The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #132: New DI Strategies Increase Agency Revenue - With Patrick Irving
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week, we welcome Patrick Irving, Managing Director of Covala Group, to The ShiftShapers podcast to help us explore the overlooked opportunities available with disability income. With only 30% of Fortune 1000 companies (and fewer in other segments) providing coverage in this area, advisors willing to develop a DI expertise will be in a prime position to expand their practices while providing invaluable coverage for their clients – often at a discount!
This episode is packed with useful information for benefit advisors: Patrick clarifies some of the DI terminology that can often be confusing. He goes into detail about the taxation of DI benefits so advisors can better serve their clients while saving them money. He also tackles the classic chicken or the egg question regarding whether Group or Individual coverage is the best first option.
Advisors dealing with commission compression or looking for additional revenue streams will definitely want to leverage the opportunities available in DI coverage and you should begin with this episode. Patrick provides a wealth of information and specifics on how to help your clients seamlessly integrate DI benefits into their existing plans.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- The market opportunity available with disability income.
- The difference between multi-life, group, GSI and individual plans.
- An expert perspective on whether an Individual or Group plan should be purchased first.
- Why it is important to understand the taxation of disability.
- Which items are generally not covered by Group DI.
What are the opportunities to increase your revenue and your service level by incorporating disability income into your practice? And what do you need to know to capitalize on a virtually untapped market? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. Hey Shift Shapers, be sure to visit the special offers section of the Shift Shapers website. That's ShiftShapersonline.com to download a white paper so you can learn more about this week's episode. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Patrick Irving. Patrick is the managing director for Kovala Group, and we're going to talk today about probably one of the best opportunities to easily increase your agency's revenue. And when I say easily and tell you what we're talking about, you may think they're different things, but they're not. They're completely compatible. And it's also a way to increase the level of service that you provide for your clients. And what we're going to talk about is disability income. Maybe in a little bit different way than you're used to thinking about DI. So with that, welcome, Patrick.
SPEAKER_02Thanks, David. Glad to be here.
DavidLet's level set. What's the opportunity? What does the market look like from a 20,000-foot vantage point?
SPEAKER_02Well, there's tremendous opportunity out there. And really, when you when you look at any company with a group long-term disability plan, they always have or often always have at least one of three income protection gaps. You know, so group LTD coverage, even the most robust plans, there are people and there's income of some people that is not covered by the group plan. The first gap is based on the maximum monthly benefit amount. So, you know, I'll cite a few stats. You know, there have been various studies of group LTD benefits out there. The American College has done them, Institute for Benefit Alignment. And generally speaking, you're going to see about 70% of group LTD plans out there have a maximum monthly benefit of $15,000 or less, meaning, assuming a 60% replacement ratio, income above $300,000 not covered by the Group LTD plan. Another gap that exists with group LTD is bonus coverage. Almost 90% of group LTD plans out there do not cover bonus compensation. So again, any employee out there with a significant portion of income in the form of bonus has a lot of uncovered income. And then the third gap is the taxability. About three-quarters of group long-term disability plans have taxable benefits. So that means there's another significant gap there. So that's really, you know, from the the, as you mentioned, the 20,000-foot view, that's how we see the world here and realize that, you know, company large or small, there are employees and often, you know, the most valuable employees who have significant amounts of income that are not protected by the group long-term disability benefit.
DavidAaron Powell We throw around a lot of terms in DI, and sometimes they can be confusing to folks who aren't practitioners in this area. Educate us a little bit about the difference between multi-life, group, guaranteed standard issues, some of these phrases that listeners may hear, but not really be keen on exactly what they mean.
