The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #78: Fortress and Frontier, Part 1: Why Healthcare Innovation is Lagging Behind Other Industries – With Robert Graboyes, MSPA, PhD.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode of ShiftShapers Podcast, we are privileged to welcome a leading economist and thought leader in our field, Robert Graboyes. Bob is a Senior Research Fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University where he examines the economics of healthcare. His paper, “Fortress and Frontier in American Health Care” (link below) caught my interest and I invited him to discuss that – and much, much more – on the podcast.
We begin our conversation by exploring why he once referred to health care as an “Economic Oz.” We touch on the implications of the ongoing left-right political struggle over the health care. For good measure, we also delve into the ancient paternalistic tradition of physicians, and how that has contributed to the fortress vs. frontier mentality.
Join us discover why Bob believes that healthcare has been unwilling or unable to take on disruptive innovation like many other industries today and what we can do in order to allow for these beneficial changes to happen. You won’t want to miss the this interesting and informative discussion – or part 2 next week!
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Why ACA is “an unworkable vision with multiple applause lines.”
- What Robert means by “Fortress and Frontier.”
- Why healthcare innovation has lagged behind other industries.
- How much of the overall problem is due to seeing this as a “demand” rather than a “supply” issue.
- When and how did we go from insurance to prepaid health care.
- What we can learn from WWII Pacific operations.
Why does one of the nation's leading healthcare economists believe our fortress-like mentality has limited innovation in healthcare? And how will a reset to a frontier mentality change that? We'll find out on part one of this two-part episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidAnnouncing Ascend, the agency growth and leadership summit that's coming to Nashville, Tennessee this January. Ascend is a fresh, interactive experience exclusively for benefit agency leaders and focused on providing practical and proven strategies to help you maximize your growth. This isn't just a bunch of talking heads, it's a hands-on, take it home and implement it ideas and tools meeting. I'm going to be there, and I'm so psyched about this meeting that I've arranged a special discount just for Shift Shapers listeners. To get all of the details, go to www.shift shapersonline.com and click on the Ascend logo at the top right. Thanks for being among the thousands of Shift Shapers listeners who tune in each week to hear the top subject matter experts in our industry talk about ideas, techniques, and best practices that help you to build your knowledge base and your practice. I know many of you subscribe on iTunes and Stitcher so that you get each week's podcast delivered as soon as it goes live, and that's a great way to get the jump on every new episode. To make it even easier, and for those of you who may not be iTunes or Stitcher users, we've added an exciting new feature to the ShiftShapersOnline.com website. If you click the new subscribe button, we'll automatically notify you the minute each new episode is published, and we'll also send you a short description showing who we're chatting with and what we're discussing. And it will let us notify you about some upcoming special offers, online content, and webinars we're building just for Shift Shapers listeners. So go to www.shift shapersonline.com and click the subscribe button. Our motto is listen, learn, profit. Now you have a way to do that ahead of the crowd. Subscribe today. In this episode, we're privileged to talk to Robert Gray Boys. Bob is the senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. He's the lead researcher. He examines the economics of healthcare. For those of you who want to know, and no comments on my miserable Latin, Mercatis is the Latin word for markets. I'm sure if I got that wrong, Bob will correct me. And a great jumping off point would be that in a Newsweek article not so long ago, you described healthcare in the United States the way a lot of the people in the business of healthcare would describe it, as an economic oz, kind of an interesting concept. Where'd that come from?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's uh I'm thinking back when I wrote that, but uh the idea is the laws of physics are tampered with and seem rather odd. We do things that are uh we're not in Kansas anymore in healthcare in a lot of ways. Now I I'm trying to remember whether that was the the article that I um I wrote one not long ago that said the laws of economics function perfectly well in economics, that when when you you will often hear people say laws of economics just don't apply in healthcare. But in fact, what we do is we interfere with them to the point that they they have trouble doing what they're supposed to do. But the laws of economics are are perfectly fine in in healthcare as well as anywhere else.
DavidAaron Powell As long as we don't monkey with them and create all kinds of artificial pieces to them.
