The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #143: Shifting from Commissions to Fees – With Mike Grinnell and Kirsten Tudman
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Commission compression is causing advisors to rethink their business model – especially looking a few years out. One option is to shift to a more consultative fee-based motif. Our guests, Mike Grinnell and Kirsten Tudman of CPI-HR, are among the handful of advisors at the forefront of this shift.
They join us today to discuss the impetus for the change as well as some lessons learned along the way. They also take us through what the employer conversation sounds like and what kind of questions and objections advisors can expect. We also explore some of the current state regulatory barriers and how those might change. Listen in to learn more and to kickstart the fee-based discussion in your practice or agency.
All of us at ShiftShapers thank you for you continued support. We hope you enjoy holidays with family, friends, great food, and this encore episode:
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Mike and Kristen’s background as traditional commission-based producers.
- Their “Aha!” moment.
- How ACA affected their practice.
- Their typical client.
- Whether the shift to fees work with all clients.
- How the state statutes and regulations play in the process.
- Whether they have a written agreement and what is included.
The Shift Shapers team is taking some time off over the holidays to enjoy the season with family and friends, and we hope you are too. Please enjoy this encore edition of one of our most popular interviews. How did a traditional product-centric commission-based practice become fee-based? And what can other advisors learn from their process? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_02Either feralyze it or energize it. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industry. Get ready to become the change that you want to stay. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultim.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. Today we're talking with Mike Grinnell and Kirsten Tudman of CPRHR, and Mike and Kirsten are kind of on the forefront of a shift that a lot of us have been talking about, especially with commission compression, which as we all know is an all-too-real thing for most of us. They're shifting their business model to a consulting-based advisory practice. We thought it'd be a really interesting discussion to have because they're further ahead than most of the producer practices, at least that I've come in contact with. So with that, Mike Kirsten, welcome to Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, David. Well, we're glad to be here. We're glad to share with everybody our thoughts on how things are changing and our ideas.
DavidWe're glad to have you. A good place to start is how things are changing. In our pre-show interview, you you described yourself as producers and that you take a team-selling approach. Talk to me a little bit about your background and so listeners will understand how you got to where you are. Did you start as a more traditional commission-based practice?
SPEAKER_01Yes. Both Kirsten and I were actually producers, and then we evolved to agency managers. We both ran two different practices. I ran about a $3 million benefit practice with six producers under me. And then Kirsten ran an agency with, I'll let her fill in the blank, how many she had with her?
SPEAKER_00Um, I ended up with it's been about 10 years and had 11 people under me. And then Mike and I both decided when the Affordable Care Act came that we needed to shift our business into fee-based and consulting business.
DavidSo ACA was kind of the push?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Before that, we had our larger self-funded clients on a fee-based business. So instead of taking the stop loss commission, we would go with contract of our services and exactly what we were going to do and set a fee to that. But really, the Affordable Care Act was on our push to say, wait a minute, these people need more, all of our clients need more background on the Affordable Care Act, and there's really not a product for that out there.
SPEAKER_01And David, we had an interesting opportunity. We were asked to speak on health care reform to municipalities and school districts, and that marketplace is very shallow as far as an HR department. So we looked at it as an opportunity. So we started in May of 2010 presenting on healthcare reform, and it was great. We had about a hundred people in the room with us. We ended up leaving, and then we ended up on the phones and filed up, and lo and behold, we had 12 new business appointments. We're sitting in front of these groups, and we have a state health insurance plan here in New York that doesn't recognize brokers or consultants, so there is no commissions or fees that we can earn. We're sitting in front of them and we're explaining what they're going to have to do with healthcare reform in the coming years, and then we said, okay, how are we going to sustain ourselves in this marketplace and generate some revenue? So we sat down and we developed basically an ACA compliance contract. We've been marketing that now for four years, and we're getting great success with that.
DavidSo the aha moment, if indeed there was one, was when you were doing that presentation and realized that there was a call for providing more consultative services around some of the complexity that ACA had driven?
SPEAKER_01Correct. The municipalities and school districts they typically have their own homegrown payroll systems. They're not going to adapt to an ADP or a paychecks. So they have to find a means in order to do this employer reporting. So we started laying the seeds for that back in 2010. And we have a system that will help our clients do that reporting.
DavidSo you guys started in what looks to be kind of a narrow vertical. Is this kind of an arrangement, do you think, applicable to a more traditional, you know, one-off client relationship rather than a school system or those kinds of entities? And do you guys have some of those as clients?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Anyone who doesn't have the background or the personnel to keep up with the Affordable Care Act and the daily changes of what's going on and what's required from employers today needs some sort of an assistance. Some similar to like they have a CPA or they have an accountant or somebody who's going to focus just on that business. We do have clients that aren't school districts or municipalities, larger, actually, even under anybody over 50 employees really has a lot that they have to do. So we have contracts with them, just keeping them up to date on the changes and what they have to do with their employees.
