market.
- The three immutable characteristics that must be present.
- How to move beyond surgical and include diagnostic and therapeutic.
For all the talk about consumerism in healthcare, true consumers are still unicorns, mythical and invisible. Is that finally beginning to change? And what tools, techniques, and updates are on the way? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Eric Haberichter. Eric is the co-founder at Access HealthNet, which is a new kind of a tool. It's a transformational e-commerce platform for healthcare where providers bid for non-emergent services and more. But this is a space that we are starting to hear an awful lot on on the podcast. And Eric's done a ton of studying. So we thought it'd be great to have a conversation and let everybody know what some of this new stuff is that's coming down the pike, which will affect you and how you interact with your clients and how you build plans. And with that, welcome, Eric. Thank you. I'm glad to be here. So not so much for advisors, but for employers and employees, they're still focused on that mythical net discount. Why is that not a good idea?
SPEAKER_01Well, it's a discount from what? From the charge master. And the charge master at every hospital is different. And if you knew the charge master prices, you'd be like, those are crazy. So a discount from crazy, you know, is still kind of crazy. And not to oversimplify it, but as a former hospital administrator, I'll just tell you that I could give people pretty much any discount that they asked for. And through creative coding and really looking to maximize reimbursement by finding the right things to charge for, we could get all that money back. So let's say we gave somebody a 50% discount off of the rack rate or the charge master. Most charge masters throughout the country are at something like 800 or 850% of Medicare. So 50% off of 800% would be 400%. But that's about 150% more than what most people actually pay. So that discount isn't even real. So again, it's kind of a mythical horse. It's that unicorn that we can never find. And that's why I say that we need to look at a better way of thinking what the actual unit cost of healthcare is.
DavidThat's the case, and we know that. Why have we spent so much time unicorn farming?
SPEAKER_01Well, because it's an easy thing to sell, right? You know, healthcare and health benefits are really, really complex. And as a salesperson, and that's what a broker is, they're an advisor, and and you know, we all love the brokers, but ultimately they're out there, you know, trying to close a deal. And are you gonna close a deal in a simple way, or are you gonna close a deal in a highly complex way that, you know, just glasses over the person you're trying to sell to? So what's an easier story? We're gonna go out and aggressively manage per unit cost, or we're gonna sell you, you know, ABC insurance company, and they're one of the big three, and they get a 52% discount off of everything, and it's the best in the state. It's a much easier sell, a much easier thing to explain, and I and I think that's the primary source.
DavidSo would you say that that's really the main reason why the shopping experience around, especially non-emergent medical care, is still so opaque to folks?
SPEAKER_01Well, that and the fact that the way that the fee for service PPO is set up is set up so that it's not transparent. There are secret negotiated rates between the provider and the and the insurance company, the payer, and there's a gag out there that says, you know, you can't disclose from either side exactly what that price is. So even in states that have mandated transparency like Minnesota, it's still very difficult to say exactly what something will cost unless the coding is very, very simple. Something like an X-ray. There's there's one code, and they can tell you what they're going to charge for that. But make it something like a knee surgery, a meniscus repair that has a huge variability in what could actually happen. There's really no way to come out and give that price. So it's two things it's complexity, and then of course, the secret negotiations.
DavidWhen we talk about complexity, I don't know that a lot of people have actually seen a real live hospital bill. When you talk about, well, let's use the example of a knee replacement, besides the variables that could or could not happen in the operating room, how many lines are there in one of those bills?
SPEAKER_01It varies tremendously. There could be as little as 20 or as many as 200. And it depends. You know, there's there's going to be coding for the facility, for the skilled nursing, for the anesthesiologist, for the surgeon, for an assistant surgeon, for any type of medical devices that they use. But there could also be additional charges for different types of rooms, a recovery room charge versus an operating room charge versus the time that you spend in a potentially skilled nursing unit. And each one of those items adds up. They give you an aspirin. There's a line for that. If they use some antibiotic prophylactically to keep you from getting an infection, there's a line for that. So it can be extremely complex. Now, when the bills come through, they typically group a lot of those charges. So the bill is a little bit more simple, but underlying that, there could be literally hundreds of lines of code. And for an extensive hospital stay, there could be literally thousands of lines of code.
