The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #159: Helping Brokers Find a New Strategy – With Jeff Hogan
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On this episode of ShiftShapers, Jeff Hogan shares the innovative approach his company has used to deliver an engaging, modern, and consultative approach to employee benefits. At the core of this approach lies a focus on building strong partnerships with brokers to provide better options for employers and employees alike.
Jeff and his team encourage employers to view their benefits offerings like any other corporate asset. Once they’ve established this mindset, Jeff works closely with his brokers to bring them quarterly data and analytics about everything from core benefits to wellness and other benefit initiatives.
Jeff shares a practical example of this process in action and illustrates its financial and medical benefits. He also talks about the effects of the ACA on brokers and clients. Tune in to hear how you can adapt this model to your practice and bring greater value to clients while differentiating your agency.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- How Jeff and his team established themselves as top competitors in a challenging environment.
- What led to their “benefits as corporate asset” strategy.
- How they create unique partnerships with their brokers.
- Why simplicity and logic are sought-after qualities in an increasingly fragmented market.
- What steps they take to create long-term relationships with employers.
- The innovative steps they have taken to bring other relevant stakeholders into the equation.
How does a 65-year-old National Brokerage General Agency help insurance professionals to bring their clients an engaging, modern, and consultative approach to benefits? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. We're pleased to welcome Jeff Hogan, who's the Northeast Region Manager for Rogers Benefit Group to Shift Shapers this morning. Good morning, Jeff, and thanks for joining us.
SPEAKER_02Good morning, David. Thanks for having me.
DavidYou've faced some interesting challenges in your role over the last number of years, but I want to go back a little bit even further than that. Some of our listeners may not be familiar with Rogers Benefit Group, and it's kind of a different model. Could you give us kind of a three by five card view of Rogers and what you think makes Rogers different?
SPEAKER_02Sure, glad to. Rogers is uh based out of Minneapolis, has been around since uh 1947. It's unique in that John Rogers, the founder of the company, was able to put together an organization that pooled small group risk via relationships with unique brokers and consultants in geographic regions, those that had relationships with people in the hometown. So kind of a folksy roots genesis to the company, and it grew that way. Based upon relationships, we were able to pull groups together to spread risk. It was the first group health insurance trust in the country.
DavidNow you're headquartered just outside of Hartford, Connecticut, and Hartford is to a lot of people Insurance Town USA. When you began to build a presence for Rogers, Rogers hadn't had a presence prior to that. So how do you go into a marketplace that's so insurance saturated and start creating a name for yourselves and start attracting brokers?
SPEAKER_02So I moved to Connecticut about 20 years ago. I helped to open our Boston office. I actually grew up on Cape Cod, and the uh the Boston region is entirely different than the Connecticut region. When you come to Connecticut, it's uh much more provincial. There are insurance professionals. Basically, every neighbor is with an insurance company or a defense contractor. So it was uh it was a tough marketplace to come into. In fact, we entered the marketplace with only two small group medical carriers and not the carriers that we necessarily had to work with in the Boston marketplace. I decided that the best way to enter this marketplace was to take an activist approach or a paradigm shift approach. And literally the way that we worked our way into the marketplace was through the sale of non-med products, specifically disability products. We started with this notion to disturb our prospects, which were the brokers and consultants that we wanted to work with. And we went to the marketplace with this disturb the prospect notion. We would go out to a broker and tell them that basically any of their group disability coverage that was written in force was probably written incorrectly, that it used language that was inadequate and inappropriate. So we were able to show that disability coverage had been written in a commodity fashion. We taught all of our folks how to rip down a summary plan description and to prove to the brokers that they probably weren't appropriately covering their groups, and we worked our way into the middle marketplace. My practice focuses on groups between 50 and 500 lives. We've had tremendous success in that marketplace, and we were able to gain uh the full faith of the brokers that we still work with by taking this strategic approach into the marketplace, and we wrote a lot of disability.
DavidWell, you've talked a little bit about how you attracted the brokers and being disruptive and whatnot, but I know that one of the things that you've done from our conversations is that you've tried to also help employers see their health and benefit plans the same way they see their other corporate assets. How does that work in the sales environment and in the consultative environment? And how do you bring brokers into that process as well?