SPEAKER_00Right. And and in that particular article I noted um well actually as a little bit of politics in it. Uh I noted that uh around 1900, William Jennings Bryan, who wasn't the keenest on science, thought that lifting his foot up off the ground was defying the laws of physics. He didn't understand that no, it was simply you are exerting energy and resources in order to tug away at gravity. You're not, you know, gravity's still working perfectly fine when you lift your foot. And similarly, since about the time of William Jennings Bryan, we have tampered with the structure of healthcare institutions to the point that regular market functions have great difficulty operating. Yeah, but again, economics is is still plugging away just as well as anywhere else.
DavidBut it it's pushed us into an area, and it was another one of your articles that actually brought us together. Last fall you authored an interesting paper, and it was titled Fortress and Frontier in American Healthcare. And maybe that's a great descriptor of where we're at today, and we can talk a little bit about that and how we got into this mess, and then maybe we can talk about some of the steps that we might take to move into a system where we aren't quite as defiant of the laws of economics. Explain what you meant by Fortress and Frontier.
unknownSure.
SPEAKER_00By the way, let me put in a little bit of a plug. We now have that available on Amazon Kindle for a big $1.99.
DavidWow, and we'll link to that from the from the podcast website so people can access it if they want.
SPEAKER_00Terrific. Um yeah, that's the only way I read anything now, so I was especially happy when they decided to do it that way. So the idea is we think of healthcare as this incredible left-right struggle, you know, the left for Obamacare and the right against Obamacare. And really, it's been for about 70 years, since the end of World War II, we've had this what seems to be a left-right struggle. And it is a struggle, and it is a bitter, nasty political fight over uh health care. But I argued in my paper that both sides really are quite similar in more ways than they realize, and neither side is really dealing with the real issues at hand. Again, the things that turn healthcare into an oz. So I said the real difference in healthcare policy is between two visions that I call the fortress and the frontier. So the fortress assumes two things. One, the purpose of public policy in healthcare is to imagine every terrible thing that could ever happen to any patient in healthcare and to spend all of your resources trying to prevent any bad thing from happening. So that's a heavy dose of paternalism. The second part of the fortress is the notion that, well, doctors and um, you know, they've worked real hard at getting uh where they are, so they need to be protected from the forces of competition. They need to be protected from downward price pressure from foreign providers uh through medical tourism or from nurse practitioners doing what nurse practitioners actually do very well and perhaps better than doctors in some cases for certain procedures. They need to be protected against telemedicine. So it's protectionism. So really the fortress is all about paternalism and protectionism. The frontier is the opposite vision. The frontier is, and if you want to imagine it, think of where information technology has been for about the last 25 years. First of all, there hasn't been the same level of paternalism. When we unleashed the internet around 1990, we unleashed dangers and threats to personal property, personal wealth, personal your life and limb, that I would argue are at least as great and perhaps greater than the dangers that medical procedures pose to you. It's September and we've just passed the anniversary of 9-11, and it's important to remember that that only was possible because there were cell phones, new technology that was cheap and attainable and anyone could use it. Similarly, if you look at the internet, there's all sorts of financial fraud, identity theft, the ability on you know with a Twitter mob to uh destroy someone's reputation in seconds. These are dangerous things. And yet the miracle was that Congress, around 1990, both parties for some reason stepped away and said, you know what, there will be dangers in this internet thing, but let's just let it go. And when a problem crops up, we'll deal with it as we go along. Which is what we do in most other industries. So somehow Congress achieved a bipartisan consensus around 25 years ago that said, we're gonna let people take risks, and when something dangerous, something bad happens, we'll deal with it as we go along. The second part of that was the protectionism. If you look at what people were suggesting, I just read, um, and by the way, you can also link if you like to my Twitter handle. That's how I do most of my communicating these days. And I just linked to something, it was an article on a vision around 1990 of how the internet would disperse news. And the presumption in this article was that like the New York Times and Hewlett-Packard would get together and the Times would provide the content, and people would print out the news on their HP printers, and this is the way the web was going to operate by and large. They have little idea that there were going to be just endless numbers of new providers of content, new means of delivering that content. So the web has been the antithesis of protectionism. It's been anyone goes. IBM had to deal with Steve Jobs in his garage. Western Electric didn't have a monopoly on telephones in the U.S. any longer. They had to deal with a couple of guys in Canada who invented the Blackberry. So in IT, we changed the world in 25 years. I like to point out that in IT, 25 years ago, I knew one person with a cell phone. Now virtually everyone on Earth has access to cell phones. There are about 7 billion cell phones or at least SIM cards on the earth, more than there are toothbrushes or toilets. And what this means is that in IT, we went from information technology being the domain of rich people, toys for the rich, to universal coverage. Now we've, you know, the left has been talking about universal coverage in healthcare for since time immemorial. We really haven't gotten particularly close, and we're not getting close to whatever that means now. So in contrast to IT, healthcare, we protected, we we we had paternalism, and we have kept innovation at a tortoise crawl. Whereas IT was able to change the world in 25 years.
