The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #109: Why Using Statistics in Your Long Term Care Marketing Process May Be Hurting Your Business – With Steve Cain
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week, we’re featuring an interview with Steve Cain, Principal and National Sales Leader at LTCI Partners, on the topic of the practice area that has completely redefined itself over the past few years – Long Term Care (LTC).
On this episode of the ShiftShapers Podcast, we discuss why using statistics to market LTC is no longer the best method to use and what advisors should change in their approach to achieve better results. We delve into the reason why Steve believes that Long Term Care is an event-triggered sale.
We also discuss the major differences between the first and second generations of LTC plans and why combo products have recently been getting quite a bit of traction. Join us to hear Steve’s advice on how to have the LTC conversation with employers, and discover the new types of plan designs that are being offered today.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- Whether advisors are using the right techniques to market LTC insurance.
- Why Steve believes that LTC is an event-triggered sale.
- The difference between first and second generation LTC plans.
- How behavioral finance factors into decision making.
- The new types of plan designs that are being sold today.
Do you want to know why the statistics that help you sell first-generation long-term care plans won't help you sell second-generation long-term care plans? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of the Shift Shapers Podcast is brought to you by Captivated Health, a captive insurance arrangement designed specifically for educational institutions. If you have clients in that vertical, you know the healthcare deck has been stacked against them. Today, Captivated Health offers the stability, control, and savings they've been waiting for. For more information, go to www.captivatedhealth.com or click on the company logo on the Shift Shapers website. How can you be the first to know about each week's podcast and get on the list for special listener-only content? It's simple. Go to ShiftShapersOnline.com and click the subscribe button. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're talking with Steve Kane. Steve is principal and national sales leader at LTCI Partners, and we're going to talk about a practice area which has almost completely redefined itself over the last few years, and that's long-term care. So with that, welcome Steve. Hey, thanks, David. So before we talk about different product types or we dig into some of the more granular stuff, a top-level question. Are advisors using the right techniques to engage prospects and clients?
SPEAKER_02Well, some are, but but you know, we've really taken a hard look at this and tried to study behavioral finance or behavioral economics, not only with some of the stuff we're reading as a firm or the stuff I'm personally reading, but we're trying to do a better job of understanding, predicting, and influencing consumers' behavior. And if you look at the long-term care world, we did all that with statistics, which hasn't really worked. You know, statistics really create debate rather than action. So we've we've pounded, you know, consumers out there saying, hey, 70% of people over the age of 65 are going to need this. Here's the average cost of long-term care, yet people aren't taking action. There's a disconnect or there's irrational behavior. So, in my opinion, there are some folks out there that are doing it holistically, they're doing it with storytelling, but by and large, the industry has done it with stats, and I don't know that it's served us well.
DavidWell, I know one of the things that you say when you educate advisors is that long-term care is an event-triggered sale. What do you mean by that?
SPEAKER_02Well, we really think that this has got to be on your mind. Not only does it have to be something that makes sense for you financially and and from an age standpoint, but we feel that that it's an event-triggered sale in that at some point in your life there's going to be an event that makes you take action on seeking out or purchasing insurance. It could be a birthday, it could be like me recently dealing with my mom's long-term care event, it could be an accident that somebody close to you or someone has themselves, and that's going to push them into taking action about this issue.
DavidIn terms of the product mix, I mean, when we started, it was all standalone long-term care plans, and there were different varieties of them, but basically they were standalone. And today what we're seeing is a lot of growth in what we call combo plans. And I think it's bringing some life folks over to selling LTC and understanding that that's a uh an integral part of what they're doing, and it's doing the same thing for the long-term care folks. What happened to the standalone products and why did these I know there's still some out there, but why do these combo products all of a sudden seem to be getting such traction?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I think we're in a really interesting time as it relates to insurance solutions around long-term care planning. As we see this shift in demographics in our country, there's a real need because of the pressure on Medicare and other entitlement programs, there's a real need for individuals to plan. And so, you know, what we saw was Generation One long-term care was about 30 years ago when these products really came about. So it's an immature product line compared to other product lines, and you have longevity issues, a higher number of claims versus expected, low lapse rates in terms of people hanging on to these policies, and then record low interest rates that we're seeing today. And that's the recipe for pain, unfortunately, for some of our manufacturers or carrier partners. This is what created a situation where we've seen suspension of sales or outright exits out of the marketplace, and then of course enforced rate increases where carriers are trying to work hard to get back to even on some of these older blocks of business. So really what we've seen is first generation long-term care is over. We've seen some departures, we've seen constriction in the marketplace, and second generation long-term care has begun, and that's with products that have more current actuarial assumptions, but also the result has been more of these combination products. So I don't necessarily think it's a bad thing. I just think the market is kind of figuring itself out. You know, where does standalone make sense and what size of the market is that going to be? Where do these combination plans make sense? But overall, I still think there's a tremendous opportunity with this type of planning. You know, if you look at private insurance in terms of solving people's long-term care problems, it's only about 7 or 8% of the overall pie. So there's a ton of opportunity and certainly a lot more options today.
