The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #77: Free Market Medicine is Disrupting and Transforming Markets - With Charlie Sauer
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In earlier episodes (see links below) we have spoken with physicians who are taking a very different, and more free-market approach to pricing health care. Their numbers are growing rapidly and while some may think that “free market medicine” is an oxymoron or an impossible dream, a new and growing association is beginning to prove otherwise.
On this episode of ShiftShapers podcast, we’re excited to welcome Charlie Sauer, co-founder and the executive director of the Free Market Medical Association. Their organization is dedicated to promoting transparency and forwarding the ideals and practice of medicine without the intervention of government and other third parties.
We invited Charlie to talk about the transformative nature of free market medicine. We asked Charlie how it can be possible to have free market in medicine in an environment where the government pays more than 50% of health care spend. We discuss the issue of whether consumers would be better off if artificial discount arrangements and multiple third parties were removed from the health care pricing landscape and why Charlie believes that our country is headed in that direction.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Whether the health care in the United States is an economic Oz.
- How you can promote free market solutions with the government paying more than 50% of health care expenditures.
- How we can get out of this cycle.
- Whether the ACA complicated the problem.
- The tools do consumers need.
Would consumers be better off if artificial discount arrangements and multiple third parties were removed from the healthcare pricing landscape? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Stoltzman.
DavidThis episode is brought to you by the Evolve Marketplace Division of National Benefit Partners, developers of the innovative employee benefits in a box, a game-changing tool for brokers working in the 10-250 employee market who want to easily and efficiently add a best-in-class voluntary benefits portfolio for their clients. To learn more, go to www.evolvemarketplace.com. Hey, thanks for being among the thousands of Shift Shapers listeners who tune in each week to hear the top subject matter experts in our industry talk about ideas, techniques, and best practices that help you to build your knowledge base and your practice. I know many of you subscribe on iTunes and Stitcher so that you get each week's podcast delivered as soon as it goes live. And that's a great way to get the jump on every new episode. To make it even easier, and for those of you who may not be iTunes or Stitcher users, we've added an exciting new feature to the ShiftShapersOnline.com website. If you click the new subscribe button, we'll automatically notify you the minute each new episode is published. And we'll also send you a short description showing who we're chatting with and what we're discussing. And it will let us notify you about some upcoming special offers, online content, and webinars we're building just for Shift Shapers listeners. So go to www.shift shapersonline.com and click the subscribe button. Our motto is listen, learn, profit. Now you have a way to do that ahead of the crowd. Subscribe today. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're speaking with Charlie Sauer. Charlie is the co-founder and executive director of the Free Market Medical Association. You may not have heard of them, they're fairly new. They're dedicated to forwarding the ideals and practice of medicine without the intervention of government or other third parties. And we've spoken a lot about transparency in the podcast. Transparency is actually kind of the end result of what Charlie and a lot of his members do. So with that, welcome, Charlie.
SPEAKER_02Hey, thanks for having me on.
DavidOur pleasure. Next week we're going to start part one of a two-part interview with another economist, Dr. Robert Greyboys, who wrote in Newsweek that healthcare in the United States is an economic oz where normal rules of nature don't apply. Does that kind of summarize the problem?
SPEAKER_02I think it summarizes the problem. And Dr. Greyboyce is one of the leaders in this movement talking about what entrepreneurs are doing out in front from his paper, The Fortress and the Frontier. He likes talking about the frontier and where this is going. And it's because in the movement is growing and going someplace. And that's because in economics, an Oz or something that is just fictional, creates this movement or this zone for true entrepreneurship to go. And that the Oz in this case is the government. The government is the biggest buyer in healthcare. They set up the rules so that hospitals can uh double charge for things. They can buy a surgeon, a physician-owned surgery center, and they can arbitrage. They can pay the surgeons that work there more, they can make more from the surgeries that happen there because the government's reimbursing them more. The Medicare isn't paying what their charge master says. So the hospital is actually incentivized to have these prices that don't mean anything. And the more that they negotiate down for the insurance carriers, the more that the insurance carriers like them. And that doesn't mean anything to the government that's paying a completely separate price, yet they get to write it off because the government's giving them other things. And I uh babble on that a little bit, and that's because it is a confusing zone, and that's part of how the Oz happens, is they can misdirect from place to place, and so you end up with this fictitious market that doesn't exist until you have people that say enough is enough. And uh you have Keith Smith, you have Jay Kempton who get together and say, We're going to do business the right way, and uh they show how much money you can make doing it the right way. And that's what the market that we see growing, and that's where we see the Free Market Medical Association is bringing these people together that are willing to say Oz is a fantasy and we need to do business the right way.
