The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #65: What You Need To Know To Position Self Insurance – With Jay Kempton
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Jay Kempton, president & CEO of The Kempton Group has been described as “the personification of a disruptive force in the self funded world.” In our wide ranging discussion, Jay talks about everything from what buying a truck would be like if we applied today’s insurance purchasing rules to why Health Savings Accounts aren’t a real long-term solution.
We also explore the gap between the insurance provider and the consumer of the health goods and services, how it has grown over the years and how it has affected buying decisions. Jay also shares his views about how PPACA has strengthened TPAs and increased interest in self insurance. Whether you are currently discussing self insurance concepts with your clients, or you are new to helping employers become insurance owners rather than insurance buyers, you won’t want to miss this episode.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- How the Kempton Group was founded.
- How to help employers go from insurance buyers to insurance owners.
- How the “distance” between provider and patient has distorted buying decisions.
- Despite early concerns, PPACA has accelerated self insurance and strengthened TPAs.
- Why HSAs are not really a long-term solution to creating consumers.
- Whether patients are beginning to wake up and demand up-front pricing and quality metrics.
What does buying a truck have to do with learning how to explain and position the opportunities in self-insurance? We'll find out on this episode of Chip Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Chip Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the chips in the registries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chip transformation strategist, David Saltman.
DavidToday's episode is brought to you by HR360, the trusted source for customizable compliance tools used by brokers and their clients nationwide. Their monthly benefits newsletter, HCA alerts, wrap SPDs, HR library, and other attorney review tools will help you keep your clients and win new ones, and at a cost that will amaze you. On this episode of Shift Shapers, we're pleased to be speaking with Jay Kempton. Jay is president and CEO of the Kempton Group. Jay was described by a business associate of ours as the personification of a disruptive force in the self-funded world. So with that, and that's an auspicious beginning, welcome, Jay. Good morning, David. Thanks for spending some time with the Shift Shapers audience. Tell us a little bit about what your journey was like that led you to founding the Kempton Group.
SPEAKER_01Well, actually, David, I didn't found it. I was uh I was kind of born into this. My dad uh founded the Kempton Group um back in 1969. And uh after college, and I graduated in 92, and my dad uh kind of laid out what uh my next steps were going to be, and uh he ended up putting me on the road going out and talking to clients. Uh, and I've been doing that ever since February of 92. But uh, you know, as a second generation business owner, the onus is on me, and I'm just trying to uh keep it between the ditches and um continue to build on our our reputation and uh build on what my dad started.
DavidUnderstand that there, you know, there's a different dynamic when it's a family business, and and you know, there's always the the entrepreneurial pressure, but you're right, it's something that you want to keep going. These days, you know, it's interesting. There's a been a lot of interest in self-funding. It's one of the challenges that advisors face is getting prospects to change their mindset from a buyer to an owner. How do you go about that? What's that conversation like?
SPEAKER_01You know, it's a difficult conversation until you strip out all the noise. We've been doing this for quite a while. As you know, you know, back when I first started here in in 1992, the very first task I had when we came to work was I was going to be introducing a new concept to the employers that we did business with. And this new concept was a PPO, preferred provider organization. Most employers and even most TPAs couldn't even spell PPO back then. We didn't know what it was. But that was really, David, the beginning of starting to put layers between the buyer of healthcare goods and services and the seller of healthcare goods and services. You know, the invention of the copay, the invention of the of a provider network, those were all things that uh kind of dulled the uh consumer gene in this marketplace. And so I really I kind of point back to the early 90s as self-funded employers and patients really started to look at health care differently, where they didn't have a stake in it, they didn't have control of it, cost of care started to transform into my out-of-pocket cost. And what is it gonna, I don't really care what it costs. I'm just interested in what it costs me, which is is very deleterious to uh everybody's mission here to have high quality care at low cost. So, to your question of how do you how do you get somebody to think of it as an owner, you really have to start stripping the layers back and taking people. I talked to folks and say, well, what are you doing here? You know, what's all what is the Kim to group all about? I'm saying, well, I'm really just trying to get back to uh the late 80s and uh trying to get people to think of of healthcare before uh all the layers were introduced.