DavidSo how do you start moving or how do you create a more normal market where a provider, just like I'm going to Best Buy to Buy a TV this weekend, where a provider offers a price and you can evaluate quality, and then employers or employees select which model to buy and where to buy it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there are many paths to that. Personally, I prefer, you know, bundling. Internally, we call them transparent episodic case rates, and that's kind of jargony. But the idea that you have to, I would say, retailize healthcare, and I say retail eyes, not commoditize, because we don't want to commoditize doctors and nurses and other skilled medical professionals. But there's an enormous component of what you buy, the hospital stay, the durable medical equipment, the drugs, that there's no reason why those should not have a completely retail purchasing experience. I mean, I always say the difference between a hospital room and a hotel room is, you know, you have an IV pump instead of a mini-bar, you have a medical bed instead of a you know a double pillowtop queen. But they're really still just items that you know the exact cost of. And there's no reason why you can't tell people what they're going to cost in advance. So what are when I talk about retailization, what I mean is you have to give people the ability to comparison shop. And we've spent the last you know 30 years or more since the invention of the PPO making the shopping experience virtually impossible. So by allowing people to see what the total unit cost of something is, like that knee meniscus surgery we talked about before in advance. If you knew that that was going to be $6,500 and that's it, and no matter what happens, that's the price. That's consumable. The current model, it's really not something that a consumer can intelligently apply.
DavidSo how does this work? I mean, let's say I'm a patient and I'm and I'm shopping around, it just sounds it sounds so strange even to say that, but I'm shopping around for a knee replacement. How do I do that?
SPEAKER_01You know, there's a lot of ways that that might happen. I think the most important thing is whatever type of, we'll call it alternative payment model or an alternative shopping model that is presented to an employee of any group. And really what we're talking about, I think self-funded folks here. There has to be a breadth of services that allow people to engage in shopping the entire journey. If I'm a member of a self-funded plan with a higher deductible, and I've I've gone to the urgent care, I've gone to my primary care, I've been referred out to an orthopedist, and I've already got a surgery scheduled, or I'm being referred somewhere, this is a really poor time to now try to engage that employee, that member, and say, let's start start shopping. So you have to start very, very early, and there needs to be some incentive, quite frankly, for people to do it. I think there's a real knowledge gap for a lot of folks about what their role in insurance and healthcare costs are. I'm shocked when I talk to people. I shouldn't say that, I'm not shocked. How many people know or don't know that they are part of a self-funded plan? So figure anybody who their employer has 500 or more employees probably is self-funded. But I would be willing to bet if you went out and talked to your friends and family that work for large employers, they would have no idea that they're self-funded. And what's really important for those folks to understand is it's not just your employer that's playing insurance company, you are too. You know, the employees are paying an increasingly large portion of the entire medical spend. It can be 50% at some employers, but it's at least 30% everywhere. If I was paying, you know, if I'm paying 30% of the cost of anything, I'm in the game. I'm part of it. And I need to understand that I'm part of the insurance company.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients. And over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solution, go to our website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. So how do you gain engagement? You mentioned incentivizing, and I guess there's a few different ways that you can do that, right? The first is obviously to have a fixed dollar amount to say if you use this, we will give you X or we'll waive a deductible. The second would be to say you share in the savings. What do you see that that's working to actually gain engagement?
