The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #180: Cross Border Benefits with Ron Hansell
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Every time talk turns to single payer, folks use the Canadian healthcare system as a reference. How does that system really work and does it provide better care for our northern neighbors?
For answers, we went to our Canadian friend Ron Hansell, President of Cross Border Benefits. We start by asking Ron for an overview of their system – just to level-set the discussion. He explains how their system is paid for, what it costs and how their citizens interact with it.
We discuss some of the results of a recent Fraser Institute study about how their costs are rising and how and why so many Canadians seek care abroad – most in the United States. We also look at the effect of ever-lengthening waiting times for treatment that seems to be inherent in their health care arrangement.
An ever-growing number of U.S. companies have a presence in Canada, and Ron explains what those companies and their advisors need to know to advise them properly.
What You’ll Learn from This Episode:
- What the Canadian Healthcare System is like.
- What the Canadian system costs.
- How Canadians interact with the system.
- How lengthy wait times drive Canadians to the U.S. for healthcare.
- What U.S. companies need to know about benefits in Canada.
Is the Canadian healthcare system a model for the United States? How does it really work? What does it really cost? And what do U.S. companies need to know about it? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. There's been a lot of talk, especially as things kind of go south in the Congress of the United States, about single payer. And it comes up every now and again, and there are pluses and minuses in people on both sides of that discussion. But when people in the States think about single payer, they typically think about Canada, not surprisingly, our closest neighbor, single payer system, mature single payer system. And so I thought it would be really instructive for us to have some conversation around what the Canadian system does, what it doesn't do, because there are a lot of misconceptions. And with that, we're pleased to welcome Ron Hansel, who's president of Across Border Benefits, which is an Ontario-based benefits and consulting firm. With that, welcome, Ron. Thanks very much for having me, David. It's a pleasure. Could you give us kind of a 10,000-foot overview as a starting point, at least, of the Canadian system and kind of how it works?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'd be pleased to. The Canadian system is a federally mandated system that was established in 1966. So as you mentioned, it's a mature system. It started in Western Canada and then was established by the federal government. And the mandate of the federal government is to that all doctors' charges and hospital charges will be paid for for every Canadian citizen. And the program is mandated by the federal government and is administered by each and every province. So the basic foundation of the of the plan is that every province needs to have doctor's charges, so doctor visits, doctor visits in the hospital, visitations for colds, sicknesses, flus, something more acute, all the way through to stays and visits in the hospital are covered. So a Canadian resident has no deductible or has no coinsurance and has access to those services, albeit they may have some weights for some types of services, which you may want to explore as we go through. But that's fundamentally the program.
DavidThat's great. So everyone's covered, except that there's a new Frasier Institute study, and this may speak to the to the waiting times, that talks about 63,000 folks in their last survey, Canadians, went abroad for medical care, and most of those folks uh came to the United States. To what do you attribute that?
SPEAKER_01Largely wait times. The system does not is uniform across the board. So regardless of economic circumstances, everybody is in the same system. And for some people who have the economic means, that's not satisfactory. So for example, you may have um if you have an acute situation, pain in your heart, you go to the emergency, it's uh determined that you've got uh blockage of significance, you're going to get treated, I believe, as well as you get treated in a in a U.S. hospital. But let's say you're you've got a nagging uh knee injury or a shoulder injury, you may wait, you would go to your general practitioner and he would prescribe a visit to the specialist, which which may take, which may take literally months before you see your specialist. Your specialist would then order a battery of tests, MRIs, etc. You may wait a period of time for that. And then once it's all diagnosed, you may wait again for surgery. So it's depending on the triage, it's depending on the level of um requirement will determine how fast you get you get through things. But so what people to answer your question more directly is that some people are, for example, if you're living uh close to a border town, which many Canadians do, you have to appreciate that probably within about 50 to 150 miles over the US border is the majority of the Canadian population. We're seeing more and more Canadians turning to, I don't really want to wait for my shoulder injury to be diagnosed through an MRI. And they go across to, in our case, go across to Buffalo and and have the MRI performed and pay out of pocket $350 or $400, take those results back to their doctor and have them reviewed just to speed things up. And they may further go all the way to you know acute situations like like cancer and other things that they may not feel that they're either getting adequate treatment or having to wait extended periods of time.
DavidSo they're paying the stuff out of pocket, which belies another question. How is the Canadian system actually financed? Because again, you know, going back to that same recent Fraser Institute study, and correct me if if their data is wrong, but what they're talking about is that a family of four, the overall cost, and and you'll talk about, I guess, how it's collected, but is about $12,057 a year. And costs have gone up about 70% over 20 years. So A, are those numbers accurate? And B, how is that money collected?
