The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #121: The Future of Value-Based Care - With Eric Parmenter of Evolent Health
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week on the ShiftShapers podcast, Eric Parmenter outlines the differences between the HMOs of the past and value-based care at the provider and hospital level. Eric is the VP of Employer Solutions at Evolent Health. His vast experience at all spectrums of the insurance industry makes him the perfect guest to identify the benefits and potential in store with a value-based approach to pricing.
We begin our conversation with a definition of value-based care. Ultimately, this approach is a shift away from a fee-for-service model which allows providers more control in how they interact with patients. The changes won’t be immediately noticeable by patients, but it has the potential to revolutionize the way doctors deliver care.
Eric provides a wealth of information that is sure to help you understand how value-based care differs from the HMO model and the benefits it provides. Listen in to discover just how value-based care will impact the future of healthcare pricing models.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Eric’s path to working at the provider and hospital level.
- What value-based care is and how it differs from value-based pricing.
- How three different types of providers are reacting to value-based care.
- Whether current networks as we know them will survive.
- How the incentive-based payment structure is being realigned to account for the quality of care.
- What the next generation of ACOs will look like.
Is value-based care at the provider and hospital level just a move backward to the old HMO days? Or is it the future? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully changed the shifts in their industry. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. How can you be the first to know about each week's podcast and get on the list for special listener-only content? It's simple. Go to ShiftShapersOnline.com and click the subscribe button. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Eric Parmenter. Eric is VP of Employer Solutions at Evalent Health, and we're going to discuss a topic we've touched on before, but we haven't really done a deep dive into, and that is the transformation to broadly speaking value-based care that's slowly taking hold of all facets of the industry. So with that, welcome, Eric.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. I'm delighted to be here today.
DavidThank you. You know, I know today you work with doctors and hospitals, and we'll get to that in a while, but you have a background as an advisor. How'd you get to where you are?
SPEAKER_02Well, I started as an insurance broker right out of college in 1986. I sold life and disability insurance to individuals. Wanted to migrate away from the kitchen table to the boardroom table. So I started working in the area of employee benefits as a broker, selling group life and health and 401k plans. And then I moved from that into fee-based consulting and administration. I owned my own TPA in Illinois and I provided consulting services kind of wrapped in a fee-for-service package of both administration and advice. From there, which now we're up to about 2004. I moved to Chicago, became the practice leader for compensation and benefit consulting for Grant Thornton, the fifth largest accounting firm at the time. It might be the fourth largest now. And then went from there to Towers Perrin, focused on middle market employers, and from there within Towers, I became the national practice leader of the hospital industry out of the Towers Chicago office. Towers then merged with Watson Wyatt and became Towers Watson. I left there in 2011 and came to Evalent Health, where I am now. And Towers has gone on to merge again with Willis. And so now they are Willis Towers Watson, as many of our listeners will know. And I've been with Evalent Health working directly with hospitals and health systems for the past five and a half years.
DavidSo you've got a great background, and you can speak to all sides, including most of our listeners who are in the benefit advisory space. At 10,000 feet, let's let's start way up high and then we can zero in. At 10,000 feet, what is value-based care and how is it similar or different from something that most of our listeners may be more familiar with, which is value-based pricing, or is it one and the same?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think if you ask 10 people in the healthcare industry what value-based care is, you might get 12 different answers. And so that's part of the challenge is that there isn't a consistent understanding of what we're talking about when we talk about value-based care. And I think it is different from value-based pricing or value-based insurance design. And so hopefully, as we go here, I can tease out some of those differences. But let me start with value-based care. To me, what it means is it's the shift in the way healthcare is delivered from fee for service medicine, where doctors and hospitals get paid on a per unit basis or a per click basis, if you will, fee for service, to more of a quality-based payment structure. So, what is fee for service? A doctor has an office visit and gets reimbursed X amount of dollars for that office visit. Or a hospital performs a surgery, gets reimbursed for the room and the equipment and the surgeon's fee, etc. Those are all kind of piece rate forms of compensation to our beloved medical providers, whereas value-based care is based on taking care of a population of people, a group, and managing the overall total cost of care and quality for a population, for a group of people, and based on how the group of providers perform, managing the group of patients, the payment structure could create bonus opportunities for those providers if they do a good job of managing cost and quality.
DavidSo who sets these metrics for what is quality and what is not? Where's that level set and how does that happen?
