The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #153: How Technology will Revolutionize Patient Care – with Samir Qamar – Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week, we continue our conversation with a pioneer and disruptor in direct primary care (DPC): Samir Qamar, M.D. Dr. Qamar is the founder and CEO of MedLion and MedWand. On this episode of Shiftshapers, Dr. Qamar shares his latest invention, which aims to take telemedicine to another level.
Telemedicine is a huge component of the direct primary care model. First generation telemedicine tools only allowed doctors to provide consultations because doctors weren’t able to examine patients. MedWand is a project that Dr. Qamar is working on that would launch telemedicine into the future. MedWand makes health care portable and interactive.
We talk about a brand new device that Dr. Qamar is bringing to market – a mouse-sized piece of technology that has the potential to revolutionize patients’ interactions with their physicians. This new technology will allow physicians to spend more appropriate time with clients. Tune into this insightful exploration of the new technologies being developed that will help extend our virtual interaction with our primary care providers.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Whether direct pay will take primary care/family medicine back to the era of the family doctor.
- The evolution of today’s telemedicine.
- Why the first generation of telemedicine wasn’t helpful for more than consultations.
- How accessible this technology is for consumers.
- Why frequent claims are an insurance killer.
- The other technology coming to market that will extend our electronic interaction with providers.
For some time now, telemedicine has allowed you to speak with a physician. How much more effective would it be if you could also transmit vital signs and other medical data with that conversation? We'll find out on this episode of Chip Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Chip Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the chips in their industry. Get ready to become the change that you want to study. You're your host and chip transformation strategist, David Salton.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is being brought to you by the NAHU Platinum Advisor Summit, an exclusive mastermind group where you and 20 to 25 of your peers can share ideas, brainstorm, and develop solutions that work in today's environment. To learn more, click the link on the ShiftChapersOnline.com webpage. And now, part two of our interview with Dr. Samir Kamar. One of the things that you mentioned early on was that in the fever service model, physicians have to pack their schedule, otherwise they have losses and wasted time. Using a direct primary care model, does that bring us kind of almost back to the old family doctor motif that perhaps a lot of even younger listeners?
SPEAKER_00I'm sure younger listeners won't remember. And so you're absolutely right, David. It's taking medical care back to the way it used to be. The only difference between now and say 1916 is that we charge a subscription now for that type of care, whereas back then it was fee for service at a much lower rate. The fee for service doesn't work anymore because of the way it has been exploited today. And so this almost you can call it capitation, except that the capitation now is limited to high-quality primary care and not to everything in the health program, as most who know capitation will remember it as. So yes, it is meant intentionally, by design, to go back to the way things used to be, where good old-fashioned primary care with your family doctor would result with better care.
DavidA few weeks ago, back in episode 83, we interviewed Dr. Eric Topel, and you may have read Eric's book called The Patient Will See You Now, and he talks an awful lot about the use of technology, especially revolving around smartphones and the ability to transmit data back and forth. One of the things that you've been working on, I know, is a project that's near and dear to your heart that will actually allow for physicians not only to spend more time, but to spend more appropriate time with clients, and that's called MedWand. Can you talk a little bit about how that is what that is and how that extends the initial model that you began working under?