DavidSo how do these combination products differ? Because I'm an old life guy and you know, I keep up. We have life with accidental death benefit, we have life with chronic illness, chronic disease riders. How do these products differ?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I would say when you when you look at the long-term care solutions out there, you have standalone long-term care insurance, as we discussed, then you have life insurance with qualified long-term care riders, meaning the benefit triggers are exactly the same, the language of the riders are exactly the same as a standalone product. It is considered long-term care insurance. And again, you're looking at either universal life or whole life as the chassis with a qualified long-term care rider. So what this is creating is a situation where win, lose, or draw, I get something as a consumer. You know, I'm able to either have my family receive a death benefit, or I've got a defined pool of long-term care dollars. And this has really been something that uh has appealed to consumers out there who say, well, wait a second, I don't know if I want to pay in this standalone long-term care for the rest of my life and maybe never need it. And uh, you know, that use or lose objection is overcome with this product.
DavidI think it may surprise some people to know that there are also annuity products that have long-term care or chronic riders. Are you seeing a lot of play in those?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we are, and and and frankly, they're uh unfortunately really hurt right now in terms of the leverage that those products create because of the interest rate environment. We are seeing a lot of activity in that marketplace, carriers who are creating products or enhancing products to have long-term care components. And we really think that um what we're going to see is when interest rates go up, we're gonna see these become much more popular because the leverage is gonna be better.
DavidAnd these are all deferred annuities. So you're talking about whether they're single premium or multiple premium, it's a rider that can be bolted onto a traditional annuity chassis.
SPEAKER_02That's correct. And and again, uh I I look at it and you just have more options. Yes, the long-term care on the standalone side, that market has contracted, there's fewer players in it. You know, today's product or products are more responsibly priced, but as a consumer or as an advisor, you just have a lot more options. And and it comes down to what's the best fit. I mean, every day we get questions from advisors out there or consumers that say, Hey, what's the best product? And uh, you know, I really think the best product is the one that works at claim time, number one.
DavidAlways.
SPEAKER_02But beyond that, it's you know, what are we trying to accomplish here? You know, is it a situation where somebody's planning and needing life insurance, and then you can add on an additional rider at a low premium load? Or is somebody looking to solve a long-term care problem, and that'll usually dictate the recommendation that the advisors make.
DavidBefore we finish with annuities, one quick question. Are are those riders also available on index products?
SPEAKER_02I I've started to see some of that today, yes, where it's a chronic care kicker. You know, I'm not sure which product's out there, but I have read and seen some carriers who are adding that.
DavidSo let's go back to something, because we always like to talk about, you know, kind of what does the advisor conversation look like. Let's go back to something that you mentioned at the open, which is this whole notion of behavioral economics in long-term care. What does that mean? What are the s what are you finding? W what kind of things are coming to your attention that are leading you to the conclusion that trying to sell this statistically is not the best way?
