The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #111: Why Behavioral Economics is Crucial to Your Business – With Jeremy Pincus
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Behavioral economics may sound like an oxymoron, but it has everything to do with success in everything from benefit design to sales success.
Jeremy Pincus, Principle at Forbes Consulting Group, studies the topic and believes that it is crucial to more productivity and happier clients. Jeremy explains what that useful offshoot of economics and psychology is all about and why “there’s a factor of emotion all the way going back to policy design, it isn’t just at point of sale.”
In our conversation, we learn the science that explains why giving prospects and clients fewer choices is key to successful sales. Jeremy explains the concept of “focalism” and how it plays into the sales equation. We also gain insights into the paradox of choice and the hidden forces behind every decision our clients make.
We wrap up the conversation by addressing the importance of storytelling and how it can minimize the biases that often make it challenging for clients to complete their plans.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- What behavioral economics is all about.
- What emotional policy design is.
- What the “number of choices” effect is.
- The concept of “focalism” and how it plays into the sales equation.
- Whether storytelling is effective in behavioral economics.
Behavioral economics sounds like an oxymoron, but is it the key to more productivity and happier clients? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. How can you be the first to know about each week's podcast and get on the list for special listener-only content? It's simple. Go to ShiftShapersOnline.com and click the subscribe button. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Jeremy Pincus. Jeremy is principal at Forbes Consulting Group. He is an expert in a field that you may think is very dry and not necessarily applicable to what you do. And we are going to shortly and quickly disabuse you of that thought process because it is key to everything that you do, and that is behavioral economics. So with that, welcome, Jeremy. Thanks. Good to be here. Thanks, David. Our mutual friend Steve Kane mentioned behavioral economics on an earlier podcast, and I thought it was such an interesting field that it was worth delving into. And let's level set and let's start with an explanation of what is behavioral economics.
SPEAKER_02Sure. So behavioral economics is a kind of a growing field that is an offshoot of economics and also an offshoot of psychology. Essentially, what it posits is that we do not actually make decisions for rational reasons, which would be the assumption of traditional economics that we have a rational decision-making model. But instead, we make decisions for a whole host of sort of reasons that have to do with a thing called system one, which is the kind of intuitive, emotional, heuristic-based, you know, sort of mental shortcut approach. It's sort of making fast decisions, quickly assessing situations and making decisions based on partial information, not the sort of careful, thought-out approach that sort of the uh economics had traditionally assumed about people. And uh it's kind of taken off in a big way. It's actually something that's that's showing up even at the government level. The Obama administration, for instance, has an office dedicated to this to better serve the American people in terms of being able to convince them, nudge them toward better health behaviors and better choices. The UK government has this as well. They call it the nudge unit, again, cabinet level position. So governments are certainly taking this very seriously, and um uh I think business is uh waking up to this as well.
DavidAaron Ross Powell We've spoken about Daniel Kahneman on this program before. Is some of this the the fruit of his research or others before him?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Oh, absolutely. I mean Kahneman is one of the pioneers. Um Richard Thaler is another luminary in behavioral economics, and there are others as well. But yeah, definitely Kahneman is among the top. He he actually got the Nobel Prize for this, so he's uh certainly recognized for this.
DavidThat certainly puts him at the top of the heap, absolutely. Um and you know, it's an interesting subject. We've gotten so used to using statistics and statistical analysis in order to sell things, uh especially in the benefits arena and certainly in core benefits where you're we've been used to up until recently spreadsheeting the bejabbers out of everything, that we forget, I think at our own peril, that every sale that's made is an emotional sale at some level. Would you agree?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I think you know there's a huge over-reliance on rational arguments and particularly statistical arguments in order to try to motivate people to take action. And we know that you know insurance in particular is a highly emotional topic. You're talking about some very significant life changes, whether you're talking about life insurance or long-term care insurance or disability insurance or you know, anything, even P and C. You're talking about major life events, highly emotional subjects. And what unfortunately happens is, and this may be because they it all kind of starts with an actuarial mindset, is there's an emphasis on risk statistics and cost statistics. And I think there's a ton of evidence coming out of behavioral economics that would suggest that not only is that not helpful to the cause, it's actually harmful to the cause, that that providing statistical information actually interferes with emotional processing, and emotion is critical toward taking action.
DavidOne of the things that you talk about, and I know one of the fields you study significantly is long-term care insurance. Is you use a phrase in some of your writings that there's a factor of emotion all the way going back to policy design. It isn't just at point of sale. Would you explain what you mean by that? Sure.
