The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #186: The New Way to LTC Success - with Jesse Slome
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Jesse Slome is Executive Director at the American Association for Long Term Care Insurance. We asked him whether LTC was dead or alive and his answer may surprise listeners. We explore what happened to the first wave of LTC carriers and talk a bit about the recent divestiture and acquisition some major carriers have made.
Are so-called combination products, which provide both life and LTC insurance the wave of the future or are pure-play LTC products still available and appropriate for clients? Jesse talks about how to position these new plans and how to deal with underwriting. Finally, we discuss different practice models to see which might be the best fit.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- If LTC is dead, alive or just misunderstood.
- What happened with the first wave of carriers and products.
- What the recent wave of LTC book sales means for advisors.
- Why combo-products may be the wave of the present and the future.
- What opportunities there are to move forward and improve in this area.
Is long-term care dead or alive? And what do advisors need to know about the new way to help clients with this critical coverage? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. Is long-term care dead or alive? How long will it last? More importantly, what's the opportunity for agents? Our guest today says there's a great opportunity for agents, but not what he calls the old way. We're pleased to be speaking with Jesse Sloam, who is Executive Director at the American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance. And Jesse will answer those questions and as they say, much more. Welcome, Jesse. Oh, my pleasure to be here. So is long-term care insurance alive or dead? We we hear a lot of consternation from brokers who want to get into it or brokers who used to be into it but were there when things kind of fell apart. What's the story?
SPEAKER_01It's evolved. You know, the analogy, because people don't really get it. The analogy that I use is movies. I'm 65, love to watch movies. You know, it wasn't that long ago that I would go to my local Blockbuster and I would go walk up and down the aisles and I would pick two or three movies for the weekend and I would take them home. And if I was lucky, they didn't jam in the video machine, and then I could watch them, and then I had to drive back to Blockbuster and return them on time, etc. Well, today Blockbuster doesn't really exist. And in fact, DVDs, you know, are being replaced. Everybody is streaming. The same analogy is true when it comes to long-term care insurance. Things evolve, markets evolve, people's preferences evolve. Long-term care insurance has evolved. The products that were sold 10, 15, 20 years ago are, I want to say, as sort of out of vogue as videotape uh VHS movies are. Doesn't mean people have stopped watching movies, doesn't mean people have stopped planning for long-term care. They've just doing it differently.
DavidSo one of the things that we always talk about when we get into a discussion of long-term care is the kind of hockey stick-like price increases on some of those early policies. Do the carriers just not really understand how to price the risk? Did the risk completely get out of hand? What caused all of that?
SPEAKER_01I'm not a spokesperson for the industry. We never have been. We, you know, we advocate and really support agents, but I've been doing this since the mid-1980s. So here's the honest answer. Two things happened. I don't think anybody did it with any kind of maliciousness in mind. But the first major problem is what is called lapse ratios. And the insurance companies underestimated the lapse ratios. Now, I will tell you, not by a lot. For other insurance products, you know, the assumed lapse rates might be 10, 15% a year. For long-term care insurance, they were, let's say, about 4% a year. That's what they assumed over a long period of time. What really has happened is people who bought these policies did not lapse them. The lapse rate was actually about 1%. And without making anybody who's listening to this make their eyes glaze over, let me explain what that means. If you sold 100,000 policies and you expected a 4% lapse rate, at the end of 20 years, 80% of your policies lapsed. So instead of 100,000, you now had 20,000. And about a third to half of those would go on claim. So you had about five to seven, eight thousand claimants. What really happened, 1% lapse rates, those same 100,000 policies, now at the end of 20 years, you still have 80,000. The same percentage are going to go on claim, 30% to 50%. So now instead of 7,000 or 8,000 claimants, you have 40,000 claimants. And claims are lasting longer and they're costing more money. But it's the lapse rate that was the number one miscalculation. And the second one was interest rates. Listen, if interest rates today were the same as they were in the 70s and 80s, when you could go to your bank and get 12% on a CD and a free toaster oven, you know, the insurance companies would be, would be very, very profitable, the long-term care ones. But low sustained interest rates have wreaked havoc, not just on long-term care, but on life insurance policies on others. So that that to a degree is why the market has evolved. And at the same time, the regulators have not, and I put a lot of the blame on them. Not that they're bad people again, but the regulators have not allowed product design to evolve. So you have the worst of all worlds. You have a market where the regulators are saying no, you can only rent your movies on VHS tapes, and everybody looks and says, but I don't want a VHS tape. They jam my machine.
DavidA lot of that settled down, but there's still some motion. We're talking off here. ManuLife has spun off Hancock. Genworth is working on a deal with China oceanwide. Is this just the tail of that dog? Is this kind of the end of that problem?
