The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #135: Creating Operational Efficiencies Using Technology - With Paul Gable
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week on ShiftShapers, Paul Gable, President of IBX, lends his expertise on technology tools in the benefits industry to the discussion. Benefits advisors are being challenged to meet the demand of delivering a higher quality of service with more efficiency to remain profitable. Paul highlights the affordable resources available to help small and mid-sized agencies recapture efficiencies in their businesses and thus save money.
Paul points out that most agencies waste time with inefficient processes. Two-thirds of an advisor’s time is routinely consumed with non-client facing or back-office administrative duties. When these processes are restructured, advisors can spend more time with clients.
The cost of basic customer relationship management tools available can be financed in a variety of ways that make them affordable for a wide range of agencies – regardless of size. Paul highlights how advisors can best take advantage of the off-the-shelf products available and what you need to know to evaluate potential vendors.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Why advisors need to create operational efficiencies.
- The percentage of an advisor’s time that is actually spent selling.
- The steps needed to creating effectiveness at lower cost and with a higher return.
- What a CRM is and how it differs from an Agency Management System.
- The opportunities to automate the RFP process in a way that delivers higher sales percentages.
In today's environment, many advisors are dealing with commission compression and higher client expectations. How can you become more effective and efficient while delivering a greater level of service? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzmith.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're pleased to be chatting with Paul Gable. Paul is president of IBX. And if you don't know them, IBX is a technology outsourcing partner for benefit advisors all over the country. And Paul, welcome. Thank you, David. Thank you for having me. We know commission compression is a real thing. They're increasing in tangible deliverables like compliance and whatnot that are now becoming table stakes. So it's more important today more than ever, isn't it, for benefit advisors to be both effective and efficient?
SPEAKER_01No doubt, David. What we see around the country is that the demands on agencies, on advisors, only expands and it has expanded into different roles and responsibilities than may have ever been before. That's probably quite obvious to most of the listeners on the line. That said, a lot of the stuff that you've always done is still there. So when we see about what you'd like to do as an agency owner or principal in an advisory firm, is spend a lot of time in front of your clients. Sometimes what we're finding consistently is that the realities just don't afford you that. And so you end up spending a lot of your time and a lot of your resources dedicated towards, let's say, back office work, non-customer-facing work. That's really where we uh in our work with a number of firms around the country, we found that to be a very consistent fact.
DavidAnd it may shock people, but depending on the study that you look at, I mean, you and I were talking off-air, it's between two-thirds and three-quarters of the amount of time that you spend is not client or prospect facing. Isn't that amazing?
SPEAKER_01That is quite amazing. And it's also something interesting. It's been very interesting and enlightening for us to find it's not just at that level, but it's also really consistent from intra-firm, one operation within a firm to the next, and firms across different markets around the country really are facing some of the same issues. And that is their people that they're investing in inside the firm, the actual customer-facing resources that you bring on as an account manager and require significant levels of expertise, end up spending a lot of their time. And as you alluded to, David, data suggests at least two-thirds of that time is spent on back office responsibilities. And those can be a variety of things. What we see a lot of are things like the renewal and quoting process, the add terms, delete processes, particularly around small case. These eat up a ton of time and take away that amount of time that those people could be used in engaging existing customers, dealing with new issues, compliance, and the sophisticated analysis that they have to do in those areas all gets somewhat diluted by the responsibilities that they have to fulfill really in what we call the back office.
DavidSo we'll talk about a number of different things that might be helpful, but if an advisor is thinking, yeah, that sounds an awful lot like my shop, what's task one? What's the first thing that you advise folks to kind of tackle or to look at critically?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think a lot of the benchmarking that's out there really focuses on, let's say, how revenue per resource, revenue per producer. We really encourage folks to take a look at where they're spending time operationally and metrics around accounts per CSR, accounts per account manager, and really use that as a first level of understanding, and then start to break down, okay, if that starts to look out of whack, really where can you really focus in on? And then start to look at ways in which you can maybe improve that through different applications of technology, different understandings of your existing data, and so forth. So understanding that basic, how do I compare? Really, where am I folks spending my time is where we talk to people about getting going.
