The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #104: Increasing Engagement with Telemedicine – With Lena Cheng
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In previous ShiftShapers episodes, we’ve talked quite a bit about telemedicine and the role it plays in today’s benefits arena. On this episode, we’re pleased to talk with Dr. Lena Cheng, the Vice President of Medical Affairs at Doctor on Demand, about how to increase employee engagement in telemedicine.
How can benefit advisors help employers to understand the telemedicine value proposition and what can they do to assure successful implementation and utilization? Don’t miss this important discussion on what it takes to build a consumer-grade front door to medicine and to create a different consumer experience.
What You’ll Learn From this Episode:
- What consumers want from a telemedicine platform.
- How to deliver on-demand care within 3 minutes.
- Whether there is a demonstrable, repeatable ROI yet.
- The role doctor training plays in the success of a telemedicine platform.
- What “design-centric” thinking is all about.
- How we can learn from other industries.
How do you build a consumer-grade front door to medicine? And what are the long-term benefits of creating a different member experience? We'll find out on this episode of Chift Papers.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_00Either paralyzes or energize it. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Chip Papers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from business and entrepreneurs who have successfully checked the chips and registry. Get ready to become the change that you want to study. Here's your host and chip transformation strategist, David Salton.
DavidThis episode of Chip Papers is brought to you by Benazon Healthcare Advocacy. Your clients and their employees expect more service, more responsiveness, and more help than ever before. You need to focus on building your book. How do you do both? Bennazon. To learn more, go to Benazon.com or click the Benizon logo at the top of the ShiftShapersOnline.com page. How can you be the first to know about each week's podcast and get on the list for special listener-only content? It's simple. Go to ShiftShapersOnline.com and click the subscribe button. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're pleased to be talking with Dr. Lena Chang. She is the vice president of medical affairs at Doctor On Demand, and some of you may know Doctor on Demand is thought of as a telemedicine firm, and that's certainly what they deliver. We've talked a lot on the podcast in previous interviews about telemedicine, and we all understand what an important and growing part it has to be of everybody's business. But we're not going to talk about telemedicine directly. What we're going to talk about is the engagement or really the lack thereof, and it's something that Dr. Chang has studied extensively. I mean, I Dr. Chang, I saw a recent Harris poll that said 130 million visits are expected telemedicine visits by 2018. And 70% of consumers who are asset they would use telemedicine. So what's the problem?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a great question, David. So there really is tremendous interest in telemedicine, and certainly that's what we're hearing and seeing from employers. If we look at the data, you take a look at the NBGH survey that they that they did sort of mid-year and reported on mid-year, of their members that they surveyed, you know, mostly large and jumbo employers, they're seeing that over 70, 75% of those folks, of those companies, are offering telemedicine in some form. But you're right, that that's what they're facing is they're seeing very low utilization. And, you know, if you look at what's what's been going on with telemedicine, it's been around for about 10 years for employers. And I have to say a lot has happened in that time. Newer versions of telemedicine have launched. And it's really like the difference between, you know, like an AOL and Google. Next generation models have consumer grade patient experiences and also have that back-end enterprise capability that HR directors need to integrate it into their benefit programs. So a lot has changed in that time.
DavidWell, but there's been a significant amount of interest, as you say, and there's been some takeup. And the difference between a telemedicine visit and an urgent care visit in terms of cost is humongous. In generation one, and we'll talk about generation two and what's coming in a few minutes, but in generation one, have employers really realized any significant savings?
SPEAKER_02I don't think that they have. What we're hearing from a lot of the employers that we speak with is they're seeing utilization in the single digits, the low single digits, about 1 to 2%. And even when you take into consideration the survey that Towers Watson did in the healthcare changes ahead survey in 2014, they found that that utilization was around 7%. So higher, but still I think that that takes into consideration all forms of telemedicine, including nurse lines and telephone calls. So, you know, the numbers are not are really not that interesting.
