The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #146: The Evolution of Consumerism in Healthcare with John Park
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week on the ShiftShapers podcast, we speak with John Park – Chief Strategy Officer at Alegeus. As the Trump administration transitions to power in Washington, there have already been serious signals in the consumer-directed marketplace. John shares his views of how consumerism in healthcare may change and how that will impact the future of healthcare services.
Incorporating and driving more individual responsibility in health care decision-making is at the heart of the consumerism movement. We explore two elements of modern healthcare consumerism and trends that are changing the marketplace.
We also discuss the existing tools that are changing to help the consumerism evolve. We learn that while tools are an important part of helping to build consumerism confidence, there are some challenges as well. We’ll talk about both areas and look at how current products, services, and software innovations are trying to address the concerns.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- An explanation of what consumerism in healthcare means.
- Current trends and predictions regarding the future of HSAs and HRAs.
- Healthcare tools that consumers are currently requesting.
- The opportunities for advisors in the HSA environment.
- Whether employees with high deductible plans forego needed care and the impact of that behavior on future healthcare costs.
- How plans can incentives consumerism with employees once plan maximums have been exhausted.
- The importance of data and benchmarking in assessing plan efficacy.
With a new administration in Washington that appears to be more favorable towards consumerism in healthcare, what are some of the likely changes advisors should focus on? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzmith.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with John Park. John is the Chief Strategy Officer at Allegis. We're recording this just prior to President elect Trump's inauguration, but there have already been some serious signals in the healthcare direction and specifically in the consumer directed area and some of the tools and techniques that we use in that marketplace. So with that, John, welcome. I I thought we'd we'd maybe start by level setting the conversation about what does consumerism in healthcare actually mean?
SPEAKER_02Good morning, David, and thanks for having me on the podcast here. That's a great question. I think we've been, as a country, as an industry, really trying to understand how to define consumerism in healthcare. And I'm going to take us back kind of since in the beginning of when we started to incorporate this idea or concept of consumerism in healthcare. But really what it's about is about incorporating and driving more individual responsibility in the healthcare decision-making process. And in order to do that, we believe that at that time, there are two elements to that equation. The first part is creating a benefit which promotes financial responsibility, more accountability financially around the costs of healthcare. And we did that through benefit plan designs, things like high deductible health plans with health reimbursement arrangements, HRAs, or our high deductible health plans with HSA's health savings accounts. And from the early days of the creation of HSAs, it was really the idea of promoting a benefit plan that drove personal and individual responsibility of healthcare decision making. So that was one element of consumerism. The second part of consumerism really is about, okay, now that you've given the individual all this financial responsibility, you have to give them the right tools and information to help them make better decisions about their healthcare. And so those two elements together really promote what I would consider to be more individual responsibility and decision-making power, and empowering that individual to be a consumer to help them make better decisions. And the result of bringing these two elements together, we believed at the time, in the early days of consumerism, would really promote and drive better health, better decisions, and more value-conscious consumers when it comes to healthcare. And that was kind of the premise behind and the creation of these benefit plans. And I think we are, I want to say close to 20 years now into introducing this type of plan design. And we're starting to see the results and really getting the adoption that's needed in order to really change the marketplace. So that's kind of the way that we looked at consumerism in the early days. How people have incorporated those principles in the marketplace today may be a little bit different, but I think that was kind of the original intent.
DavidYou mentioned that part of the equation is to make sure that consumers have the tools that they need. What do you see as having been over the 20 years or even more recently as the consumerism movement has evolved, the most effective tools for employees to have at their disposal?
