The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #158: How To Make Your Agency A Feared Competitor – with Kevin Trokey
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week on ShiftShapers, Kevin Trokey joins us to share strategies for building a market-competitive insurance agency. Kevin is a founding partner and coach at Q4Intelligence, a consulting firm dedicated to removing the barriers that keep independent benefits and insurance agencies from reaching their full potential.
Kevin reveals how his extensive experience as a broker and a principal helped him develop the firm’s unique approach. Kevin talks about a common mistake most agencies make: focusing their marketing on their own story, rather than that of the consumer. Consumers aren’t looking for you to look exactly like every other provider out there; they want to know which agency can creatively and efficiently help them solve their problems.
Kevin discusses importance of agencies becoming more competitive by realizing their true purpose – helping business owners achieve what they really want. He also addresses the role of increased employee engagement and improved collaboration between the service and sales parts of business in boosting overall agency success.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- How Kevin’s extensive experience as an agency principal helped him to develop his transformational methodology.
- Why the traditional website design of agencies can off-putting for consumers looking for a solution.
- The often self-imposed barriers that keep agencies from taking control of their business.
- The benefits of separating the product and consultative stages of the process.
- The necessity of building community amongst agencies.
How can agencies shape the shift needed to reenvision themselves and become feared competitors? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. In this episode of Shift Shapers, we're really privileged to be able to speak with Kevin Trocki of Q4 Intelligence. Kevin is one of the founding partners and a coach at Q4 Intelligence, or we may refer to it as Q4i because that's everybody shortens everything these days. Kevin, welcome to the podcast and thanks for being with us today. Well, thank you, David. Appreciate being here. Talk a little bit about your background, because you come to the place that you're at today by way of a pathway that I think most of our listeners will understand and appreciate.
SPEAKER_00Sure, sure, absolutely. And like probably so many of the listeners, David, I, you know, kind of happened into the industry, but thrilled that that did happen. I've I've spent my career in the industry about the last 20 plus years have been part of the industry and started off on the independent agency side. I've started off as an account manager at my first agencies, did that for about three years, and then went over to another local independent agency here in St. Louis and started there with the purpose of building a benefits practice in a property casualty agency. So had a chance to do some personal production, to grow that benefits practice uh along with uh some property casualty guys, built that department up into a nice revenue generating machine, and uh eventually had a chance to move into ownership of the agency, agency level leadership. And uh for the last four years that I was at that agency was was chief operating officer. And um had had a great run there. And as I as we work with agencies today, between me and my partner, I'm I'm able to say quite honestly, with the exception of the receptionist and somebody in finance and accounting, there's probably not a single role that we haven't filled somewhere along the way. Account manager, producer, department manager, you know, COO. So we think we have a great perspective of the challenges that that agencies are met with on a daily basis.
DavidAaron Powell Knowing your story as I do, I think that having played all of those roles probably is what brought you to realize that there was a shift happening. Talk a little bit about what you saw and and how you perceived that shift.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we uh we definitely felt that shift and were there early on. We you know, we understood that employers out there, they just need more help than what is able to be provided through a spreadsheet. And uh, you know, we understand the importance of that. We understand uh the need for brokers and and producers to take good advice around the insurance product, but we also saw very early on that that was just uh one piece of what employers really needed. And for us to be able to go out and meet those needs, we had to approach those employers with a different conversation. We had to help them understand the difference between making a decision on choosing a carrier and a product versus choosing the right broker who was going to be aligned with their goals, with their philosophies, and could be an instrumental part in doing that. So the shift for us when I was still in the agency star started with getting away from the spreadsheet. And in fact, we we did not want to be having a conversation with an employer if they were really within uh any kind of reasonable distance of the renewal time. That's a sacred time, and it's important decisions need to be made there. But that's the decision again about the carrier and the plan design, not the conversation about the broker. So we had to shift that conversation away to kind of mid-year and help them understand the importance and the relevance that the right broker and the right approach can bring to their business and help them make that decision first, choose the right broker, and then together go with a focused effort of choosing the carrier in the plan design at renewal time.
DavidAnd understanding that shift is what brought you to Q4i and to found Q4i and kind of informed the process that you go through. Now, today, who are your customers?