SPEAKER_02Sure. So group LTD, which I was just talking about, is you know a policy which the company, it's a contract between the employer and the insurance carrier, and then each of the employees are covered under the terms of that contract. Some key, along with those coverage gaps that I just mentioned that are that are also that come into play, some key components or features, if you will, of group insurance are it's usually not portable. Sometimes there will be a conversion option of some kind, but generally speaking, if you leave your employer, you're not taking your group coverage with you. It generally has uh offsets for other income, primarily Social Security. And it's it's sort of a baseline coverage, which again, a lot of employers offer. Individual policies, let's say a fully underwritten individual policy, a policy you would acquire in the retail market, you know, working with your own agent, those are generally more robust. They have you know guaranteed renewable and non-cancelable policies out there where you can fix terms and pricing to you know to age 67, very robust coverage. You're gonna be able to cover that bonus compensation. If you make it through the underwriting process, get coverage amounts well beyond what you're gonna typically get in the group LTD plan. The challenge there, of course, is um getting through the underwriting process. It's generally a little more rigorous than life insurance, is if you think about it, there are plenty of things out there that are far from life-threatening, but could make someone uninsurable from a disability standpoint. So uh individual policies are great. The challenge is sometimes getting through underwriting, and you know, it's it's not cheap. You know, group insurance, you know, it's often employer paid, but even when it is voluntary, the rates are pretty low. Individual policy coverage, particularly on the non-cancelable, as you might imagine, have higher rates. So those are the challenges of acquiring the individual policy in the retail market. Now, multi-life, or you might hear it as a company sponsor disability, these are the same individual policies that someone would acquire on their own, but the company is sponsoring the plan. So rather than it being a group contract between the employer and the insurance company, these are each employee would get an individual contract between them and the insurance carrier. They are often non-cancelable policies with the same fixed terms and pricing, but the even when offered on a voluntary basis, the employer is able to offer two things that employees cannot get on their own. The first is what's called guaranteed standard issue underwriting. So what that means is they're rather than the full underwriting process, employees would just be asked a few questions and primarily establishing they've been actively at work for either 90 days or 180 days, depending on the insurance carrier. So that's there's no detailed health history question, there's no physical exam or anything like that. So that's a significant advantage, not only because it makes life easier on everyone, but there are, you know, for the employees out there who wouldn't be able to get this on their own, this gives them access to the disability insurance. The other advantage of the multi-life route is the premium discounts. Again, this will vary based on the case size and the insurance carrier, but you know, for a larger voluntary opportunities, there's probably going to be around 25% discount from retail rates. And unemployer paids, they can get upwards of 35%.
DavidYou mentioned the taxation a little bit. I know there are a lot of different aspects to DI that are a little different than folks who may be practicing on the group medical side or on the life side or even on the pension side. Talk for a moment about the taxation of disability income benefits.
SPEAKER_02Sure. So the general rule is if you're paying the premiums yourself, the benefit will be tax-free when received. If your employer is paying the premium, then the benefit will be fully taxable when received. Of course, if you know if you're if you're paying with somehow your some employers may let people pay with pre-tax dollars, then you're still going to have a fully taxable benefit. So the key is if you're paying the premium with after-tax dollars, you will get a tax-free benefit. And so that's, you know, it kind of ties back to what I was talking about earlier. It's sort of a a bit of a paradox with Group L T D because oftentimes, as I said, almost three-quarters of the time they're employer paid. And so you think, oh, this is a great benefit. This is a good thing. This is something my company's picking up for me. But unlike other coverages, in that situation, when you actually need the benefit, you're going to get less than maybe you would expect to get. So, you know, there so some employers will offer a tax choice where it's, you know, the employee has the opportunity during annual enrollment, they can select to pay the premiums directly, so they will have access to a tax-free benefit. But oftentimes they won't because there will be a load in the in the premium for the employer to pay on the group side if they have that choice. So another solution is you can keep the group benefit of employer paid and thus fully taxable, but by offering, having a multi-life individual offering to supplement that group LTD, you're going to be able to close that tax gap. So here's an example. Let's say you have a group LTD benefit, which covers 60% of base salary up to a maximum monthly benefit of $10,000, and it's employer paid, so it's fully taxable. Depending on the size of the eligible employee population, there could be a multi-life offer to cover 75% of base salary and bonus up to, let's say, another $10,000. And that would be employee paid, in this example, voluntary, and thus tax-free. So because their group is at 60, which is sort of the rule of thumb in the in the industry, the individual disability insurance carrier will allow the individual policies to cover up to 75%. And that difference is going to really close that tax gap. So even if you have a fully taxable group LTD plan, you're able to offset that by having a larger portion of individual policy coverage which will be tax-free.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. And just to clarify, when we use that phrase 60% replacement ratio, we're talking about 60% of your gross wages, your gross salary, correct? That's correct. So if, for example, I'm making $10,000 and a carrier will offer me $6,000, but I pay the premium myself, that $6,000 is not taxable when I receive it. So it's a much greater percentage of my actual pre-disability spending income than 60%, isn't it?
