The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #85: Is Your Communication Data Secure? – With Ari Gardner
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
One of the things that’s always at the forefront of everyone’s mind today, as well as an expectation from clients, is the ability to keep all of the appropriate communications secured. And it isn’t just good business – it is the law. Ari Gardner, the Director of Sharefile for Insurance at Citrix, is one of the foremost subject matter experts and we were pleased to have the opportunity to interview him about what advisors and firms need to know on this critical component of our business.
Many practitioners believe that data security is a federally induced and regulated mandate. Ari points out that there are state requirements as well and we explore how advisors can comply with both. He explains which data exactly needs to be secured and why, as well as the importance of having a comprehensive system that makes the process easy and which integrates easily in all the ways we communicate today. Listen in as we discuss what you need to know to be able to offer your clients an easy-to-deploy secure environment that meets and exceeds current legal requirements.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Where the secure file and email sharing first intersected with the health and employee benefits universe.
- Whether these regulations are all Federal or state driven, and which takes precedence.
- The importance of ease of use and user experience.
- The additional considerations when using mobile devices.
- The meaning of the different security standards.
- The data storage requirements and how they differ from the communication requirements.
Secure data and communications has to be part of all advisors' toolkits. What do you need to know to offer your clients a secure environment that needs and exceeds current legal requirements and that's easy to deploy across all your systems and devices? We'll find out on this episode of the first time. Announcing a stand the agency growth and leadership side that's coming to Nashville Tennessee this January. A stand is a fresh interactive experience exclusively for benefit agency leaders and focused on providing practical and proven strategies to help you maximize your growth. This isn't just a bunch of talking heads. It's a hands-on, take it home and implemented ideas and tools meeting. I'm going to be there, and I'm so spiked about this meeting that I've arranged a special discount just for Shift Papers listeners. To get all of the details, go to www.shiftpapersonline.com and click on the ascend logo at the top right. Thanks for being among the thousands of Shift Papers listeners who tune in each week. Talk about ideas, techniques, and best practices that help you to build your knowledge base and your practice. I know many of you subscribe on iTunes and Stitcher so that you get each week's podcast delivered as soon as it goes live. And that's a great way to get the jump on every new episode to make it even easier. And for those of you who may not be iTunes or Stitcher users, we've added an exciting new feature to the ShiftShapersOnline.com website. If you click the new subscribe button, we'll automatically notify you the minute each new episode is published, and we'll also send you a short description showing who we're chatting with and what we're discussing. And it will let us notify you about some upcoming special offers, online content, and webinars we're building just for Shift Shapers listeners. So go to www.shift shapersonline.com and click the subscribe button. Our motto is listen, learn, profit. Now you have a way to do that ahead of the crowd. Subscribe today. One of the things that's always on everybody's mind, especially in today's litigious environment, and frankly, with talking to clients, it's an expectation, is the ability to keep all of the appropriate communications secured. And we wanted to find somebody who has had real depth of knowledge on the subject. And so today we're pleased to welcome Ari Gardner. Ari is director of Sharefile for Insurance specifically at Citrix. Ari, welcome to the Shift Shapers Podcast. Thanks, David. We appreciate you spending some time with us today. Let's go back to the beginning. When did all of this discussion and thought process about secure communications enter the our universe?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a really great question. So HIPAA has been around since 1996. But really what most people are familiar with is the state data breach laws, and that's one of the things that's kind of been in the forefront. HIPAA has really gotten a lot of attention, I would say, within the last five or ten years specifically. But PII, personally identifiable info, has got to be encrypted under the 47 state data breach laws. This is a law that trails all the way back to California in 2003. It is a state that started this. Any two factors of PII, it's typically a name in combination with any other element. So a name and an address, a name and a birth date, a name and a policy number. Any two factors that a business entity is sending, it's not unique to the insurance industry. It's any business entity, which is interesting, has this state law to encrypt the data. So that's really one of the things that people are concerned with is the PII. And HIPAA has actually been around longer. Many PHI protected health info has got to be encrypted. That's been a law since 96. It's my personal belief that with mobile, with you know being able to work remotely, mobile work styles, it's really become in the forefront. And so really now HIPAA is the nasty one that everyone's worried about because it's a federal law, not a state law. So the fines are more severe, the laws are a little bit tighter. So I think people ultimately now are more concerned with PHI, but PII has been kind of the staple because everyone's got to worry about it.
