The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #156: Making Sense of Health Care and Washington - with Jessica Waltman - Part I
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On this episode of ShiftShapers, Jessica Waltman joins us for her quarterly visit. She’s an expert on all things legislative and a Principal at Forward Health Consulting. If the twists and turns on Capitol Hill have you scratching your head, Jessica will help you make sense of recent events.
The Republican led Congress and President Trump decided to pull legislation designed to reform the Affordable Care Act. Contrary to common media messages, this bill would not have repealed the ACA. As a reconciliation bill, it was inherently limited. No one really liked the bill and attempts at compromise continued to anger opposing factions in the House. Ultimately the bill was pulled. Elected leaders on both sides of Pennsylvania Avenue are now making efforts to revisit health care reform. The American public will have to stay tuned.
In this first of a two-part series, Jessica explains just why the reform attempt failed. She’ll shed light on what we can expect as lawmakers return to the drawing board. Should President Trump proceed as cautioned and just let the ACA implode? Jessica walks us through that approach and explains the regulatory steps that can be implemented now to make the ACA more responsive to market realities.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- What exactly happened with the Republican’s health care bill.
- Whether or not the effort was doomed to fail from the beginning.
- Regulatory reforms that can be made without legislative involvement.
- Whether the PPACA is actually imploding.
What the heck is going on with healthcare in Washington? What really just happened? What does it all mean? And where do we go from here? We'll find out on part one of this two-part episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Either paralyze us or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the chips in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chip transformation strategist, David Stoltzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement that helps small and mid-market companies escape the fully insured marketplace and delivers stability, control, and savings without watering down employees' benefits or increasing their premium share. If you have clients in the educational institution or the engineering vertical, go to our website at captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're going to enjoy our quarterly visit with our expert on all things legislative and regulatory. She's a principal at Forward Health Consulting, Jessica Waltman. Welcome back to the podcast.
SPEAKER_02Hi, David. It's great to talk with you again.
DavidAnd, you know, very timely. So let's start with an easy question because we're we're recording this on the 28th of March, and it'll air next week because we always try to air your episodes timely. What the heck just happened?
SPEAKER_02I know it's so funny you said that. I was just thinking, I listened to the NPR Politics podcast, and they always have people record the date and time, and then they say things may have changed by the time you hear this. And I think that that's a very apropos warning for what we're about to talk about, too. Crazy, right? So we're talking about this on Tuesday, and just as a refresher for anybody that's listening to this in the future, last Friday was the day that the Republican House leadership in President Trump decided to pull the American Health Care Act from congressional consideration. It was about to be voted on by the House of Representatives and then go over to the Senate. And the legislation was a budget reconciliation bill. So that means it was inherently very limited in its both text and construct. And it was supposed to, you know, it was being billed, I think, by a lot in the media. And, you know, people may have had the perception that it was the repeal and replace bill to the Affordable Care Act. It actually repealed very little and really didn't even truly repeal things, like things that it tried to get away from, like the individual mandate and the employer mandate. All it really did was zero out the penalties. It didn't actually strike those provisions from the books because that was the way that it had to be written to meet the constructs of the way that they were trying to pass it using the budget reconciliation process, which is like a really nerdy thing that it's it's hard to understand. But essentially it allows you to pass something without having to worry about the Senate filibuster. But it means that you have to follow very strict rules and it makes the whole process chancy, gives the Senate parliamentarian a lot of power, and it really, really limits what you can do. So they were trying to do this healthcare bill. It was inherently very limited, its construct was weird, and essentially the bill pleased no one. The House, some conservative House members did not like it because they felt like it really wasn't a true repeal and replace bill and it didn't go far enough in a lot of areas. It contained a lot of entitlement reforms relative to Medicaid that were kind of unrelated to the ACA, I mean, tangentially related. A lot of people did not like those. And then there were concessions made to some of the more conservative members of the House Republican caucus, and that aggravated some of the more moderate members of the House Republican caucus. And just basically it was kind of two steps forward, one step back every, or maybe it was one step forward, two steps back, I guess would be more apropos. Every time they tried to get, you know, win a vote here, they lost a vote over there, and they just did not have the votes to pass the legislation. No one really liked it. And so it was pulled. And then following that, on on Friday afternoon, both Speaker Ryan and President Trump spoke to the nation via press conferences. And they both said, you know, that this is it. We failed, we tried really hard, we came close, but we are not gonna be able to move forward on health reform, repeal and replace is dead for the time being. Obamacare is the law of the land. And we may move forward with other things, but in general, we're gonna we're gonna push forward with other issues. Then, of course, the weekend happens, and then Monday and today's Tuesday, and we had the you know, Sunday news shows, we had the news cycle spin, there was a lot of blaming, you know, what went wrong and why. And then Republicans on both sides, uh, you know, both sides of Pennsylvania Avenue began to change their tune a little bit. And President Trump said and had his spokespeople say quite a lot over the weekend that he wanted to work with Democrats and that he would move forward on health reform in some shape or form. And he talked a lot about being bipartisan. And then early this week, both yesterday and today, Speaker Ryan has talked to donors and other Republican leaders and has made some public statements saying that he too would like to move forward with health reform, but on a slightly different track. And they will be moving forward with other issues like tax reform and infrastructure, but they'll also be working on health care reform some other way, maybe more of a true repeal and replace effort, but that would require the votes of Democrats to stop a filibuster in the Senate. And he said he will lay out his plan about how to do that later this week. There's a Republican retreat this weekend. So I think we'll we'll see some more details then. So that's kind of where we are right now. It's a little, it's crazy.
