The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #79: Fortress and Frontier, Part 2: The Move Towards the Frontier – With Robert Graboyes, MSPA, PhD.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On this episode of Shiftshapers Podcast, we continue our conversation with Dr. Robert Graboyes, Senior Research Fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, about the economics of health care and why both sides are losing the debate.
Join us as we discuss the reasons why traditional economic principles have worked differently in health care and what is happening (and needs to happen) to move us toward the frontier. Tune in to discover what Bob believes needs to happen in the United States in order to fix our health care system in a way that will help provide better care to more people at a lower cost, year after year. Don’t miss this engaging conclusion of our conversation with one of the nations preeminent healthcare-focused economists!
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Why most metrics in health care have been focused in demand.
- How much of the overall problem is due to seeing this as a “demand” rather than a “supply” issue.
- How innovation in health care currently happens in the U.S. and why that system is broken.
- The examples of countries that we can learn from to help fix our health care.
- What we can learn from WWII Pacific operations.
On part two of our interview with Dr. Robert Greyboys, we ask why traditional economic principles have worked so differently in healthcare, and what, if anything, is happening to move us toward the frontier. We'll answer those questions and more on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultzman.
DavidAnnouncing Ascend, the agency growth and leadership summit that's coming to Nashville, Tennessee this January. Ascend is a fresh, interactive experience exclusively for benefit agency leaders and focused on providing practical and proven strategies to help you maximize your growth. This isn't just a bunch of talking heads, it's a hands-on, take it home and implement it ideas and tools meeting. I'm going to be there, and I'm so psyched about this meeting that I've arranged a special discount just for Shift Shapers listeners. To get all of the details, go to www.shift shapersonline.com and click on the Ascend logo at the top right. Why have most of the metrics in healthcare been focused on demand?
SPEAKER_00Well, that's a good question. That's again part of this whole fortress mentality. It is the notion that, and again, I teach a lot of doctors. What's interesting is when I talk about new ways of supplying medicine, new technological innovations, very often the doctors in my class, and these some of these are med school professors, have never heard of the developments that I'm talking about. There is a sense, part of it is a problem with med schools. Med schools are very backward looking. It's here's how you practice medicine, and now the only thing we need to worry about is how do we pay for it. So we focused entirely on insurance. Everyone, if you the whole debate, actually since World War II, has been okay, should we have Medicare? That's insurance. Should we have Medicaid? That's insurance. Should we have Obamacare? That's insurance. And state matters, if you ask conservatives, they'll say, well, you ought to be able to buy and sell health insurance across state lines, which I like to point out is perhaps the single most ineffective, useless idea you could possibly come up with to improve the health care system, and that it won't work, and it wouldn't do much if it did.
DavidWouldn't it expand the pool? I mean, it at a minimum wouldn't expand the pool and then be able to make risk both more predictable and lay risk over a larger population?
SPEAKER_00No, it wouldn't it wouldn't do much. The pools are you you need a pool of a couple thousand, and any insurance plant out there has a pool of a couple thousand. I like to say that uh buying and selling health insurance across state lines is equivalent to buying and selling haircuts across state lines. If you live at the border, it might be slightly useful in that town. The problem is that health insurance, the way we've structured it, is an extremely local good. It's not like life insurance where the only thing the company has to know is, did you die yet? With health insurance, it's okay, I've got to develop a network of doctors and hospitals and nurses and home health care. It's an intensely, intensely local good. And here in Virginia, there's no one in Nevada who's going to say, I'm going to develop a provider network right there in Alexandria, Virginia for your benefit. I don't know enough about it. So it's a very local good. So the way we have structured healthcare to deal with all the minutiae, and that's part of the problem, it's just buying and selling across state lines isn't going to do much. But the fact is, both sides, uh, essentially the left has argued for 70 years, the only thing that matters is how many people have an insurance card in their wallet. And the right has argued, we can hand out insurance cards more efficiently than you can. But as long as you are focused entirely on insurance issues, you're really dealing with two things, which is fear of risk and redistribution of wealth. It is somebody saying, your life may be in terrible danger, therefore, I'm going to take someone else's money and put it in a big pot so if you ever need it, I can hand it to you. That's an important thing. I have lots of health insurance. I want health insurance, whatever. But nevertheless, that particular uh focus does not get you innovation. It doesn't get you new sorts of techniques, it doesn't move us into 21st century care. The good news is other countries are beginning, and I think beginning rapidly to shift into new modes of care. My concern is that we may be the last ones to the party uh on that after having been the leaders in innovation for the last century.
DavidWell, I mean, we know about Singapore. We've talked about that on the program, and we've talked a little bit about Switzerland, and years ago I spent a fair amount of time having a great conversation with Reggie Hertzlinger over at Harvard about because she had done a lot of studying on the Swiss system. Are there some other examples of countries in a more modern milieu that you think might be exemplars for us to use?