SPEAKER_02I think, you know, when you're thinking about the way you set up the need for any product, it doesn't even have to be insurance, but let's just take insurance for an example. You can frame it a number of different ways. You can frame these things in terms of gains or losses. So that's one way of looking at it. You can look at it as, you know, if this thing happens to you, you will avoid a loss. You know, potentially, let's say it costs $100,000, you know, for a couple years of nursing home or a year and a half, let's say. Uh you buy this policy, it's gonna help prevent that loss. That's a loss framing. You could also look at it another way. You could say, this is gonna pay you $4,000 a month. That's a gain framing. So this thing happens to you, and suddenly you're gonna be paid out this amount as a stream of money. So you could frame it either as a loss or a gain. You could also frame things in terms of the level of risk. You could look at this as, you know, what's the sort of worst case scenario that's extremely unlikely and frame that. That would be a low risk framing. Or you could take the sort of most common event and say, you know, what's the risk of needing any long-term care ever in your life, and that's a high probability framing, and you could frame it that way. Then you can also cross those two, losses and gains on the one hand by levels of risk on the other, and end up with sort of four different scenarios. The thing I talk about when you talk about policy design is you can think of each one of those sort of quadrants of gain or loss versus high or low probability as relating to product design. You could basically design something for any of those scenarios. The most common one in insurance would be a low probability loss. So here's a situation where something is relatively unlikely to happen to you. Let's say, you know, big catastrophic house fire, for instance. Very unlikely, and people would generally think of that as a loss. So that would be something you would design for low probability loss. That's sort of the theory of insurance, that's where most insurance lives. Long-term care insurance, on the other hand, is really marketed as a high probability loss. It's something that, you know, the the emphasis is always on, you know, this many people need long-term care. There's a you know, seven in ten probability you'll ever need long-term care in your life. It's it's almost a certainty, and it's a huge loss, and you, you know, this is what it costs you, you know, and the costs are totally unmanageable. So it's it sort of bucks the trend a little bit by focusing on that high-risk loss. You could also frame something as a low-risk gain. So here's a probability that's unlikely, but we're going to create a product there that's going to pay you out, let's say, a lump sum, you know, upon diagnosis. And things like critical illness will fall there. Here's a situation where it's a very unlikely event, hopefully, that you have one of these dread diseases. And then when that happens, boom, you get a check cut to you for a large amount of money. So that's a sort of a low-risk gain scenario. And then finally, you've got this other quadrant, which is the high risk gain. So high probability gain. And this is things like, you know, investments. You know, you're basically, you know, hoping for a gain. It's all about contributing money towards something which you then see as a high probability. You know, example there would be sort of a tax advantage investment vehicle, whether it's a HSA or a 529 plan for your kids' college or whatever have you. Essentially, products can be designed for any of those quadrants. And any product, I think, and I would argue, you could build a case using any of those quadrants to try to market it. And some of them are associated with much better results in terms of willingness to pay and willingness to take action than others.
DavidAaron Powell So it isn't a one-size-fits-all. I was going to ask, you know, what motivates human animals more, loss or gain, high risk, low risk. Do I understand what you're telling me is that this is kind of dependent on the prospect and the product?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah, it it really does shift all over the place. I think you know, if you look at sort of the marginal effect, so you kind of take all the detail away, sweep that aside, and just backing up, losses generally are more powerful motivators than gains. In general, you know, as humans, we we work harder to avoid a loss than we do to try to realize a gain. And you see this all the time, you know, that people will basically demand more payment for something that they already own, you know, because they perceive that as a loss of the thing, then they will bid for the same thing that they don't currently have possession of. They call that the endowment effect. So in general, as humans, we're more motivated to avoid losses than we are to achieve gains. That being said, once you cross it by high probabilities and low probabilities, really everything changes. And what people are willing to do, for instance, in a in a kind of a high-risk loss scenario versus a low-risk loss scenario is quite different. Just to take that example a little further, high-risk loss scenario, you know, you're kind of facing uh almost certain loss, tends to generate a really unhelpful set of emotions. It tends to generate panic, it tends to generate feelings of desperation. This is sort of, you imagine why people leave casinos with no money in their pockets. It's when you're losing, generally, people find that an unacceptable situation and they're willing to take all kinds of unreasonable risks. That I believe is part of the reason that long-term care insurance hasn't sold as well as it could, because people are essentially acting in a desperate way and saying, I'm going to take my chances when faced with that scenario.