DavidTo what do you attribute that, the inability or the unwillingness of this particular industry to take on disruptive innovation?
SPEAKER_00He got a really good idea if you look at a book that came out early this year. Dr. Eric Topol, T-O-P-O-L. Another good thing to link to, if you like. He wrote a book called The Patient Will See You Now, talking about the changes, the sort of flipping the relationship between doctor and patient. And in the past, the doctor had the upper hand, and you came on the doctor's terms, and you sat in the waiting room, and you you waited till the doctor was ready, and now technology and in particular that IT, the smartphone, the tablet is flipping that. So it's the doctor who is at your back-and-call wherever we allow that to happen. But part of his argument was that medicine had an ancient history of paternalism. As he notes in there, if you really read carefully the Hippocratic Oath, it is a founding document of inequality between doctor and patient. Essentially, the it's the onset of over 2,000 years of I'm the doctor and I'm smarter than you are, and I'm better than you are, and you do what I say, and you're not to question it. So it's an old, it's an ancient tradition. Yeah, I teach a lot of doctors, and they tend to have been socialized in medical school to think I'm very, very, very special because what I do is a matter of life and death, and people's safety and health and life depends on me. And when I teach them, part of the teaching process is saying, well, you know, the same is true of the guy who fixes my brakes, the person who designs the jet engine that gets me up into the air, and the people who maintain it. And I don't know, perhaps the flight attendants uh serving me the food, which I'm hoping has been properly refrigerated, the people who load the groceries into my grocery store. There are a lot of people in the world whose errors can lead to deaths, maiming, etc. And one of the things I try to get across the doctors is you're not as special as you think you are, and you'll be better off when you realize that. And so will healthcare. So it's an ancient tradition, it's a fascinating history. For thousands of years as well, there has been a tight intertwining between religious institutions and medical institutions. At times in history, they have been the same institution. And so healthcare was imbued with this sort of religious aspect. And we're somewhat stepping away from that, and I think all for the better, because we really need innovation. The only way we fix healthcare is for it to innovate as quickly, I don't know, in the next 25 years as IT did in the last 25 years.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Imagine a place where you could discover proven business building strategies and pick the minds of top benefit agency leaders in the industry to maximize your own firm's growth and success. Well, now there is such a place. Announcing Ascend, the agency growth and leadership summit coming to Nashville, Tennessee this January. Ascend will be hosted by my friends Nelson Griswold and Scott Cantrell, authors of the industry best-selling book Do or Die, Reinventing Your Benefits Agency for Post-Reform Success, and founders of one of the most successful marketing and sales consultancies in the industry, Bottom Line Solutions. Ascend is a fresh, interactive experience exclusively for benefit agency leaders and focused on providing practical and proven strategies to help you maximize your growth. I'm going to be there, and I'm so excited about this totally different type of meeting that I've arranged a special discount just for Shift Shapers listeners. This event is invitation only, so there is an application process to attend. To get all of the details, go to www.shiftchapersonline.com and click on the Ascend logo at the top right of the page. See you in Nashville. And now, back to our interview. So as we come into the run-up for the next general election, there's an awful lot of talk about healthcare, and everybody seems to have an idea of how to fix it. Are the left and the right both stuck in the fortress?
