The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #74: New Opportunities in Previously Uninsured Group Markets - With Bob Gardner
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
More so today than at any time in the past, benefit advisors are looking for new markets to serve. In this episode, we discuss some non-traditional markets that may be new to many of our listeners and we discuss the techniques that resonate in those markets. There’s no better person to talk about this topic than our guest, Bob Gardner, the National Business Development Coordinator of Freedom Care Benefits.
We invited Bob to talk about the new opportunities and imperatives in previously uninsured group markets and what advisors need to know to be able to capitalize on those opportunities. In this conversation, we define these traditionally uninsured market segments and discuss the reasons why advisors should consider serving them. Don’t miss this important episode that will surely open your eyes to some new and interesting possibilities.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- What these traditionally uninsured markets are.
- What has made them a new priority.
- Interesting ways to solve problems while mitigating costs.
- Whether traditional group carriers participate in these markets.
- What the advisor/client conversation looks like.
How has ACA created opportunities and imperatives in previously uninsured group markets? And what do you need to know to capitalize on those opportunities? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultan.
DavidThis episode is brought to you by the Evolve Marketplace Division of National Benefit Partners, developers of the innovative employee benefits in a box, a game-changing tool for brokers working in the 10-250 employee market who want to easily and efficiently add a best-in-class voluntary benefits portfolio for their clients. To learn more, go to www.evolvemarketplace.com. Benefit advisors are always looking for new markets to serve, more so probably today than at any time in the past. And so we wanted to take uh this episode to discuss some markets that may be new to many of you who are listening and to explore some techniques that resonate in those markets. And we couldn't find figure out anybody better. He's the best. We're talking to Bob Gardner, who's the National Business Development Coordinator of Freedom Care Benefits. And Bob's got really deep chops in this area. So with that, welcome, Bob.
SPEAKER_00Hey, well, thanks for the opportunity, Dave. Look forward to talking to you a little bit about this and uh you know giving some people some education on how the ACA is affecting everybody in the health world now.
DavidWell, that's the that's the truth. Let's take a step back and then we'll get to ACA. We'll level set, let's set the table for listeners. We're talking about some markets that may not be traditional markets that employers have looked to provide benefits in or that benefit advisors might have served. So talk about what those markets are and and then we can pop into why ACA has created the need to serve those markets.
SPEAKER_00I think what uh you know I'm experiencing and our company's experiencing is, you know, traditionally benefit advisors have always gone with a traditional route of as far as a gold, silver, bronze plan to mostly those key employees, those higher executive people that are used to getting insurance. But now with the changing laws that are going on and just healthcare and self is changing, you know, now employers are forced to think about those newly insured employees that they have and how do they cover them? How does it fit within their margins? You know, all those things are now going on that are forcing it. And so it's making those, you know, health brokers expand their margins a little bit, saying, hey, there's you know, opportunities here for us to secure this other business that we've never had before, or might be a potential client saying, hey, I used to you know offer you insurance for your 20 key employees, but now we have to do something for your 200 employees. And maybe the current model that I'm doing for the 20 isn't working for all 200 because of cost reasons, enrollment requirements, other options like that. So I think those brokers who realize that one are increasing their book of business by you know going out into the market, seeing what other products are available there to give those clients that complete solution and just not still just not staying focused on those key employees that they used to insure.
DavidSo let's drill down a little bit. In particular, what kinds of industries? Maybe you can give us a couple of examples of the kind of industries that you're talking about that might fit this profile.
SPEAKER_00Yes, we're seeing a lot of industries out there that are traditionally have low to medium wage earners and maybe have never offered insurance to their employees before. And these industries are like the staffing industry or PEOs, home health care, assisted living, restaurants and hospitalities. And another really big area is agricultural, where there's a lot of you know hand-picked products on that aspect. These employers are really kind of facing a new crisis because now they're saying, hey, I used to insure those 20 people, and now I have 500 people I have to insure. And what do I do? You know, what's the interest level of these newly insured people? What's their interest level of insurance? What type of insurance they want? And ultimately, these owners of these companies are saying, How is this affecting my, you know, my bottom line? A guy that owns 10 jack in the box is going, wow, you know, I make a decent living, but I don't have huge margins to supply a United Health gold plan to. What are my other solutions out there? And I think that's some of the frustrations that business owners are feeling. One, the law is very confusing, as we as we very much know, but ultimately sometimes the brokers that they've traditionally been dealing with don't have a you know kind of an out-of-the-box thinking for these types of solutions for these business owners. And you know, we are hearing business owners every day saying, Oh, I'm closing down five of my restaurants, or you know, hey, I had to, you know, really do something that maybe is not a direction I wanted to go with my company, and I'm still worried about being compliant with the ACA. So there's a whole bunch of things that companies have to consider as far as you know the compliance, the uh you know, overall structure of their company. Are they profitable? Can they afford this new stuff? And that's where we're really seeing the you know education factor with brokers has to you know increase and think of new ways to give these guys a solution.