DavidEven something as rudimentary as a CRM, as a customer relationship management system. I know a lot of firms, especially the mid and small size firms, have looked at them over the years, but they haven't really deployed them, which I think is problem one, we can certainly talk about. And problem two is where they have deployed them, they've been the shiny new thing for a little while, and then they've gone by the wayside. So, how do we address both of those problems? How do we start talking to agencies that need to deploy a CRM solution as a base level to improve their throughput? And then what's the key to keeping it in force once you get it?
SPEAKER_01That's a great area of understanding. I think there is a ton of promise in a variety of CRMs, and in fact, everything from really specified and unique industry-related things that are out there to the broader applications, even including things like Salesforce. You've got all the capabilities you could ever imagine. But the fact of the matter is, over, I think what happens over even a relatively short period of time, what people focus on are just the relatively narrow applications like commission tracking. And no, nobody's going to say that that's not important. Unfortunately, what it then creates is that you don't have central repositories of customer data. And so that when you go back to repeat some of those processes that we were talking about earlier, you have to start from scratch. For example, we see people that when it comes to even managing an ad term delete process for their small business segments, they're repeating the same process over and over again because they don't have a central repository of data. Their CRMs don't have an accurate depiction of plan designs. They don't have an accurate representation of what product is with what carrier. So you're really repeating that process over and over again. And that's part of the inefficiencies that we see in the back office.
DavidWe hear an awful lot about agency management systems. And some people think that they're synonymous with CRMs, and some people think that they're different. What's your take? Are they two separate things? Should an agency, especially a small to mid-size agency, look at these as two separate animals, or are there such things that are combined and work well?
SPEAKER_01I think there are things that are combined and have some of the common functionalities that exist both on the agency side and the customer management side. Reality is, though, we find in our work very few people utilizing the cross-functionality. What's likely been the best course for people is just to say, look, I'm going to manage my commissions, I'm going to manage my producer compensation over on this side, I'm going to manage my bonus programs in a separate way, and then look at a wholly different approach towards understanding what my customers do in terms of plans, carrier relationships, customer contact, all of those things, really move that into a more traditional CRM approach. Now, that's a very expensive thing to keep up with, as you can probably imagine. And the business processes inside of a lot of firms just haven't been oriented towards managing that data. It's one thing to say, yeah, we're going to go make sure that we follow up with the carrier community on a monthly basis for commissions. It's quite another to organize your business process to say, okay, I'm going to make sure that I know exactly how many times I'm touching each customer, how many times my carriers are touching that customer, store that information, interrelate with telephony so I can gauge customer inbound calling and those kind of things. We see that done almost in no situation well around the country.
DavidWell, is part of the problem that the CRM is only really useful if it starts long before a sale, if it starts when someone is just an unqualified prospect being loaded into a pipeline, and the agency management system is kind of more of a rearview mirror look.
SPEAKER_01It definitely is. I think that is definitely a significant root cause of the call it the lack of quality data. And again, when you get to a renewal cycle, it's an ideal time to really recapture that data, reauthenticate it, revalidate everything, obviously incorporate any changes as part of the renewal process. But what we find is that, hey, you get to that and you're just most people are just say, okay, we got it done. Let's just make sure that it gets placed, get the contracts out, and move on to the next one. And reality is that that leaves this big gap in terms of your systematic understanding of your customers.