DavidAnd now, a word from our sponsor. Captivated health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health Solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. So is the lump sum payout something that mitigates that kind of a thought process or those negative emotions?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think you can just look at the market and kind of get part of your answer. I mean, critical illness is selling at something like 20% growth per year. Long-term care insurance has always struggled and, you know, is is sort of barely alive. And you know, I think with some exceptions. I think that is a big part of it, that, you know, kind of guaranteeing a payout, a gain framing in a product like that helps a lot. I actually argued uh recently at a conference that that the high-risk gain scenario, based on some research that we did, actually was associated with the highest willingness to pay for long-term care insurance. And the way I elaborated that was talking about what is it, what's sort of the most positive lifestyle scenario you could paint for a person who is in a state of disability in older age? And how would this policy support that lifestyle? So you'd emphasize, you know, what you could do with that money as opposed to, you know, it's all about the negative. It's all about avoiding a Medicaid nursing home. Now we're talking about, you know, assisted living, having companionship, having someone there to help you do the things that you love, you know, whether it's gardening or fishing or who knows what. But it's all about supporting a positive vision for the future as opposed to removing a horrible negative scenario.
DavidSo if there are any number of ways to frame a particular product, it leads me to my next question. And you know, we've all been in front of clients and we've all been taught you need to have choice A on the table and choice B and C in your bag, or present a multitude of choices to clients. Is more choice better if your goal is to help a client achieve a goal, fill a hole in their financial plan, however you characterize it?
SPEAKER_02It's a great question. And I think it's uh there's a whole book written on this subject by Barry Schwartz called The Paradox of Choice. And, you know, as humans, we want choices, we demand choices, you know, we like the idea of choices. But the truth is, and there's a ton of research that supports this, is the more choices you put in front of people, they simply can't handle it, and they tend to shut down and make no decision. This has been seen over and over again. We actually did some work for the Employee Benefit Research Institute where I did a sort of meta-analysis on uh participation rates in the group long-term care side, and what we found was with each additional separate choice that participants needed to make in order to sign up, it drove down the overall participation rate substantially. So, you know, making two decisions was, you know, drove it down some percentage versus one, three more than two, four more than three, five more than four, et cetera. And this, again, flies in the face of what the sort of conventional wisdom is that you'll hear, especially from the sort of policy experts. They'll say, you absolutely need to give people a choice of their inflation option, you know, that whether they're going to accept, you know, a sort of 5% compounded or a 3% or a CPI base. So that needs to be a choice. You also need to give them a choice of their daily benefit amount. You need to give them a choice of their lifetime benefit pool. You need to give them a choice of their elimination period. They should have a choice of whether they have non-forfeiture or return a premium and et cetera, et cetera. And all of those choices basically drive participation into the ground. The fewer choices, the better. That's all really people can handle. I think ultimately what people are looking for is a recommendation. One thing with a good, you know, good supports for it, the rational explanation for why this thing is a good idea, and and no other information whatsoever.
DavidIt sounds like that's the same reason, or probably a similar reason, why long-term care's cousin, individual DI, is so challenging a sale for most practitioners to make, is that there are just too many options and clients get overwhelmed with options.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah, it's not limited to that either. You hear the same criticism about annuities, you know, that is just these are overly complex. There's just all these different benefits that come with it, that are optional, you can do this and that and the other thing. I think that makes a lot of sense. That's what the evidence is telling us, that you really need to simplify. And uh I know it can be challenging, especially if you have an employer involved or consultants who want there to be options. They they kind of have this ingoing assumption that options are good, and that for the employer they can say, well, I've provided a bunch of options, and people then made their own decisions. That just doesn't that's not the way human nature works, unfortunately. And I think you know producers as well, you know, get very excited about all the different options that are available and and they want to demonstrate their understanding of it. Again, less is more.
DavidSince we're talking in small measure as well as large measure about how people make choices, there's a thing you talk about called focalism that I think people need to know more about. Can you explain what focalism is and how it enters the picture?
