The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #176: Consumer Oriented Surgery Shopping – with Sanjay Prasad
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
“Consumer” and “shopping” go together everywhere in our lives – except in healthcare. What would happen if consumers could easily shop for non-emergency surgery and get bundled pricing, all with the help of a concierge to guide them through the process?
That is the question that Dr. Sanjay Prasad, Founder and CEO at SurgiPrice discusses on this episode. We begin by discussing how the current system has trapped patients and employers and forced unnatural consumer behavior. A surge on himself, Dr. Prasad has designed a system that helps to correct this anomaly – at least, for non-emergency surgical needs.
He acknowledges that it might be difficult for patients to understand and assess the price and quality metrics and believes that a concierge can help. We also explore what happens when a consulting surgeon indicates that they feel a surgery might not be medically necessary, and how a patient’s primary care physician deals with that second opinion.
Finally, we explore the notion of bundled pricing and how much plans can save versus the itemization that has become the standard – until now.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Why bundling costs can have a lot of benefits.
- Why consumers haven’t been able to shop for non-emergency care.
- Why this is the perfect time to bring this pricing tool to consumers.
- How benefit advisers can add this option to their practice.
- If fully insured carriers are interested in bundling costs and consumer-driven surgery selection, or will be dismissing the concepts.
How would the market change if consumers could shop for non-emergency surgeries and pay bundled pricing too? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzmith.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. We talk an awful lot on the podcast about consumerism and more to the point the lack of consumerism, the lack of individuals to be able to move markets in ways that they want that make sense for them and to discern pricing. And we're very excited this morning to be talking to Dr. Sanjay Prasad. Dr. Prasad is founder and CEO of an organization called SurgiPrice, and he's studied this area and this problem, and they're working very diligently on trying to bring some tools to market that will impact that in a very significant way. And with that, welcome, Sanjay.
SPEAKER_02Well, thank you, David. It's an honor to be on your show. I think very highly of you and your show. Thank you.
DavidWell, we appreciate that. Thank you. A little bit about your background so that folks understand where these solutions are, what part of your brain these solutions are coming from.
SPEAKER_02Well, I've been a practicing surgeon for 25 years, and you know, I've seen patients come and go, and I've seen my colleagues and how they operate and how things work in a hospital setting, how things work in a surgical setting in an ambulatory surgery center, what the costing is, the finances, et cetera. And I am absolutely flabbergasted by the system we currently have that has not evolved. We have a system now where patients are herded from primary care doctors to specialists without any regard to cost, without any regard to quality, the quality of care that's delivered. And this is absolutely unbelievable. We don't shop for anything else in this way, but in healthcare, patients, and I I can easily be a patient, and you can easily be a patient, we are herded from primary care doctors to specialists without any regard to our needs. So it's horrible what's happening out there.
DavidAaron Powell To what do you attribute that? I mean, it it doesn't happen, or more to the point, I guess, we don't allow it to happen in any of our other consumer encounters. Why has it been allowed to happen? What what's the the ground in which those infertile seeds have been planted?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Well, I think people inherently trust their primary care physician, and there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. But when the condition is severe enough to warrant a surgical specialist getting involved, they have to ask themselves the proper questions. You know, why is my primary care physician referring me to this surgeon? What is the basis behind that referral? Is it based on quality of outcomes over a number of cases that he sent that person? And are there other possibilities, other alternatives to treating the condition that's at hand? So I think consumers have to be more intelligent, but they have to be armed with tools that allow them to make more informed choices.
DavidSo you obviously feel that the time is right to start bringing those tools to market. Why? What what's the perfect storm that's come together to make this the right time to move forward?
SPEAKER_02Well, uh the exploding healthcare costs, obviously. Employers are dealing with double-digit annual increases in their premiums, and uh healthcare spend is becoming a bigger part of their expense sheet, you know, uh, month to month, year to year. The insurance carriers continue to raise the premiums uh on a yearly basis. Uh and on the patient end, what's happened is that there's been a certain shift of uh financial responsibility uh from the employer uh to the employee, uh, as you are well aware. The deductibles are getting higher. Patients oftentimes are not even able to afford some of their surgical care. And when you can't afford surgical care, then it's a question of access, and now we don't have access to surgical care for some folks.
DavidAaron Powell So it is it is indeed a perfect storm of a of a number of different things in Confluence that are bringing us to this point. Where you've been focused is on helping folks get pricing and pricing in a different way as well for non-emergency surgical procedures. Talk a little bit about the process and how that works.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Sure. Uh the sim the system is really simple. If you really look at it from the outside, 30,000 feet up, it's a very simple system. When patients are told they need surgery, we're basically gathering the medical records. We're helping the patient gather those records through a concierge service, and then we are uh uploading these records in a HIPAA compliant fashion to a server, cloud server, and then distributing those records to board-certified surgeons, it could be local regional, it could be national, through an app called the Surgy Connect app. And what we're doing here is basically getting multiple opinions. We're getting multiple opinions using the flow of electrons. And what we're doing is we're validating the medical necessity of having the procedure, alternatives that there might be to the procedure, and if that procedure is indicated, and surgeons can review the MRI scan or the CAT scan that shows the condition right on our app, they can uh enter their pricing, surgeon's fee, facility fee, anesthesia fee, and they can also add in there and report on what their experience has been with that procedure in terms of how many cases they've performed, what's been their success rate for that procedure, what's been the complication rate, and they can also qualify their complications. They can have a little uh an area where they can actually discuss and explain why they may have had certain complications. So we're creating a platform for patients where we're really creating a platform for marketplace competition, if you will.