DavidBut that's the question that I've asked for years, and and maybe you'll have a really good answer for it. When people say we have to have a free market in medicine, my question is always how is it possible, no matter what your members do, no matter what citizens do, how is it possible to have a free market in medicine if you've got a player like the government who's paying arguably more than 50% of the healthcare spend? Can we get over that hill or around that obstacle?
SPEAKER_02Before I met Keith Smith, my answer might have been no. I I would have said, you know, we need to steer the iceberg or we need to chip away at the government. We need to remove them from the equation. So I met Keith and I found out about his practice and what he's doing, and he's going in a different direction. And before economists call what Keith is doing an island of excellence, they also refer to the Mayo Clinic as an island of excellence. Geissinger is an island of excellence. And really what it came down to is what these islands are doing is they're providing a service cheaper and better than anybody else in the market. And it seemed to me that most of that was free market health care. And that's when I started paying attention to Keith, that's what he was doing. But it goes beyond that. If you look at entrepreneurs in almost any sector, the small guy, the guy on the frontier, can run faster than the bureaucracy. So they can make these changes. And what happens is that they change the market. There's the people that ran West shaped America. And Keith was the first person to post his prices online. There's 24 facilities now in the Texas, Oklahoma region. And we just got through our uh conference last month that it doubled in size in a year. And uh this year we now have facilities in uh Florida, Ohio, Virginia, California, people talking about it in Pennsylvania, New York, all across the country. So if you would have asked me again a few years ago, I would have been with you and said, no, I don't know how we get around it. But now we see the market growing. And what's funny is in Oklahoma, it's the government that's changing. So Oklahoma County added the ability to go to Keith's clinic, surgery center of Oklahoma, into their plan, and I'm sure he's talked about this, but they saved a million dollars in the first seven months. And you know who paid attention to that? The state of Oklahoma. And now the state of Oklahoma can go to these physician-owned surgery centers that charge less of a copay. The copay was actually what the legislation was about. And uh now they are on track, or the forecast is that they will save $25 million in the first year.
DavidWell, that certainly is uh is a number that gets people's attention. You know, for longtime listeners, you'll know that we we've interviewed Keith and we'll link back to his interview so it's easy for those of you who may not have heard it in the show notes. We'll link back to that episode. But, you know, the majority of the folks who listen to this podcast are insurance benefits professionals. And so I thought maybe let's spend a little time and talk about some of the instigators and how they play into what the problem that's been created and the problem that you and your members are trying to solve. And, you know, let's let's go to the one that's on most people's minds because we've gone through fat networks, skinny networks, you know, closed networks, open networks. What role do have networks played in, if any, in creating this problem, or have they not been part of the problem?