DavidYou mentioned something that those of us who are kind of geek-oriented understand, and that is that presentation layer's consumer experience is king. Is that the entry point to starting to change the behavior around people actually engaging rather than being infatuated with telemedicine?
SPEAKER_02Well, I certainly think it is. I think at the end of the day, people want to know that they matter. And when you take a typical healthcare experience, such as trying to find a new primary care physician, making an appointment with that physician, and then actually going through the struggles and the hassles of actually making that appointment happen, you know, fighting traffic and sitting in the waiting room and so forth. The experience leaves people feeling like they don't matter because they have to wait, they have to fill out a lot of paperwork. It's really a lot of the burden of that visit is placed onto them. With next generation telemedicine, it's really all about simplifying and humanizing the healthcare experience. It's focused on design-centric thinking, and it's making healthcare as easy and as straightforward as possible. And really it mimics what we've done in other industries and what we've seen going on, such as in banking or car insurance and travel, you know, booking hotels and flights and making restaurant reservations. We want to make healthcare as easy as possible.
DavidSo, other than traditional physician training, which goes back, hasn't arguably changed for 50, 60, 70 years in terms of experience and how patients are handled and brought through a system, exacerbated, of course, by the weird medical system we've had in this country. Other than that, I mean, how do you start making that change? What are the gateways? What do you have to do?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we gave this a lot of thought at Doctor on Demand before we embarked in this industry. And before we even had our first product, we thought about, thought carefully about how to do this. We talked to lots of employers to understand what they were seeing and the barriers that their employees were were facing when it came to utilization. And what we learned is that these products were difficult to use. They were very clunky from a technology standpoint. You usually had to maybe download something in order to access your password. And they were mostly telephone-based models. So we actually decided to launch our product to consumers first. We knew that in sort of a very pure way, consumers would tell us through their behavior what was working and what wasn't. In other words, we could analyze how they were interacting with our app. Every click, swipe, tap, anywhere where they were getting stuck, anything that was working well for them, we could see that through their interaction with the app. And so it really wasn't until we were fully satisfied with the feedback we were getting from them, the reviews, uh, we could see through our analytics that the app was seamless in its usage that we decided then to roll this out into employers and health plans.
DavidWell, far be it from me to suggest that the most difficult thing in the universe to change is anything other than human behavior, but what did you find? What do consumers want? If a benefit advisor is looking for a platform, what are the elements that they ought to look for in order to try to drive higher engagement?
SPEAKER_02Well, it has to be an experience that is consumer grade, meaning right now what we're seeing in the marketplace is that people are, uh, first of all, they're they're all using mobile devices. So it has to be a mobile option. It has to be as easy to use as you know, the countless number of really popular consumer apps that are out there, whether it's Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Google, it has to be that easy to use. You cannot have any training involved, any instructions. You just have to download the app and start using it. And it has to be that easy. So that at a very basic level is what you need to have to actually get someone to use it and not have any barriers to trying the service and then becoming a repeat user. So that's I think the the first thing. The second second thing is from a clinical standpoint, from a patient experience standpoint, you need to offer on-demand care. You need to be able to, you know, give someone access to a provider in three minutes or less. And it really needs to be also very, very high quality care. And that comes down to hiring physicians that are specifically trained in telemedicine and where there's a quality assurance system that's really centered around that.