SPEAKER_00Our customers today are independent agencies and brokerages through throughout North America. And uh, when I say North America, that that does include Canada, even in light of the national health care that they have up there. Uh some of our most successful clients are those Canadian brokerages.
DavidYou talked some about the unintended consequences of traditional insurance agency marketing. And I think that's that's a keystone of what you're founded on. What does that mean, and how do you explain that when you go and and talk to a prospective client? How does that conversation go?
SPEAKER_00Well, the the unintended consequences of marketing, first off, uh, you know, true marketing, I think, is something that's really just starting to get the attention of independent brokers of our industry. And when we look at marketing, you know, one of the first places that you're gonna go look is you're gonna look at uh an agency website. And we get so frustrated, we go there and we see such consistent messages every time we go and and we look at an agency website. They want to talk about the decades that they've been in business, and they want to talk about all the significant milestones that they've reached along the way, and then the transitions of the agency. And you'll find that click here and get a free quote button, and here's all the carriers that we represent, and here's all the free stuff that we give away. And they are so focused on telling their story and their history that they miss what the prospect is really there for. The prospect really isn't there to learn the story or the history of that particular agency. They're there looking to figure out is there somebody that can help improve my story from the employer perspective. They go out searching not because they're they're curious about insurance agencies, they have some problem, they have some need, and they're out there actively looking for somebody that might be able to help address that need, bring better results to their business. And so one of the unintended consequences of the way so many agencies approach marketing through their website, we'll start with that, is they make themselves sound just like everybody else. They miss an opportunity to really uh communicate to that prospect why they should pick up the phone and call, or why they should send an email, or why they should consider taking a meeting. And that that becomes uh such a huge missed opportunity because they end up sounding like everybody else. They I think taking it, they they make an attempt to try to communicate value by saying, if you click here, we will give you a free quote. And I think that is just such a uh a misdirected attempt at delivering value because that is the one thing that makes every broker just like everybody else. And I think if somebody has come to your website looking for help, why would you encourage them to evaluate you on the one thing that makes you just like everybody else, reduced down to that spreadsheet? Yes, that's an important thing to be able to do, and you need to be able to do that very effectively, but first and foremost, get their attention, put front and center examples of how you have brought results to your existing clients. I think a great example is, you know, maybe, you know, we we we know of the stories where agencies have brought a strategic communication answer to a client. And because of that communication approach, the the clients of that employer, they they have more confidence in the decisions that they make around their benefits, they place higher value on the benefit program that's being provided. And that's the type of results that employers out there are looking for. And those are the type of stories that that brokers need to be putting front and center out there on their website, the things they need to be doing to share socially, the types of stories they need to bring into their sales conversation. But what we see is the unintended consequences is they reinforce the idea that I think most employers have out there and that all brokers are the same, that I should choose them based on a spreadsheet, and whoever can give me the most free stuff.
DavidDo those unintended consequences in some way create a barrier that precludes an agency from really taking control of their business?