SPEAKER_01I think the three models that you talked about are all really good. You know, use a value option and we'll give you a spiff. Use a value option and we'll waive out-of-pocket costs for you and make it no cost to you. That that's a great model. You know, or just letting people know, and this is maybe the least effective, but it's a starting point, what their cost is and what their share is in paying a lot or paying a little. Because most folks now have pretty substantial out of pocket amounts. And if I knew that I could have a CAT scan, for example, at one place for $2,000 or someplace else for $300, and I'm going to pay 20% of either, well, the math is pretty straightforward, pretty easy for anyone to digest. So I'd say there are many paths to engagement, but the number one thing that people need to be engaged is a feeling of trust and ownership. And advocacy is really what sells that. And when I say advocacy, what I mean is somebody who is a trusted individual who can be the fiduciary of the patient and help them through that journey. Now, whether that's a company hired physician or a direct primary care doc that a member goes out and hires on their own, or one of many advocacy groups, or even just a great HR director, all of those folks can be someone who can help people to understand their stake in the game. And then all of those incentive models will work, I think, very well. Personally, I prefer the idea of making things no cost to the member because it's really easy to understand. Who doesn't love and understand free?
DavidWell, sure. I mean, I guess, but because patients don't interact with the medical system except on a on a on an occasional episodic basis, at least for the kinds of procedures that you and I are talking about today, there's been a discussion on the podcast over the last few months about the efficacy of changing SPDs so that these elective procedures almost require a quote unquote second opinion so that you get the employees to the table so that you can then have the discussion about cost or free. Are you seeing that? And do you believe that's an effective strategy?
SPEAKER_01I'm seeing that everywhere, and I believe it can be a highly effective strategy. Now, there's there's two versions of that. The first is what I'll call the light version, and that's just having a kind of a double check at prior authorization. And if you have an authorization that's either going to an overpriced provider or potentially for something unnecessary, that that's a time to take a timeout, that's a medical thing, and go out and inform that member that there might be a lower cost option or maybe you don't need this. And that's the soft version. The hard version of this is where orthopedics, cardiac, and oncology actually are directed right to a second opinion program. In the case of orthopedics, what they'll often do is a very, very extensive physical therapy evaluation, a Mackenziean evaluation, and then look at whether or not surgery is the proper solution. And the national statistic would say that about 40% of all orthopedic procedures that are performed, surgeries at least, are unnecessary, and that there would be a minimally invasive or non-invasive solution that would be equally effective. The same thing can be often said in cardiac and in oncology. It's a matter of looking at, number one, are we using the most effective treatment? Are we following the best national protocols? And are we getting the type of decision support that we would get if we went to a top academic medical facility where something called tumor board reviews every case and folks from multiple disciplines are out there discussing what the best options are and how they're going to coordinate care. If you're at a smaller rural facility, that that just might not happen. And those are the three areas where we're seeing really a lot of progress in very powerful programs.
DavidNow, we've talked a lot about surgical procedures, but do you think there's an opportunity to expand this into diagnostics and therapeutics as well?
SPEAKER_01I do, and that's our business model. We want to cover as many elective procedures as possible, but I think anyone who's doing direct contracting of any kind or putting up any type of an alternative payment model needs to think about having an expanse of services. So many folks have focused just on surgery for, I mean, really the last 15 years, that's been the focus of where to save money. And it's true. If I can shift someone from a $70,000 surgery to an equally good, maybe even the same doctor, $35,000 surgery, it's a giant impact. But the reality is that only about one in 125 folks is going to have a major surgical event in a year. But about half of people are going to access general health care, which will run you into X-rays, lab, PT, things like that, sleep medicine, even limited behavioral health. So what you want, I think it's important to give people the ability to save money on all of those things. And as a percentage basis, you can save a much larger percentage on, for example, imaging than you can on surgery. You know, by picking the right outpatient provider, in particular going to an independent, which could be equal quality or potentially higher quality than the hospital, you can often save 75, 85%. It's very rare you'll save 85% on a surgery. So there is a real opportunity to save here. And if you think about the fact that like one in 11 working age adults will have an MRI in any given year, that's a lot of engagement that you can find in that space.
DavidSo kind of a two-part question. Are you seeing this both with doctors and with facilities? And what's in it for them? Why would they entertain doing pricing this way?