SPEAKER_02It's just about every piece of the healthcare market has been a problem or is a problem at some point. And that's because the way that business is done here is that people create layers in the market. And so they get through, they uh get in and they don't charge for a product, or they don't charge one price for all. So you have these negotiations taking place, the discount is the biggest disruptor in the market. So the hospital charges $100 for an aspirin, the insurance company comes in, negotiates a discount down to $5. They've negotiated $95 off of that price of the aspirin, they get a percentage back from the business. If they're a self-insured business, they're doing the negotiation, they get a percentage back from that. But five dollars can still buy, you know, a thousand aspirin. And now we have people coming in that are expert negotiators, and they can get that not just five, they can get it down to four dollars, but they charge based on the negotiation. So this makes the hospitals increase their prices more, and it makes insurance companies want to move towards hospitals that have higher prices but they're negotiating down further. So it starts there. If we move to almost any place else in the market, a lot of the entrepreneurs that come in to try to work in Oz are trying to figure out how many different ways that they can filk or get money away from the fact that there's no cost to the end user. And it all comes down to the patient in the current system is paying 5% of their healthcare costs. It's or 15% of their healthcare costs. And so since the payers are distributed, there's money to be made on the confusion. Hopefully that kind of answers your question. But uh the fact is that there's layers. There's so many layers in healthcare that sometimes we forget what it is. Uh, we just set at the Free Market Medical Association some tenants of healthcare or free market healthcare, and one of them was that you need to price your product. So I know Jay Kimpton, for instance, how he prices his product as a third-party administrator is that he just charges basically uh for the paper. So if you have something, whether it's a a cheap surgery, you know, a trigger finger release, or uh something complicated, a robohysterectomy, his price is the same thing because for him, he's just moving a paper from one corner of his desk to the other, and he knows how to do it in the right way for his businesses. But other people charge a percentage of that, and then they negotiate the prices down and get a percentage on top of that, and then Jay hires somebody else that can negotiate just the robohysterectomies. And then, you know, we then move into where uh the networks that they can steer business away from a Keith Smith, and now we start multiplying onto the problem. So as we come around, really for us, if you charge for your product, you start getting rid of all of these other issues in the healthcare market.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Whether you're new to voluntary benefits or a seasoned professional, you'll want to check out the latest innovation from Evolve Marketplace. Employee Benefits in a Box is an innovative product that gives brokers in the small to mid-size market a turnkey set of solutions that until now have been reserved for large market brokers alone. Employee Benefits in a Box is truly capable of revolutionizing the way you go to market for employee benefits and for voluntary benefits. Evolve Marketplace provides a best-in-class voluntary benefit product portfolio with preferred and guarantee issue underwriting, a proven enrollment platform, and one consolidated bill. And we know how important that is for clients. Best of all, they give you all of this with no impact to your commissions. You can learn more about Evolve Marketplace and employee benefits in a box by visiting their website, www.evolvemarketplace.com, or by clicking the sponsor link on the podcast website, shiftshapersonline.com. And now back to our interview. I'm interested in what role consumers may play in this. You know, A ACA's had a lot of effects on a lot of different constituencies, and certainly one of the effects that it's had is that unwittingly, perhaps it's created a bunch of consumers, albeit they're consumers in a little small walled garden at the moment. But they've also now got vastly increased personal responsibility on plans. They're starting to become aware of outfits like uh Ralph Weber's Metabid and some other places where the rules as they've known them on pricing healthcare are starting to break down and starting to change. So it's uh do you do you see and do your members see ACA as a help to your overall mission or a hindrance?
SPEAKER_02I call this broken window economics. So it is a help to the movement, but what is that help to the movement? It's a help to the movement at a loss of other people's healthcare. So we're not going to spike the football on this one. It is not a good win. It is accelerating the growth of the free market based on uh where you said you, Ralph Weber and Medibid, that's a great company. You have pricinghealthcare.com, you have dot cost.com, you have pricem Ds, Healthcare Blue Book, you have all of these companies that are out exposing costs to people, and uh some of them trying to move into the quality space, which is its own show, quality in healthcare. But this is a growing movement. The ACA is increasing the costs, it's increasing the cost of healthcare for everybody, whether you're insured or not. I mean, whether you're uh employed or not, and so we do see this movement growing just because of the ACA. Now, to go to the consumers, there's uh, I don't know, there's the healthcare sharing ministries. I don't know if you've ever uh heard or talked about them, but it's an interesting group of uh in the ACA there were four ministries that were exempted, and they're all just growing at this rapid clip, and it's because the healthcare costs in the exchange are exploding, and uh so people are moving over to these healthcare sharing ministries, and so our guys are seeing the businesses pick up from that. It's a uh a small margin in the market at this point, but it is every place that a consumer can take more control, it's growing rapidly. So the other place that we see it is not exactly in the end consumer, but where we see the largest growth in our market is the uh self-insured businesses. The self-insured businesses are rapidly increasing, and the number of employees that people have and decide to become self-insured is dropping. So it's was what about a thousand employees uh just like a decade ago, and now we're seeing it 300 and even lower.