SPEAKER_00Oh, absolutely. And I have great fun going to conservative audiences and libertarian audiences and telling them, look, you don't like Obamacare. I get that. Neither do I. On the other hand, if you look at your states, the states where you have a tight control on the political process, you are as obstructive to the supply of services and innovation as Obamacare is at the federal level. You know, probably Texas is the single most obstructive state in the Union as far as uh allowing telemedicine. Well, actually, that costs lives. I recently did a um a forum, a panel at Alec, which is the Association for Conservative State Legislators nationally. And what I had was uh a doctor from an outfit called Doctor on Demand. And he was I was using it through this iPad that we're talking on and broadcast it up onto a screen, and a doctor there explained how his company, doctorondemand.com, does physical examinations and writing prescriptions, whatever, through a smartphone, through an iPad. And the audience contained mostly conservative legislators, many of whom were doctors, and many of whom are extremely skeptical. They will be of the mindset that, well, you know, I you know I'm an old-fashioned guy, hands-on examination is an absolute necessity, and if you do it over an iPad, you might miss something. So the doctor was on the screen and said, Well, hands-on medicine is what I taught for 10 years at Stanford University. So I understand that. That's the environment I came out of. And I realized that 80 to 90 percent of what we do in an ER or a primary care doctor's office can be safely, effectively done through a tablet or a smartphone. And in fact, much of it can be done better that way. As an example, you're gonna get a better blood pressure reading if the person is sitting at home in the comfort of their own sofa than if they've driven 45 minutes to get to the doctor's office, struggled to find a parking space, run down the street, sat in a waiting room full of sick people, and you know, seen a bunch of people in white coats, and by the end of that, their you know their blood pressure is through the ceiling. And there are there's some other aspects that actually work better if you're if you're doing it uh remotely, certain mental health things, you get more honest answers when the person is speaking from their own environment than if they've come into the office. And so I asked this doctor, I said, the other night you mentioned at a dinner we had that you had just saved a woman's life by using this technology. I said, Could you explain? I hadn't actually heard the story, just the fact that it existed. So he explained in this room full of legislator doctors. He said, I got a call from a woman. She had been ill for three days. Her father-in-law was a um nurse practitioner. And he said, I think you're really, I think something's wrong. I think you need to check it out. And let's not wait till tomorrow. This was at night. He said, let's let's go on your iPad and talk to a doctor now. So he explained a lot of it in very lengthy, complex medical terminology that I can't repeat here. Uh he said, I said, I asked her her questions. She has to first fill in her symptoms on the introductory screens to the visit. And by the way, you get a visit for $40 for 15 minutes, and you are virtually guaranteed to see a doctor within 90 seconds of your calling in. So he looked at her symptoms and said, Come close to the iPad. I want to look at your eyes. And so she leaned over. He could see a discoloration of the eyes, which indicated to him some particular, again, complex medical term. He said, Let me look at your hands. So she holds her hands up to the screen and he looks. He said, I could see a tightening of the skin of her hands, which indicated blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, another term. At that point, he said, You need to get to an emergency room as fast as you can get there. You're in serious danger right now. So they rushed her to an ER, and indeed she was gravely ill without realizing it. And she's now recovered. He said, Without our service, what would have happened is she would have said, Okay, I'll call the doctor tomorrow. Her symptoms weren't that awful. And the doctor would have likely said, let's give it three or four days, see if you're feeling better. Maybe next week you'll give a call and come in and we'll schedule you for a checkup, whatever. He said, by which time she probably would have been dead. So meanwhile, the doctors in the audience, I could see their eyes were as big as saucers. Some of them were actually downloading the app. They were just absolutely stunned. Now, in many of the very conservative states, which hate Obamacare, they have restrictions that make the story that I just told you impossible to happen. Texas, for instance, the only way you can do telemed, uh, the medical society there, the medical board uh has issued regulations. You can only do that sort of a visit with a doctor you know personally and whose office you have been to in the past. So this woman wouldn't have had that capacity to do that. She'd probably be dead now. I uh again tweeted out on Twitter uh that Texas needs to learn from institutions that are more free market oriented, like the VA in New York State, which have much better regulations on telemedicine. They allow it. California, guy I work for here at Mercatus, he thought about these stories. He arrived in California. He was really sick with a sinus infection one Saturday morning. He said, I'm just gonna log on and do this thing that Bob has written about. He did. He had meds, the only holdup was CVS, it wasn't open yet, so he had to wait till 10 a.m. to get his drugs. But for the next four days, he was feeling fine because he got them. Otherwise, it would have been a four-day wait, a flight on an airplane with clogged ears and clogged sinuses, and he would have been sick for his whole business visit because he had no time for an ER.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you, to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Shift Shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803-386-8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the ship shapers to work in your business.