SPEAKER_00Yes. What's interesting is as a doctor, when you don't have to see 40 patients a day, you actually have time to do productive things. And uh MedLion, as we talked about, was starting to grow. And we became very quickly the largest direct primary care provider in the country. We got a call from Google, the Google in California, and they were launching a new program called HelpOuts, which ran for less than a year, sometime a year ago. And on Help Outs, David, you could actually get a doctor to advise you on a medical issue, if needed, live by video. It was a telemedicine HIPAA compliant platform. And so they called us and said, Would you like to pilot with us in Nevada State? Since you're the largest direct primary care provider and you believe in telemedicine, because by the way, that's another big component of direct primary care is telemedicine. We actually can take the time now to speak to patients over video or over phone because we don't have to worry about the reimbursement issue. We said, sure, we'll pilot with you, and so we did. And very similar to our Skype chat this morning is the way it works. Is you basically have your video screen and you're speaking to your patient and you hear them and you can see them, and uh how you see them and visualize them is really directly proportional to the quality of the camera, if you will, on the patient's end. So that's what we did. And I was not impressed. To me, that's just simple video chat. There's been no change in video chat since the 1980s. It's technology that's very old, in fact, and just because you have a doctor on the other end and the conversation is encrypted to be uh privacy compliant, to me doesn't really amount to it being telemedicine. It's just video chat. I had no way of getting patient data. I had no way of examining them. I had no way of getting their vitals if there were a patient, because typically they would call when they needed medical services. And similar to David, the way you might be walking past my office and would give me a call and say, Sam, I'm not feeling well. I've been coughing a lot lately. By the way, I happen to be right near your office. If I have time and I care about you as your doctor, I'll ask you to come in. Because it's important for me to listen to your lungs. I want to know if you have a fever. I want to be able to measure that, get your blood pressure. I can't do any of that with a video chat. So I was perplexed with why telemedicine was getting all of this very strong investment attention in Silicon Valley and beyond when really it was nothing more than video chat with some provider. There had to be a way to get data, examine a patient. That to me would be telemedicine because today, otherwise, it's just tele. And so I set about looking for the tool that would allow me to examine a patient. And I couldn't find anything, David, that convinced me that uh this could be done on a on a massive scalable level. So I created something, I invented it myself. With my own two hands, I created something called the MedWand. And it's the sign of things to come, really. Telemedicine now is growing very quickly as an industry. I'm sure many of the benefits providers have heard of MD Live and Doctor on Demand and Teledoc, which just filed its IPO, because it allows employees to stay on the job when employers subscribe to that. However, you can't examine patients. I can tell you from the provider end, we are all a little bit cautious, sometimes overly cautious about examining a patient over the internet or over the phone because we can't get data. I wanted to change that. And so what Medwand does, it's a computer mouse sized device. While you and I are chatting over our televideo conference, I can actually examine you. It's on your end as the patient. And so I'll say, David, please put the Medwan up to your chest. And when you do that, I can actually listen to your lungs. It's like a stethoscope. There is a stethoscope in it. I can listen to your heart. I can listen to your heart valves, I can listen to your belly. We put a high definition camera in the end, so I can now look into your ear, nose, and throat. No more guesswork. We also put vitals data in there. If you put your finger into one of the crevices, I can get your pulse socks, I can get your heart rate, I can get both distal and core temperature, I can get your respiratory rate. And so when you have all these tools available to you in a very compact, easily usable device that's medical grade, it really gives the provider a lot of confidence and it really does take telemedicine to the next level where now, in addition to just consultations, you actually get a proper examination. That is what Medwan does, and uh we are currently in development at this time.
DavidSo it's like having a house call without having anybody knock on your door.
SPEAKER_00That's correct. In fact, there's a trademarked term that we have called a doc. The Medwan Doc stands for Digital On-Site Clinic. And as I'm sure a lot of the benefits professionals who are listening to this know, on-site clinics is a very popular component of healthcare, which is primarily reserved for larger employers that can afford that type of care. It's very expensive to hire physicians and the management folks who will take care of that and to pay for the clinic. It's a luxury that smaller businesses typically can't afford. With this, all you need is our Medwand dock station. And basically, it's a computer setup with biometric identification for employee to employee. And you set this up in some corner of your office where there's some privacy. You just need a shut door, really, for that. And you go and, as a patient, can be seen by a physician and get examined live while you're at work instead of just having to do a telemedicine visit that has no examination. So it really does make health care and urgent care, if you will, very portable, and you could pretty much do this anywhere. We have internet connectivity with this where you could carry it with you with your laptop, and if you're on an assignment out of town and you're in your hotel room and you're sick, you simply plug this in, and now you have instantaneous examination capability with your telemedicine provider. You could be on a plane and be examined that way. That is coming soon. Uh you could be on a ship. We examined a patient from London, England a few months ago, all the way in Texas. So it can be done in countries that are remotely located, whether it's villages or even industrialized countries that may want American expertise for healthcare. So many applications because we've just all of a sudden erased all the borders with being able to be examined. Borders both locally and internationally.