DavidYeah, there are there are some specialty stop loss products and other motifs that are coming on the marketplace for microgroups. We're seeing some smaller groups start joining together and captives. There's lots of different interesting things going on in the marketplace, but it it begs an interesting question, and that is what tools do consumers need in order to be able to access your members and folks who are pricing healthcare and doing this differently? And what what's available now and what do you foresee?
SPEAKER_02So our target market, because we do think this is still a frontier movement. So when I closed down, I gave the last speech at our first conference, and I gave the speech to a video, it's a YouTube video that everybody should look up. You need to search for uh leadership, uh, shirtless guy dancing. So leadership, shirtless guy dancing, and it shows that this one crazy guy out dancing in a field can grow into this huge movement. But since we see the growth as the self-insured businesses, that's our focus right now for the individuals. It's using sites like Medibid, using sites like PriceMDs, using uh pricing healthcare, using uh dot cost to find the individual places, and uh, or you can use our site and we link to all of them because they all kind of use different solutions. They're going out and approaching doctors more or less aggressively, they're getting people to sign up for sometimes you have to pay to sign up. So we have everybody on our site on a map. And for me, that was the biggest thing that was needed in the movement was this I don't want to go to the doctor who is the shirtless guy dancing alone in the field. I want to go to the doctor that you know has a buttoned-up tie and is part of the mainstream. Well, when you look at our map, you can see that that's all over the country. And so it is part of the mainstream. But what you can also see is that there's people around you that are listing their prices or participating in the free market of healthcare.
DavidWe're hearing an awful lot about a concept that's not brand new called medical home. And ultimately the goal there in a lot of other places is to go back to creating that old kind of family-doctor relationship that some of us of a certain age remember, where there isn't anybody in between the physician and the patient. Is is that ultimately an offshoot of kind of where your movement is going?
SPEAKER_02Well, we have a a lot of members that are in the direct primary care space. Atlas MD in Kansas is the first one that comes to mind. And, you know, I'm not even one of their patients, and I text the owner of that, Dr. Josh Umber, at 12 at night, one in the morning, and uh he answers your text message almost right away. I think that when you pull third parties out of the way, that you open up this ability for doctors, doctors become doctors because they want to treat people. They want to help people live a healthier life. And when a doctor has to spend most of his time coding or doing something for insurance companies or the government or his liability versus treating the patient, uh, you see a movement away from the medical home. I'm based in Washington, D.C. and spend a lot of time on Capitol Hill. One of the things that I don't like about the talk of the medical home, or for that matter, a lot of the discussion about transparency is that we move into the government mandating it, the government mandating transparency, or the government mandating somebody have a medical home, you know, somebody to coordinate care. What happens in a real market is that that happens because there is a value in it. There's a value in transparency. As uh, you know, when Keith posts his prices, the self-insured businesses around him can actually see how much lower his prices are than what they're paying out monthly for other surgeries. So that the businesses decide to steer people towards him. And the government, when they make that happen, it just doesn't work out the same way. Everything gets messed up.
DavidYeah, the government has a propensity for doing that. They're very good at messing stuff up. Charlie, in the minute or two that we have left, we we oftentimes like to ask our our guests what they see in the future. And you can define that however you like, but what do you see the future looking like from you and your organization's perspective?
SPEAKER_02Well, we uh our first year's conference went was at 100 people. This last year's conference was at 200. This year, the third year, we're gonna take the show on the road. I see it more than doubling again, but that's also what we're seeing in the market. We started with Keith Smith with uh one facility listing their prices. We now see 24 again in that region. It's a national movement now. This moves from a marginal movement from things that are happening on the edge to moving uh into the more mainstream in the next five years, especially if uh the ACA hangs around as it is.
DavidAnd it looks like, at least for the moment, that's going to be the case. Charlie Sauer, co-founder and executive director of the Free Market Medical Association. Charlie, thank you so much for spending some time and sharing your expertise and point of view with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_02And thank you again for your time and everything you do.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you, to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Shift Shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the ship shapers to work in your business.