SPEAKER_02That's right. Yeah, exactly right. And so and and oftentimes, you know, employ we're all guilty of this, right? You know, we're we're in this industry, so we we pay more attention. But for the things that we we don't look at every day, so people in, you know, whether they're in another aspect of financial services or in a law firm or especially, let's say, a physician, you see your benefits, you see, okay, I have a group benefit, you that 60% number catches your eye, that's it, you call it a day, and then if it the time comes to you need to file a claim, you're expecting 60%, not realizing that, well, if if my employer's paying for it, then I'm gonna be uh taxed on that. If I was earning above that maximum monthly benefit, I'm I'm not gonna get that full amount. If there was any bonus or incentive comp that wasn't covered, that won't be there as well. So those are those are really key things that people don't think about. People out there who sell individual disability policies, you know, this is something they know, and so they're when they talk to their clients, they help them understand that and they put them through underwriting and they help them acquire the additional coverage that they need. Through the multi-life channel, you can do the same thing, but rather than just selling one policy, you're selling 100 policies, and you're allowing your client to get that access to that same coverage without going through underwriting and with a significant premium discount.
DavidWe'll get into that in a second, and I think that's a fascinating area to explore. But let's settle one other kind of level set question, which is the chicken or the egg question that always gets asked. I'm an individual, premium is really not an issue. I have the opportunity, I have no disability coverage at present. I have the opportunity to buy both group and individual. Which comes first, the group or the individual?
SPEAKER_02Well, with generally speaking, individual coverage, as I mentioned before, is when they're non-cancelable policies, insurance you own, that's what you you want to be able to get your hands on, because it's again it's fully portable. You can take it with you if you move to another job, if you if you're if you're working for yourself, if you're starting your own company, et cetera. If you're you know at a larger organization, like I said, most of the time the group coverage is employer paid, so you're getting it anyway. But if there is the opportunity to purchase that group coverage, that's something that you should do because probably if they're, let's say they have a multi-life offer there, the insurance care is going to assume that you have access to that group coverage anyway, and you know, take that into account when they're underwriting the amount that you're eligible for.
DavidSo there are still offsets in the amount that individual insurers will offer if you have enforced group coverage.
SPEAKER_02That's right. It'll determine what they offer. Now, again, once the benefit amount is in place, there will not be any offsets on the benefit. So let's say once you acquire, you have an individual policy, a benefit amount of $10,000. If then, let's say then you move to another job and they've got a $15,000 group LTD benefit. As long as you're paying premiums on that individual policy, you know, let's say it's a non-cancelable individual policy, when it comes time to pay a claim, that benefit, the individual benefit, will not offset in any way. Once you acquire that amount, you have it, it's in the in the underwriting process when they're determining your benefit amount, they will consider outside coverage both of an individual and a group nature.
DavidSo I'm a benefit advisor and I've been listening very carefully, and I've come away with a lot of knowledge so far. And I'm also thinking, dang, you know, it's a whole lot better if I try to do multi-life because I have existing corporate client relationships where there are three, four, five, ten, fifteen significant people in the firm who might be able to take advantage of this. How do I educate myself about this stuff? How do I go about doing it? And in point of fact, follow-up question do I do it or do I find somebody with whom I can create a strategic partnership? What's best?