DavidWell, and you you raise an interesting issue. And how do you train physicians who have not really been focused on this part of the process in their training, in their traditional training? Is that starting to change? Are medical schools dealing with this? Is this post-medical education? How do you get physicians who are sensitive to these issues and who put them forward?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that was a serious issue that we wanted to address from the very beginning. And what we did was we created a full set of evidence-based clinical protocols, over 200 of them focused on the most common issues in urgent care. And we trained our physician on those. And first, actually, you know, I'll back up for a bit. First, what we did is we were very careful in the way we found our physicians and hired them. We screened, vetted, and interviewed really thousands of physicians to come up with the then the core physicians who support our panel. And it was really only about 20% of those candidates that we decided to keep on and have them practice through our model. Because we were looking for not just the clinical acumen, the you know, the ability to make really critical uh decisions through the telemedicine platform, through a video platform, but also we wanted those folks that had that EQ, you know, that bedside manner that helps to make up for the fact that they're not in the same room with patients. So that at the very foundation was how we started. And then we took them through a clinically evidence-based clinical protocol training process through which they they learned how to actually kind of rewire their brains and think about urgent care issues in terms of video medicine. Now, I really believe that telemedicine is going to be a sort of a specialty within medicine itself. It is a very different way of treating patients, and you do need to have certain skills and knowledge in place in order to make appropriate clinical decisions.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Today you're being pulled in multiple directions. Employers want you to deliver a higher level of service and employee satisfaction, and you want more time to grow your business. How do you do both? Bennazon Healthcare Advocacy is the answer. Bennazon helps plan members understand, utilize, and maximize their health plan, and answers their benefits questions while you improve productivity, increase client retention, and grow your book. The best part about partnering with Benizon is that your agency gets all the credit. Clients see your logo, while the Bennazon team of subject matter experts work to ensure resolution to specific member information and service requests. Each agency gets a dedicated telephone number and year-round 24-7 customer support that answers the phone with your agency name. Turn your benefit on with Benazon. For more information, go to www.benizon.com or click their logo on the Shift Shapers website. Benizon. Healthcare as it should be. Now, back to our interview. A few weeks back we spoke to Dr. Eric Topel, who wrote a really fascinating book, I'm sure you're aware of, called The Patient Will See You Now. And his entire thesis is that the worldwide rapid adoption of smartphones has the potential, more than any other single thing, to change these kinds of physician encounters. And then a few weeks later, we spoke with Samir Kamar, and Sam runs a company called Medline, which is a direct primary care practice, but he's bringing out a device called Medwand, which will allow physicians who are doing these telemedicine visits to get more metrics about their patient. Do you see devices like that becoming ubiquitous and enriching the patient experience and the physician's ability to diagnose well as we move into the future as being something that might also drive engagement?
SPEAKER_02I absolutely do. And actually, um Medwand and Samir, they're partners of ours. We work closely with them. We are the telemedicine platform that supports that device. So I guess the way I would answer that is that today, our physicians do really, I think they practice the best form of medicine that they're able to through video. The next kind of iteration and where we're going is supporting their decision making with objective data that can be captured through devices such as the Medwand. And, you know, when you think about all those amazing devices that are out there, there's the Clinton Cloud Wireless Stethoscope through which you can listen to lung sounds, heart sounds. There's the Cellscope Otoscope, there's the eye health blood pressure cuff and glucometer. All of these devices we're integrating through our platform so that our, we can really empower our physicians with that patient-generated data so that they can they can make more nuanced diagnoses and frankly, you know, make a wider range of diagnoses. What we're also doing is integrating with physical lab facilities such as LabCore and Quest so that that can supplement their clinical decision making as well.
