The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #193: “Bend The Healthcare Trend” – with Mark Gaunya and Jennifer Borislow – Part 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Nine years ago, Mark Gaunya and Jennifer Borislow wrote “Bend The Healthcare Trend” to explore how healthcare consumers could counteract the damaging effect of a system with misaligned incentives, opaque pricing schemes, and unnecessary complexity. They are about to release the 2nd edition of their definitive book and ShiftShapers talks to them about how much has changed; and how little has changed!
The authors believe that what has not changed is that consumerism and transparency are still the answer to an industry that remains unnecessarily confusing, even for many folks within the industry. The average layman stands no chance in a system created by the rule makers, for the rule makers.
Our guests lay out how the government, Big Pharma, hospital systems, and health insurance companies are incentivized to stop price deflation and maintain complexity.
The second edition is peppered with actual examples of how they have used the principles in the book with their clients – and the success those clients have enjoyed in gaining control over their plans while delivering a climate of health and well-being for their employees.
Mark and Jennifer also outline what has changed since the first time they wrote about consumer-driven healthcare in 2009. The lack of transparency in the market is still an issue, but organizations are starting to deliver tools that aid consumers in making choices.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- What prompted the first edition back in 2009
- What has changed since then and why update now amid the unsettled environment
- Have we made progress in consumerism since 2009
- What will it take to de-isolate consumers from the cost of care
- Cost is the third rail. Why won’t politicians deal with it
- The three principles: Transparency, Responsibility and Opportunity
- What is the difference between wellness and well-being
- Do we need to create a higher level member experience
- Why the uptick in interest about self-insured plans
- How can small and mid-size firms self fund and how does an advisor begin that conversation
Hi there, Shift Shapers listeners. It's that most wonderful time of the year again. We all take a break after the fourth quarter craziness, and we enjoy family, friends, and a couple of encore episodes of Shift Shapers. From all of us on the Shift Shapers team, happy holidays. How can consumerism, health, and well-being transform your client's culture, lower insurance costs, and provide a richer member experience? We'll find out on part one of this two-part episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industry. Get ready to become the change that you want to study. Here's your host and chip transformation strategist, David Saltman.
DavidThis episode of Shift Shapers is brought to you by Benazon Healthcare Advocacy. Your clients and their employees expect more service, more responsiveness, and more help than ever before. You need to focus on building your book. How do you do both? Bennazon. To learn more, go to Benazon.com or click the Benazon logo at the top of the ShiftShapersOnline.com page. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking in studio, and we don't do that an awful lot, so it's a it's a real privilege to be able to do this person to person. Usually when we record these podcasts, the person we're talking to is in some other part of the country, and we do it via the internet, but we're doing this live, which is nice. We're speaking with Mark Gagna and Jennifer Borislow about the launch of the second edition of their highly acclaimed book, Ben the Healthcare Trend. Welcome, guys. Thanks, David. Glad to be here today. So let's go back to 2009. Let's go back to where it all began. What prompted you to write the first book? What were the conditions? What was going on at the time? Why did you think the book was necessary?
SPEAKER_02The reason we wrote the book was out of a passion to tell the story about how consumers can get better educated and engaged and empowered about their health care. If we go back all the way to the beginning, for myself personally, and then I'll let Jennifer weigh in. I'm the product of two healthcare entrepreneurs. My dad was a physical therapist, my mom was a nurse. And the reason I share that is because all I've ever known is healthcare. And we used to sit around the dinner table talking about is how complicated and unfriendly healthcare is to the consumer, and that we really needed to change the paradigm. If we wanted to fix healthcare, we had to make it about the consumer. Second thing I would say is at that time the debate about the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare, whatever word you'd like to use to describe it, was in session. And so we took an opportunity to publish the book at that point in time when they were debating the legislation. And we actually sent it to all 100 U.S. senators with a letter and the book itself to say if you really want to reform health care, why don't you start with the principles that are outlined in this book?
