The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #72: Best Practices and Innovative Agency Techniques - With Emily Bremer
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In today’s environment, the average age of benefit advisors and agency owners is increasing, but there are some younger people coming into the insurance business and they are bringing innovation and new best practices to the table. Emily Bremer, founder at Bremer Conley Insurance Brokers & Consultants is one of those advisors, and she joins us to discuss some of the things her agency is doing.
We discuss some of the issues with the traditional agency systems, as well as compensation compression and what Emily and other new independent benefits advisors are doing to solve those problems. While these newer advisors are “fiercely independent”, you may be surprised at how some of them are joining together to create a cooperative that maximizes resources and eliminates duplication and waste – all of which will increase profitability.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Emily’s journey into the insurance business.
- The problem with traditional agency compensation systems.
- How and why she is working on forming a cooperative.
- The new best practices she is developing.
What new ideas and best practices are some of the newer, fiercely independent benefit advisors bringing to the industry? And what can we learn from them? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultan.
DavidThis episode of Shift Shapers is sponsored by the Protect Plans. All-level premium and maximum funded plans offer employers the chance to earn refunds when claims are less than expected. But the Protect Plans help deliver on that promise with their unique refund assistors. Learn more at www.protectplans.info. Back not so many years ago, Apple had a marketing slogan called Think Different. One of the things we all talk about when we gather is that the average age of benefit advisors, agency owners, etc., is kind of getting up there, and that there aren't a lot of younger people coming into the business who are thinking different. And we found one for you. And we think you're going to be fascinated by some of the stuff that they're doing. And we're pleased to welcome Emily Bramer, who's founder at BramerConly, to the podcast. Hi, Emily.
SPEAKER_00Hi, how are you, David?
DavidI'm doing well. Thanks for sharing some of your expertise and your experience with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_00Oh, thank you for having me. I'm looking forward to it.
DavidA little bit about your background and your agency. How do you get to be doing what you're doing?
SPEAKER_00Sure. Well, you know, I got into the business, I think, the same way a lot of younger people do who, you know, end up in producer roles or agency ownership roles. As I, you know, I got suckered in by my father, who had been in the insurance industry for quite some time and was on his own at this point, an independent agency. It was him and a partner. His partner had pretty much retired. So it was really just him at that point. And he was battling cancer. So even though I am third generation in insurance and had fought it kicking and screaming my whole life, you know, I'd already lost my mom and I wanted to spend some time with him. So it was an opportunity for me to do that. And so I decided to, you know, I really got into it thinking I was going to get to spend time with my dad and be a help to him more than I really thought of this as a long-term career. But once I got into the industry, what I found was I finally the light bulb went on and I discovered why my father liked it so much. And it was really interesting and challenging. And there were so many things to learn. It was like putting giant jigsaw puzzles together, which is something that's always appealed to me. But, you know, and beyond that, I felt like the work that I did really mattered for people, that I could make a real difference, that I could be of service or help somebody with something that for most people, you know, insurance is stressful and frightening. It makes them feel stupid because they might have a hard time understanding it. There's a lot of lingo involved, obviously. And it's a counterintuitive thing. You're spending quite a bit of money to buy something that you hope to never use. So it's not usually people's favorite thing to do. But when you can, through your knowledge, expertise, and service, get into the mix of that and help them have those aha moments and finally understand what they're purchasing and why, it really makes a difference. It's it's a very exciting and rewarding, I thought, thing to do. And as well as the people in the industry are just wonderful. And, you know, through my involvement of NAHU, I've gotten to meet more people in the industry nationwide. And what I have found is that, you know, you you'll just never meet so many really great people, as you will, in the insurance industry, particularly those who are members of NAHU, I feel. So it's just, you know, it was a good opportunity for me.
DavidIt is nice to be around folks who who really enjoy helping other people. And you're right, oftentimes or too often, I think that gets lost in the scrum of all the other gobbledygook that we have to deal with on a daily basis. So with that said, and it's a great introduction, let's dive into some of the meat of the matter. One of the things that you realized early on is that there's a problem with the traditional distribution and agency structure that's really, for lack of a better word, a margin killer. Talk a little bit about that and what you learned.