DavidSo almost all of our listeners are benefit advisors or engaged in providing advice to employers about employee benefits. If there's been no real significant, demonstrable, repeatable ROI in telemedicine as of yet, how would you advise a benefit advisor to make the case to an employer that this is a worthwhile path to follow?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a great question. I think generally, and we we talk about this a lot, we ask our employers and our benefit advisors and consultants to forget what they think they know about telemedicine. So, as I mentioned at the beginning, you know, telemedicine has been around for a while, but it really is like night and day. With next generation models, it is so different. To make the case for a next generation model, I think at the very core of it, you need to look at the patient experience and take a look at how that product has performed with the consumer market. Take a look at the App Store reviews, the Google Play reviews. See what real everyday people are saying and doing with these apps. And if you can find success there, then the next step is to look at how well does this company integrate on the back end? You know, can this company do eligibility checks and claim filing real time? Can they integrate with any health plan carrier? You know, how seamlessly can a company do that so that it doesn't add more work for an HR director? So if you can find a company that can do both really well, that really forms the basis of a great partnership. And then you need to find a company that after that deal is signed and after the telemedicine solution has been integrated into the benefits program, what is that telemedicine company going to do to partner with the HR department to ensure that telemedicine is successful within that employee population? The old model is well, you know, let's get telemedicine on board. We're charging a PEPM fee. And so once that deal is signed, you know, we as a company we just don't have the incentive to get people to use this program. Well, things are different now. The PEPM fees are really a thing of the past or a thing that is associated with the legacy telemedicine options. And now the new model is you pay for the healthcare services that are actually used. So a really forward-thinking telemedicine company will say, we're going to partner with you to make sure that telemedicine usage is optimized and we're going to help you through marketing communication programs and engagement programs to ensure that every employee knows what this is, knows how to use it appropriately, and is reminded, and this is sort of kept top of mind for them throughout the year.
DavidAs the model's changing, do you foresee a day when there will be, and I don't know the a better term for this, but involved in the sale, a service-level agreement, which either guarantees to hit certain targets of engagement or adoption?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell I do think that that is an interesting option. And I think that given that, you know, it's estimated that a third of all ambulatory visits, medical visits in this country could be replaced by some form of telemedicine. But yet, you know, we're we're only seeing with legacy models uh utilization, as I said, in sort of the one to two percent range. I think it's reasonable to expect that we would see utilization sort of in, you know, at least in the in the 10% range. And whether that's sort of a firm, you know, service level agreement or it's a uh it's a goal that is set between the telemedicine service provider and the employer, I do think that there needs to be some expectations that are set on the type of utilization that a company is hoping to see and what a telemedicine company is able to do to help achieve that goal. But also, you know, it brings the employer into the mix as well. It says to the employer, if you do want to have a certain level of success with telemedicine, there are things, there are definitive things that that company can do to give the telemedicine company the access to patients through direct mail, through email, through posters in the break room. There are things that employers can do to help ensure that telemedicine is successful.
DavidAaron Powell One of the things that you touched on a while back, I'd like to kind of circle back on. We understand that these programs, on the benefit advisor side, we understand that these programs are oftentimes easier to integrate in a self-insured environment. But you mentioned carrier integration. And I know for an awful lot of electronic initiatives, that's been a sticking point in the past. Are you starting to see carriers come along and kind of drag themselves into the more current environment and be more forthcoming and more welcoming of integrating with external services?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell They absolutely are. We're definitely seeing movement in that area. I think more and more carriers are recognizing that telemedicine is of great interest to employers and that many times these employers will want to choose the service provider uh that they want. And that involves integration so that it can, you know, on the back end really serve the employers appropriately. So we're we're seeing a lot of uh a lot of movement in that area. And uh where previously there might have been some reluctance, I see a lot more willingness to work with us on those things.
DavidWell, that's certainly good news. We've got about a minute or so left, and we always like to wrap up by asking our guests what they see in their subject field. What do you see the future looking like? And you can define that near-term, long-term, short-term, however you like. But what's coming? What's the cool stuff that you guys are just starting to think about?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell What we're most excited about at Doctor on Demand is being that front door to healthcare. That's really where we see ourselves going. And we think that a video telemedicine solution is absolutely poised to do that. With mobile usage going the way it is, and with high-quality care being available through a video option, and with the integration with digital health devices and insurance carriers, the telemedicine industry and a solid video option is really poised to be healthcare's new front door. That's really where we aim to go.
DavidWell, that's a great place to leave it for now until we can start knocking on that new front door. Dr. Lena Chang, Vice President of Medical Affairs at Doctor on Demand. Thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_02Thanks for having me, David.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Strategic Vision Publishing and David Saltzman. This podcast may not be reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express written permission of the producers. All rights reserved.