SPEAKER_01So Mark was one of the early pioneers of health savings accounts and looking at healthcare differently, how the consumer can actually participate in the process and at the same time get a better understanding of what the actual cost of healthcare is, which today is still an inordinate challenge for somebody to really truly understand what the actual cost of healthcare is. So our focus in writing the book was to share what we felt were the guiding principles of consumer engagement and at the same time allow them to see health insurance very differently. Health insurance is expensive because healthcare is expensive. And I quote that often because that's exactly what it is today. It's a very challenging topic for many people to understand. And we felt that the book would highlight opportunities for them to learn to grow from it.
SPEAKER_02And it's okay if you use that as long as you say it's trademarked by me.
DavidDuly noted. All trademarks apply.
SPEAKER_01And this is why we don't do interviews in studio. That's right. I think you're talking about it. We're just having a little fun.
SPEAKER_02The other part, David, I wanted to just add to it, I think the the third element was that everything you see out in the public domain about consumer-driven healthcare makes it complicated for people. And it frustrated Jennifer and I to no end that something that really is not that complicated was being made to be complicated and then also shared with the American people as though it was inferior or less better health insurance. And so the drive for us was to educate our clients and our prospects that this isn't inferior insurance. It's the same coverage comparability of your current managed care plan. What's different is the way things are covered as opposed to them being covered or not covered.
DavidAaron Powell In all of your public speaking engagements, you talk an awful lot about the rulemakers. Did they make consumer-driven health care seem complicated because they were being challenged and their status quo was being challenged? I mean, why go out of your way to make something seem complicated or inferior if it really isn't?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Well, I'm glad you asked the question because when you take a look at our current healthcare construct, and as you rightly noted, I do talk about the rulemakers, and there are four bodies. There are four governing bodies. There's a government itself, there's big pharma, there's big hospital systems, and they're health insurance companies. And collectively, together, they created the healthcare construct you and I live in, and they administer through an opaque process called coding and billing. I believe that they have actually created uh CDHP, at least in the early beginnings, they created it to be confusing in terms of their messaging because it doesn't necessarily serve their interest to have people buy lower premium healthcare plans. That may sound uh counterintuitive on the surface of things, but at the end of the day, uh CDHP really gives members and employers more control over their spend than those rulemakers.
DavidAaron Powell And no rulemaker ever wants to be controlled, they want to just make the rules, correct?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell There's a big myth with CDHP and combining it with a health savings account or health reimbursement account, and that myth was that it was really only for those that are young and healthy, and that the people that were interested in saving money in a health savings account for future use. The natural response to that is, well, it might make sense, but it's not the reality. It's not the people that benefit the most by a CDHP plan because it is for everybody universally across the board can really benefit by getting more engaged with their health care, making more educated decisions on how to access health care, and looking at the true cost and the quality of healthcare that's being delivered.
DavidAnd we're going to talk a little bit more about both of those points in in just a bit, but I'm curious now. Fast forward, the original book was 2009, and now as we record this, it's 2017. What's changed? Why an update now?
SPEAKER_02So the reason for the update now is really twofold. Uh the first is that when we wrote the book, it was before the Affordable Care Act was put into law, and a lot has changed in the last seven to eight years with regard to how the healthcare system is functioning, the costs associated with it, the metrics. So we had to update the book to refresh the metrics about where the market is place, where the marketplace is today. The second reason is that as we speak and as the book goes to print, the American Health Care Act uh has already passed the House of Representatives and now moves over to the Senate. Regardless of what happens with that legislation, the big underlying theme are the five principles that the current administration has put forward. And that is about accessibility, affordability, high quality, incenting innovation, and most importantly, empowering consumers through transparency and accountability. So we felt that timing was right with legislation that may or may not pass, but invariably something will happen that we think it'll feature health savings accounts and health reimbursement arrangements, and that as the new administration pushes that forward, that employers are going to be looking at these types of plans. And so we thought giving an updated version of the book with new facts, new figures, new case studies, a couple new chapters would allow those employers who haven't yet availed themselves of this opportunity to take advantage of it.