SPEAKER_00Well, one thing that I've been noticing is that as my agency has been growing and thriving and bringing on new accounts, and some of the other agency owners and producers that I've been talking to have been not seeming to share the same experience. And, you know, and I don't know that it's not that they're not sharing the same experience. It's maybe they're not sharing the same perception of their experience. I started to think about how my father structured his agency, how I have structured mine now, and then how I see others being structured and what the point of difference is. And one thing that I have noticed is that in many of the traditional models, you have a very, I guess what I would call payroll heavy structure. So you have this pot of money, whether it be commission or fees or both, that's being obtained via the client, you know. Well, I guess, you know, from your clients, but via the insurance company. And in the past, you had some more control over negotiating that commission. That control has decreased in some cases substantially. You know, I just got another email this week from a large major national carrier saying that they are going to stop paying commissions on individual policies on any new policy September 1st and onward. And, you know, for those people who've always been in that commission-based structure, I think transitioning to fees is a challenge. I think for any of us, transitioning to fees is a challenge. It's hard to go to your clients and ask them to pay you a fee when they feel like they're already paying so much more than they would like to for the products that you're selling them. But in addition to that, what I noticed with this model is that so you have this pot of commissions, and the pot of commissions in some cases is decreasing. And within that pot, there are a lot of people that have to be paid out to. So you have the agency and they need their cut. And their cut has to be big enough to cover all the support staff and turning on the lights and the ENO and you know, the technology, the tools that are being offered to the clients and everything else that needs to be taken care of. And those needs are getting larger and larger every year. Whether it's a private exchange or a benefit administration system or ACA tax reporting tracking software or whatever it is, HIPAA compliance tools. You know, there's more that is demanded of an agency to provide. And then in addition to that, I think staff are getting more expensive. And I think one of the reasons for that is sort of the second part of the equation, which is how much money goes to the producing agents. And for that, you then have maybe one or more producers involved. For example, if it's a P and C agency structure, you may have a producing agent who's really, while they might work for the agency, they might be more of a referring agent in that they don't necessarily know health and life, like they know property and casualty and they're bringing, they're bringing the business in-house, but they're not really necessarily the one providing the advice and the consultation. And then even within a life in health agency, you know, how are you getting your business? Is it being referred in? Are your producers used to being in more of a hands-off setting with a large back office? How is that being handled? And as the ACA makes things more and more complex, those back office staff aren't just pushing paper, you know, really. I mean, in in many cases, they're expected to know quite a bit of information about the Affordable Care Act, compliance, all the constant changes in plans. There's just so much to keep track of that is supposed to be being communicated to these clients that really your main account managers, or in some cases, if it's account executive layered above account manager, they are really responsible for quite a high level of knowledge. This is not somebody who's making 10 bucks an hour. And in some cases, it might be somebody who's making six figures. So now you have the, you know, the agency having to pay these sort of larger salaries. You have the producers that are still, you know, trying to make their living off of this whole situation. You may even have additional account executives and account managers or and or administrative staff. And once you get all of those layers in, and then you look at the compression of commissions, it becomes very hard to make this sort of business profitable. So I think that one of the things that I noticed when I was looking at all of this is what am I doing that's different? Why does this not feel like a problem to me per se? And I think part of it is that in my agency, the producers are all very actively involved in the servicing of the account. So the back office staff is truly that. They're in the back office. The producers are the ones who are like myself, are the ones who are out in front of the client, who are providing the actual advice and who are the ones who are responsible for staying on top of all of the, you know, new regulatory guidance, what's going on with the plans, what's happening with the carriers, that it's really a team effort where the producers are actively engaged and involved. I think that's one thing that's different. I think another thing, though, too, is that my agency has started charging fees where it makes sense. In some cases, you know, fees are not necessary at this point. And we've been able to sit down with our clients and talk to them about what we make and how we make it and the work that we do for them. And we're able to, you know, negotiate a commission that makes sense. Or we are able to charge a fee in addition to the commission, which I know in some states you're not allowed to do. So we were lucky in Missouri that that's an option. Or we charge a fee instead of the commission altogether. And, you know, that's been an interesting transition. At first, it was a little scary because, you know, my father had always raised me that you don't talk about the commissions, you never talk about the money with the clients. But I figured most of our clients at the time when I started were law firms. And I thought, well, you know, they all charge by the hour. They know that the work that they do has to be paid and