DavidInteresting question. I'm sure that's something you've contemplated years ago. Major hotels at least had house doctors, so that if a guest got sick, they had a way to diagnose them and then get them to the appropriate treatment. Do you foresee a time when, for example, this will be so ubiquitous that hotels might have one to say this is what we're using instead of having our house doctor as the first line of defense?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I think technology as a rule advances society. When it's technology that can be used, that cuts down labor, if you will, especially. In that case that you mentioned, I myself was the house doctor for Pebble Beach Resorts. I was asked just to do that. I would get a call from the resorts and they would say, Dr. Kmart, there's a patient who's sick in room so-and-so who has so-and-so. Would you mind coming out for a visit? And I'd get in my car with my doctor's bag and my toolkit and drive all the way over there and do that. I also did that, by the way, for my elderly patients. When Med1 comes out next year, there is no reason why that same hotel couldn't have one of these in the patient room and say, Doctor on Demand is one of our telemedicine providers. Why don't you kindly use the Medwan that's in your hotel room, plug it into your computer, or we can provide you with one and be examined right there on the spot. So that will happen. And in fact, we're already starting to get orders now from consumer-based entities, employers especially, who want to keep employees on the job by offering these type of on-site, uh, digital on-site clinic capabilities.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Industry change is accelerating. Every aspect of our business is in flux, and yesterday's answers just don't cut it. Change is making our jobs more difficult and our success less predictable, and no one of us has all the answers. That's why NAHU created the Platinum Advisor Summit. There are three Platinum Advisor groups that each meet twice a year. Our next sessions are in early April in Washington, and we'll meet again in Chicago in August. Coaches Karen Kirkpatrick, Kevin Trockey, and I enable you to share ideas, brainstorm, and find new solutions that help lead to success in today's environment. What do we discuss? Pipeline development, selling techniques, handling objectives, marketing, branding, time management, presentation skills, new solutions, stewardship, compensation strategies, and much, much more. Who's in the room? Agency principals, producers from independent agencies and national brokerages, former NAHU presidents, past broker of the year recipients, and producers who are developing strategies for unparalleled success. Where else can you discuss your challenges and have the opportunity for feedback and advice from a room full of professionals with such diverse backgrounds and perspectives? To learn more, click on the link on the right side of the ShipshaversOnline.com website or download the application form from the link right beneath the notes for this episode. Space is limited, so apply today. Now, back to our interview. Once you scale up, do you believe the pricing for this device will be in a realm where it's accessible to mere mortals, or is it going to be? I know there were some early experiments, Virgin Life Care had kiosks years ago that they put into employers' offices, and it was a huge upfront spend. Where do you think this will shake out in terms of accessibility?
SPEAKER_00Sure, we can tell you exactly where it's going to be. We've already done the financial modeling. So one of the things I did not like about kiosks were they were not portable, uh, they were definitely not affordable for most people, number one. Number two, I also didn't like the fact that regular people can't use kiosks in their homes. I think a lot of people when they're sick would rather not go into work to use the kiosks. They would rather be in their pajamas at home and get care from home. So I wanted to create something that could be used in the home environment as well. I can tell you exactly how much we cost. So the Med Wand device alone, if you were to buy one for your home, is going to run you around $250. That's with all the components made here in the US. Our labs are here in the US, and we use the best Silicon Valley technology companies, uh, their components and their help to get this made together. For employers, we actually have a very robust system. It includes several Medwands, in fact. It has the video conferencing video monitors and has the portable tablets, which you can take with you off-site, biometric identifiers like we talked about, and all that goes for $3,200, a one-time cost. You're done once you pay that. And so we've priced it at a level where we think it's much more affordable than the kiosks that you might find today, the telemedicine carts and so forth, with the exact same, if not more, examination capabilities.