SPEAKER_02Well, a lot of the uh medical boards have already established the definition of quality, evidence-based medicine, fairly well established from the various governing bodies of medicine, whether it's the you know the American Academy of Pediatrics or Cardiology or places like the Centers for Disease Control. So there's all kinds of think tanks and associations and governing bodies who determine when is it appropriate for a male to have a colonoscopy. Probably a 20-year-old male having colonoscopy isn't appropriate, but a 50-year-old male it is, depending on factors such as you know family history and other factors. And so those are guidelines, if you will, that are pretty well established in terms of determining what is quality. I think the bigger question isn't who determines what quality is, it's who determines how we pay for quality.
DavidWell, and that's really the next question that I was going to ask is so you've got point A. How do you connect that to point B? How does that translate into this, for lack of a more elegant term of art, a more incentive-based system for these groups of physicians treating groups of patients?
SPEAKER_02That's a great question. And it's really not lack of incentives, it's it's misaligned incentives that is the problem. So right now we have incentives in the system. The incentive is based on more. The more you do, the more you get paid. And so that's an incentive, but we're trying to realign the incentives so that the incentives are based on quality and total cost of care. And so payers or insurance carriers are submitting contracts to provider groups that say, hey, if you can bring in, if we attribute to you a population of commercial lives or a population of Medicare lives that CMS would attribute to a certain provider group. And we establish a benchmark of here is the baseline for cost and quality, and if you exceed those benchmarks in terms of higher quality, lower cost, then here's a contract that determines how you will be paid either a bonus or some kind of shared savings or some kind of risk taking, where if you bring it in below a certain level, you keep the difference. That's called a capitated model. And so payer groups, whether it's CMS, the largest payer in the Medicare space, is CMS, governmental payer, Medicaid, is the main payer by states for that population. And then commercial payers, insurance carriers for the commercial groups, they're all trying to establish these contracts where, hey, provider, you take risk, you manage this population, and if you do, there's some upside to be had, or if you don't, there's some downside to be had. And so that's what's happening now in the world of value-based care is a lot of different risk arrangements that are being entered into between provider groups and payers, whether those payers be governmental payers like Medicare and Medicaid, or commercial payers such as insurance companies.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever-increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff, while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. And to that point, what does this look like? Let's investigate two areas here. What does this look like at the carrier or at the network level? And then maybe more importantly, in the long haul, what does this look like at the consumer level? Why does this matter?
SPEAKER_02Great question. At the carrier level, this looks like, on the one hand, something that we've seen before. Like this movie looks familiar. We've seen this before. Doesn't this look a little bit like HMOs back in the late 80s and 90s, where weren't providers supposed to be managing populations under an HMO? Weren't they supposed to be managing the quality of care that those patients received? And so it looks a little familiar in that regard, but it's different. It's different in a lot of different ways. One is an HMO is really an insurance company or an insurance product, and it's governed by the governing board of an insurance company or group. And they basically say, here are the providers that are in the network, no one else. And the patients have to select a primary care physician, a PCP, and then that PCP serves as the rationer of care, determining how much care the patient receives, what kind of referrals to other providers within that closed panel the patient can see. And there wasn't a lot of data to make those decisions. It was basically a sophisticated way to ration care. Not that all HMOs were unsuccessful. There are still very many successful HMOs in operation today. However, the value-based model tends to not be built upon an HMO chassis. It's more freedom in terms of choosing your providers, it's less restrictive in terms of who you can go to. However, there's an attribution model where the insurance company says, we're going to attribute to a certain provider group an individual. So it's less about enrollment where the individual chooses to be in a plan and to have a provider. It's more around attribution where the insurance company says, here's a list of people that have had claims in your area. We're going to attribute that list to you, and therefore we're going to measure your performance on how that list of people performs around cost and quality. And these people can, you know, go outside of that closed network. It's not a closed network. It might be a regular PPO product or it could be a point of service or an EPO product. It could even be an HMO product. It's less about the product and more about attributing lives to a population of physicians to manage a population of patients.
DavidWell, so before we get to the consumer, then if I'm a physician, I'm kind of looking at a pooled risk that may or may not be reflective of the excellence or lack thereof in my particular practice. How is that starting to play out in the provider community? Are they accepting of that?
SPEAKER_02Slowly. They like the way it is now, they're happy with fee for service reimbursement and those incentives. Thank you very much. Maybe they're toward the end of their career and they're going to ride this thing out for another three to five years and retire. And so they don't want to change fundamentally the way they practice medicine. So let's call that the first group. The second group on the opposite end of the spectrum are the physicians and hospitals that say, look, this is why I went to medical school to actually practice medicine, to spend more than five minutes with a patient in my office to actually help coordinate their care and to provide them with good advice, not just to run them through a factory of medical care so that I can see enough people in a day to make the money I need to make to have the kind of lifestyle I want to have. And so that's the second group. They're a gung-ho, they're on board, they're willing to enter into these agreements right now. The third group is the group that sits on the fence. They're taking a wait-and-see attitude. How is this value-based care or this population health or this ACO world going to evolve? And is it going to be good for me as a provider? And if so, I'll jump in late. And if not, I'll stay the way I am. And so I think what we're seeing is the very beginning stages of value-based care and population health management and ACOs. We're seeing a group of engaged physicians jumping in early and a group of folks that are waiting to see how this turns out. And of course, the other group, the first one I mentioned, that just would assume to have nothing to do with this.