DavidAnd following up on that education comment, and I think that's key in every place that we go and and every sale that we do, where we're especially where we're working with a group or a number of executives, even, the education is key. But does this population, which has arguably, for the most part, not ever had insurance before, do they react differently? I mean, uh we've talked about a little bit about employers not being able to afford a gold plan for for this population. But is that is that the plan that this population needs and will use, or are they more comfortable with some other kind of benefit array?
SPEAKER_00I think most of these people, what we're seeing in the market is that most of these newly insured people don't really, you know, because they're usually a younger workforce. They're a workforce that's truly working from paycheck to paycheck. So even though in their minds they might think that they want a you know gold plan that's out there in the market, but they don't have any history on it, they don't understand the costs relating to it. And really it comes down to can they, even though the you know, ACA has said this, you know, they have to make a plan affordable, affordable to what the government outlines, and affordable to a guy making $9 an hour, you know, and has two kids at home, it's a totally different ballgame. So, you know, what we're seeing in the market is a lot of these employees still don't want a full-blown plan just due to the fact that they can't afford it to begin with and stuff. So that's what we're seeing, even those plans that are maybe being offered to them that people aren't taking just due to the economic reasons.
DavidSo, what are some interesting ways that you can solve that problem while also mitigating the cost at the employer level?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think you're seeing a lot of companies out there that are really kind of thinking outside the box and really kind of trying to identify what the laws and the new playing field is under the ACA and really addressing specifically what is required to comply with the ACA. And I think a lot of those companies are, you know, like an agricultural company that says, hey, I got 20 office people and I got now 500, you know, field workers that are out there. He knows most of the time, because most of these companies in past have tried to give insurance and maybe have had l very low enrollment numbers or very low utilization. So a lot of these business owners probably already have somewhat of a negative taste saying, geez, I don't want to pay all this money for something they're not gonna use. So they're looking for ways, one, to give their employees maybe a little bit of benefits with the option to buy up, still coming in compliance with the ACA, but not giving them the full-blown pan just because they know there's gonna be low participation and low utilization on it. So they don't want to spend all that money on something that's not gonna happen. Mostly now it's affecting their bottom line. So, you know, there are companies out there that are saying, how do we let's identify what the law is, let's give specifically the benefits and the coverages that are required under the law, and then you can get these newly insured people on that plan and then give them options to buy up if they want to. But really, it's the most important to give these people the coverages that are required, give them the education on what they're giving them, and then what education is needed to advance that plan if they have that desire.
DavidSo it's almost kind of like a bottom-up approach. You start with minimum allowable coverage, minimum essential coverage, and then you offer options that let them build up from there.
SPEAKER_00Correct, correct. You're seeing a lot of companies that will do that just take that base platform and let, you know, obviously the indemnity market is a very big market. And I think as we you know move along in health insurance, everybody wants to be you know more engaged in their health insurance and what coverages they really want and what coverages they use, that the indemnity market is going to get bigger and bigger. But ultimately, we still have to play within the new guidelines of the ACA. So indemnities themselves won't make a employer compliant under the ACA, but they're nice additional benefits for those employees who want something more than just the bare minimum that's you know now required by their employer.
DavidIs this a market that traditional commercial group carriers have kind of ignored for years and years, or just it hasn't been fruitful, so they haven't focused their efforts there?