they're used to billing their clients. So they know we make money. They don't really know how much, but why shouldn't they know? You know, is what we make inappropriate for the work that we do? And what I found is that it's not really the case. I think that what we get paid is very appropriate for the work that we do. I think that sometimes it can be unbalanced, where on some cases we make way more than is needed, and on others we make less. But is that something that the client should have to handle, or is that something that we should handle by taking those clients that are not profitable and either adjusting their expectations about what we do versus what they do, or bringing their revenue up by putting in additional lines of coverage or charging a fee, and then going back to the clients where maybe they're subsidizing other clients and bringing those revenues down where appropriate. You know, and those are the kinds of conversations that we're having with our clients now on a regular basis, and I found that everyone has been very open to them.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. Level premium self-funded programs have been around for some time. The first generation offered employers the opportunity to get a refund if their group's claims were lower than expected. Meet the next generation, the Protect plans, delivering simple and safe, fixed-cost self-funded medical coverage with refund assistors that pay cash rewards to employees who improve and manage their health, helping employers earn those claims refunds. The Protect plans deliver quality and pricing data on in-network facilities, and they include the expertise of experienced insurance executives and actuaries to review program expenses. The Protect plans also deliver proven quality administration and Aetna's strong national PPO network. They also feature only AM-best A-rated stop loss carriers and proven third-party administration. There's the first generation of level premium programs, and then there's the Protect Plans. Safe and simple, fixed cost, self-funded medical coverage with refund assistors. Learn more at www.protectplans.info. What's interesting is you're having some other conversations as well that that directly relate to the front end of the thinking you talked about on how you're trying to change the model. You know, we talked offline. One of the things that you said, some other agency owners that you've been talking to are struggling with some of the similar issues. You've created what you are in the process of creating what you call a cooperative. And it's a really neat idea. Can you talk a little bit about that? Explain how it came about, where it's at, and what the goals are that you hope to achieve?
SPEAKER_00Sure. So one of the projects that I'm working on right now in my spare time, right? Because we all have so much to say.
DavidTons of it, tons of it.
SPEAKER_00Right. Is getting like-minded agency owners together to try to build a cooperative effort. You know, through my involvement in NAHU, I had already met a number of agency owners where I found that we were collaborating from time to time. It seems like a lot of people are moving into their own niche or niche, or however you want to pronounce that within the industry. You know, some folks are specializing in self-funding, others are targeting small groups of two to 50, others are abandoning small groups of two to 50 and targeting groups of over 100. Some are expanding their individual block of business for under 65, some are expanding their Medicare revenue. But, you know, it seems that there's so much to know. You can't know it all. And not unlike sort of the division between property and casualty in health and life, there's also seems to be increasingly a division even within health and life where you're seeing smaller agencies that are kind of finding their own path that makes sense for them where they can really specialize. And where you can take a number of those agencies and bring them together, there's so much opportunity to share ideas, share information, collaborate on pieces of business, which in some cases, a large, you know, someone who's part of a large national agency might say, well, but that's why we're a part of a large national agency. And so we can do all of that too. But I think that, you know, even within a large agency, you know, it can be hard to get everybody to communicate and to work together as a team. And what I thought was interesting about this is that, you know, it allows those of us who I refer to as the fierce independents, the outliers that still have not joined up with a larger program, that, you know, want to be able to innovate, that want to be able to do their own thing and have that independence, that to allow them that structure for them to continue to do that, but then also be able to have a team to collaborate with kind of brings together the best of both worlds. So this is something that I've started working on probably about a year ago, um, started bringing together some like-minded agencies. And I mean, this wasn't just something that, you know, I've done on my own, obviously, because the other members involved were also very interested in doing some of the of the same things. So it's something that, you know, really came about pretty organically through us talking and collaborating and kind of figuring out what we would need to do from a structure perspective to take that to the next level. So it's still in a building stage, you know. We're working on it and trying to launch it for 2016, but we're still in the process of building it because obviously, you know, there's quite a bit, you know, that needs to go into something like this with, you know, non-compete agreements and how's the ENO going to work and what's the corporate structure is gonna be, is it gonna be a not-for-profit or an LLC and all those sorts of things? So, but I think we have some core players together that are interested in doing this. And I think another thing that's interesting too is that they all seem to have a pretty long time horizon left before retirement. They are people who are really committed to making it onto the other side of the transition of what's happening right now within the industry and ACA.