DavidSo it's it's not just federal, despite what most of us may think, just that HIPAA kind of put a spotlight on turned up the amperage a little bit on us in our industry.
SPEAKER_01Exactly, exactly. So 47 states have that state law defining any PII has got to be encrypted. Um again, trailing from California in 2003. Uh the top three most strict states are incidentally Massachusetts being number one most strict for PII, followed by California and then Nevada. Minnesota and Florida are two states that in 2014 tightened up that data breach law. Florida's is now called the Florida Information Protection Act of 2014. So they tightened up the law, tightened up the signs surrounding that. The only three states that do not have data breach laws still are South Dakota, New Mexico, and Alabama. Rumor has it, Alabama and New Mexico will uh be 48 and 49 shortly.
DavidSo if you're practicing in one of those states, do you follow the federal requirements or the state requirements, or is one broader than the other?
SPEAKER_01So yeah, if you're in one of the 47 states, you need to worry about both. So any PII that you're handling, any PHI obviously would be anywhere. So even the three states that do not have state neighborage laws, you still have to worry about the federal law, obviously. So you'd still need to be concerned with any kind of PHI you're handling under HIPAA, high-tech, those types of things.
DavidSo would your advice to benefit advisors be, regardless of where you're practicing, just take into account both of those things for safety's sake?
SPEAKER_01100%. So I would recommend really any business entity, particularly dealing with benefits, because you typically deal with more sensitive info than other businesses, perhaps. So I would definitely recommend no matter what you're doing, if it's for business, you need to be securing the data. It's just a business expense. Um you want to find someone that does easy and takes the guesswork out of it, obviously, but definitely you want to be securing all of your stuff.
DavidSo let's talk about what actually needs to be secure, because I know there's a lot of confusion about whether it's just emails or it's emails and files or whatever. What kind of electronic information needs to be secured?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, really great question. So if we start with the basic info, PII is any basic personally identifiable information. That's what PII stands for. So it's a name in combination with any other element. So basically anything that somebody can use to take out uh a credit card in your name or anything like that. So a name and a social, a name and a birth date, a name and a policy number, a name and a driver's license number. So any two factors of basic info has got to be secured. Uh and then PHI is really any protected health info at all. So anything about the status of someone's health, a provision of health care, any kind of payment information regarding health care. Um certainly if we're talking with folks that are dabbling in in life insurance, we've got to worry about any kind of APS forms that you're handling, things like that where there's a medical history, any kind of health info. So it really kind of ups the ante. So it's not just the personal info, but it's also the medical stuff. That's specifically what PHI is targeting. So I definitely want to worry about all that stuff. So any any state that you're in, you really got to worry about it.
DavidSo if I were transmitting, let's say, a health insurance quote with no identifiable information, that wouldn't necessarily need to be secured, would it?
SPEAKER_01If the quote has PII on it, yes. So there might not be any health information, so maybe in that instance you don't need to worry about the HIPAA rule. But if you do have a name with any other element, yes, you definitely would want to secure it under the state laws. So I would just say encrypt everything, and that way you're not worried about it, and that way you're you're mitigating all that risk.
DavidNow, one of the things that we know, I mean, I I worked as president of a software company for about a year and a half, and I know it's an industry that you've been in for a long time. Years ago, this wasn't quite as important, but today the user experience, the piece that's client-facing, all those presentation layers are very important. So if I'm a benefit advisor and I'm I'm looking to find a system that isn't so complicated that my folks will actually use it and that I can explain it to people, et cetera, what are the things that I ought to be looking for?