DavidAaron Powell You know, the layers analogy is is really interesting, and I wonder if some of the problem is because, to use your words, there are too many layers between the buyers and the sellers. How has that made it more difficult for folks to think like consumers, especially when you couple it with the I'm spending other people's money, I don't care phenomenon?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's extremely difficult. Most of the medical providers, and it seems like it gets worse the larger uh the provider is, large hospital systems are terrible at this. They really don't see the patient as the buyer at all, even though they will make the patient sign a financial obligation agreement before they will provide care, which says you are the buyer, it doesn't matter whether or not you have insurance or not, whether your insurance pays or not, we're gonna hold you responsible. But then, if the patient was to ever ask a question about what they're buying and what it costs, and can you define the services that you're gonna be providing to me? There is just a blank stare from the seller from the hospital that uh, hey, why are you even asking this question? Who are you to add? This has all been worked out, all been decided ahead of time between us and your insurance company. And so the patient is truly made to feel that uh they are really just an insignificant cog in this wheel and everything has already been laid out.
DavidWhen we were talking off-air, I think you gave me a great analogy, and I'd like you to, if you would, share that with our listeners about buying a truck.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely, David. And yesterday I didn't mention uh that I was going to expand on the truck analogy, but the analogy is if you were going to buy a Ford pickup truck and that Ford dealership was not able to give you a price for the Ford pickup truck before you bought it, there's no way that you would buy that pickup. You would look for a Chevrolet or a Dodge or whatever. Um we also hear in healthcare a lot about, well, healthcare is different. It's very complex. And and even if you ask a hospital what a surgery is gonna cost, they say, well, you know, I I can't really give you an answer, but but if I was able to, I can really only speak for the hospital because this is so complex, we're gonna have other medical providers that are not part of the hospital are gonna be working on you like an anesthesiologist or or a radiologist or a surgical group or et cetera, et cetera, and we don't speak for them. That we would not tolerate that type of an answer from any other industry. You know, going back to the Ford dealership, Ford makes pickup trucks, but they do not make every single thing on that pickup truck. For instance, the tires, a lot of times those tires are made by Firestone or Goodyear or some other manufacturer, and that manufacturer of tires is a subcontractor for Ford. Ford is not able to when you walk into a dealership and you look at that window sticker, Ford cannot say on the window sticker, well, tires are not included, and we can't really tell you what the price of the tires are going to be because you're gonna have to wait and get a bill from Goodyear three months from now. Again, Ford has has to take responsibility for their subs because the Ford dealership is a point of purchase. The hospital is the point of purchase. The seller is responsible for bundling all of the component pieces. And some pieces they're gonna be more profitable on, some pieces are gonna be a loss leader, but they know if they're gonna sell Ford pickups, they have to be able to bundle all their prices. They also have to work with their sub their subcontractors, their sub-providers to be able to offer a unitized price for the Ford pickup that is market competitive, because if Ford doesn't do that, no one will buy a Ford pickup. And when you you you break it down into those components, most people will say, you know, guy, that is right. The anesthesia cost at a hospital, that's not my responsibility to wait to see what that bill is gonna be. If the hospital wants to sell me a surgery, and of course I'm assuming it's a non-emergent surgery, if they're wanting to sell me a surgery, it's their responsibility to get the prices ahead of time from their subcontractors and present that to me, or simply I'm gonna go buy somewhere else.