SPEAKER_01Well, insurance companies are either mutual companies or for-profit stock-owned companies. And either way, they have to make a profit. Long-term care insurance is a small market. It always has been. Not the case. It's always been a rather small, very defined market. So some insurance companies have left the market because they looked and they said, hey, it's a tough market to uh do business in. We can make more money doing business in other areas, better return, less risk. So, you know, each company makes their own decision. A lot of them who were big names in the industry, and I'm never going to mention names, but you know, they were household names in the insurance industry. But when you looked at how many long-term care insurance policies they sold a year, it might have been three, four thousand policies a year. Doesn't pay to keep a whole business unit open for that. So for various reasons, the insurance companies have one by one looked and said, we're going to get out. Now, at the same time, conversely, when I say the markets have evolved, you know, you mentioned John Hancock. I think they very recently came out with a family of life insurance policies that pay long-term care benefits. So it's not that they're not making available long-term care protection. New York Life, I think just last week or this week announced uh a new product. You know, they are evolving. Their products are evolving because at the end of the day, they have to serve their customers. They have to either serve the stockholders or serve their policy holders. And that's that's that's really why everybody makes an economic decision.
DavidYou said that there is an opportunity for brokers, but you you said not the old way. So what is the old way? What's the new way? And then let's chat a little bit about what that opportunity is.
SPEAKER_01Well, okay, the old way. There are plenty of folks who've been in the business for a long time and bemoan the old days, and uh, you know, of when you could go in and sell somebody lifetime coverage with 5% compound inflation, and the policy cost them, you know, way under $100 a person a month. Well, you know, that just you can't have policies that are priced that way. So the new way is a couple of things. First, like everything else, people are not interested in a one-size-fits-all solution. And I've advocated for years that insurance agents take a good, better, best approach to selling long-term care insurance. And in fact, yesterday, uh, I forget what I was watching on television. Oh, I know, there was watching about the introduction of the new Apple iPhone. And they looked and they said, look, the iPhone 10 is going to cost $1,000. Now, not everybody is going to be able to afford the iPhone 10 at $1,000, but that's why they have other models. And so you by having a good, better, best approach, the vast majority of people will pick not the most expensive or the best, certainly not the cheapest, but there's a category, and most people, there was a term for it, I forgot what they used on the show last night, but there's a term for people who will pick something right in the middle of the road. And that's the mistake that many, many agents make when it comes to selling long-term care insurance. They only take a one size fits all. That's number one. Number two, today you must be knowledgeable about the link benefit or the hybrid products. And there's a variety of them out there, and you need to, because those are the dominant sellers in the industry today. Probably I'm gonna say three or four out of five policies that are sold today are link benefit or hybrid products. And so it's very likely that if you're an agent or broker that is out there prospecting for long-term care insurance sales, you're going to come across clients where their financial advisor, their stock broker, or somebody else has been or is proposing a link benefit product. And if you're not knowledgeable in them at the very least, and able to compare and offer a variety of options, you're going to be at a decided disadvantage.
DavidHow do you position, if you're not a life person, um, but you're more of a an overall benefits broker, how do you then position and get knowledgeable about a hybrid product?
SPEAKER_01I I would honestly tell you, and and I've been doing this, as I said, since the late 1980s, to be really honest with the people who are listening to this, you have two choices. You can either take all the time that you want to learn about these products, to understand how to sell them, to understand how to overcome the objections, to understand the health underwriting that is absolutely essential today, more essential than ever. But I don't think you will. And I think that's been part of the issue that this industry has faced. And my recommendation is that you partner with somebody who knows what they're doing and you just share in the sale. If you're a benefits broker and you have clients, great. You can you can bring in a long-term care specialist who really understands what they're doing. Because I have to tell you, after talking to hundreds, maybe thousands of agents, you're gonna believe that you can do it. You're gonna try the first time, and and the first of all, you're gonna be scared to death because the client is more knowledgeable than you. And the second thing is when the client asks questions, or now when you have to start asking health-related questions that get very personal about, you know, diabetes and their scores and all of that, you're gonna shy away from this business. And even if you do get it through the first time, when you get a client declined, and a vast, I don't want to say a majority, a significant percentage of applications are declined. And today, if you are declined by one insurer, some of the other insurers are making that an automatic decline. So the the the short answer and the long answer to your question is listen, you can go it alone. I wish you well. I congratulate you. In today's environment, I think you're going to be so much happier and better off if you partner with somebody who knows what they're doing.