SPEAKER_00I think absolutely. And you touch on a key piece right there, David, and and now more than ever before, agencies do have to take control of their business. We we sit back and you know, if if you were to talk to any typical entrepreneur who was interested in going out and starting a new business, and you say, David, you can go out, you you can start any business in any industry that you want, but I'm gonna put a couple limitations on you. You're gonna have to be dependent on somebody else's product, and you know, if they choose to change that product or increase the price of that product or choose a different distribution model, then you're gonna be vulnerable. That's one limitation I'm gonna put on you. The other limitation I'm gonna put on you is you don't control the revenue that you get paid. You're gonna depend on that third party to tell you what you're worth. Well, for most entrepreneurs considering going out and building a business and you know, the blood, the sweat, the tears that go into that, but if their hands were tied that tightly, I think they would struggle seeing that as being a good approach. Yet that's the very lack of control that agency after agency after agency has been built on. They their businesses are dependent on a third party's product, the the insurance carrier's product, and on their commission schedules. And right now, with the the transfer with what's going on in our industry, we're seeing the vulnerability of having built agencies without that type of control. And that does become one of the unintended consequences if they would just to step back from only focusing on one way of helping their clients, the insurance, as important as that still is. And if they were to take the blinders off and say, well, what is it that my customers really want? You know, most employers out there they don't get excited about going out and buying an insurance product. They look at it as something that they have to buy, that's part of doing business, that they understand that it's part of an answer to help them achieve what it is they really want. Given their drawers, they they would not buy the insurance, but because they are attempting to be seen as that employer of choice, they they want to have higher levels of employee morale and engagement. They want to be able to attract and retain the employees that are going to make them most successful, that's what every business owner wants. And if the brokers would say, my job is not to focus on the fact that they have to buy an insurance product as part of that answer, my job is to help them achieve that goal on as grand a scale as I possibly can. Step back and say, how can I help my clients achieve what it is they really want? Help them to be that employer of choice, help them to have higher levels of employee morale and engagement, attract the employees that they need to be successful. If more agencies and brokers would recognize that that's their real job to help their clients achieve what they want, they're gonna find lots of opportunities to truly take control of their business, both of what they sell, and at the same time, when you're helping a business owner achieve what it is they really want, they're gonna find themselves much more in control of their revenue stream. It might mean that they get paid on fees along with traditional commissions, but when they deliver that kind of value proposition, they'll have no problem getting business owners to write the check.
DavidAnd now, a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now, Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solutions, go to our website at www.captivated health.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. So we've talked a bunch kind of about the goals. Maybe we're kind of doing this a little bit inside out, but that's okay. What does the actual work look like when an agency approaches you and says, we'd like to engage, what is that process like?
SPEAKER_00Well, the first thing we do is we want to make sure that they're going to be a good fit. You know, so the the process that we go through, David, to figure out if an agency is a good fit. First off, there's there's three criteria that we look for in a prospective agency, and that is that they truly have a desire to change the way they bring value to their clients. They truly want to get away from that spreadsheet and then want to bring more meaningful value to their clients. We want to make sure that the agency has strong leadership in place, leadership that's going to lead by example, that doesn't look at this as something to join and have the producers go out and follow what it is that we prescribe. And the last thing is that they're willing to do the hard work because what we bring is it's not easy to go out and change your business model. So we need to be seeing organizations that are truly are willing to embrace that hardware. But once we believe that those pieces are in place, then you know what we bring to them is through our sales training and our coaching, we bring a process that helps them shift away from a spreadsheet and helps them become that more consultative model. That's really the core of what we bring to our member agencies is that sales process that allows them to go in, be consultative, figure out what is it that might be missing in terms of solutions or processes or results that are keeping their clients from achieving what it is they really want. And then around that process, instead of bringing a spreadsheet, bring a plan that says when you work with us as your broker, this is how we're going to help you become that employer of choice. And so that really becomes the core of the relationship between us and our clients, and it's from there that we help them add in the new solutions that they need to be bringing to their clients to help the service team work alongside the sales team and delivering that client experience. Help at the agency level to plan for their evolution more effectively.
DavidSome of those with some agencies, especially old-line agencies who are in the kind of we've always done it this way and we've been successful mode, those must be challenging conversations. Do you find that oftentimes there's a lot of friction or they're tough conversations to get through to get from point A to point B?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no doubt. You know, it's always hard to change how how you work, but what we help them see is that we're not taking the value that they've always brought and pushing that to the side and replacing it. We're still recognizing that the way they have always brought value is still a very important piece of what they're going to bring. But what we teach them is that they need to expand beyond that. So yes, you still, and and I think in in many ways, more today than ever before, their advice, their consultation around the insurance solutions is critical. I think employers really need that more today than they ever have before. But what we help them to see is that that's only part of the answer. That as they start to broaden the conversation that they take to their clients and to start to have conversations about how do you communicate that more effectively. How do we have conversations and start to bring solutions around employee engagement and attraction retention? So as we help them to see that we're not that that all we're looking to do is to take the value proposition and expand it, then you know that's where we start to get buy-in, and that's when they start to make the transition, is when they see their ability, and we provide the training and the coaching to help them continue to grow that value proposition. That's when the cool things happen. That's when we start to get calls back from producers who have just gone through the program and saying, you know what, I am finally having fun again doing what I'm doing. You know, I I have a predictable way to ensure that I deliver value to my clients. That becomes the validation that of us being on the right track, of helping them truly help their clients achieve what it is they're looking for.