SPEAKER_01Definitely. Um I think you hit it on the head. I think ease of use is by far the most important because if you have something complicated, it's unlikely that your customers, your clients are going to be utilizing it. You're gonna get a phone call, hey, how do I use this? I can't open this email. So really just to expedite your workflow, expedite your cycle, keep a nice smooth ship. You want to avoid any kind of complicated system. So you definitely want to get something that's gonna keep it simple. Ease of use is the big thing. Other than that, you really got to worry about who is handling the data and how they're handling it. So you definitely want to go with a big company that has a lot of security parameters in place. And you definitely want to make sure that they have backup recovery measures in place, things like that, so that way in the event of a breach, there are measures already in place. It's not uh you know a server sitting in somebody's basement where you know if they have a breach, uh you're kind of on your own. So you definitely want to make sure that you're going with somebody trusted that's encrypting the data the right way. There is definitely a minimum encryption rate that you need to be using. We're getting a little techie here, but basically what the state and federal laws require is a minimum of 128-bit encryption. We, for instance, encrypt at a 256-bit key, and we use an EES algorithm, so it's really the same algorithm adopted by the U.S. government for encryption in most cases. So it's really that top grade security. You want to go for somebody that's covering it, covering all the bases and covering it that way.
DavidSo if a breach should happen, you want to be able to have a very heavily defensible position to say, look, we did everything we could, we were we were using the most rigorous standards.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And the other thing you want to do too is make sure that you have a BAA signed, a HIPAA VA, it's a business associate agreement. So any company that you're working with that's handling THI on your behalf, anyone that's an encryption service, for instance, or backup data service, you want to make sure that you have that document signed as well. And um For instance, we were one of the companies that did that before it was it was actually a law and then it became part of HIPAA, where if you are using a third party, a vendor regarding encryption or file storage, you do have to have that BAA signed. So that's definitely something you want to look out for too. If somebody's saying, hey, you know, just pay us, we'll encrypt your data, there's definitely a lot more to it than that. So you definitely want to make sure that there's some measure of liability.
DavidWell, and speaking of using third parties, has has the industry gotten sophisticated enough so that if I'm an advisor or if I'm a small firm and I'm looking to select a vendor, that one of the things I need to ask about is a service level agreement, which specifies things like uptime and how the how backups are done and different standards to which you might adhere?
SPEAKER_01So exactly. So most businesses will have what we call a EULA and end user license agreement, and usually that is kind of paired with terms of service as well, and those are made publicly available. So you definitely want to take a gander at that. They're likely all going to be the same when and that the company really retains the right to do whatever and this and that. But overall, you want to make sure that the BAA agreement is signed. So anyone that won't touch one of those, you definitely want to steer clear of.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Imagine a place where you could discover proven business building strategies and pick the minds of top benefit agency leaders in the industry to maximize your own firm's growth and success. Well, now there is such a place. Announcing Ascend, the agency growth and leadership summit coming to Nashville, Tennessee this January. Ascend will be hosted by my friends Nelson Griswold and Scott Cantrell, authors of the industry best-selling book, Do or Die, Reinventing Your Benefits Agency for Post-Reform Success, and founders of one of the most successful marketing and sales consultancies in the industry, Bottom Line Solutions. Ascend is a fresh, interactive experience exclusively for benefit agency leaders and focused on providing practical and proven strategies to help you maximize your growth. I'm going to be there, and I'm so excited about this totally different type of meeting that I've arranged a special discount just for Shift Chapers listeners. This event is invitation only, so there is an application process to attend. To get all of the details, go to www.shiftchapersonline.com and click on the ascend logo at the top right of the page. See you in Nashville. And now back to our interview. So we're communicating in a lot of different ways these days. It's not just somebody sitting in front of a green terminal with a little blinking lights on a CRT. And there's a tremendous amount of work being done mobile via mobile. We interviewed a few episodes back Dr. Eric Topel, who was talking about how smartphones are going to change the entire characteristic of how medicine is delivered and in point of fact what medicine is and how we interact with it. But that's true of data as well. Does folks out there using smart devices and mobile devices complicate the process? And again, what do we need to look for?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, really good question to you. So one of the big things that we're starting to see, a big trend in the software industry, particularly surrounding encryption of PHI, is mobile. If you go to HHS.gov, there is a space on there. It's kind of jokingly called the hit the wall of shame. But any any breach that's happened is actually public knowledge, it's of public record because it is a federal law. So all the breaches are on there, and interestingly enough, a lot of the breaches are from a lost or stolen laptop, a lost or stolen mobile device, meaning a smartphone or a tablet. So I wouldn't say that it necessarily complicates the process because really mobility is around making life easier and being able to work remotely and enabling that mobile work style, but it is something to consider. So you definitely want to make sure that your solution not only encrypts your emails, not only encrypts your data when it's at rest, but you also want to worry about mobile because let's face it, I mean business is done mobily now. You can be sitting in Starbucks and working on an enrollment form or working on getting census data over to somebody. So you want to make sure that you're encrypting what's on your mobile device as well. A lot of people don't think about that, but it is definitely something that you need to worry about. So if you are doing business on a mobile device, whether it's a smartphone or a tablet, you want to make sure that the solution you get is going to cover that device and also cover it for your employees because the last thing you need to worry about is somebody lost their phone and there was no password on it or it was hacked or something and all that data is not compromised as well, because you can face the face the uh the wrath of the law for those breaches as well. It's not just the computers. It does include mobile.