SPEAKER_02So that's a it's a great uh it's a great question. You know, traditionally the payers that work with agents and brokers do so in a very common fashion. Here's our products, here's what you can sell into the marketplace, here's the compensation. Instead, what we've tried to do is to take a very, very strategic and tactical approach, a three or four-year approach. I'll give an example of that. We we moved into the consumer-directed marketplace 12 or 13 years ago. It was uh quite frankly easy to do in this marketplace because Aetna, one of our larger carriers, just happened to really be positioning consumer-directed as the next coming. So we involved ourselves in that process. When the products came out, uh, when the relativities came out, when the collateral came out, we were able to uh gather that data and literally go out to agents and brokers and help them position these new consumer-directed products uh to their groups themselves. Almost 20% of our gross domestic product is for healthcare. So, really, the way that we were able to do that with the brokers and with the plan sponsors was to monetize the value and the cost of these plans. Curiously enough, we go through this facilitation process every year upon renewal, RFPs, and we worry about 16, 17, 18% increases. But we never think about what it actually costs to the employer, the fact that benefits often are the second largest expenditure that an employer makes. So instead, we go back and break down the actual cost of these things and try to find a way to control that cost via trend and single-digit increases. How do we do that? We've formed relationships with our payers so that on a quarterly basis we can secure real data about the group. Utilization, catastrophic claims, preventative usage, claim stratification, data that pertains to the financing of the plan. And what we do is to analyze that with the broker and go out to see the employer, the executives on a quarterly basis to convey that to them, much like an accountant or an attorney would.
DavidSo one of the things that it sounds like you've done, one of the shifts that you've shaped, is to try to use this seeing the health plan as their other corporate assets, and to try to approach the value proposition of that benefit that way as a way to decrease the commoditization that has kind of crept into our marketplace over the number of years. Is that a fair statement?
SPEAKER_02That's absolutely a fair statement. So we find that employers are particularly interested in this whole notion of financing their health plan once their health plan is benchmarked in relation to other health plans in the marketplace. So if we can show an employer that's in technology that what they're paying or investing into their health plan and other benefits is 20 or 30 percent higher than what their cohort may be investing, they want that information. They want to be benchmarked. If we can show them that they're underpaying or that they're paying too much toward dependents, their contribution strategies are inadequate or inappropriate, this is information that is extremely important to them. Again, the broker or consultant making themselves look like the firm's attorney or accountant. They rely on this information. In this new ACA environment, plan sponsors are desperate for uh strategy, tactics, information on compliance, and now on how to take risk appropriately so they they can manage their spend appropriately to keep their employees or to attract employees for that matter.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years experience working with healthcare and benefit clients, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solution, go to our website at www.captivated health.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. So to the brokers that you work with, it really isn't about product. It's about all of these other intangibles and tangibles that they can bring to the table. Product, it seems to me, from our conversation, is just the end product, the end result of all of the other consultative work that gets done up front.
SPEAKER_02That's correct. So the best way to categorize this marketplace right now, the healthcare marketplace in general, is that it has become extremely fragmented, inefficient, and complex. So as an activist, it becomes our role, as a broker, consultant, activist, it becomes our role to come in and bring simplicity, logic, and direction to the plan sponsor because they're craving it right now. There are so many agents and brokers in the marketplace that go into plan sponsors and dump on them with this complexity. And all it does is to scare them. It makes them think about ways to get rid of this quote-unquote liability instead of maintaining the asset that they have.
DavidCan you give our listeners kind of a practical example or a story where you can illustrate how this work might have fit with a particular employer and what the results were?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. We have an employer who's local to us that I'd refer to as a mini Google. It's a smaller group. It's under 100 employees, about 80 employees. It's a very proactive CEO, CFO, healthy guy. He'd invested in wellness plans in the past. However, he was finding it more and more difficult to attract programmers to his firm, even though it was a really neat place to work and kind of a beautiful place to work. He'd been using traditional copay plans on a fully insured basis. And basically, when we came in to see him, he gave us direction, which was to do whatever it took to engage his population of people so that we could literally scrap the wellness plan and do things with the employees that we couldn't with other groups. In this particular group, in the last year, we converted them to a narrow risk corridor, self-funded medical plan, basically that duplicated the fully insured plan that existed previously. Because the group was only about 80 employees, they had never received data or information about their utilization, their catastrophic claims, their demographic, disease process, uh comorbidities, and things of this nature. So it was really a guessing game. He was about to receive a 20% increase on his fully insured plan. We were able to go in with this narrow risk corridor self-funded medical plan and engage them directly. Out of the gate, it saved about $250,000. We were able to take the money that was being spent on the wellness plan, and we were, we noticed that one of the issues that the employees described was not having primary care physician access. So we we went to the largest PCP group in Connecticut because the employees were spread all over the state. And we were able to bring them in and get them primary care physician access to coordinate their care. We also brought in a concierge doctor's group for the uh executives who had been having some problems with access as well. A year out, we renewed the group. The group got money back because it ran so well and was so engaged that we achieved 86% preventative, which means everybody had 86% of the group had uh their physical exams and they were plugged into the system. Our feeling is that if we can achieve this, we get people into the system so that they don't use the emergency room as their doctor's office at $1,600 a visit, and we can achieve continuity of care. The old system with this group was to use biometric screening on a one-off basis without baseline, without continuity. That really wasn't a long-term strategic, there was no strategic end game for the group. So in our mind, in my mind, this is a really good example of what employers can do to get their plan under control, to manage it to single-digit increases and to engage the employees at the same time.