DavidNow you've done something that I think is a little bit unique. You you've not only created all this great content in your program, but you've created community. Talk a little bit about that and talk about why you felt it was important to create that aspect of what you do at Q4i.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, I think the the community is critical because nobody wants to be taken on anything alone, especially times of crisis and types of challenge that we're going through as an industry. And I think all too often we have just these great agencies out there, but it's scary to be on your own. And especially when all of a sudden you're recognizing that that your very business is threatened, and it becomes an even scarier time. So we've created a sense of community of you know, our model is we you know, we're very selective about who we work with. We only want to be working with one agency in any given market, and it's it's critical for several reasons. And one goes directly to your question of community. We we bring these agencies together to share ideas, to share resources, to celebrate together, to, you know, maybe once in a while shed a tear together of the hard work that they're going through, but also to find inspiration and motivation and accountability from a non-competitive peer group. And uh, you know, that community, we we foster that community, we reinforce that community by by bringing them together a couple times a year to sit down and have a live conference event together to share ideas, to push one another and uh to reinforce that community. But we reinforce that community on a on a daily basis, on a monthly basis as we pull these these agencies together and coach them together and create an environment through our members site where they can ask questions of one another, provide answers, share documents, share materials, share success stories, and uh again help build that confidence and of I'm not there alone, and I've got other people who have similar goals, who are on a similar path, that together we're gonna be able to go a little bit further and we're definitely gonna be able to get there faster.
DavidKim, we've just got a minute or two left, and and I'm interested about your views of the future in in two areas. First, kind of the industry writ large, and and second of all, where you see practice models evolving, since that's the area that you're concentrated on.
SPEAKER_00Anyone that's heard me speak has has heard me reference uh the opening line to a tale of two cities. And uh, you know, a lot of people are gonna know that that their opening line is it's the best of times of work and it's the worst of times. And I think that's could not be there, I don't think there could be anything more descriptive, David, of where we are as an industry. It is scary times, and and some of the challenges we're facing, not everybody's gonna survive it. And we're seeing that happen through consolidation, through exiting on a daily basis. But it's also the best of times. I'm absolutely convinced the best time to be a broker, the best opportunities that have ever been presented to us are still out there in front of us. Those opportunities look different than they ever have before because the needs of our clients are different than they've ever been before. And because of that, the the way that we have to work is different than it's ever been before. And whoever is willing to embrace the fact that their clients need them to bring help in new ways, that's willing to do the hard work and change their model and the way that we engage our clients, they're gonna find the best opportunities are still out there. I think that there's gonna be a separation of the model within the industry. I think there's going to be one side of the industry that gravitates much more to the product, the commoditized side of it. I think that's gonna tend to be the national brokerage, maybe even competitors that are are gonna be new to the industry. Those that can invest heavily in technology, that can accept a low profit margin per transaction, but are gonna be able to drive the volume, I think, is one model. Where we absolutely see for the independent agency is gonna be much more on the consultative side. That they're going to recognize really what the model that we promote, and that is we have to be an advisor, we have to become much more of a consultant, we have to quit depending on a spreadsheet and a price and somebody else's product to grow our business. And we're gonna have to take control of that for ourselves, be able to have a sales process, a sales model, a client experience that focuses on our ability to help our clients, again, achieve what it is they really want. Help them to be that employer of choice. And uh, you know, I I keep using that phrase because I think we understand that every business owner has their varying definition of what that means, but I just use that as a way of saying that is what we have to be focused on. And when we do that, those that are willing to do the hard work, to make the change, and make the commitment to helping our clients achieve that, they're gonna find the greatest opportunities that they've ever experienced right out there in front of them.
DavidAnd a great place to leave our conversation for today. Kevin, thank you so much for spending time with the Shift Shapers audience. We look forward to speaking with you again.
SPEAKER_00Uh well, thank you, David. Appreciate it.
DavidThe Shift Shapers podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.