SPEAKER_02You know, that's a great question. And it really depends on the decisions that a consumer is trying to make. So I think the first line of tools that that's required is providing information at the point of enrollment when someone's trying to understand which benefit to select, which plan, health plan to go with, giving them the right information and tools to understand how to make that decision. I think we all are familiar with the early days and saying, well, if your providers in the network, that was kind of the primary decision-making process of selecting a benefit. But the first part of this is really trying to help consumers understand what their benefit covers and what it doesn't cover. You know, in a survey that I saw recently, I think we saw something like 45% of the folks that we surveyed didn't understand what was even covered by their insurance plan. And so that's a fundamental problem. When you don't understand what your insurance policy covers, it's very difficult to really understand how to navigate the healthcare system. So I think the first part is really about understanding your benefit and giving people the right information and tools to help them. And what we're finding is that in the early stages of change of a benefit plan, a lot of folks turn to the eight, they're HR folks, they turn to their peers in their office and say, What did you pick? Why did you pick that plan? But we have to give them the right tools that are relevant and personalized to their situation because obviously the decision-making process for somebody who's single, in their 20s, and healthy is going to be much different than somebody who has a family, has two kids, and is dealing with a chronic illness. And so giving information at the right point, at the right moment of truth is what's really critical in helping consumers make better decisions. So that there's the enrollment decision around understanding your benefits. There's also an element of understanding what resources are available to you and how to make what I would consider to be more of a consumer trade-off decision. So cost and quality, which the trade-off there is really about establishing the best value. And it's very difficult because it for so long we've masked the true cost of healthcare to the individual. The insurance plans have really kept the individual away from having to understand. And we've implemented benefit designs with copay. So they believe that just going to your primary care physician is a $25 copay. And in reality, you know, the cost of that encounter is much higher. And so the next line of defense is really to get individuals to understand their true cost of healthcare and what types of services and options they have to make decisions about which channel to go to. So I think if I were to look at the in the past 20 years, I think we've done a very good job at incorporating and helping educate around the healthcare benefits, but we have a long way to go. As it relates to the cost of healthcare services, that's one of the areas where I feel like there's a little bit of a disconnect. I think even though there's more information available to the consumer than ever before about cost and quality of the doctors that they're going to, very few are actually exercising a decision-making process that leverages that information. So right now it's just information, it's not actionable. And until we get to the point where it becomes actionable, I think that's when we'll start seeing the real value of that type of information, cost and quality relative to the doctors and the hospitals that consumers are going to.
DavidWell, and there's another concern too. And I'm interested in your thoughts about how you get consumers past this notion. In a lot of other aspects of their consumer life, the highest price is the best quality. And especially with facilities-related charges in healthcare, that's often not the case. How do we help educate people about that?
SPEAKER_02That's an interesting dynamic because there is this perceived or inherent idea of brand associated with care delivery. So if you think about it, the Mail Clinic, Johns Hopkins, Cleveland Clinic, they all have very good reputations. But if you dig into the next layer of healthcare services, there are certain services that the Cleveland Clinic excels at and is the best hospital in the nation, but there are other procedures where they're not in the top tier. And so it becomes very difficult as a consumer to really navigate that. And they really need the help of uh professionals to help them understand how to work through that information. So it really depends on uh the type of services that an individual goes through. And to your point, the first step is understanding the cost. There's this perception that higher cost equals higher quality, but in the healthcare space that isn't necessarily the case. So the first line is to truly understand the cost. And then we have to simplify how we look at quality in the market. And for a consumer, quality can be defined as many different things. And so we need to help simplify what that means. And I'll give you an example. When I'm looking for a primary care physician, quality may mean they have very good bedside manner. I can relate to that individual, that doctor actually understands my personal situation. I've been going to this doctor for 10 years. That is a definition of quality that I would look at for personally as a for a primary care physician. If I'm having heart surgery, I don't necessarily care about those same metrics. I probably I want to look at success rates. I want to look at the number of procedures that the that the surgeon has gone through. So quality can mean something very different when it comes to the situation and the type of physician you're you're talking to. And so right now, like I like I mentioned earlier, there's a lot of information, a lot of data. We have to figure out how to make that relevant to the individual and their current situation.
DavidSo let's go back to some of the tools and techniques. And obviously, as you mentioned, the king of those is HSA's HRAs. We know from the early drum beats that we've got an administration and certainly an HHS secretary designate who are HSA friendly. What changes do you expect to see in either or both of those two plans?