SPEAKER_01Other areas that you know have vertical markets when you look at the healthcare law that give you opportunities are restaurants, hospitals, because you have to do the tracking with healthcare reforms. So tracking those 30-hour employees actually makes an opportunity for you to come in and be a consultant and help them measure their employees and charge a fee for that measurement, but you're providing them a service and allowing them to understand what the potential exposure is come 12 months later when the measurement period has evolved.
DavidSo I mean, I know one of the questions that our listeners will have is across your book of business entirely, are you all fee, fee and commission? Are there some arrangements that are hybrid? How what does that look like at this point?
SPEAKER_01Um, right now, about 95% of our book of business is fee. We have actually four groups currently that are are still on commission. Um they happen to fall in the middle market of the fully insured world. So that hasn't been eliminated as of yet. But in New York State, our community rating is now going up to 100 starting one. So things could change.
SPEAKER_00We do have a large group, um, and you have to really look at your book of business and what can happen. But we have a group of five or six hundred that's owned by a Japanese company who wouldn't do fee-based. So we do get the stop loss commission built in on their self-funded account. So we really look at each client individually and say, does it work better for you to work it this way or do a fee-based contract? Even with our fully insured people that we get commission, we do have service agreements. So the expectations of exactly what we're doing is out there.
SPEAKER_01And David, I'll tag on to the end of her statement there. And why we do that is because you know, we believe that in the future commissions will probably vanish. So if we have a service agreement and we state right in that service agreement, we're we're gonna do these services for you, and we're getting paid from this policy to do these services for you. If the commission dries up in that health insurance plan because they eliminate it, then we're going to have that conversation with the group. We're still delivering the services. We share with them how much they paid us year over year, even though it may come from commission, then we're going to turn around and actually actually ask that for them to be cut in checks.
DavidNow you mentioned that there was one client who would not do a fee arrangement, and that that's something that always interests me, and and not with that client specifically, perhaps, but this is a new conversation for most employers. They haven't had this kind of a conversation with their benefits advisors. Take me through what that conversation sounds like and and what kind of questions or objections an advisor might be expecting based on your experience.
SPEAKER_01We'll walk right through that one example. The parent company is in Japan, and we went in there talking about precisely doing a consulting agreement and basically shopping their stop loss, managing their health plan, and charging them fee. And we showed them they were unaware of what the commission was in their current stop loss, so we got an authorization letter and were able to show them what dollars were there. Then we turned around and um really had them sold on that consulting agreement. At the last minute, the employer comes back and said, Hey Mike, you know, I really want to do this consulting agreement, but because we're owned by a Japanese company, with an agreement you become a line item. So whether we believe that your services are valid or not in a consulting agreement, it's better if it's hidden at this present time in that commission. And that quite honestly was how that example worked out.
SPEAKER_00Most of the time we see the clients don't have a problem and they would prefer it because, like Mike said, we explained to them what commission is built in there. And we ourselves don't believe that we deserve a raise in the every time the commission goes up simply because the commission goes up. So we would rather be upfront with our clients and say, This is the commission that's there, this is the fee for our services, and we would rather earn our fees.
DavidBut is that the conversation? I mean, when you go to an employer, absent the the cultural differences and perhaps the bookkeeping differences of your Japanese client. When you go to an average client in your area, you guys are up in the upstate New York area, when you go and you talk to a more traditional client, a manufacturing client or what have you, what is that conversation like? Because they're used to paying commissions and not seeing a fee agreement from their advisor. How does that conversation go?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, it varies from carrier to carrier within New York State, and based on how they're filed with the insurance department, um, the Aetna's, the United Health Cares of the World, they filed commission schedules with the state of zero to four percent. And our local carrier here in central New York, a Blue Cross plan, they basically have socialized commission in it. So in central New York where we live, there is no such thing as being able to net out the commission in the business. So what we do that is different than our competitors in central New York is we put that service agreement alongside of it and say that as healthcare reform evolves, the commissions may go, but we want to make you fully aware of exactly the services that we're going to provide.
DavidSo does that mean that you end up with kind of a hybrid while you're taking commissions and also providing services for a fee, or is it generally one or the other?
SPEAKER_01It is generally one or the other, but what we like to do is we like to put that agreement alongside of it so that they see these are the services that we're doing, so that they can identify those along the way, and we tell them exactly where we're getting paid.
DavidI see. So what you're doing is you're explaining what all your deliverables are and the value that those deliverables add, even though you're being compensated on the other side of the agreement, on the commission side for the time being. Would that be a fair statement?
SPEAKER_01That is correct.
DavidOkay. Now, I I know that in a lot of states, when advisors start talking about this fee-based discussion, that they get caught up in these 1950s and 60s anti-rebating statutes. Your law in New York is a little bit different, but you may have clients out of state. Have you run into that? Do you have a suggestion for how those advisors might move forward?