DavidSo if I have a mobile device, whether it's a laptop or a smartphone or a tablet or whatever, is it enough to simply be able to remotely lock the tablet or the device once I find out that it's lost, or do I need to be able to wipe it somehow?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say both. And so one of the things that that's really nice about our system is we'll allow you to remotely lock it, remotely wipe the contents of the account from the remote location. But it's it's not just that, it's also the sending of information. So you want to make sure that your encryption solution will also allow you to send securely from those devices. So having the data on them and locking it is part of the equation. The other is going to be safely sending and safely receiving on those devices. So you just want to make sure that you do have sort of a mobile device management schedule in place so you know exactly how you're doing it, how it's how it's going through. So you definitely want to choose someone that has that.
DavidWe've talked an awful lot about sending data, but there are requirements, obviously, for storing data as well. If I'm an advisor, what are the things that I need to be concerned about? What are the things that I need to look for and make sure that I can accomplish on behalf of my clients?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely. So it's a really great question as well. So you're hitting on all the really good points here. So you're correct, in that sending is part of the equation. So any business entity that's sending that data needs to encrypt it. The other piece of the puzzle is storing data. So even PII, even the state data breach laws require that that data is stored with encryption at Arrest as well when it's being handled by a business entity. So sending is part of it, but you also want to make sure that your hard drive is encrypted or you're storing your files in an encrypted portal or something. So that is important as well.
DavidOne of the things that advisors are working on these days in in terms of being able to build their brand is that any software, any vendors that they use, the software is white labelable, so it comes looking like it's from their agency. Is that something that the industry has responded to?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I would agree. I mean, I think everyone nowadays likes to have this kind of setup where they just have this really high level of professionalism, and especially if you're moving towards more of a consultative sales approach, it really, really can help. So instead of it looking like it's coming from techcompany.biz, you know, it's really nice if it's coming from your agency, from your business. Just keeps it looking really professional and smooth and secure. So definitely that's one of the things that we've been really big on, is white labeling our product. So when a customer signs up with us, you know, it looks like it's their business, an extension of their website, of their brand. So it's not um, you know, some random email coming from techcompany.com and the person on the other end really isn't sure if they should click on it or not.
DavidNow I know that you guys work with a lot of benefit advisors. Um I also know that you have a really nice discount deal for NEHU members, and that's terrific. Uh something that everybody who's listening who's an NEHU member ought to check out. And if you're not an NEHU member, you ought to consider doing that as well. But I wonder when you're advising benefit advisors who are new to this part of the business, how do you advise them to have this kind of a conversation, this component of the conversation with their prospects and their clients? What is it that they need to talk about in those situations?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so basically you just want to let them know that you are abiding by the state and federal laws and you're doing XYZ because of that need to encrypt their data. And usually the conversation is pretty simple. Once you explain to a customer or a prospect, hey, we're we're doing it this way because of your security, and because we want to make sure that your data is secured so your information isn't compromised. They're usually really willing to oblige. But going back to one of the earlier questions is surrounding the ease of use and that being a really important thing. So want to make sure it's easy for them. You don't want to complicate what they have to do to get information over to you or get information from you, but you do want to make sure that they know you're doing it for their benefit. And when you do that, they really respond well to it. And it really separates you from someone down the street that maybe isn't doing it yet and knows they need to be, or someone that has something a little bit more complicated. So it really will help you stand out as well.