SPEAKER_02As you mentioned, there are different approaches you could take. I think it may depend on really what what space you're operating in now and and and and what your experience level is with DI and also where your client contacts are. So, you know, let's say, you know, for example, if if you have a practice where you you work with a lot of individuals, you're not really in the in the group benefits space at all. You're selling individual, you sell your clients' disability policies on an individual basis. These are people who are people of great influence in their employers. That's a situation where it might make sense to reach out to someone who has more of an infrastructure and a process around doing these things. Some, you know, all the major carriers in this space, in the multi-life market, they have their own enrollment capabilities that are, you know, as as insurance carriers in any space are limited because generally they're large organizations and they they've gotten large and efficient and effective because they do things a particular way. The drawback of that is they're not as nimble and maybe as customizable as always. Whereas if in certain cases, to make this, to get all the moving parts of this corraled, you need to be more customized, have more customized communications, other aspects of the enrollment, et cetera. So that could be a case where a third party who is already built out for this, you make a call, your role is really connecting them to your client or to your client's employer, and they're running with everything from there. And in particular, if it's a very large organization and if there is a voluntary opportunity. If, on the other hand, let's say it's a smaller group and let's say it's you know 50 lives, something like that, and really the only people who have these income protection gaps that the group doesn't cover are the top you know 10 folks there. It's probably an employer-paid carve out situation, then the insurance carrier's resources will do just fine. And they'll they'll really do a great job and take care of you and and and make it a very seamless process for both you know and for your clients. And again, it's for this one client who maybe you're you're going to sell one policy, get him one policy, he's still going to get access to that same benefit, but without going through underwriting and with the premium discount.
DavidHow do advisors educate themselves about DI?
SPEAKER_02That's a great question. You know, if they could listen to this podcast, first of all, there are you know websites out there, but you know, your your carrier reps have plenty of literature on this in terms of you know, our website you know has other stats on there as well. So I guess you stumped me a little on that one because what I would normally say is you give me a call.
DavidWell, that's okay too. We understand. I mean, there's lots of lots of folks who are knowledgeable out there. I mean, I guess it goes to the question of do you find some kind of strategic partnership with some folks who can help bring you along. You know, we've got a couple of minutes left. I I know one of the things we talked about off air was that only 30% of the Fortune 1000 companies actually have a DI presence. We've always heard that the market is only about a third penetrated. I mean, I heard that back in the early 80s when I got into the business. Is that still the case? Is there still that much opportunity out there?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there really is. So it you know, 30% is a is a good, you know, round number to use in terms of in the in the Fortune 1000. And it and that sort of holds up as you move throughout different shapes and sizes of employers and across different industries as well. And I really think a big reason for that is, you know, so when you sit down with someone and you show them the numbers, right? And you've seen the graphics where you show, you know, here's someone's insurable compensation, here's the group LTD coverage they're available, they're able to get, and then here's the gap that exists, here's how you close the gap with an individual policy. Very straightforward, makes a lot of sense. What holds this up is the folks in HR thinking, hey, that's a great idea. This makes complete sense. I am completely understaffed, I you know, don't have time to do this, and it's even if they don't say that out loud, that's what they're thinking, and it sort of just always moves to the back of the line. And so, really, the key is to be able to show them that look, this can be the multi-life benefits can be put on a group chassis, if you will, and from their standpoint operate as smoothly as the group LTD plan while being to able to offer this benefit. And that and getting that message out, you know, that's a conversation that a lot of people haven't heard yet. So even if you know this isn't primarily what you do, if if someone even looking to start a conversation with an organization, this is a great way to do it because maybe they have been pitched IDI, but maybe not as a as a way where it's you know it's easy for them to do it. And there's a and there's a way to do it where you know they don't have to completely disrupt their lives.
DavidLots of information, but still an amazingly great opportunity for benefit advisors who are dealing with commission compression or lack of market and the desire to expand their offerings to their clients. Patrick Irving, managing director for Kovala Group. Patrick, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, David. I enjoyed it.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.