DavidAaron Powell And if I'm a consumer, does that information all come back to me? Does it come back to my primary care physician? Where does that go?
SPEAKER_02So the information we gather back from the surgeons, that is pricing data and quality metric data, we take that data and compare it against uh what's nationally reported and against national norms and letter grade their quality metrics. So what the patients see are a list of surgeons, they see their qualifications, uh, how many cases they may have performed over the last 12 months, they see their out-of-pocket costs related to going to surgeon A, B, or C, and then they see a list of quality metrics and up to five quality metrics graded on a letter grading system, A, B, C, and D. So this starts the conversation. Patients are free to contact their bidding surgeon through a telemedicine platform. So what we what we've created is a system where you can sit at home and you can get multiple opinions uh from the universe of providers that are local to you, regional to you, national, and even international.
DavidAre you finding that consumers are comfortable once they're armed with that information in going out and contacting the bidding surgeon? Because, you know, uh a lot of for a lot of folks, physicians are still on pedestals and it's difficult, and it may be a generational shift for, and we've talked about that on the program, until they're completely comfortable saying to their primary care doc, you know what, I'm gonna go get some other prices and some other opinions.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm I mean, and this has to this this really deals with healthcare literacy, and there there will be some patients that will will listen to their primary care physician, only go to the surgeon that was referred to. And then there will be mostly other surgeons and the per perhaps other younger patients that will embrace this whole idea. It's very disruptive, there's no question. But what we're doing is we're holding the healthcare system accountable, accountable both in terms of pricing and accountable both also in terms of quality. So in the very beginning, it's going to be a bit difficult for the consumers to understand. That's why we have the concierge to help them understand what the differences are.
DavidSo they have somebody who's qualified who can kind of talk them through the data that you provide back to them.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah. That's the you know, we call ourselves a healthcare technology company, but we're really service first. We're really service and technology. Yeah, the concierge is critical. You know, you it's similar to going to a hotel and, you know, having a concierge desk and having basically everything taken care of for you. Any questions you have, you can communicate with the concierge at any time you want. So we have someone, a compassionate soul that really handholds them from the moment that they're told they need surgery until they're back to work.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now, Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solution, go to our website at www.captivated health.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. Two things from chatting with you off air that I thought were really interesting. I'd like to explore both of them. It's entirely possible when the information is sent out to the network of surgeons that somebody may come back and say, we don't think this surgical procedure is medically necessary. What happens then?
SPEAKER_02Well, it creates uh yeah, the multiple opinion service does create this system where you have some conservative opinions. And remember, surgeons are very different. Surgeons are different, they've uh trained at different institutions. Some institutions are conservative, some are more radical, thinking that surgical options are necessary earlier on. So what we're doing here is taking advantage of the varied opinions that are out there. Again, these are all board-certified surgeons. Yes, some will render opinions that the condition isn't severe enough to warrant a procedure. Maybe physical therapy is warranted, maybe acupuncture, maybe alternative forms of treatment uh would be recommended initially, and a surgical option would be recommended later. So it starts that whole conversation. And on our platform, the customer, the patient, can reach out to that bidding surgeon who says that a conservative option may be more prudent and determine the reasons why and what his reasoning is. You know, it's all about information, David. And in today's world, patients are just completely information locked. And we want to unlock their information, their ability to get the proper information.
DavidAaron Powell Well, and that that's going to be the key. And what's interesting besides the medical information that you get back, and you've alluded to it a couple of times, the pricing that's being offered here is what you refer to as bundled pricing. What does that mean and why is it important?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Well, it's important to bundle simply because it creates a system of accountability. You know, if you have a knee replacement and what we're talking about is bundling the surgeon's fee, the facility fee, and the anesthesia fee. And if you provide upfront pricing, and yeah, you can do this procedure at this cost, then there's some accountability in the operating room with opening disposables, et cetera, that's already been taken into account, then there's an effort within the healthcare system to control the cost because there has to be some profit margin, obviously. So I mean, those are the beauties of upfront bundled pricing. I'm not sure I made myself clear, but did you have another question on that?