SPEAKER_02Well, we've all, you know, you we've all been in those situations, you know, where you where you share with somebody the hard numbers, the reality that one of two of you, if it's a couple, are gonna need this at some point, or you as an individual, it it's likely that you're gonna need this. And uh when you tell somebody that 70% of people are gonna need it, they're thinking, oh, those poor 70%, you know, I'm in that 30%. You know, it's it's not gonna happen to me. And then also you show somebody what the average cost of care is for a private facility or for a high-end home health care agency to come into your home, and oftentimes you paralyze them with that number. And so what we've tried to do really is get a client to say yes. And and what I mean by that is not yes to the coverage, but yes to the issue. One of the biggest unfunded liabilities in somebody's retirement portfolio is healthcare. You know, big picture healthcare. We're gonna live longer, there's gonna be medical advances, we're gonna eat and exercise better. Am I gonna outlive my money? And what if I have a healthcare event in my retirement years? How am I gonna handle it? So, what we suggest is get your client to say, yeah, this is a real issue, and and I've got to address that issue, and you can address that issue in a few different ways. You can self-insure, and and what does that look like? Where how are we gonna finance this? Who's gonna be the quarterback during a care event, or you look to insurance and then look through the different options that we just discussed and figure out what's the best plan. But at the end of the day, what you're trying to do is get the client to do something, you know, to create a bona fide strategy to manage a long-term care event from a caregiving perspective or from a financial perspective.
DavidSo for some benefit advisors, if I understand you correctly, their focus would change from being maybe more of immediate needs to looking in a more, as you use the word, holistic manner, looking at a long-term client continuum, correct?
SPEAKER_02Correct. And and what we've also seen benefit advisors have success with is to kind of wrap this into the financial wellness and retirement readiness conversations that you're having. Look, we're we're all trying to appeal to a consumer that's short on time, that doesn't want to think about a chronic illness or a disability. So the best way to have this conversation resonate with those folks is talk to them about protecting the integrity of their 401ks. Talk to them uh about protecting their retirement plans, and you do that by wrapping it into those programs. And look, we've done a good job as an industry with upscale clients, with wealthier clients, the market penetration, whether it's with standalone products or these combination products, is okay when we look at the data. But 99% of America buys their insurance at work. And so benefit advisors have a significant opportunity to go to their corporate clients and talk to them about protecting the integrity of their 401ks or providing that financial education as it relates to this benefit.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Captivated Health is a single source solution for your clients and prospects who are in the education vertical. The founders of Captivated Health have nearly 20 years' experience working with educational institutions, and over that time, they've developed a keen understanding of the unique problems these clients experience. Frustrated by a lack of control, the unpredictability of ever increasing health care costs, and the pressures and regulations of the Affordable Care Act, these groups have been adrift in the fully insured commercial marketplace until now. Captivated Health has built a program that solves those problems, and it does so with virtually no disruption to faculty and staff while saving clients millions of dollars. We wanted you to be among the first to know that Captivated Health is building a national distribution partner network so you can bring this cutting-edge solution to the educational clients you advise. To learn more about the Captivated Health solution, go to their website at www.captivatedhealth.com or click on their logo on the Shift Shapers website. And now back to our interview. Beyond a group chassis, are there also opportunities for multi-life sales?
SPEAKER_02That's where we've seen the shift. There is one carrier that's active using a group product or group chassis, but we've seen a shift to multi-life products. Right now there are two or three multi-life products on the marketplace, and I'm encouraged that we'll likely see additional companies come into the business, whether it's this calendar year or the beginning of next year. I'm not at liberty to share which ones because I've signed NDAs, but I I think the carriers are looking at this saying, hey, multi-life's where it's at, uh, where you have a group that you're going after, provide simplified underwriting, unisex rates. We're going to find younger buyers, and typically buyers that aren't buying as much as an affluent consumer out there, so it's less risky for the carrier if you can say that. And really that's the trend that we've been seeing. I don't anticipate more carriers entering with a group chassis, but these multi-life chassis seem to be the trend as to what the carriers want to do. I don't anticipate carriers coming in and offering true group product with guarantee issue. We've learned as an industry, and frankly, uh, from the carrier standpoint, most feel that it's more beneficial to them and the consumers to have these individual contracts with unisex rates and underwriting concessions versus group products. But again, we do have one group carrier out there that's very active in the business.
DavidSo the multi-life on long-term care is pretty analogous to multi-life on an individual disability sale.