SPEAKER_02There's been a lot of conversation discussion. And first of all, just so everyone understands it, you know, HSAs have been around for a long time. In fact, I was one of the early adopters with the Archer MSAs, which stood for medical savings accounts back in 97. It was kind of the pilot program before health savings accounts came to the marketplace. And what's really interesting is there's been ongoing changes and improvements to how HSAs work. And HRAs were a different account type, but really had the same intent, which was again creating that benefit design that promoted more individual accountability. There have been suggestions around HSAs, specifically around HSAs, where there may be opportunities for that market to grow. So even before the election, we we saw the marketplace growing at a significant rate, you know, 20 plus percent as are related to these account-based plans. HSAs were gaining the most traction, and the properties of HSAs were a little bit different than HRAs, but HRAs are still a very viable account type to promote the same type of benefit design. As it relates to HSAs, you know, what we're hearing and what we're seeing in the market are some possible potential accelerators for growth and things like an increased consumer base. So expanding HSA availability to state and federal programs, things like Medicaid, Veterans Affairs, and really kind of promoting the concept of an HSA to a broader population, not just the commercial population. There are conversations, discussions happening around expanding the contribution levels for HSA. So right now, the contribution levels for an HSA for an individual is $3,400 or self, and then for a family, it's $6,750. And there are some discussions around increasing the limits of the contribution so an individual can contribute up to the out-of-pocket maximum that may have with their high deductible health plan, which will expand it from $3,400 to $6,550. So there are elements to the proposals that what we're hearing that will really be an accelerator to HSAs. And there will be other things that come into play, things like the regulatory restrictions, Cadillac tax, excise tax is one of those topics. And then there will be other things that we will look for, things that make it more consumer-friendly, things like being able to pay for premiums from your HSA, which you can't do today. There is a restriction on that. And I think at the end of the day, what we can agree to is that the things that happen with L Savings Accounts, it will be it will accelerate the growth and adoption of the accounts themselves.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. A couple of the things that we hear frequently about high deductible health care plans, and there are a couple of criticisms I know they're going to start coming up as we go into whatever national healthcare 2.0 is all of are first that with a high deductible plan, there are some employees, even with a spending account, who put off care because they don't want to spend the money in the spending account, or if they don't have a spending account, they put off care because they don't have the money to come up with the deductibles and the co-pays. And the second part of the question is that's always asked is what is the incentive for someone to act like a consumer once they've maxed out their out of pocket? What are your thoughts on both of those?
SPEAKER_02Those are interesting dynamics because we've been dealing with that since the early stages of CDH. And I will I will um comment on the first piece. The first piece around for delaying care or foregoing care that they should be getting, the health plans recognize this as being a problem, and this was not a good dynamic. And what they started to do is incorporate certain elements in the policy that said, even though you're in a high deductible health plan, all preventive care or uh well-woman visits or standard routine checkups, those preventive care services would be covered at 100% and wouldn't fall under that deductible. So it did promote the ongoing care that people should be getting and to eliminate that dynamic of people foregoing care. As it relates to some of the other behaviors of consumers, the the behavior is not to say I'm not going to go to the doctor or not going to go to get care if you have a sickness or an illness. It was really to find the best channel that met their needs and recognizing that there are costs associated with it. For instance, does it make sense for me to go to the emergency room, which we know is the highest channel for a consumer and for the industry, versus going to urgent care? Or even nowadays, you know, what we're starting to see is consumers are starting to look at those types of elements because of that financial responsibility. And there are other channels that are becoming more available, things like telemedicine. We're starting to see the increased uh usage and utilization of telemedicine. In a lot of cases, think about your own personal experiences. If you had an incident where your child was sick on a Sunday evening and the urgent care center was closed, your only option was really to go to the emergency room if you were concerned. Even if you just wanted to speak to a doctor about the situation. Now you have other channels and other avenues that you can go through, nurse lines, you know, that triage the situations, telemedicine where you can get on a mobile device and be able to chat with a physician, whether that's through video, Skype, or just through the phone. So there's so many different options that are now available. And I think that is really being driven by some of the positives of consumerism, which is consumers want options to access care and speak to a doctor and find lower cost options. And so we're seeing positives as well as concerns. And so that was, I think, the some of the things that we've adjusted for, given the concerns around consumerism and high deductible health plans. Uh, David, you had a second part of your question.