DavidThat's very, very fascinating because that really will make it easily accessible to pretty much anybody. And so one of the things that we talk about a lot, and uh as as we're talking about how this is going to be so ubiquitous and so easy to use and so portable, one of the things that I know is on everybody's mind is data security. If you've got this kind of a device and it is so portable, how do you make sure that all of the data that you're collecting is both secure and accessible in a way that's meaningful for the physician and also perhaps meaningful for the individual?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So a two-part question. One is security, the second is the meaningful use of data and the accessibility. From a security standpoint, that was something that uh we were aware of from day one. Medwan isn't that old of a project. We started on this about a year and a half ago, right in the middle of times when huge data breaches were occurring and a lot of hacktivists, as I call them, were sort of wreaking havoc on the world. So we we knew from day one that we would have to do something airtight when it came to security. After all, this is medical data. So we don't believe that HIPAA security is even tight enough. We went to military grade encryption, and we have several layers of military grade encryption for the data that's flowing. That's number one. Number two, the data that is actually flowing is real-time data. It's it's audio, it's and not the audio I'm referring to of perhaps the patient on the doctor speaking, it's the audio of the heartbeat of what I'm hearing, of uh the video, uh, of the snapshots that are taken of the eardrum or the throat uh or or of the skin. And that data has to be translated. And so that the translation of that data is what I would consider would be more valuable to someone who would want to break in and steal anything. We've also secured against that. So there are many facets involved in this. And in fact, we we were also at the Pentagon last year speaking to them because they're interested in our technology, and I can assure you security is extremely important to them as it is to us as consumers. So that's the level we've taken this to in terms of accessibility of data. I didn't want to create something that would be difficult for providers to use, uh, nor for consumers. Not just from a practical standpoint from using the device itself, but also from a data standpoint. One of the problems, David, that I've seen today with electronic medical record systems is that in this capitalistic environment, every EMR company was born to make a profit, which is fine. Unfortunately, none of those EMR systems talk to each other. So you're sort of stuck if you're a doctor with a certain healthcare system and want to get records from another healthcare system. It takes days, if not weeks, sometimes to integrate that. I did not want that to happen with MedWand because currently this is the only such device that's available in the US. So we knew that many different telemedicine companies would want to use this. We knew that it would have to be integrated into many different EMR systems. And the goal was to create an open API that we could have hooks then for you to grab specific data pieces securely if you would need them. And so to answer that question, we have made it extremely accessible for the entities that want to work with us in terms of getting the data that they would like for their own needs. When it comes to insurance companies, they'll be able to extract the data that they want. When it comes to consumers, they'll be able to extract the data that they want. It's going to be very easy and protected, and of course, nothing is done without the patient's consent. Everything is done in HIPAA-compliant fashion.
DavidIn the couple of minutes that we've got left, two quick questions. First of all, um, when we talked to Dr. Topel, one of the things that he talked about was a wide variety of remote sensors and gadgets, for lack of a better word, that are coming to market. I'm reminded of Google, I think it is, is piloting a contact lens that transmits glucose levels for diabetics and other conditions. If I'm in a home of the future and I've got a bunch of these different devices, can those connect to the Med One system?
SPEAKER_00Yes. So we actually already built that into it. There's Bluetooth connectivity to ingest data from other types of devices. That is already happening. I'm a big fan of Dr. Eric Topal's view on gadgets and medical devices. One of the challenges that I think we face as a society is not just the ability to extract that data and own it, that medical data. It's what we do once we get it. That's very important. If you were able to get all sorts of EKG data, that's great. Now, number one, it would have to be translated into something that you could understand. Very important and difficult for folks who have not been trained in medicine to know what a particular atrial rhythm means, for instance. Number two is once you do understand what it is, and maybe even understand its implications, and if there's some type of threat, how does that information, how does that data get transmitted in meaningful ways to a provider who is incentivized to do something about the data that you have collected as well? And that is where I see a huge chasm currently that there are very few solutions for. If you were to go with all of your Fitbit data and put that on the desk of your doctor today, the average doctor, they wouldn't know what to do with it. They don't like to see pages and pages of volumes of data. It's fun for the scientist, it's fun for folks like me and Dr. Topal and even consumers who want to know what they're getting, but again, it means nothing if you can't apply that into practical application. So I think you're going to start seeing companies come up, and it's already happening, that are gonna take your data or Medwan's data and aggregate that into meaningful ways and then push that to providers in meaningful fashion for some direct type of clinical impact. That is starting to happen as well. I also envision one day, and um, this is something that I think is gonna come not with necessarily Medwan, but I'm already thinking of other ideas. You're going to have invisible devices that you'll wear on your person that will continuously monitor your vitals or some type of health parameter and then call you. I envision something that you'll be wearing which will not be seen to the world. It won't be obtrusive to your life. It can be something as simple as putting a sensor on the ends of your glasses, for instance. And it will send you a call. Maybe you'll get a call. It'll say, David, something's wrong with your heart rhythm at this time. Please contact your medical authorities immediately. That's all you need, is you need a warning while you're being monitored silently. I think that time is coming, and it's all going to be automated very soon. And that gets me pretty excited. I think once you have that and you put the power of care into the consumer's hands, you as the consumer will then make the decision to contact medical authorities because you'll have the power with that knowledge. And uh that I think is a very exciting time. So MedWuan is also starting to tread on that territory as well.
DavidA great place to wrap up our discussion. I wish we had more time. Please come back again. Dr. Samir Kamar, founder of and CEO of both MedLion and MedWon. Sam, thank you so much for spending time with the Shift Shapers audience today.
SPEAKER_00It was a pleasure. Thank you very much, David.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.