DavidSo that's kind of where we are and what the future looks like. But I have a question. Let's dial the clock back. Was this first at bat destined to fail? I mean, if if you look at the campaign rhetoric, and I know Mario Cuomo once famously said that you campaign in poetry, but you govern in prose. So there is a difference. But with the campaign rhetoric, and then once it got into the House, the Republicans typically being messaging challenged, and first talking about, well, this is just the first of a three-part series, and then doing that god-awful PowerPoint that Speaker Ryan did. Was this first effort really doomed from the start? Did it ever really have a chance to get out of the box?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I would say I think it was doomed, and there was a number of issues with it. Personally, I think they did, and you you mentioned a three-part strategy, and so one of the things that they had planned was to do this bill through the budget reconciliation process, and it's very narrow constructs. They also want to do a lot of regulatory reforms, which is something that's completely within President Trump's power. And so that can continue on, and I believe will continue on. And then the third phase was other legislation that they kind of put out there to say, like kind of to be named later. Actually, the House has considered a number of small bills that they just, you know, had out there that that kind of get introduced regularly, and they they actually passed two of them. They have others that are in the committee structure that you would think might be part of a GOP phase three, and they were actually pointing to them and saying, look, we're already doing phase three. I personally would have probably started with another issue to kind of build some goodwill amongst Democrats, like maybe start with infrastructure. But then they decided to go right out of the gate with healthcare. And then they decided to go right out of the gate with this budget reconciliation process. And there were a lot of issues. Like you said, the messaging wasn't there. I don't think anyone, the American people, even probably a lot of people in Congress, understood the budget reconciliation process and the limits on the constructs. A lot of people said, oh, well, this is how President Obama actually passed the ACA. That's actually not true. Both the House and Senate spent, you know, over a year and they each passed their own two pieces of legislation. They passed comprehensive, long, you know, bills. I mean, the Senate bill is essentially the ACA we have today. Then they lost their filibuster-proof majority in the Senate before they could reconcile the two bills in a conference committee. And so what they did was they said to the House of Representatives, just sign off on the Senate bill. Just even though you don't completely like it, sign off on it. And then we'll use budget reconciliation to make what amendments we can, knowing that it's a really limited process to make it palatable for you. I mean, you Democrats in the House of Representatives back in 2010. And so when they use reconciliation, they were just using it to make limited amendments. To use reconciliation to make changes to a bill of that scope, it was just a crazy idea. And then not messaging it appropriately, not explaining what all the provisions were, not getting out in front of stakeholders, you know, building the coalition ahead of time. I mean, unfortunately, I think that that both the president and the leaders in Congress decided it was better to do it fast. And so hopefully now they'll they'll realize it's probably a little bit better to take some more time, build a coalition, and make some more thoughtful changes and use the processes. And there's a there's a bunch of different paths that they can take to make big change. I don't think agents and brokers and their employer and individual clients should worry. I think there will be changes made that will help improve the system. They just won't be as fast as maybe some have would have hoped.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects in the education and engineering verticals. The founders of Captivated Health have 35 years' experience working with healthcare and benefit clients, and over that time they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems mid-market clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace. Until now, Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems and does so with virtually no disruption to employees while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to your education and engineering clients that you advise. To learn more about Captivated Health Solution, go to our website at www.captivated health.com or click on our logo on the Shift Shapers website. So if the legislative process going forward is going to be kind of a longer, more drawn out, more deliberate process now that they've tried to rush something through initially, are we likely to see more changes on the regulatory side before we see another cut at something legislative? And and if so, what are the things that Dr. Price and his folks are going to be looking at that are within the realm of doing without having congressional approval?