SPEAKER_01Well, the Fraser Institute is a very credible organization, so I wouldn't want to uh to differ with their numbers at all. I could give you some insights as to how those numbers are likely uh attributed to. So general tax revenue is is a large funder. Uh the federal government collects the taxes. The taxes are then, and not solely, but they're those, they're then they provide transfer payments to the province, providing the province is doing what they're required to do, minimally doctors' charges, hospital charges, they're receiving big grants, big blocks of money, transfer grants to to fund that. The provinces sometimes, and each province is different, but in the province of Ontario, they have a payroll tax of 1.9% of earnings with no cap. So regardless of whether an employee is making $30,000 or $300,000, it's 1.9%. So I'm sure that's in the calculation. In addition, there are benefit programs, group life insurance, disability, short and long-term disability, dental programs, and wraparound health care plans, which are prescription drug programs primarily, semi-private hospital and paramedical programs in Canada. And that's where I make my living. And that the cost of those programs on average for a fam on average for an employee would be $3,000 a year. So if you have a husband working and a spouse working and they both have full benefit programs, there's probably $6,000 a year. There's payroll taxes of 1.9%, and there's general tax revenues. And then there's some probably out-of-pocket coverages or costs that employees may be incurring as well. Drugs or non-over-the-counter drugs that aren't covered under the benefit program, or possibly maybe they're considering some of this medical tourism as well that's taking place.
DavidSo we've talked a little bit about where the money comes from to fund the program, and there's rationing of just of a different sort than what we have currently here in the States, based on in the wait times, I guess you might say. But is there any transparency? I mean, i are Canadians able to, or do they even have a desire to shop around and understand what the cost of a particular plan is? If they have no deductibles and no coinsurance, it's almost like being at a point in the consumer-directed plan here in the States where you're at 100% coverage, or is it not?
SPEAKER_01There is some move, particularly in the prescription drug area in the space. And when we say a healthcare plan that's provided through your employer, about 70 to 80 percent of that cost is attributable to the prescription drug program. And just like in the United States, we're experiencing very rapid increases in the cost of that prescription drug program. We're seeing the same biologics that you're seeing, the same specialty drugs that you're seeing. So the cost of the prescriptions, and we're also seeing dispensing fees that are increasing. So there are some moves afoot. Generally, programs say some employers have limited the amount of the dispensing fee. Some employers have said we need to move from uh brand name drugs to generic drugs. So generic generic drugs first. If there is no generic drug, then you go to uh a brand name drug. And I might say that the legislation in Canada is not in the favor of big pharma from the standpoint that the patents come off much quicker in Canada than they do, as I understand them to be in the United States. And so we move to generic drugs at a much quicker pace. Hence, I don't think I can't say for all drugs, and certainly for the drugs that are in the category of these biological or new specialty drugs, probably comparable pricing. But when we're into some of the longer run programs that have moved to generics, we do enjoy lower cost pricing in Canada. And hence businesses have been set up in Canada to distribute drugs into the United States, which is a whole other which is a whole other topic. But from time to time, there is there is some cross-border shopping of US employers looking into Canada, and there are businesses set up in Canada to price drugs and bring them across.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now, Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solutions, go to our website at www.captivated health.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. Speaking of cross-border, I know one of the things that you guys have encountered over the last few years and have have kind of made a study of and made a specialty of is US-based companies that are establishing footprints in Canada, whether it's through an acquisition or an expansion. Talk a little bit about that. And if I'm a US company and that's something I'm thinking about, what are the things that I need to consider?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, there is a I didn't really realize it until I got researching this, but there is $300 billion of trade from the United States going into Canada each year. $300 billion. And conversely, there's $300 billion of trade going from Canada into the United States each year. Phenomenal number. We are, you are certainly our largest trading partner, and I think we're your second largest trading partner, but our balance of trade is the most level of trading partners. So what we also see is that you know we have free trade agreements, which are being discussed right now between Canada, Mexico, and the United States. We have a tremendous number of U.S. corporations that have set up subsidiary operations into Canada, thousands of them, as a matter of fact. And similarly, Canadian companies into the United States. How do I understand the Canadian system? How do I understand what's even paid for? What would a benefit program look like in Canada? What would a retirement program, which is a key composition of a benefit program in Canada, what does all that look like? How does a government program come into this? What are the laws of the land? And how do we understand all that? As I say, the the big employers have had that opportunity, the small, medium-sized employers have not. And the advisors looking after them have somewhat been handcuffed over time. So over time, as we've been doing this, we've in we have worked with a number of U.S. companies on their Canadian benefit programs. We know the questions they've been asking. So we're we're talking to more U.S. companies about their benefit programs and trying to set the table for them, much like this conversation, so that there's an understanding of what is what is taking place in Canada so that they can do business and feel comfortable and meet their fiduciary responsibilities, their corporate responsibilities, and feel good about having uh and understanding that they're meeting all the needs and requirements.