DavidNow, this also has a byproduct of repositioning or positioning the the broker in a very different light. Is this kind of a process approachable for any broker? Do you seek out particular types of broker relationships? And if somebody's not doing this kind of thing today, how do they shape that shift so that they can get into this kind of a process?
SPEAKER_02I've traditionally tried to stay away from persons who are strictly taking a commodity approach or I call it a milk bottle approach to the marketplace. The broker who has been successful here from a profile point of view is the broker who goes in and asks questions. The broker who can get to the CEO, the CFO, or the COO. I would say that our big paradigm shift back to consumer-directed healthcare 12 years ago was to find ways through the appropriate brokers to get beyond the uh HR director who was making these decisions. The key here is to get to the CEO, the CFO, and the COO. And it's hard, it's difficult, but brokers and consultants who are capable of doing this are the ones that will engage in relationships that are long-term and enduring. The one-year shot doesn't work with these brokers.
DavidNow, are the there's a cost, obviously, to all of the metrics and analytics that you do. Does that get passed on to the employer, or is it just simply a service that you offer as a value add? How do you handle that?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell So all the arrangements that we have with our carriers, we're basically outsource wholesale distribution for the carriers. So whether we're involved or not has no bearing on the premium or the cost. Our carriers rely upon us to do a good job and to make the business persistent. And uh that's really what we do. Our relationships are very, very strong with our carriers because of that, because they do see the value in the functions that we perform.
DavidNow you mentioned being in a post-ACA environment, and that certainly is where everybody finds themselves on the medical side these days. One of the things that's happened and has been in the news recently is a move to try to prohibit carriers from keeping the network skinny. That seems to be the consumer backlash or at least some of the conversation that's going on. I know there have been some states that have started to take legislative action to prohibit that. Have you seen that where you are? And also what are you doing to help your brokers and ultimately their clients realize a broader, more comprehensive network?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a great question. So the narrow network is inevitable. If we take a look at the larger health economy around us, as I was saying before, there's some significant activism, decentralization occurring or disruption that's occurring in the marketplace. Why? We have some really interesting things that are happening. We see ACOs being created out in the market, accountable care organizations, brick and mortar accountable care organizations, and then multi-specialty accountable care organizations, which will pay these large providers for having the infrastructure to exchange data appropriately, and will pay them for better cost and better quality. Again, hearkening back to the capitation days. Technology promises better outcomes and perhaps better compliance to watch these things. So we're seeing a battleground for many of the payers are actually buying large doctors' groups. We've seen that occur out in California and in other areas as well. In our own marketplace here, we've aligned ourselves closely with the largest uh primary care physician group in Connecticut. We actually have a broker advisory board that meets with this PCP group and its medical director on a quarterly basis to learn about ACO and the medical home and care coordination and all of the things that are occurring to increase the quality of care in the marketplace. So we feel that narrow networks are inevitable and even needed to create efficiencies in this marketplace. And plan sponsors are also very interested in direct-to-employer products that are being created by some of these provider groups in the marketplace. So whereas payers are trying to determine the appropriate partners to create efficiencies in economies, we're also seeing the providers themselves reach out to plan sponsors in the marketplace, trying to brand themselves in the marketplace. Other players, merchandisers, coming into the marketplace to offer services. Wall Street Journal three weeks ago featured a front page article about retail clinics and how popular they've become. Why? Because it's hard for someone who's working all day, who has a sore throat or an earache, to make it to their doctor who closed at five o'clock. People want this type of convenience and they're choosing alternative methods to secure their coverage. Back to your question specific to the neural networks. We will see them here by the end of this year. The carriers have told us that. We know that they're coming. We welcome them, and we do not see impediments to them coming to this market.
DavidAaron Powell We've got just about a minute left. I'm wondering, as you look into the near-term future, what are the shifts that you see coming and what are the approaches you might take to try to shape those shifts to keep your brokers active and in the marketplace and relevant?
SPEAKER_02It's a great question. I think the thing that brokers need to realize at this point is that the cost of ACA will be significant and palpable, and all employers are really looking for a way to take on risk themselves and to manage their own risk in the marketplace. So that brokers and consultants really need to embrace this opportunity to go to their plan sponsors and show them how to take risk appropriately. Incremental risks. There are a variety of hybrid products in the marketplace that will allow them to do this. And most importantly, will give the employer data about their own group that will help them to manage their own risk.
DavidThat's great. Jeff, I want to thank you so much for spending time with our Shift Shapers audience today and sharing some of your insights and the journey that you've taken to build a marketplace in your area and to bring some innovation to your brokers that they can use to differentiate themselves with their client base. Thank you again.