DavidBut in your model, it's different than just, at least from our previous conversations. It's it's different. What you're envisioning is very different than a traditional roll-up where a bunch of agencies just come together to maximize commission structure resources, et cetera. Would it be accurate to say that it's kind of a hybrid cross between that and uh a master group?
SPEAKER_00I guess you could say that because you know, we're really looking at it in terms of what are our needs and what would bring more to our clients and to help us grow than in worrying about what anybody else is doing in particular. So one of the things that we've talked about is, you know, pooling resources of staff. So for example, you know, you may not need an extra set of hands all year long, but there might be a particular time of year that's busy for one agency over another, or there might be a particular client that you're trying to onboard that has a very, you know, heavy enrollment need that requires extra helping hands, where you could have a shared staff or pooled staff, where that way you wouldn't have to have as many people necessarily on staff all year long, but you could share and use it where it makes sense. Now, obviously, this only works if everybody doesn't have the exact same busy periods and needs. So it would have to be that there would be some fluctuation there. Otherwise, you know, the model doesn't necessarily make sense. But I mean, staffing is one of the things that we've looked at, using, you know, volume discounts to purchase additional resources, collaborating on bringing in new pieces of business is joint effort. We've looked at a variety of things. And already, even just sharing information has been huge because right now I believe that knowledge is power, you know, not necessarily just the knowledge of your competitors or your knowledge of your clients, but also just the knowledge of what's going on in the industry. Every single day we turn around and something new happens. How do you possibly, as a business owner, as an agency owner, stay on top of all of those things all the time and take care of your business? So, how can we share time, you know, in terms of research, in terms of staying on top of what's happening with regulatory guidance, the new Cadillac tax guidance that just came out is a perfect example. You know, I mean every time we turn around, something gets issued that's tens of pages or hundreds of pages that has to be reviewed and shared in a meaningful way. So, as well as just the projects that are involved with researching and staying on top of all these different things. I think that forming and into, you know, joining into a national agency is one solution for that, but you really do let go of quite a bit of control. Whereas with this, the members would have an option to buy into what made sense and work independently where it makes sense. So let's say, for example, everybody in the cooperative, you know, except for one agency, agrees that they want to use Zixmail, but you've got an outlier that really doesn't want to use it. They prefer the the Citrix share file because it works better for them and their clients. Well, they could do that. The services could be built out based on what's actually used, as opposed to just handing over a percentage of your revenue and then letting somebody else figure it out. So it would take still more engagement, but it would also allow you to have more control.
DavidFascinating, fascinating. Emily, in the in the two minutes or so we have left, we always like to wrap up by asking all of our subject matter experts where they see the future. What does it look like? And you've got a very interesting perspective. So would you spend the next, you know, minute and a half, two minutes sharing where you see the future, what it looks like?
SPEAKER_00Oh my goodness, that is, you're asking the hardest question at the end. I, you know, I don't know where I see the future. I think it is so much in flux right now. What I've been trying to tell my clients and also to tell myself is just to constantly maintain a position of flexibility. So much could change with the, you know, with the election next year. So much could change with the next set of regulatory guidance that comes out. The one thing though that I see more than anything is that our clients need us more than ever. Negotiation is such a small part of what we do and what we can offer to them. And so, you know, I have never felt so needed as I do in this environment right now, and I don't think that that part of it is going to change for the foreseeable future.
DavidGreat place to leave the conversation, and I could not possibly agree more. Emily Bramer, founder of BramerConly. Emily, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, David.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you to help shape the ships in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com. Or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Ship Shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803-386-8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the Ship Shapers to work in your business.