SPEAKER_02Sure. So focalism is a really interesting cognitive bias. Uh and and you know, for anybody who does any reading in in uh behavioral economics, there's a great sort of tradition of identifying these mental heuristics or or biases that we use and giving them little, you know, cute names. So focalism is this tendency to over-rely on the first piece of information that somebody gives you when making a decision. The way it shows up in long-term care insurance sales is, you know, people will, producer or employer, whatever the scenario might be, will put long-term care in front of somebody, usually for the first time that they've thought about this, actually planning for long-term care. What happens in that situation is you end up with a kind of over-reliance on this one piece of information to the exclusion of everything else. So you're you're thinking about what would happen to me if I was totally disabled? What would happen to me if I was cognitively impaired? Everything else goes away. That becomes an incredibly narrow perspective to have. And what happens is it interferes with the ability to actually plan. There was a one researcher who called it, you know, devalued future selves is the reason that people don't plan for elder care. They tend to devalue that future self as someone that they don't, you know, they don't like that person, you know, relative to who they are now, and they don't actually want to do anything to protect that person. The reason that that happens is because of focalism. So a good example of it was some work that was done on Living Wills, advanced directives. You know, they actually asked a whole series of very sick patients, you know, i, if what they what their care choices were, and looked at whether or not they had living wills in place or not. And what they found was that having the presence or absence of the living will had absolutely no ability to predict what they actually chose to do later in life. And it's essentially the same idea. The living will, you know, you're you're kind of at diagnosis saying, I don't want to live in that state. When you get to that state, all of a sudden you realize that there are maybe other reasons to live, uh, and you don't really want to withdraw care just by the same token with long-term care insurance. People don't want to buy it because they don't want to prepare for that eventuality. But when they get there, they certainly wish that they had. So again, focalism, over-reliance on that first piece of information to the exclusion of everything else. Again, it's the reason why we need a strongly positive positioning for this and other products to talk about the best possible life you could have with disability, not the worst possible life.
DavidInteresting. We've got a couple of minutes left. I'm curious, one of the things that you touch on in some of your research is is how storytelling, for lack of a better word, mitigates some of these biases, some of these challenges. How important is that for advisors in helping clients complete their plans?
SPEAKER_02Sure. Good example of that is some work that was done by Deborah Small and George Lowenstein and Paul Slovic at uh Carnegie Mellon and the Wharton School. They looked at whether you told a sort of a story about a person or whether you used statistics and talked about the sort of the extent of a problem. And what they were interested in was the extent to which people would give donations, you know, and it was a kind of a save the children kind of scenario. And they they gave one scenario that kind of talked about the number of children affected, the amount of the sort of uh rainfall deficit and the impact it had on uh food production, the number of people who face hunger, etc. Another story, they they in another case they told an actual compelling story about one girl, you know, a seven-year-old girl who faces hunger, and you know, with your contribution, her life will be better. What they found was that people were gave more than twice as much money in response to the one person than they did to the sort of the three million. And that kind of makes us sound like you know, bad people, but again, it's it's tailoring the information to match people's innate biases. So storytelling is absolutely critical, and the more you can make it about one person, not two people, not three people, not ten people, but one person, the more effective it will be. It's something that, you know, it certainly is not a new insight. Uh, you know, uh, Mother Teresa actually uh was one of the first to say this, you know, in a way that was repeated. Uh you know, if I think of the mass, I will never act, but if I think of the one, I will. And she kind of captures the spirit of this point very elegantly, that we will respond emotionally and we'll have empathy when we hear about one person's story that will get us to take action. As soon as we start talking about statistics, it becomes a thing called the drop-in-the-bucket effect, which really undermines anybody's uh willingness to actually take action.
DavidJeremy, if benefit advisors who aren't social scientists, who aren't PhDs in this area want to learn more about this to help them do a better job for their clients, where would you suggest they go?
SPEAKER_02So fortunately, there's a lot of great resources out there about this. You know, you can read the articles that we wrote for Ibris, that's one source, although it's not specifically about behavioral economics. There's a lot of examples in there if you're interested in long-term care. More broadly, there's a book called Nudge by Sunstein, and that is a great sort of overview of the way that behavioral economics can be used in a lot of different contexts, more again at the government level, but looking at you know, 401k saving and that sort of thing, and you see this a lot now, even in it's being adopted in 401k plans, this idea that you know you could basically commit today to increasing your contributions over time, you know, so taking advantage of temporal discounting and getting people to make healthy choices and kind of almost you know fooling them into doing things that are good for themselves. So Nudge is a great resource. Dan Arielli's book, Predictably Irrational, is another great resource. Kahneman's book, uh, Thinking Fast and Slow. So these are not hard to find. They're available pretty much everywhere, and uh highly recommend all of those.
DavidAnd we'll link to all of those in the bottom of the show notes. Jeremy Pinkis, principal of Forbes Consulting Group. Jeremy, thanks so much for sharing fascinating insights with our audience. My pleasure. Thanks a lot for having me, David. The Shift Shapers podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.