DavidLet's fast forward that a little bit and take that same kind of a thought process about creating a unitized price and giving an entire solution an entire price to the conversation that advisors go out and start having with prospects and with clients. How important is it for advisors to bring a complete package solution rather than in the old days at a TPA, we used to call a bag of parts?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, if you're talking to an employer about self-funding, it is the much deeper conversation than this is the cost of the benefits and here's the PPO network. Employers are really looking for an overall strategy. I try to break things down and make them simple. And when an advisor is going to go and talk about being self-insured, they really need to say, you know, we're gonna be setting you up as uh you are a buyer of healthcare goods and services. And truly the self-funded employer is. Their employees are also buyers, and so we need to be able to educate these buyers on how to buy better. We need to be able to, hopefully, an advisor would be able to make a buyer aware of fair free market sellers, um, and and there are a growing number of medical providers out there. But really, we need to make, I think an advisor at this point in the game needs to be kind of a magician that is telling all the secrets. A self-funded employer needs to know the fallacy of a PPO discount off of an unknown starting point. They need to know that all PPO networks and all negotiated discounts are not in their best interest. They also need to know if they want to control their costs, they cannot blindly choose to incentivize employees to go to the biggest hospitals because they've got the best TV ads they really need to have a deeper conversation about value. What is the quality from that facility? What are the prices at that facility? Even though they may sponsor a sports team here in our community, maybe they've got wonderful TV commercials, but are they a valuable place to buy healthcare? If not, we need to look, we need to educate ourselves on that, and we need to look elsewhere.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. In today's market, you need a competitive edge, and HR 360 delivers with their special program for brokers called the 750 solution, loaded with every major compliance tool your clients need. And it's great for prospecting too. HR 360's all-in-one program includes 750 subscriptions to HR 360's attorney-reviewed online HR library that acts like an HR department for your clients so you can provide a subscription to all your clients and prospects. Keep your clients current and compliant with ACA news alerts, checklists, and guides branded with your logo, in addition to customizable monthly benefits newsletters and a free emailing system to send those newsletters and ACA alerts. And best of all, this entire popular program, including all of the tools I just mentioned, is only $899 a year. That's a special 30% discount just for ShiftShapers listeners. You really have to try it to fully understand the value in these attorney-reviewed customizable compliance tools. For free trial access to HR360's tools, just click on the sponsor link at ShiftShapersOnline.com or email sales at hr360.com and mention Shift Shapers to take advantage of that special 30% discount. So how do you get employees educated? And you know, some folks thought that HSAs were going to be a great way to create healthcare consumers, but that hasn't gone far enough and it's got some flaws, I think, in the overall logic of creating a consumer. So what's your view on how those have worked to move that bar and what's still needed if you're going to try to help an employee turn into a thoughtful and intelligent consumer?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it is difficult because you know the numbers that the cost gets, you don't have to have very many medical procedures or very uh expensive medical condition before the costs overwhelm a health savings account. And so you can't just concentrate on claims that are spent within an HSA or within a person's deductible, even with deductibles as expensive or as high as they are today, they're still just a drop in the bucket. So you're gonna have to expand that conversation into the overall cost. And so you want the patients, the employees, and their dependents to look at the entire nickel as theirs. Not just what does this procedure cost me, but what does it also cost my employer's benefit plan? Most self-funded benefit plans are paid out of the general assets of the company, which happens to also be the same pocket that pays their paycheck and their bonuses, buys new equipment, etc. So the employees need to look at it from a holistic perspective. Health savings accounts, I love health savings accounts. However, the federal government, I think, screwed up health savings accounts pretty badly because they they did tie those to participation in a qualified, federally qualified high deductible health plan. And those high deductible health plans have a few mandates in them. One of them is that an employee has to be out, they have to exhaust their entire high deductible out of their own pocket. They have to spend their own money before the benefit plan can assist them. What we have found, David, is employees, at least at this stage of the game, they need an incentive to buy better. And if we can show them where there are free market medical providers that offer bundled cash pricing and also make them aware that if they choose that facility based upon their transparent bundled pricing, that their employer will back them up and will pay that cash bundled cash price at this facility. It makes a lot of sense. It provides a heck of an incentive for the employee. It also puts the buyer and the seller back into basically a two-party cash transaction. But you can't do that under an HSA model because the benefit plan cannot waive, essentially, the employee's deductible on a health savings account chassis. And so it's you kind of shoot your foot off on that. You're just not able to get the employee to think holistically about the expense. They simply are focused on what does it cost me? What is it within my deductible? If the charge is over, if the procedure costs more than the deductible, they don't really care whether the procedure is $20,000 or $20 million. Either way, it's over my health savings account deductible, so that expense is somebody else's problem. That's what we've got to change.