DavidYou know, how important is agency management support for this or mandate, if you will? I mean, I had I had one client years ago who used to tell people that they didn't have to use the CRM system, but they couldn't work for the agency if they didn't. How important is that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a great anecdote. And the reality is I think there are a lot of people out there in really high-quality firms that put these stakes in the ground, but then what happens? You have turnover in your CSR account management staff, or the most recent brush fire created is something that people would have to run into and fix. And the reality is you've got these enormous gaps in the quality, and we see that quite consistently. You're an agency with 100 or 150 clients, and most commonly what people will say is we have this data, we have this CRM that aligns with our agency system, but we don't trust it. And that trust has to be developed by utilization over time, consistent application, consistent expectations that the information coming out is correct. And we just we see that in such a minority of our relationships that we know it's a big problem for everybody.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivated health.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. So if you're going to use a CRM system for your agency, it's really a long-term commitment.
SPEAKER_01It's a long-term commitment to the both the technology and your business process so that you're building that in along along the various touch points. Again, that every time that call comes in, I talked about, you know, just briefly alluded to the idea of interacting with your telephony so you can track customer inbound calling and those kind of things. That is just a it's more than a long-term commitment. It's a real commitment to re-engineering your entire business process.
DavidWell, and you alluded to this earlier, and we've talked about it a few times. So many agencies don't spend time thinking about their business process. And if you don't do that, it's virtually impossible, isn't it, to get a CRM to deliver the kind of results that you want.
SPEAKER_01I think that's exactly what it is. So you're just you're really what people ultimately do, and it's nothing terribly surprising, is that when that that relationship is back front and center, when something is in the moment that you're needing to do, you're going back to the shared drive, or at worst, maybe even paper filing to figure out where things are, as opposed to the opportunity that we see, which is, hey, what if that was all there? What if it was really accurate? What if it really did reflect exactly what has happened both recently as well as prior renewal cycles? That's a tremendous opportunity for you to add efficiency to your back office. And as you can imagine, that efficiency drives right to your bottom line margins.
DavidAnd so the link between the two, between a CRM system and an agency management system, is something that I know that you're very passionate about. And for a lot of agencies, especially small and mid-sized agencies, it's a giant time suck that's not often productive. And that's the dreaded RFP. How do you counsel firms to look at RFPs and what's new on the horizon? What can help agencies turn that from a low percentage win into a high percentage win, or at least not a time suck?
SPEAKER_01Sure. And that's really where that percentage of time that we spoke of at the outset of this conversation really starts to take shape. You think about that 70, 65 to 70% of the time really focused most of that on the renewal process. And a lot, unfortunately, a lot of that is is compressed in the in the timing of the year towards towards the fourth quarter work. And what we see successful firms doing is having an organized process and not just uh an ad hoc one, obviously, and having a data management strategy within the technology of whatever CRM you choose that allows you to plan out your renewal cycles, to plan out and inventory your data, build a call it a data warehouse with your existing plans for your upcoming renewal processes, and then integrate those with the technologies that are out there from an RFP process. So as opposed to just this set of ad hoc processes from where your data comes from to how it gets into the market and back from the carrier community, what if you could integrate all of those given some of the technologies that are out there? And on small case, on ACA Medical, for example, we're starting to see, and I think a lot of your listeners are probably starting to see some of the new applications out there that feel a little bit more consumer-friendly, things that we're used to doing in our own lives. For example, how do we shop for airline tickets and the various choices that are there are starting to be built in these databases and filtering processes and the technologies that exist now that allow you to say, okay, here are my choices. I might be in Ohio where there's 500 different plans, but I can quickly get to my best two carrier options with my best two networks and my best three to five plans. And that all can be done in literally five minutes, as opposed to interacting with a bunch of carrier websites, pulling down information, trying to array those in spreadsheets. And again, when you're doing all that, by the way, it's none of that's going to go back and feed this the CRM data that we talked about being so critical to operating your business. So think about all the time that you're saving in that process, given the utilization of some of that new technology that's out there. Likewise, in the what I call the underwriting interactive businesses, things where you're actually going back and forth, iterating different plan options, negotiating even perhaps with carriers around contract terms and price, there's a tremendous amount of advancement been made there, as opposed to an expedia type approach where you're buying certain provisions, you're buying certain things that are fixed. You've got a more of an interactive approach on the mid-market business level funding, stop loss, all sorts of ancillary programs that you can interact with the carrier marketplace with. And so there's a tremendous opportunity for both organizational savings, process savings, as well as time savings.