SPEAKER_00Sure. Now, the Singapore and Switzerland cases are both insurance stories. Singapore is heavy use of health savings accounts. Switzerland is a sort of semi-privatized version of insurance. It's not single payer, it's not the government providing, it's lots of lots of individuals. But it's still insurance. Their novelties are insurance. Therefore, while they're they're nice cases, I don't find them the most interesting. What I do find interesting is, first of all, before I say that, let me say people ask me, what are the most important things you could do to fix American health care? And habitually, both left and right will give you something about insurance. I would say it is, okay, on the insurance side, the Medicare reimbursement system is a disaster. It skews everything wrong, including on private insurance policies. It misallocates resources. So the whole Medicare reimbursement system was terribly designed. It's a set of centralized price controls. Secondly, the FDA approval process for drugs and devices. Third, we have this veneration for hospitals, that they're the good guys, and therefore we award them essentially monopoly privileges in many ways. Reggie Hertzlinger writes a lot about how we demolish the notion of specialty hospitals. So we don't allow them. There's a whole set of the state regulations, again, on nurse practitioners, on what pharmacists can do, on telemedicine, certificate of need, corporate practice of medicine, all sorts of things that stunt the growth of healthcare. So you've got all of those. And also, again, I mentioned medical schools are very backward looking. Essentially, most medical schools in the U.S. are based on a 1910 pedagogical model that assumes that every doctor is going to be a solo practitioner in a small town. They don't look anything about how do you innovate, how do you get to new modes of care, how do you work as teams, how do you really correctly manage the delivery of health care. It all assumes you're, for old timers, Marcus Welby MD. So you've got all of these things. Now, there are countries that have improvements. Oddly, are all the criticism the right hurls, often correctly, at Europe. The European Union has a much better drug and device approval system than we do. They don't have an FDA in the European Union. What they do is the uh the governments of Europe have appointed or have certified private individual agencies. If you want an example in the U.S., think of underwriters' laboratories, which measures the safety and efficacy of electrical devices. That's essentially Europe is filled with underwriters' laboratories for drugs and devices. And they have an agreement that says once one of those agencies agrees to release a drug or device, the rest have to agree to it as well through reciprocity. In the United States, the FDA has a very one-sided motive. If they release a drug that kills 10 people, you're going to have screaming headlines for five years and careers will be ruined and they'll be vilified and Twitter mobs going after them. But if they don't release a drug that would have saved 100,000 people, there is no cost to pay. So the FDA has learned the lesson well. What we need to do is slow walk everything out there and always err on the side of extreme caution. That's the fortress. Europe, these independent agencies, they have that same motive. They don't want to issue something that kills people. On the other hand, if you are the approval agency that's always slow walking everything and overly extraordinarily cautious to the point of recklessly cautious. So kind of an interesting term there, you're not going to get any business. No drug or device manufacturer is going to come to you and ask for you to be the one who approves them. They'll say these guys never get the job done. They turn down everything. I'm going to go to someone else. And so you have both sides. So right there, and by the way, it's kind of that very much resembles the system of regulation of safety on the high seas that has been in existence for 250 years. There is no FDA of ship safety. What you have is about 60 private entities, and a shipping company can go to any one of them and say, look at my ship, look at the way I pack my cargo, tell the world that I'm okay and it's okay to ride on my ride on my boat or put their container on it. Then you're getting all sorts of interesting little tiny innovations in strange places. Sub-Saharan Africa, and I used to do work in Sub-Saharan Africa, has been an early adopter of using drones to deliver medications to remote areas. If you look at others, I've tweeted a couple of stories, a couple of guys in Uganda, Uganda, which is very resource poor. Their healthcare system has very little to provide. And they have a very high rate of maternal death and fetal death complications during pregnancy. And these two guys who weren't doctors, they were just a couple of smart guys, said, I think we can improve this. So they took their smartphone and they developed an app that you can put a sensor on the mother's belly and measure her metrics, measure the baby's metrics, and tell when either baby or mother is in trouble. And they are lowering the uh the rate of death there for babies and mothers. And really interesting because just last week Apple released something called Airstrip, which is wireless telemetry that can monitor a pregnant woman and separate out the heartbeats of mother and child in real time. And again, on Twitter I noted maybe uh maybe they ought to tip their hat to these two guys in Uganda who, essentially on their own, with you know very limited capital, had developed something quite similar to that. I have been very much involved in an organization called Enable. Enable, let's say it makes connections between people who need a prosthetic hand and people who have a 3D printer and want to build a prosthetic hand. Two years ago, if you wanted a workable prosthetic hand, the minimum cost was $5,000. And on average they were about $40,000. A couple of amateurs, actually, an injured carpenter in South Africa and a puppet maker in Washington State invented a 3D printed hand that costs somewhere between, depending on how elaborate you make it, $5 and $50. So you're talking about a 99.9% reduction in the cost of getting someone a hand that enables them to ride a bike or pick up a cup of coffee.