DavidAnd now, a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. I was a DI geek for a long time, and that was a big part of my practice when I was out in individual sales. And I wonder if you have any idea or any thoughts around how many of those declined apps are declined because the apps, especially the medical portion, are not fully disclosed or written properly so that an underwriter can really get their arms around the risk, versus how many are declined because they just are cases that should be declined medically.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's it's two things. First of all, everybody lies. You know, we I mean the association supports agents around the uh the nation, and and we take dozens of calls literally every day from consumers that we then farm out to agents who are selling it. And so we get feedback. You know, everybody, oh, I'm in perfect health. No, no, no. All I take is a little cholesterol and a little blood pressure medicine. You know, that's that's not the case today. The people who are talking and thinking about long-term care insurance are in their mid-sixties, their mid-70s, or older, and they have diagnoses that they are not disclosing. They feel that they're in good health, but they're in good controlled health. So I think it's a combination. I think first they're not fully disclosing, and they don't realize that it's going to come up when the medical records are pulled, or they are disclosing, and the agent looks and says, Well, I've spent this much time with you. You know, let's let's just put it through. Now I will tell you that there is a significant opportunity out there today that is vastly overlooked for agents, and that is what are called short-term care insurance policies. And there we have set up a separate entity where one, we are training, we are appointing agents to do it because nobody is addressing that market. So let me spend a minute. Is that okay? Can I can I just talk to you? Because you raised a good question on the health insurability. Short-term care insurance is is ideal in the following situations. I'm holding up my finger so I can count them off. When you have a client who can't or won't afford long-term care insurance, and that's a lot of people today. When you have a client or a prospect who cannot health qualify, and that is also anywhere from 25 to 40 percent of applications that are submitted are decline. When you have a client that's too old, because traditional long-term care insurance basically stops policies at 75, there's some short-term care insurers today who will go up to age 85 and some even up to age 89. So when you have all of those situations, some coverage is better than none. And short-term care insurance, which is not available in all states, we are finding to be an ideal solution because people want some long-term care. They want care in their own home, not necessarily in a nursing home. And these type of short-term care recovery products are are really filling the gap. And I I guess the the call that we get all the time from agents is, oh my God, I sold. I mean, I literally had one just before we started to record this, where a long-term care insurance specialist, all that he does and has done for 10 or 15 years is sell traditional long-term care insurance and a few hybrid products. He emailed me to say, hey, one of the consumers that we had sent him just bought a short-term care insurance policy and bought a significant one. So it wasn't, you know, they were willing to spend a premium, but they would never have health qualified for a traditional policy. So it really is an option that people should look at. And actually, uh, let me take one second. Only plug unless you want me to do more at some point. So I created the National Advisory Center for Short-Term Care Information. And if you want to learn more as an agent, go to, it's real easy, short termcareinsurance.org, shorttermcareinsurance.org. And we've really started to post quite a bit up there. I think that's a market that is going to continue to take off.
DavidWe'll link to that in the show notes for certain. Well, something you said a moment ago I I found interesting. You said that most applicants today are in their mid-60s to mid-70s. So it brings two questions to mind. Question number one, is that older than it was back 10, 15 years ago? Because I seem to recall that it was a little bit younger. And second of all, do these policies, these long-term care policies, now belong in the realm of what folks are calling broadly senior products? And would that be the kind of practice that might benefit most from incorporating this?
SPEAKER_01No, the the average age is actually younger. It's 57, 58, but people in their 50s, that one, that's the average age, because remember, as you get older, you're less likely to be approved health-wise. So that definitely skews the average age of policy purchasers. But but when do people really start to think about long-term care when they're in their 60s and older? So is it a senior product? Well, the answer that what the insurance companies and everybody would like to tell you is, oh no, this is something you have to do in your 50s. And that's true, and that's nice if you can, but most people in their 50s are not doing it. And really, your prime market, what I tell people when I'm talking to reporters or others about long-term care, is I tell people the following the best age to do your long-term care planning is just before retirement, just before you go on Medicare. And here's why. So basically, for most people before age 65. And the reason for that is I'm turning 65 in a few months, November of 2017. I am three weeks after I get on Medicare, I've got my internist exam, and baby, I am going to go for every free preventative screen that I can get that's covered fully by Medicare. I've been holding off on a bunch of them. Why? Because I'm no different than any other consumer. I don't want to pay if I can avoid it. I pay enough for everything. So those health screens that Medicare provides are wonderful benefits, and people take advantage of them. They are also the things that can uncover health conditions that can prevent somebody from health qualifying for long-term care. So, in my mind, the ideal time to target and the ideal message is before you're on Medicare, before you retire, because it's not about the cost, it's about those health issues that are going to be discovered when you qualify for Medicare and you do what we all do is take advantage of all those wonderful preventative screens.
DavidGreat advice and a good place to leave today's conversation, Jesse Sloan, Executive Director at the American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance. Jesse, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience. Always a pleasure. Thanks. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.