DavidUm, could you repeat? Yeah, once somebody maxes out their out-of-pocket, what is their incentive to act to continue to act like a consumer?
SPEAKER_02Well, well, most plan designs still incorporate some level of coinsurance after the deductible is met. The question still is applicable, though. So once you hit your out-of-pocket max for the year, then what what's the incentive? I think the incentive is not about a financial incentive at that point. It's really about getting more value for your dollar and maximizing the value that you have. And what we found, and there are a couple of health plans that have some really good studies on this, what they found is even after the deductible, consumers still exhibited the behaviors that they were looking for. And so it doesn't change all of a sudden once you hit your deductible. What they're finding is that consumers, once they've kind of established this idea of financial responsibility, that carries over even though you've hit your deductible. And there are certain elements that what we're finding is there are behaviors that consumers are exhibiting, positive behaviors, consumers that are that have been in these high deductible health plans versus consumers that aren't in those types of benefit designs. And those are the things that we like to promote. And you know, there will always be those instances where people will maximize the value of their benefit by changing their behavior once their deductible is met. We can't, we're not going to stop that. But I think the early indications in the studies that we've seen, at least from a trending perspective over the last few years, is that people aren't doing that. And that's a positive thing. I think that's a good thing for the industry.
DavidWe've got just a couple of minutes left, John. And I'd be remiss if I didn't talk about something that advisors are talking about a lot, which is the importance of data. And the piece that doesn't get discussed so much is the importance of benchmarking. It's great to have data, it's great to be able to analyze the data, but if you can't normalize it to some mean, it becomes problematic to actually advise clients. What's coming in terms of benchmarking? What are you guys seeing?
SPEAKER_02Well, I'll make it relevant to the consumers in space. I think the benchmarking that we're starting to incorporate in and that we're seeing is now that we have good data is to understand how to contribute to these accounts and take full advantage of the efficiencies that things like HSAs provide. And that's a perfect example. The benchmarking data that we have now can really identify for an individual in your current situation with your income level, with your risk tolerance, um, trying to understand how much should I be contributing into these accounts. I've seen tools that are available out there that kind of help the consumer make that decision during the enrollment process to say, what's the right contribution level for me? It's also providing the analytics and the tools, leveraging the data sets that we have now to be able to say, in the following year, to say you may want to consider contributing more to your HSA for these reasons. Here's a value to you, here's a benefit to you. And it's not just about their financial situation, it's also about their healthcare situation. So it's incorporating not just benchmarking data on the financial side, but it's also benchmarking data from the healthcare side. And when those two things come together, that's when you're really going to get relevant and powerful tools to help consumers make those decisions. The first piece is, in my opinion, on the benchmarking side, is really trying to identify like what's the best way to get the most value for your dollar and for a consumer. And if you think about all the decision points a consumer has to make, traditionally they've made them in what I would consider to be silos. Um, I make my healthcare decision, then I make my 401k decision, then I make my ancillary life insurance decisions around my benefits on an annual basis. I think what we're starting to see is there's competition for that dollar. And we recognize that not all individuals have the financial means to be able to fund all elements of their benefits. So we're trying to help them with benchmarking data to find the best way to leverage the benefit dollars that are being provided to them. And part of that is the HSA investment, part of it is the retirement investment. And some of those things are starting to blur together. So we're starting to see HSAs and 401k contributions starting to blur, and consumers are recognizing that there are efficiencies to both, and there are pros and cons. So that would be kind of my view of the benchmarking data that we'll be seeing starting to see in the marketplace.
DavidA great place to put a pause on our discussion. I won't say end it because we'd love to have you back and chat more about this stuff. John Park, Chief Strategy Officer at Allegias. John, thank you so much for spending time with the Shift Shapers audience. Thanks, David. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.