SPEAKER_02You got it. You know, we're we're not seeing the guarantee issue, but that's typically what it is. It's fully portable. So you got to ask yourself, why would an employer do this if it's voluntary? Right? If they're not funding it, why would an employer do it? Well, there's ease of access in terms of securing the coverage. There's an educational component, whether it's done online or face-to-face. And again, there's slight discounts in pricing, but what you're doing is allowing somebody access to this individual contract that's fully portable.
DavidAre there minimum, generally speaking, I I know you don't want to name particular carriers, but generally speaking, is there a minimum number of employees necessary in order to enact a multi-life sale?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and it's going to vary by the carrier, but I would say ten active or eligible employees might be the magic number with a couple carriers right now. And you know, as the carriers gain more experience, they're looking for more eligibles than that. But I would say whether you're working in the small group market, mid-market, or large market, there are options out there. And it just depends on what type of option. Typically, we're seeing more funding with closely held small businesses, and then as you get larger, we're seeing more voluntary plans.
DavidNow you said that there's no guarantee issue. We're not seeing that, but are there underwriting concessions?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. I mean, you're looking at simplified in issue underwriting. You're looking at six to seven what we consider knockout medical questions. Now, the seventh question is usually like 25 part. You know, we joke around with advisors that there's a kind of a dreaded disease list. Do you have this, this, and that? But what we're seeing within our book of business is about a 98% approval rate for that simplified underwriting. So we make sure that when we're working with brokers or or employers, that we manage everybody's expectations, share what the questions are, and uh, unless you've had a couple conditions that that are red flags, most people are getting this coverage.
DavidBut the same triggers, the same ADLs, that hasn't changed.
SPEAKER_02No, I mean the the coverage is the same as an individual long-term care contract. That's exactly what's issued. You just have these concessions that are built into these programs. And what we've tried to do is really take the model of the large group market and distribute and implement these plans so that it looks, smells, feels, acts like any other group benefit.
DavidSo if an advisor isn't in today, isn't in that market today, and they want to get involved, how do you counsel them? What do you tell them to do? How do they educate themselves? What are those conversations, those beginning conversations with prospects and clients like?
SPEAKER_02You know, I I always I always joke around with folks that people are down, and it's just human nature. People are down on what they're not up on. And, you know, when you engage an advisor and share with them that the market's not over, you know, frankly, that that's one of the biggest challenges that we face is producer or advisor apathy. When you share with advisors that it's not dead, it's just different. You know, they certainly open up to it, and then you speak to some of the success that you're having. And I'm I'm a big fan of kind of sharing an island of success, going through a case study, asking an advisor, do you have a client that looks like this, and then sharing an idea or sharing a success story about a group like that. I think there's a a ton of information out there as it relates to long-term care, whether it's through distributors, whether it's online, you know, generic websites or ltc.gov. There's a number of resources out there that at your fingertips that you can go out there and find.
DavidSteve, we've got a couple of minutes left, and we we usually like to wrap up our interviews by asking our subject matter experts, what do you see the future bringing? Where do you see this going near-term, midterm, long-term? What's the glide path for long-term care?
SPEAKER_02You know, I'm active in the industry and sit on a number of uh advisory committees, and I'm active with Nahu, and Nahu just put out a position paper on long-term care insurance, really asking for help from the federal government to create some tax incentives for employers or individuals to purchase this. You know, I I think at some point, if there's real look, a real look given to a penalty-free withdrawal from a 401k or an IRA, or making this a pre-tax purchase, you know, that would open up the floodgates as it relates to long-term care insurance. Until then, I think what we're seeing is just it's getting easier to talk about. You know, everybody has got uh somebody that they know in their life that's gone through a long-term care situation. So as we speak to employers, I don't have to tell them what long-term care is anymore. Now, we certainly have to tell them about product, but they get the issue. So I think the standalone long-term care market probably not gonna fly because the other product lines that we talked about, the annuities and the combinations, but where we're gonna see significant growth in the standalone market is in the work site with these multi-life plans. So I think regulators, I think carriers realize there's a place and there's a need for this planning, and over time, I think we're gonna see less denial simply because we're going through this stuff.
DavidSteve, thanks. It's a great place to end our conversation for today. We hope you'll come back. Steve Kane, principal and national sales leader at LTCI Partners. Steve, thanks so much. Thank you. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.