DavidWhat does a retirement program you mentioned retirement programs. What does a retirement program look like and how is it or is it at all analogous to the 401ks that are so prevalent here in the States?
SPEAKER_01I would say very much analogous. There are two major pro there's a defined benefit program in Canada. We've been a little slower to dismantle defined benefit programs, but have in a great many instances. So we end up with a defined contribution program, and there's two products that come from that a defined contribution pension program, which has more legislative requirements, or you get into what we call a group retirement savings program. And that has a little more flexibility to it. But again, it's it like your programs here, it's an employer contribution, it's an employee contribution of somewhere between 3 and 5% are the most common types of programs, with uh a multitude of different funds from uh GICs through to aggressive growth funds that an employee can choose. Safe harbor rules are not as we don't have the same safe harbor rules, though we have and the provinces, each province uh um regulates the uh retirement programs, with the exception of a if you were a federally regulated corporation. But most people coming in and operating are are governed by the provincial statutes and they're governed by some form of capital accumulation plan guidelines, not as stringent as your Safe Harbor rules.
DavidSo are are there still highly compensated employee testing methodologies that that need to be taken into account?
SPEAKER_01There are maximums to the programs. So the you know, you're in the mid-20,000 dollar range of a contribution that you could make to a defined contribution either to a retirement pro pension program or to an RSP. On the defined benefit program, yes, there's there are rules that govern uh the weighting of the contribution and the benefit accumulation for the more highly compensated and also the those that own the corporations. So there are rules that that that uh preclude big whacks of money putting just put in just for those folks.
DavidAnd presumably the the mutual funds that employees have access to are self-directed?
SPEAKER_01They are. They're very much. And and a lot of the names that you hear, the Fidelities and the Templetons, those are names that we have in Canada as well.
DavidAaron Powell Interesting. So there's an awful lot of similarities, except that you guys are still kind of hanging on to defined benefit plans. And I don't know when somebody's seen a defined benefit plan in the States since probably the Tax Reduction Act of 86. But that that's interesting. So as as we kind of wrap up here, we've got through two or three minutes left. I know one of the things that you folks have recently done is you've created what you call the cross-border consortium. What is that and and why does it matter to advisors? Okay.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the cross-border benefit consortium has been established to work with advisors that have U.S. business to build build better fences around their clients. So many advisors don't have the capability. So the cross-border benefit consortium gives them the capability to provide Canadian benefit advice to their clients, to provide them with the capability without a lot of cost or input to have to establish that program. It provides them building better fences. It also allows them to build better prospecting opportunities. So now they have a capability they didn't have before. And in addition, for those advisors that qualify, Canadian opportunities that will arise through our network in Canada that come to the U.S. with Canadian companies, it provides them with opportunities for new clients. So that's those three things.
DavidNow, for folks who want to learn more, especially on the employer side, we'll have in the show notes a link to crossborderbenefits.ca, or you can just click on the link on the shiftchapersonline.com website. But there's some videos there, and those also will help if you're an employer, right? Those are employer-based, as I recall from our conversation.
SPEAKER_01That's right. There's five five different videos that are there, David, which explain a lot of what we've talked about, but there's short 90-second vignettes of the Canadian landscape, the Canadian retirement scene. It's great for employers to use to get an understanding, and it's great for advisors to use. We welcome them to use that to bring those forward to their clients to help them with the Canadian scene.
DavidSo in the minute or so that we have left, we oftentimes like to wrap up by asking where you see the future. What do you see the growth patterns of this? How do you envision what the next five or ten years will look like?
SPEAKER_01Oh well, I think that we're there's certainly cross-border benefits and going across markets, regardless of how free trade continues, is that it is uh a wide open world now, and there'll be there'll be more and more of this. And so being able to understand Canadians understanding the U.S. and the systems, and U.S. understanding Canada will be doing more of this, I think, not not less of it. So they're frontiers, they're maybe not frontiers as we once thought of them, but um we will be doing more, and I think there'll be there'll be some movement in the Canadian system to maybe to a two-tier system over time. I think uh it'd be more medical tourism that will take place. And as far as the US goes, it's a very interesting question. It certainly has had a lot of talk and a lot of thought put behind it. There is no one panacea. The Canadian system is not perfect, nor is the US system, but somewhere in in there, there's probably a hybrid that each side has to give a little bit.
DavidSo we we continue to hope for wisdom, and that and that's a great place to leave our conversation today. Ron Hansel, president at Across Border Benefits. Ron, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience. My pleasure. Thank you. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.