SPEAKER_01So part of the process of reevaluating the book was to look at what was still the same and was still pertinent, and a big part of the book is still very current today. So as Mark suggested, we really looked at the case studies and made sure that they were very pertinent to today. And we updated the facts, the statistics, and more importantly, we refreshed the book so that it is very much speaking into today's world and today's economy.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Today you're being pulled in multiple directions. Employers want you to deliver a higher level of service and employee satisfaction, and you want more time to grow your business. How do you do both? Bennazon Healthcare Advocacy is the answer. Bennazon helps plan members understand, utilize, and maximize their health plan, and answers their benefits questions while you improve productivity, increase client retention, and grow your book. The best part about partnering with Benizon is that your agency gets all the credit. Clients see your logo, while the Benizon team of subject matter experts work to ensure resolution to specific member information and service requests. Each agency gets a dedicated telephone number and year-round, 24-7 customer support that answers the phone with your agency name. Turn your benefit on with Benazon. For more information, go to www.benizon.com or click their logo on the Shift Shapers website. Benazon. Healthcare as it should be. Now, back to our interview. Well, you know, as I read the second edition, the galleys on the second edition, I was taken by how much hadn't changed. Despite the cataclysmic change that's gone on in the universe that's widely known as healthcare. And I think that that's a testament to the fact that the base of the principles that you guys talk about in the book really don't change. And I want to delve into some of those, but I want to ask a question first that'll set that up, which is so now again, we've we've gone from 2009 to 2017. Have we made any progress in consumerism?
SPEAKER_02I think the short answer to that is yes, but not enough. And what I mean by that is it's hard to promote consumerism when you still have an opaque marketplace. If you look at the principles of the book, the first principle is transparency, the second principle is opportunity and then responsibility, or other way around, responsibility, then opportunity. What I would say is that without a transparent environment, it's hard to have people make educated decisions because they can't see what something costs or the quality of that service before they buy it. It happens afterwards. That said, since the publishing of our first book, there have been a proliferation of discussion about transparency one, and then two, there's been a number of organizations that have been created that are actually now delivering some form of transparency tool to the marketplace. So I would say we've made some improvement, but not nearly far enough in terms of where we need to go.
SPEAKER_01There's actually a lot more conversation today, and a lot of the large insurance carriers are placing emphasis on transparency and providing tools, but the utilization of these tools hasn't been as prevalent as we would want it to be.
DavidSo what's it going to take to move from conversation to implementation? How can we take it as an industry to the next step? How can we get that engagement that we need in transparency and in having more people act like consumers the same way they do in every other aspect of their universe, except for healthcare, which makes no sense at all?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell So eight years ago when we published the book, there were a few million people in a consumer-driven health plan. Today, if memory serves me correctly, there are over 20 million people that own a health savings account. So the short answer to your question is the voice of the consumer is what's going to change this paradigm. And as more and more consumers are subjected to higher deductibles, subject to more responsibility with regard to how they access and purchase health care, the need for transparency, the call for transparency is getting louder. Legislatively, there are things we could do. In fact, I would like to see in the new American Healthcare Act a provision that specifically states and requires every state to make healthcare cost and quality transparent so people can make an educated indecision before they buy. Now, do we need to wait for legislation and regulation to pass? No. It would certainly make life easier because then we would have the rules of the game that would be applicable to everybody. But in the interim, I think consumers, because of the responsibility they've been asked to accept, because of the enormous spend that every organization invests into their people with regard to health insurance, their voices, their loud voices are really what's going to change the current paradigm.
DavidBut your guys' home state Massachusetts has such kind of a regulation on the books, don't they, about transparency? Yes. How's that worked out?