SPEAKER_02Sure. So two things on that. One, I don't know that they these are things that can happen simultaneously. So yes, I think the regulatory items will move forward. I think they're already moving forward to some degree, and they'll continue to do so. And then the legislative stuff I'll speak to second, but that can kind of go on a parallel track, I think. But in terms of regulations, there's a lot that can be done. And there's, you know, sometimes I was just asked the question the other day. Well, do you think the Trump administration will actually do it? You know, over the weekend there was some talk about letting health reform blow up. And so maybe they won't take any regulatory action because they want to hasten its demise. I don't think that that's gonna really happen because there's parts of it to just keep the current system functioning in any way, shape, or form, including the good parts that they like. You have to do kind of consistent regulatory review, like there's things that expire and they're gonna have to address it. So there's regulations that come around every year that would be very, very hard for any administration to ignore. And I have known Dr. Price for a long time. He was a member of the Georgia State Senate before he came to Congress. And I actually had lobbied him and worked with him on some issues with our with the Georgia Association of Health Underwriters, going way back early in my career, and then knew him when he first came to Washington and you know, through his progression to secretary now. So that's kind of exciting. A lot of agents and brokers have a very strong relationship with Dr. Price. And he is a medical doctor. He's also a you know as a small business owner. So he really understands the role of agents and brokers. He was a state legislator, he worked with a lot of agents in the legislature too and in the Congress. So we're in a really good position there. So some of the things they're already working on market stabilization efforts. There's a regulation pending on that that they issued very early in the Trump presidency. And so we're waiting for finalization to help stabilize some things mostly in the individual, also in the small group market. I know that he is looking at, and the administration is looking at, some of the mandated benefits that come from health reform. And one of the more controversial provisions added to the AHCA at the end was something, or there was an attempt to try and add something to address essential health benefits. And there were questions about how much they could do. You know, the essential health benefits is a list of 10 benefits that are pretty basic. They're things like hospitalization, prescription drugs, maternity care that, you know, most health insurance policies people would want to have. I mean, you could argue a male might not want a policy that has maternity benefits in it. But you know, the list of essential health benefits is pretty, pretty general. Then there's also the preventive care mandates in the health perform law. They're a little bit more specific about benefits. But the implementation of those and how you know plans were required to cover the 10 essential health benefits in the individual and small group markets, and how large groups were required to cover those, you know, if without if they covered them, they weren't allowed to limit them. That was very discretionary on the part of the secretary. And so some of the things that made offering those plans a little bit more costly, perhaps, than they had to be, could be you know, turned back relative with regulation changes. Same thing with preventive care. So, you know, you could maybe say you have to cover a service, but the scope of how you cover it or how it's applied with cost sharing, how it interacts with the metal requirements, how you have to offer it, you know, for example, the offering of pediatric vision and dental, the mandates on carers on how they did that was kind of clunky, costly, maybe not the best for consumers. There's a lot there that you that could be gone in in terms of some other issues that are important to agents and brokers, the medical loss ratio regulation, not just relative to the treatment of commissions, but just what falls under the quality expenses in general. For example, fraud is really not considered to be a quality expense at the moment. And I know that if it were, that would be very helpful to rates overall. There's other things that could be done. Many technical details with the exchanges, you know, with requirements on deductibles, on cost sharing. There's just a ton there. Age rating, composite rating. There's lots of places where things could be tweaked. In the other agencies, there's regulations sitting out there. For example, the Obama administration proposed a massive overhaul to the Form 5500 filing process and also the scope of the Form 5500. They didn't finalize the rule before they left office. It's just sitting out there. The Trump administration could announce we're not going to finalize that. Or they could finalize it, make some clarifications and do it in a much, much more limited, more reasonable scope, which would be a huge win for businesses. The proposed rule would have extended that requirement, which now only applies to plans with 100 enrollees and up, to down to groups of two lives. So the Trump administration could say, we're not going to do that. They could go back and tweak other regulations that have been costly for businesses. You know, employer reporting was going to stay under the changes to the law that were proposed. It didn't go away, actually. And it's of course still staying right now. When those regulations come around to finalize those forms for next year and those instructions, there's a lot that could be done to make that process simpler. So those are the types of things that I am very hopeful the Trump administration will listen to employers, agents, and brokers and others in the industry and make tweaks that will make it all of our lives a little bit simpler and maybe a little bit more consumer and business friendly, a little bit more in tune to market realities. So I'm very hopeful will go on on the regulatory side in the coming months.
DavidWell, you you touched on something in your remarks, and it's something we've been hearing an awful lot out of, especially the White House. So I'll get your opinion. Is ACA, is PPACA imploding is the word they keep using, although sometimes they call it exploding. I hope they know that that means different things.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, as you and I know, and most people probably listening to this podcast realize that the ACA is enormous. And what is on referred to on the news as the ACA or Obamacare, usually the people are only talking about the individual market, and sometimes even only the individual exchange marketplace. So the reality is that in many, many geographic areas, many counties, there is only one issuer right now participating in the exchanges. And without this market stabilization rule being finalized and without any legislative action coming right away, there are health insurers right out there now that are very uncertain about the future. The Trump administration had proposed giving insurers until June to decide if they're gonna participate in the exchanges for next year. I'm gonna have to assume that that's gonna be the deadline. They can't make it too much later than that because you know everybody needs to file and get the products approved and get everything ready. So it gives them a little more time than the April deadlines they were looking at in years past. But I think they're gonna have to do a lot of work to convince issuers that the market's stable enough to commit to for another year and for 2018. But then there's the rest of the marketplace. You know, that when I say marketplace, I don't mean health insurance exchange marketplace, I mean the small group, the large group, you know, voluntary product, you know, all the other parts that that touch it, all the Medicare changes. That there's just so much in this law. So is every single bit of the law imploding? No. Has it made significant changes to the market? Of course. Are they all good? You know, some are good and some are bad. But what is really blowing up or has the potential to blow up and is very unstable, I think, is the individual market. And, you know, there's again a lot that a Trump administration could do on a regulatory side to kind of shore that up and provide stability.
DavidThe Shift Shapers podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.