DavidThose are the folks who only buy touchstone phones because you can't buy rotary dial phones any longer.
SPEAKER_02That's correct.
DavidSo, okay, what does this look like at the consumer level? Let's shift our lens a little bit. And why does this matter to consumers? What's the play for all of us who are on the consuming side of the equation?
SPEAKER_02Well, the answer may not be satisfactory because I think the answer is we don't know yet. The consumers aren't necessarily aware. When I say consumers here, let's define that. You could call them patients, you could call them members of a health plan, you could call them employees or dependents of a health and benefit plan. It's the people who actually use health care. It's all of us, right? So when we say consumer, it's anyone who needs health care. And we may be enrolled in a benefit plan or a health insurance product that looks very similar to what it did three to five years ago. And we may still look up a doctor in a network directory online. We used to do that on paper. Remember those big books that were always out of date as soon as you printed them out of the doctors and hospitals in the network directory? Well, we've gone away from that, and now you look it up online, but that doesn't seem all that different. Still carry an ID card in your purse or wallet. That seems about the same. You still have a member services line to call to wait in line and go through voice gel and you know, hopefully get to a person. That hasn't changed a lot. And so I think what should be changing is the doctor is spending more time with the higher risk people, and maybe the nurse practitioner or nurse, you know, physician's assistant is spending more time with the low acuity folks, the folks that have the sniffles, the sneezes, and the basic ailments, or came, you know, came in for an annual physical exam. That's a pretty subtle difference. Now I think as we move forward, we're going to see technology emerge where you're going to have more office visits on your iPhone via video chat with your doctor, your nurse practitioner, or your nurse assistant. You're going to operate more in a digital realm, and people are going to be pre-selected for different types of programs based on their medical risk determined by claims and pharmacy. But again, a lot of the big changes that are happening in healthcare right now are happening behind the scenes, happening at the provider level, happening at the insurance carrier level, at the contracting level, and less so at the patient level. So while I regret the lack of satisfaction in my answer, I also want to be straightforward to say I don't think you're going to see a lot of change immediately. Over time, you'll see more.
DavidWell, and that that's important for benefit advisors to understand. We've got two or three minutes left, and I wanted to touch on one other area that I know that you think about a lot, and that is I know you've been talking about what is a next generation ACO model. So in a couple of minutes, this is not fair, but I'm going to ask you to do it anyway. In a couple of minutes, can you sum up what the first generation was, why it's not working the way it was intended, and what generation two might look like?
SPEAKER_02Certainly the first generation, you have to go back to Medicare. What is an ACO? It really was a vehicle that was started from the Affordable Care Act, and it was called the Medicare MSSP Shared Savings Program. And so you had a MSSP ACO. How's that for acronyms? And basically, these were Medicare Lives attributed to certain physician groups who had signed up to become an MSSP ACO, and it was upside only. In other words, if there was some savings to be had, Medicare took the first bite out of that savings apple and gave what was left to the provider. Well, a lot of those ACOs either failed or they haven't performed as well because, frankly, Medicare took too much of the savings. It was more than the infrastructure cost that the provider had to put in to really do a good job of managing those risks. As the CMS models have evolved into things like Next Gen and Track One and Track 2 and Pioneer ACOs, there's all these different types of ACOs that Medicare is pushing out. The upside is becoming significantly higher for the provider in exchange for some higher downside as well. And now we're starting to see that begin to spill over into the commercial realm, not just the retiree realm. And so I think what you will see is we're going to go from you know shared savings that offered very small incentives for providers to risk arrangements that offer much more substantial incentives for providers. And so we're going to see the proliferation of these ACOs really take off.
DavidThat's a great summation, and I think it's a good place to end our interview for today. For those of you who've enjoyed this interview, Eric has a book coming out, and we won't give away the title, but it'll be out shortly, and we've asked him to come back and talk about it. And I assure you it is something that all of us can benefit from. Eric, thank you for spending time with us today. Eric Parmenter, VP of Employer Solutions at Evelyn Health. Thanks, Eric. Thank you. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.