DavidFrom a defensive standpoint, how important is it to be able to have workflow audit trails? And in English, for those of you who aren't tech beanie brains, how important is it to be able to go back and look at what was done to a particular file and who did it and when it was when it happened?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it's extremely important. And so we we don't work just within the life and health side of the business, we're also on the property and casualty side. And you know, we really hear this a lot on that side of the business. Every single piece of communication is effectively tagged, in other words, copied and pasted or dragged and dropped into some sort of CRM. And so every little thing, every step of the way is going to be audited and locked onto. So if somebody comes back and says, hey, you never sent me that, or I never got that, or we never discussed that, you can really easily pull up this audit trail and say, well, no, you open this email this time, this date, here's the file that you opened up. So it's really good to avoid any kind of legal issues. On the flip side of that, most of our customers will get a reduction of EO costs, and some will even get free data breach coverage just by using encryption and just by having that audit trail. So there are a lot of big benefits other than just, you know, he said, she said kind of thing.
DavidYou know, Aurie, in addition to individual practitioners and and small practices in shops, I know that some of the listeners that we have are in the TPA space, and also we have some insurance company folks who listen. What are their unique challenges? Are there things that are different that they need to look at or they need to concern themselves with versus what a sole practitioner or a small insurance agency might wonder about?
SPEAKER_01So, I mean, one thing that that would stand out is potentially volume. So if we're talking about a company versus an agency, you know, a carrier versus just an agency, volume might be an issue. Larger files might be an issue. So you definitely want to want to make sure that you're tackling all of those things. Uh, that's definitely something that we would tackle with our one solution. From a third-party administrator standpoint, you might be handling a lot more sensitive info than just PI or PHI as well. So a lot of times we do have financials, we do have account numbers, quarterly statements, things like that that are handled as an outside of the business. So depending on what it is and what you're offering to your customers, you might need to worry about some other laws, FEC, FINRA, Gram Leach, Bliley. So there's all these different things that you have to consider as well as a TPA. And so you want to make sure that you're not only covering your bases with the state and the federal hit the law, but you also want to worry about some other ones potentially. So I think those are just some things that uh you'd want to think about when choosing a solution or using a solution for those cases.
DavidAaron Powell There's certainly an awful lot of different moving parts and things to think about. Ari, in in the minute or so that we've got left, we always like to ask our subject matter experts what they see for the future, where they see this particular space that we're talking about going. What's your vision?
SPEAKER_01Definitely. I think that as we keep growing from a mobile standpoint, and people keep doing, we call it work shifting, you know, working from a remote location or working from home in Citrix terms is work shifting. So as you work shift, just keeping the mobile information secure is a big thing, you know, making sure that not only are you not going to lose your laptop, but if you lose your laptop, that you have some kind of system in place to wipe it out, the data is backed up. Because not only do you not want to lose data, but you also don't want to compromise your company, compromise your clients. So having a backup in place, I think, is going to be a big thing going into the future. And then also further, further kind of diving into workflows is a big thing that we're focusing on. So it's great that you can encrypt data and it's great that you know somebody can get it really easily and all that. But if we can snap in with core systems, then it's really helpful. And effectively what we're trying to do is less clicks. You know, everyone's clicking enough. So we want to try to get it down to as few clicks as possible so that you can just focus on what you do best.
DavidGreat advice. Ari Gardner, thank you for sharing your time with the Shift Shapers audience. Ari is the director of Sharefile for Insurance at Citrix. Ari again, thanks so much. Thank you. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Assaultman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies, just like you, to help shape the shift in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at the Saltzman Group.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from Fifth and Fire on our site. You can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Fifth Papers episodes and to access some really great special offers. You can call it 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the SIF papers to work in your business.