DavidThere's also, I mean, now that now that we've gotten it out in the open and we've said technology and RFP in the same sentence, which, you know, for a long time were mutually exclusive terms, there are some initiatives that are actually operating within the construct that you just laid out on a real-time basis, aren't there?
SPEAKER_01That's correct. Like I said, on the call it the ACA side of things, it used to be there there's been some applications in the primarily located in the Northeast, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, a couple of applications have been around literally 25 years. Certainly made sense to do your business that way. And what we're starting to see is the proliferation of those in other states. Even a carrier, from a carrier management standpoint, carriers are also saying, hey, keeping my quoting sites up to date with real information, keeping them serviced, keeping them running is something that they're not all that keen about spending a bunch of time and money on. So the more that they can push that into some of these decision support tools that are out there, they're happier about it too. So there's just no, there's no way that you can envision that not being the standard by which people across the country and all really all 50 states get their quotes within just a few years. So we're starting to see that really take shape. And there's just no doubt that when we if we were having this conversation five years from now, that that'll just be a fact of the daily life of a brokerage business.
DavidPaul, in terms of cost and implementation, are these systems that we're talking about within the reach of the average small to mid-sized agency, or are they still only for the more elite and larger sized agencies with bigger books?
SPEAKER_01No, I think there's if you if you really look at some of the options that are out there, call it the democratization of the internet, has has certainly made things like this very much available to any type of agency, large or small. I don't think I think what you're you know, firms that in the past have maybe dealt with uh general agents to collect that type of information, they may have that available to them now through some of these tools. So there's not really a need to first of all, uh David, there's not a need to go build your own. And is even as maybe as efficient as as you might be in building software inside of an agency, you certainly don't have to go build your own application for stuff like this. We see people who have thought about that. And our conversations quickly become, hey, wait a minute, I don't I can go spend money on things that are gonna benefit my client as opposed to maybe buying stuff in the marketplace that benefits my operational side. So there's definitely the tools that are out there really are broadly available, I would say. I think the how you finance the acquisition of those tools, technologies, and processes are not huge capital investments. You're talking a lot of software as a service where you can either buy a subscription, a license, or even some in many cases you have other options around maybe per transaction pricing. So there's a lot of different ways to skin the cat, David. And and I think what you talked about, it's not certainly certainly not just in the purview of larger agencies.
DavidOne of the questions that we get asked an awful lot, and maybe it's a great place for us to wrap up this episode, is how important is it if you're an agency owner and you're looking at software, how important is it to look at the pedigree of the folks who've built the software and make sure that they have a benefits background rather than just being a pure technology play? Is that important today or is that no longer a thing?
SPEAKER_01I think that continues to be a thing, and I don't see I don't see it never not being a thing. I talked about, yeah, certainly there are new players in the market that that focus exclusively on on the software side of things and and they they focus on the user experience, they focus on simplicity and things like that, and that's all great. But the fact of the matter is, I think anybody listening to this, and you and I both know it's not just about simplistic. In fact, the benefits business can be really complex in terms of the negotiating process, the interaction process. What something as simple as what does the underwriter on the other side of this negotiation need to see? What are the information that needs to transpire between the two parties? All of those things require, I think, somebody with benefits expertise and experience in order to affect that transaction. Like I said, carriers are looking for ways for themselves to be efficient, but having new players who don't understand their issues are really not going to help in that regard. So the players that I think are going to be successful in these technology applications and these process changes that are being affected are going to be the ones that bring the combination of usability and technological advancement along with people who understand both sides of the benefits, really all three sides of the benefits buying experience, that of the customer, the broker, intermediary, as well as the carrier.
DavidGreat place to leave our discussion for today. Paul Gable, president of IBX. Paul, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with our audience. I appreciate your time, David. Thank you. The Ship Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.