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Imagine a place where you could discover proven business building strategies and pick the minds of top benefit agency leaders in the industry to maximize your own firm's growth and success. Well, now there is such a place. Announcing Ascend, the agency growth and leadership summit coming to Nashville, Tennessee this January. Ascend will be hosted by my friends Nelson Griswold and Scott Cantrell, authors of the industry best-selling book Do or Die, Reinventing Your Benefits Agency for Post-Reform Success, and founders of one of the most successful marketing and sales consultancies in the industry, Bottom Line Solutions. Ascend is a fresh, interactive experience exclusively for benefit agency leaders and focused on providing practical and proven strategies to help you maximize your growth. I'm going to be there, and I'm so excited about this totally different type of meeting that I've arranged a special discount just for Shift Shapers listeners. This event is invitation only, so there is an application process to attend. To get all of the details, go to www.shiftchapersonline.com and click on the Ascend logo at the top right of the page. See you in Nashville. And now back to our interview. And all of those innovations are going to help move us, I think, in a large way out of the Fortress and into the frontier. And yet we were talking off-air. We go back to kind of the shipping metaphor. Uh there are lessons that we can learn even going back to World War II in the Pacific, aren't there?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was a metaphor that I used in Fortress and Frontier. That uh you know, there are there are sort of two ways you could look at um doing battle there. One is you send an enormous force and sweep through. It's been a while since I've looked at it, I forget the terminology. Uh, one was called island hopping. And this is more island hopping, where you yeah, you sort of tactically you find an island that is attainable, you go at it, and each island that's taken is a small victory, and you're going after myriad small victories, which ultimately add up to a big victory, as opposed to this sort of brute force approach that we've got to solve everything all at once and just send massive centralized power. Problem has been, it's funny, I talk to a lot of doctors who are conservatives or libertarians, and on every other issue, they understand this intuitively. But when you get to healthcare, it's now the way we get innovation is you get the federal government to gather up a whole huge bunch of taxpayer money, and then you hand it out to the best and brightest that the federal government can find. And I don't know the demographics of your audience, but uh a message that I've sent out um again on Twitter a couple times was that um asking the federal government to manage technological innovation is like asking your mother to manage your Tinder account. You know, for those who don't know it, it's a dating app. And uh, you know, if your mom is running your dating app, you will get something that are called dates. They're probably not, you won't get as many, and they probably aren't going to be as much to your liking. Well, it's kind of like that with the federal government. And I was talking to a very smart, very good, very attentive left-wing audience of academicians who were very concerned about the federal government getting out of or reducing its role in technological innovation and healthcare. They asked if I was concerned about that. And I said, Well, no, actually, I think it's a good thing. I think paradoxically, the more the federal government involves itself, you know, the more they fund innovation, the less innovation we get. And I said, the problem is this when the federal government hires somebody to look through all the grant proposals, they hire someone like me. So, what am I? You know, I'm a middle-aged guy who limits my risk. I like two paychecks each month, and I like them to be the same amount. And I'm never going to take my house and you know, borrow, mortgage it to the hilt to roll the dice on a business venture. I'm not gonna keep a payroll. I've never patented anything, and yet, you know, I've got that PhD, and I'm just the sort of person that the federal government hires to think about these and decide, well, this guy over here, he's gonna be the big innovator. You know, and I've talked about the guy who invented the plastic hand, and I talked about Steve Jobs, and said, Do you think the federal government would have said, let's give all the money to them? And everyone in the room agreed, no, we wouldn't. We would have given it to a guy who won a Nobel Prize 30 years ago and hasn't done much since. Because when he fails, you can say, Well, he had a Nobel, I did what I could. So we really need to get it out of that's right there, that's the fortress, and we need to get it over to the frontier so we can really innovate. And as I said, I'm confident it's gonna happen. It may not happen in the U.S. first, but I think we have the possibility for it. Um, but we're really gonna have to do what we did in IT 25 years ago, and the great thing is when you say who built the internet, it's really not a Republican or a Democratic achievement. It was both parties stepping away and saying, let's go at it, let's let them do it.
DavidWhich is so difficult for government to do, at least in this country.
SPEAKER_00Yes, absolutely.
DavidCan all of that, in the couple of minutes that we have left, can all of that happen under the current framework with ACA and some of the things that we're looking at, or does that need to be moved out of the way as well?
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, the ACA is a serious impediment to this. But as I like to say to conservative audiences, many of these other things are state issues and they're fully under your control, and you're not doing the right things on those. So you can start fixing things right away. You can allow telemedicine in your state, you can allow nurse practitioners to have a stronger role in health care, autonomous practices, you can let pharmacists write prescriptions in certain cases, you can allow novel means of corporate structure for healthcare institutions. All these are fully within your capacity and can do a lot of good right now, and you don't have to wait to do something about uh Obamacare for it. That's a hard message to sell because, again, just people on the right have acclimated themselves to the idea that the AC is the only thing I need to worry about, and as long as I leave it to the states, it'll be just wonderful. We need to change the goal. What we've been talking about for 70 years is coverage. How many people have a card? What we need to talk about is how do you provide better care to more people at lower cost year after year? That is exactly the equivalent of what IT did. They've provided better information technology for more people at lower cost year after year for 25 years, and they have changed the world society forever in doing it. That's the mindset we need to get to in healthcare.
DavidDr. Robert Grayboy, Senior Research Fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. Dr. Bob, as a lot of people know him, thank you so much for spending time with the Shift Shapers audience today.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much and look forward to listening to this. Take care.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Ship Shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803-386-8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the Ship Shapers to work in your business.