DavidAnd we're back to the OPM question again. You know, back when ACA was passed, I remember, and I'm sure you do too, an awful lot of doom and gloom. Folks thought, initially at least, that self-funding was dead and that TPAs were going to be dinosaurs. Hasn't worked out that way, has it? And second part of the question, what kind of opportunities has that opened up for advisors?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, uh, you know, David, back in 2010, as a uh an independent family-owned TPA, and you know, we're we're probably small to medium-sized TPA work in essentially two states, Oklahoma and Texas. But when 2010 came around and and Obamacare was signed into law, boy, all the experts in the industry had said, you know, self-funding is dead. Eventually that's gonna happen. But the independent TPA, you know, you're you're already dead. The body's just not cold yet. You know, I didn't want to believe that, but everybody was saying that. And uh we just got to a point at at my company that we were gonna start uh if we're gonna be if we're gonna be dead here in the next year or two or three, then we're gonna start, uh, at least we're gonna go out on our own terms. And we kind of had an awakening, if you will, or uh or um we decided to get refocused. And what I mean by that is we decided to get simple. We decided to go back to 1989 and start looking at network pricing as the worst possible pricing. If all other creative ideas for educated employers and employees to buy better, when all else fails, then the network pricing is kind of the pricing of last resort. And we we did. We went we got back instead of explaining to employers and employees uh how best to utilize managed care, how best to utilize wellness or disease management, even though those are important things, we really started to focus on what is the net spend for a hysterectomy? What is the total cost for a coronary artery bypass? And where is it that we can get that at a total? We don't care what the discount is. I don't care if it's a 70% discount or a 0% discount. We're gonna start looking at total net spend, quit believing all of the hype that is involved in the the brokering of provider discounts. We're gonna start ignoring that. And we've really seen our business start to take off. I explained, you know, really pretty much everything that we've been talking about this morning. I explained it to a CEO of an oil field service company, and I had mentioned to this guy, okay, you know, we're we're gonna take a whole different track here. For everything that we've been doing with you for the last 10 years, we're gonna chuck that and we're gonna start talking this crazy idea of this free market transparency and empowering your employees to buy better, et cetera, et cetera. And after I was done explaining it to him, I mentioned, he said, I said, now does that make sense? And he I'll never forget the CEO. He said, Kempton, that's the first thing you've said that does make sense in the 10 years that we've done business. Because for the last 10 years it was blah, blah, blah, discount, blah, blah, blah, price percentage off of X, networks, utilization management, and everything. This guy understood buying and selling. And finally, healthcare, somebody was talking about healthcare in the context of buying and selling and seeking value. I mean, what a concept.
DavidYeah, and you know, every business that any of us talk to, they all understand that because they do it in every other aspect of their business except healthcare. So, Jay, in in the minute or so that we've got left, we always like to wrap up by asking our experts that we talk to on Shift Shapers, what do you see the future? What do you see in the near-term and the midterm, however, you want to define that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, David, I think you've had um Dr. Keith Smith on on your show before. You know, Dr. Keith, uh, Dr. Smith was the first facility manager that that started putting together the bundled cash pricing. I'm sure you all went into that. We're doing business now with about 33 facilities that have offered, they're starting to offer bundled cash pricing. We have not been out knocking on doors, twisting arms, and trying to negotiate with these medical providers to offer bundled cash pricing. This is the anti-network movement, if you if you want to call it that way. The reason that it has expanded from one facility offering bundled cash pricing, like Dr. Smith's office facility, to 33 that we know of, it has simply been because of market competition. As patients are starting to demand pricing, when you start to have facilities that are posting their bundled cash pricing, patients are starting to wake up and starting to ask those questions. And when they're looked at with a blank stare and they're told they can't come up with this pricing, I don't know what this is going to cost. These patients are saying, Oh, yeah, well, there's three other facilities in my region, or there's 10 other facilities that I'm aware of that do offer bundled cash pricing for my procedure. And oh, by the way, here's their pricing, and my employer is offering to pay this pricing in cash. So are you ready to step up? That's what's starting to cause in. I think that is going to continue, and I think it's going to be led by the self-insured employer.
DavidAnd that's the definition of consumerism, isn't it? You got it. Jay, thank you so much for spending some time with the Shift Shapers audience today. Jay Kempton, president and CEO of the Kempton Group. Thanks again, Jay. Uh-huh, David. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Salzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you, to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of shift chapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803-386-8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the shift chapers to work in your business.