SPEAKER_00I think a combination of both of them because I think a lot of people have tried the market before and saying we've just never got the enrollment requirements, which put the costs at a very high, high number. So I think that was one deal. And I think a lot of a lot of these brokers have just never thought about this market because it wasn't required. So I think it's twofold on that aspect that one, we have to go back into that market to educate you know these business owners on, hey, what are your options? Yes, we did five years ago try a you know a traditional plan that was $400 a month, and you you're really stressed on the cost, but we only got you know 10% enrollment in it, and we weren't able to do that kind of a plan. Now, you know, we have to educate them that you know, under the law, that certain things are now required, and maybe it's not that plan that we did last year. So these commercial brokers have to realize that there's that whole new book of opportunity to obtain that entire business and give them a solution that works for all their employees from their president down to their janitor.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Whether you're new to voluntary benefits or a seasoned professional, you'll want to check out the latest innovation from Evolve Marketplace. Employee Benefits in a Box is an innovative product that gives brokers in the small to mid-size market a turnkey set of solutions that until now have been reserved for large market brokers alone. Employee Benefits in a Box is truly capable of revolutionizing the way you go to market for employee benefits and for voluntary benefits. Evolve Marketplace provides a best-in-class voluntary benefit product portfolio with preferred and guarantee issue underwriting, a proven enrollment platform, and one consolidated bill. And we know how important that is for clients. Best of all, they give you all of this with no impact to your commissions. You can learn more about Evolve Marketplace and employee benefits in a box by visiting their website, www.evolvmarketplace.com, or by clicking the sponsor link on the podcast website, shift shapersonline.com. And now back to our interview. We've talked about on the technique side minimum plans of benefits with options for employees to buy richer, but I know that there are some other portions of the internal revenue code, captive trust, for example, that you're fond of and that you talk a lot about. Can you explain for our listeners what those are and how they fit in a scenario like this market?
SPEAKER_00You know, a lot of companies are out there really kind of thinking, once again, outside the box, saying, okay, we have these newly insured people, these employers that now have to insure 500 people. How are they going to fit that into their costs and that their monthly budgets? And there is some very unique things out there that are currently in model. So captive is basically owning a small insurance company, and the ACA Obamacare has said yet, you know, self-insuring is a very important thing. It gives you some regulatory flexibility under the ACA to self-insure. And a lot of companies are taking that. But you know, sometimes self-insurance or self-insured self-funding gets a negative vibe on because of a lack of education. So brokers themselves that talk about self-funding can't, you know, just go on half-heartedly. You really got to understand what self-funding is because you got to give those answers to those employers about their potential exposure. And that's what everybody's worried about in the self-funding world. But now there's there's areas out there that obviously with reinsurance or stop loss in place that you can minimize your exposure in a self-funding market. And then, like you were saying, under the captive world, there's a very unique IRS tax code. It's called 831B. It's been around since early 70s. And really what that is, it's a structure identified under the IRS for small insurance companies. And a small insurance company is really a captive. And what's unique about this IRS 831B code is if you're self-funded and in your self-funding premiums, there's allocated expenses for claims funding. And if none of that claims funding is used or a portion of it is used, whatever's left over under this IRS tax code, it comes back to the employer in an income tax-free format. So, you know, a guy who has you know 500 employees now and he says, hey, I'm gonna have to give this this certain amount of coverage to everyone, and I'm claims I'm putting you know $20 per person per month of claims funding in with my premium, but really I'm getting very low utilization, and that as that claims funding comes back to me under the IRS tax code, it comes back to them income tax-free. So then they can say, well, that makes that makes sense. One, I'm getting the money back, but two, it's coming back to me free. But really on a higher note with this specific tax code, is employer can overfund for his potential risk every year up to $1.2 million and not pay income tax on it. So, you know, now you're talking to somebody who's facing ACA penalties that know they have to do something to comply, and you're giving them a very lucrative tax solution. It's not a tax shelter because we're not avoiding taxes illegally. This was once again under the specific guidelines of this IRS code.
DavidWell, and especially the opportunity to get some money back on a tax-favored basis makes a lot of sense since, as you pointed out earlier, these populations tend to be younger and for for the most part, and they tend to be working more paycheck to paycheck. They're not the kind of folks who, unless something serious hits them, can afford to take a few days off to be sick.
SPEAKER_00Correct, correct. I think that's right. I mean, and in the self-funding world, you know, a self-funding plan is still tax deductible on the front end, just like any you know traditional insurance policy. So they're they're still getting that benefit. But then, you know, versus going to a traditional career and you're paying $400 a month and you pay that $400 and whatever, even if you have low utilization, you're not getting any of that money back. But in a self-funding world, you're saying, okay, I'm going to pay this money and it's tax deductible just like my normal plan is. But now if nobody's using it or very low is using it, I'm coming, it's coming back to me. And if it's structured under the 831 tax code, now you're saying it's coming back to me income tax-free. So now it's kind of like that, not a double whammy, but a double reward, really. Now you're saying it makes a lot of sense. I'm writing it off on the front end. Anything unused is coming back to me. My carrier is just not keeping that money, and off we go.