SPEAKER_01Well, absolutely know your state laws that you're practicing in and do what's best for the client. I'm a firm believer that fees are the best place to be. Even on stop loss, when you see large claims, you know, you got a stop loss trend of 15% or more, getting a 15% raise and having them not having a bad year of claims isn't justified just for shopping at one time a year. So doing a side-by-side comparison while you're going doing the quote once a year, is that worth 15%? I'd rather earn more services from the group and outline and have them pay me for those services and deliver value.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely, because every client needs different services. So we have a list, just like you said, and they can choose which services are going to fit them best, or they can get an all-encompass, obviously, um discount.
DavidSo what are your clients asking you for? You know, when a client's proactive and says, you know, I know, I know I need more than just somebody spreadsheeting a bunch of products, what are you hearing them ask you for? Because that's something we've been talking about a little bit on the podcast.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. The biggest thing people are asking for is the Affordable Care Act consulting. And we have probably 85% of our business is strictly Affordable Care Act consulting. Most of that is again in the schools and municipalities, but several of our large clients also have that built into their fees. We do everything from Affordable Care Act from going through their HR policies to make sure they're compliant all the way through union meetings, Cadillac tax projections, and making sure that those are working well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and one of the things, an example of a case study, we took a city that we did a Cadillac tax projection for them. And basically what we wanted to do is shift their thinking. They were offering a HRA and they were funding it with $350 for an individual and $700 for a family. What that dollar amount was for is for dental envision coverage. Well, when we look at their medical plan and then added the HRA dollar amounts together, it was going to cause roughly a $100,000 Cadillac tax. So we started investigating a freestanding dental envision plan. And we were able to find a $1,500 calendar year max for each individual on the dental, full vision program, and for the $350 for an individual, and $700 for the family on a calendar year. So we encouraged them to buy the insurance because that would avoid the Cadillac tax. And we got into discussions with the unions, the unions at first, because they had negotiated for this benefit, it was theirs. And management took the idea first, went to the unions, they were unsuccessful because, again, they felt that management was just trying to take something away. We stepped back into discussion and carried on some education meetings for the unions. And the unions endorsed it, they implemented it one-one, and they've got a lot better benefits. And we've actually taken what really an opportunity of healthcare reform and how Cadillac tax is written and it was going to be an employer expense and delivered it so that the expense wouldn't be there, but the benefits delivered to the union were better.
DavidInteresting, really, really interesting fix. I mean, you know, for those listeners who have not operated in the Taft Hartley environment, as you guys know, because I know that's a significant portion of your practice, that management labor dynamic is always a very interesting one to navigate. We've got about a minute and a half left, and I'm always interested when we're talking to folks who are kind of out on the edge as you guys are and leading. What do you see in the future? And you can define that as the next couple of years or five years if you're bold enough to go out that way. What does it look like from where you guys are sitting?
SPEAKER_00Well, we absolutely see the shift from commissions to fee-based across the industry. Commissions are getting smaller, and more people want to see what they're getting for those dollars. And as commissions go away, the traditional broker is going to have to prove what they do and feel comfortable collecting fees.
DavidMike, anything you'd like to add before we wrap up?
SPEAKER_01You know, I 100% agree with her, but I think we as an industry have to get from a service perspective: the more that you engage and understand the Affordable Care Act, the more that you'll actually see there are opportunities for those who want to be that consultant, be that advisor that's going to help them navigate this ever-changing law. We've got a presidential election that could actually change how a Cadillac tax could be in the future. It could be an imputed income tax. So the more you stay involved in those things and the more you're there to be a partner alongside of your employer, the longer you'll stay employed receiving fees.
DavidYeah, not to mention all the fun we're going to have between now and that election with little things like King v. Burwell. Any thoughts around where that might come out and what the fallout might be?
SPEAKER_01Well, we uh belong to an association called National Association of Health Underwriters. We were down in Washington in February, and one of the things that they discussed was that basically the administration is already going out to the states and making it much easier for the federally facilitated states to become a state-based exchange, even though they're going to be doing the federal government's still going to be doing the processing. And then we also heard when we were down in Washington that the Republicans have already got a, depending on how it comes, if it says that the decision is going to be to stop the subsidies in the federally facilitated states, then the Republicans say we just can't throw 11.7 million people out with no insurance. We're going to have to put a fix in there to extend the subsidies in order to be able to find a different solution that we can bring to the table. So I don't think, regardless of what the decision is, that it's going to change very much. I think there's it's going to go up and down.
SPEAKER_00But the Affordable Care Act isn't going to go away, is what we believe.
DavidYou know, it's like that old curse, may you live in interesting times, and maybe that's a great place to wrap it up. Mike Grinnell, Kirsten Tugman of CPIHR. Thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience today.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thank you.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.