DavidWell, no, it's so basically it's a flat price. Instead of playing the game that gets paid, and I I we'll talk about this in a moment, but at the moment, you know, you're playing more in the partially self-funded space. So a TPA, and I helped run a TPA for quite a long time during one portion of my career, a large surgical claim will come in and it maybe gets negotiated down once and maybe gets negotiated down twice. In this case, what you're seeking to accomplish is that the bundled pricing is one kind of flat fee that includes everything and is the last, is kind of equivalent or better than what that last reprice would be, isn't it?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. And the other thing our system does is, you know, when you have surgery today, you get bills for six months, a year later for radiology, for laboratory tests, for the pathology. You know, what we're trying to do is eliminate all those bills. We want to know what the bundled price is right from the beginning before the patient has the procedure and hold the healthcare system accountable.
DavidAaron Powell And there's normative data on both the you mentioned on the quality, but is there also normative data on the pricing so that when a patient is looking at these various prices that come back to them, they understand where those prices are relative to the market or their their geographic area?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Well, yeah, there are companies that are doing this right now and that have developed normative pricing uh across the country. You know, but we we think that price is very plastic. We think of uh prices being very plastic both on the surgical end, the facility end, and the anesthesia end. If they have underutilized time, an empty Friday or a Friday afternoon that's free. What we're what we're finding is that these surgeons, these facilities are willing to drop their price to get that patient through the door and just became become more efficient. So we we think of price as very being very plastic week to week, month to month, case to case.
DavidAaron Powell Interesting. Now, I alluded to the fact earlier, currently, and this makes sense, you're you're working mostly or almost exclusively with partially self-funded plans. Are there any fully insured plans that are interested in having this kind of discussion about this kind of a service? Have you found those folks yet?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell We're certainly in conversations. No, we haven't found great interest yet, but there's certainly we certainly piqued their interest. And you know, when you have a large insurance carrier with a network of providers, it's a beautiful system to adopt within their network of providers if they're able to do it. So we've we've had this discussion with Blue Cross a few years ago. They love the whole idea. They just said that the infrastructural changes and the amount of capital needed to make those changes is prohibitive. So there is definitely interest. And I think this is the wave of the future.
DavidWhat kind of reaction are you getting from the initial physician, from the primary care physician, or from the initially referred specialist or surgeon? Are how are they reacting to this? Because as you mentioned, it's it's disruptive, and I guess depending on what chair you're sitting in, disruptive can also mean intrusive.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell The primary care physicians are loving it because now they've got a way of uh determining quality where they didn't have it before. Before they were referring patients to surgeons, they were on the basis of playing golf or their kids go to the same school. Now there's accountability. So the primary care doctors actually will embrace it and do embrace it. The surgeons initially, you know, anytime you disrupt the system, everybody takes a step backwards. Yeah, the older surgeons may not find this uh uh what they want to do, but the younger surgeons have certainly embraced the platform in a very big way. And they see an opportunity to get access to surgical patients right through their smartphone, as opposed to going through a hundred patients in the waiting room. So they see this as a very efficient system, uh a way of getting uh access to surgical patients that they never had.
DavidAaron Ross Powell Well, because we've talked about effectiveness, but we haven't talked a lot in the medical community about efficiency. And that's so that's an interesting wrinkle. Question for you. Uh we've got a few minutes left. And what kind of an impact does this kind of pricing have on cost? Because at the end of the day, for a plan, it's all about throughput and cost and unit cost and et cetera. What are the deltas that you're seeing?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell We did a pilot study with uh a large employer nationwide, and uh we bid out a bunch of cases, probably about 70 cases or so, and we found savings of $3,900 per procedure uh on average. And that is unbelievable. It's an unbelievable number. And that's even taking out a couple of the outliers they had from a surgery center uh where I won't tell you where, but was getting paid $140,000 and $170,000 for sinus surgery outpatient. So we we took those cases out. And even despite even taking those cases out of that of that pilot, uh, we found a savings of about $3,900 on average, which is unbelievable.
DavidThat that certainly is attention getting, there's no question. So in in the minute or so that we have left, we I always like to kind of wrap up with our guests and ask what they see the future looking like. You're at a place where you're being disruptive and intrusive, if you prefer that word. Where do you see the future of this going? How do you see it growing and the takeup and engagement and all of those pieces that you want and and and that you need?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the engagement on the provider end has been actually quite rapid. The engagement on the consumer end is gonna require some education. But once people get used to the idea of bidding out uh their surgeries, just like they look for a hotel online for a vacation spot, now there's services where you can do that, they will embrace it. And uh they're gonna like it very much because now they've got a way of validating uh surgical opinion, they've got a way of lowering their out-of-pocket costs, and in many cases, uh getting their deductible to vanish, which is really where our end goal is. So we think the future of healthcare is in marketplace competition, there's no question. And we can only speak to the surgical aspects of healthcare, but I I see marketplace competition entering into the MRI, um, into radiology, diagnostic radiology, you know, with uh physical therapy. I mean, I think it's just going to explode. It's just a matter of time.
DavidA great place to leave our interview on a hopeful note. Dr. Sanjay Prasad, founder and CEO at SurgiPrice. Sanjay, again, thank you for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_02Uh, thank you again, David, and I wish you the best uh with your endeavors. Uh really honored to be on the show. Thank you.
DavidOur pleasure, thank you. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.