SPEAKER_02It's great that we passed a law, but the reality is it's the best kept secret in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. We ask our clients all the time, do you know that there's a law that we actually passed in 2012, by the way, that we're very proud of, because we helped author the law, which essentially says exactly what I said a few moments ago that providers, insurers, have to provide us with the actual contracted cost of services before we buy them. Now, what's different about what was passed here is we put the onus of that responsibility on the health plan, where we said to the health plan, when a member calls, you have to tell them what the contracted cost of that service is. And then secondarily, you have to tell them what their out-of-pocket would be on the health plan. So the second thing the law required them to do was they actually had to create an online presence and transparency. So the carriers did that. Check the box, check the box. What they failed to do beyond that, I don't necessarily think it was a failure, I think it was an intentional omission, was they failed to promote the fact that we actually have this law, that the people actually have the right and that they have the capabilities, that is the carriers, to administer this law the way in which it was constructed.
SPEAKER_01So most of the individuals in our state that have purchased health insurance or have it through their employer are completely unaware of this law. They are still not looking at the tools that the carriers spent millions of dollars creating, and the numbers are completely available, but nobody knows how to access it. And they're doing, as Mark suggested, nothing really to promote it. They just check the box.
DavidSo is it up to benefit provider, benefit advisors rather, to take that onus and to make sure that their customers understand that that's out there and it's a tool they can take advantage of?
SPEAKER_02Yes, and so I think it's the benefit advisors' responsibility to share that thought process with their clients. But I also think it's incumbent upon the clients themselves and the employees who work for those clients to get engaged, to understand that there are tools and resources out there and they have a responsibility. Most people fail to understand that today's claims are tomorrow's premium. And so part of the whole job of CDHP is to let them know that healthcare doesn't cost $20. It's much more expensive than that. And that you need to be engaged in the cost of this. And by the way, even though it's more work on the front end, know that you'll save yourself money on the back end and more importantly, probably get better quality care because you did some homework up front.
SPEAKER_01It's really incumbent upon the actual user, the consumer, to start asking questions, to challenge their physicians on what the the procedures are that they are being asked to undergo, whether it's an MRI, whether duplicating tests that are already happened, whether taking a prescription, whether it's generic or name brand, ask questions. And I think that as a society as a whole, we still feel that the physicians are always right. And really statistics point to the fact that as a consumer, you need to be engaged in the conversation.
DavidDo you think that that's going to take a generational shift in order for it to actually sink in? Or do you think that with today's higher personal responsibility amounts and the proliferation of spending accounts where you can save the money or you can spend it and now you're using your own money, not someone else's, do you think that will happen sooner than a generational shift?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell I think it's already happening. I think with the advent of technology, the fact that we now have 75 million millennials, and many of them are are coming into the workforce. I think they're just going to demand this type of energy and this type of uh access to information.
SPEAKER_01I absolutely think that the shift has already started with the way healthcare has been the costs have increased from an employer level, and they've had to shift to much higher deductibles and introducing the CDHP plans, people are more engaged now of the some of the actual costs. So unfortunately, with the rise in cost of healthcare, it's actually forcing people to now be more engaged.
SPEAKER_02If I could go back and revisit one thing that Jen said, and I think it's really important, the whole notion of us living in an environment where it's actually the right thing to do to challenge our physicians. That being said, we all have to remember that doctors are human beings, and human beings by definition make mistakes. You've heard me say this before, but what is what do they call the guy who graduated last in his medical school?
DavidYeah, doctor.
SPEAKER_02Correct. How do you know he's not yours? And so my point is, well, Mark, I love my doctor. Yeah, I didn't say you didn't love your doctor. How do you know on the bell-shaped curve of life that your doctor is not in the bottom 10% or in the median 80%? You want the guy or gal who's in the top top 10% of their game, I would think. The question is in our generation, if we look at it generationally, our parents grew up to believe that the doctor was the be-all, end all, knows everything because they went to school forever. Well, guess what? We now have technology that shows us that's not the case. In fact, one of the partners we work with, Best Doctors, shows us that 37% of the time people are diagnosed, it's inaccurate. And 75% of the time, even if the physician gets the diagnosis correctly, the treatment plan they're availing themselves of is not helpful to their condition.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.