DavidSo I'm a benefit advisor and I'm listening to the podcast and I'm thinking, wow, you know, there are some of these entities in my area. I'll bet nobody's talked to them yet. I want to go have that conversation with these employers. From a benefit advisor perspective, what are the elements that that conversation needs to include? How's that conversation go?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think a lot of these brokers that are, you know, entering this new world realize that there's a huge amount of opportunity because they might have been knocking on this manufacturer's door for the last two years with a similar traditional plan for that management. And now, if they think outside the box a little bit and saying, hey, I gotta I still have the solution for your management people, but I now I have the solution for your you know workers, your blue-collar who've traditionally never had insurance. Now I have that opportunity. So really it's a it's a twofold question because one, it's you know, advising them or educating them on the new rules under the ACA. You know, are they a large employer? Are they not a large employer? Do they have to do something? What are the penalties, you know, what kind of coverage they do. But then, second off is talking about, hey, let's try to mitigate your cost. One, we're gonna mitigate your exposure by giving you what's needed to satisfy these ACA penalties, but ultimately, we're gonna also maybe give you a tax solution that's really gonna help you out in the long run. And then you know, we're seeing a lot of companies who take advantage of this 831B option, that they are able to fund some of their new health care cost with this income tax-free money. Because if you had a company that say they're profitable every year, $500,000, and they're paying a 40% tax bracket on that, so they're paying, I don't know, $230,000 in taxes, income state and federal, on that $500,000. Now you say, hey, Joe, what if we take your $500,000 that you're profitable each year, and we put it into a captive structure under this IRS code $831B? I just saved you $230,000. Your new healthcare cost is maybe $250,000. So with that savings, you're able to pay for that. But it's, you know, that changing market is very, very important because ACA puts everything in difference. And, you know, I know politically wise, everybody's like, oh, this is gonna happen. This is it's a law. It's happened, it's in place. Penalties are gonna be enforced. You know, they've hired a new or a larger group of IRS agents that are out there enforcing these. And granted, people aren't seeing these penalties right now today, but next year and as years roll along, are you prepared for that? Are you in a proper place? And you would hope your advisor is directing you both on a cost measure and benefits that protect you from these potential penalties. Because they could be backbreaking, you know, on that end of it.
DavidWell, and they've just recently doubled. I mean, all the all the penalties, at least in the 1095 uh related penalties, uh doubled in the dark of night at the end of a attacked onto a little trade bill. So, you know, I'm sure most of our listeners are are aware of that. For those of you who are interested in learning more about this 831B, if you go to the Shift Shapers online website and underneath the show notes for this episode, we'll give you a link that that helps you find out more information about that. You know, Bob, in in the couple of minutes that we have left, we always like to ask our subject matter experts what they see coming in the future from the perspective of what we've talked about today. What's likely to change? What should advisors be looking for?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's gonna be interesting as our year gets closer to the end to see if you know the laws change with regards to the AECA. I mean, there's a lot of companies out there that are doing these minimal essential coverage plans. You hear that as a common nomenclature that is just the basic coverage. So, you know, there's some concern is just doing a minimal essential coverage plan, is that gonna last? We don't know. There's really no argument going on right now in in Washington on that, but you you never know as those changes go along. I mean, every day, just as the ACA changes, companies have to evolve as quickly as the ACA is. And we've known the you know, last five years, the ACA has been all over the board. So it's tough to keep that going. But I think the key moving forward is brokers have to have now a gamut of products. They just can't stay with their traditional products because that doesn't fit everybody in the market. And, you know, now that these companies 50 and and above, with 50 employees and above, are affected by that, they're entering the market because usually they may a company with 50 people might be only insured two people or maybe not even insured anybody because they didn't have to. So I think it's gonna be key as the ACA moves along that brokers are aware of all products out there because you never know who's gonna come into your into your office and saying, I'm looking for something, I have to do something, but I can't afford why I can afford X. And if you don't have X in front of you or at least educated about X, then you're potentially losing that sale because they have to search for something.
DavidBob Gardner, National Business Development Coordinator of Freedom Care Benefits. Bob, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience today.
SPEAKER_00I appreciate your time, Dave. Thank you for the opportunity of speaking out on this. But you know, like you said, it's an it's important to realize there's other options out there for brokers to get educated on, and that that's really the key moving forward if they want to be successful.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Ship Shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803-386-8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the ship shapers to work in your business.