SPEAKER_01Well, there's two answers to that. The the most obvious, I think, and shortest answer that applies to all alternative payment models or APMs, is the idea that right now hospitals and medical practices of all types have turned into collections agencies and essentially free credit cards. And with the expanding deductibles that are out there, I mean, it's easy to see where patients just can't pay their bill. I mean, think about that typical American family that has a say a $55,000 income for a family of four, it's a little bit above the mean right now. If they have an $11,300 maximum out of pocket and they have a medical event that hits that amount, they cannot pay that bill. And the hospital is going to end up ultimately writing off those charges. So that's one of the reasons why alternative payment models are attractive because typically they pay the provider the contracted rate in full, and they are not leaving the member out there to chase that dollar. The other thing, and this is a little bit of kind of a shock to a lot of folks, is how many cents on a medical dollar actually flows through to the provider. Currently, the last statistic I saw was that the national best practice is that you'll get about 63 cents on the billed allowed dollar. Well, where do that other 37 cents go to? It goes to repricers and all sorts of other folks that sit in the middle are not providing care, but make up a giant chunk of the total medical spend. So, in the best types of alternative payment models, they're doing what Warren Buffett and Jamie Diamond and Jeff Bezos are saying we should do, which is reduce the number of touches and therefore non-value add middlemen. So anytime we can reduce the number of people that look at the bill, each of whom keep a portion of the savings for themselves, 25 to 35%, that's going to return that money back to the providers. So just think about that. If we could take that 37 cents they currently don't get and ask for 25 or 30 cents of that as a discount, the provider still is getting paid more. So they're very attracted to these models when they're done right.
DavidYeah, we've had discussions on the podcast about how with these larger personal responsibility amounts, a number of employees are, it was a great phrase that one of our guests used, they're functionally uninsured. Which leads me to this question. Obviously, communication of these kinds of programs when they're built within a plan are key. Is that a fulcrum? Is that something that you can use in an open enrollment meeting to say, yes, I know you're you're probably concerned about the amount of your deductible and overall personal responsibility amount. But if you have, here's what we've done. If you have one of these procedures, you can have it for. We'll go back to your favorite phrase free.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I affectionately call open enrollment the season of tears because there's not a whole lot of good news that most employees get. Hey, great news. You're only going to have a 7% increase in your out-of-pocket amount or your premium amount, and we've raised your deductible only 500 bucks. That's not fun news for the HR department to tell. So to be able to go out during an open enrollment and tell folks that there's a new offering that we're that we have, and it could be many, many, many, many things, whether it's a pharmacy benefit, a direct contracting benefit, a physical therapy benefit, a work site clinic benefit, where it's not going to cost you any money, but you're going to be able to really reduce your out-of-pocket costs. That's that's good news. But it's not enough just to mention it, mention it at open enrollment. You have to have constant reminders, constant communication. The reality is 50% of all people will not go to the doctor or have any medical experience in the given year. So if you think about that, that's 50% of people who are just completely tuned out. For the 50% that do need care, what if they don't need care until month 10? They've probably forgotten. And a lot of times when we're getting medical care, it's at a time when we're not necessarily thinking about shopping. And if it's an emergency, chances are one of these APMs isn't going to be really applied. But in when it comes time to elective care and I'm under stress because I've I've hurt myself, my knee is killing me, I just want to get better so I can get back to my life and back to work. I'm not always thinking about what I heard at open enrollment. So you've just got to keep engaging people all the time. And you have to create a cultural shift within the employer so that everyone's talking about how A, we're part of the game, we're playing insurance company too, and number two, that there is a way to save money and it sure hurts when you don't use the program.
DavidGreat place to end our conversation for today, Eric Haberichter, co-founder at Access Helpnet. Eric, thank you for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_01Oh, thank you so much. It's been a pleasure being here, and I hope that everyone appreciates the information I was able to provide.
DavidThe Shift Shapers podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.