The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #61: A Futurist's View on Healthcare - With David Houle
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
As change accelerates all around us, most aspects of human life are undergoing dramatic amounts and various rates of shift. With that in mind, who better to ask about the myriad changes surrounding healthcare than a futurist?
Our guest on this episode is David Houle, is a not only a futurist who lectures worldwide, he is also the author of a number of books, including on that is aimed directly at our wheelhouse: “New Age Health: The Future of Health Care in America”.
David reminds us that the shift in today’s healthcare started long before the Affordable Care Act. In this wide-ranging discussion, we end by looking at the past to give us a clearer indication of the future, including some thoughts about initiatives, technologies and new ways of thinking that have the potential to lower costs and increase its efficiency. Don’t miss this informative episode.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- The true beginnings of today’s industry change.
- How Gutenberg began a chain of influential events.
- Why Dr. Devi Shetty is a perfect example of one possible future.
- The role telehealth plays in today’s health care and where it’s headed.
- Medical Miracles.
- Why payers, patients, and providers are at war.
As change accelerates all around us, what can we learn from a futurist? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidToday's episode is brought to you by HR 360, the trusted source for customizable compliance tools used by brokers and their clients nationwide. Their monthly benefits newsletter, ACA alerts, wrap SPDs, HR library, and other attorney review tools will help you keep your clients and win new ones. And at a cost that will amaze you. In this episode of Shift Shapers, we're very excited to be talking to David Hoole. David is a futurist. He lectures worldwide. He's the author of a number of books, including one we'll focus on a little bit today, called New Health Age, The Future of Healthcare in America. With that, welcome, David.
SPEAKER_01My pleasure to be here, David. Thank you.
DavidIn your book, The Shift Age, you wrote a sentence that I think maybe sets up our entire discussion today. You've said we've entered the shift age when almost everything is in a state of shift and change is accelerating all around us. That pretty much sums up where healthcare is today, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_01It certainly does, and where most of the world is as well. Back in 2005, when I started thinking about what was going to happen, I realized that the information age got its name in the early 70s. And from the vantage point of 2005, looking back, well, since the early 70s, there was the personal computer, there was the collapse of the Soviet Union, there was the beginning of the global economy, there was the internet, and there were cell phones. Just those five things were going to usher in a dramatic new age. And so I thought about what that age would be, and I came up with the name shift age because I saw from that point in time, and now ten years later it's been verified, that all industries and most aspects of human life were going to undergo a dramatic amount of shift and varying rates of shift. So that's the really the largest context. And I think you've heard me talk, and I talk about the first full decade of the shift age as being the transformation decade 2010 to 2020. And the dictionary definition of transformation is a change in nature, shape, character, and form, which means that most of human thinking and much of human in the humanities' institutions are going to change their nature, shape, character, and form in this decade. So when you talk about healthcare, that's part of it. When you talk about communication, when you talk about media, when you talk about anything, when you talk about energy, it's all changing its nature, shape, character, and form. And you know, back around 2007, when I really started speaking a lot about the shift age, people kept thinking, oh, well, now it's really the information age, and now seven years later they realize, oh my God, yeah, the world has completely shifted. My job has shifted, how I communicate has shifted, how I get healthcare shifted. So that's really the largest context, David.
DavidWell, and as you know here at Shift Shapers, we're very partial to the word shift because we also agree that it's going to be the transformative word. A lot of our listeners, they're in the employee benefits arena and they may believe that all of this shift that they're dealing with started with ACA. It really started a long time ago, didn't it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it started really 20 years ago when the internet really took root. Because what the internet did, it initiated the greatest age of disintermediation in human history. The second greatest was the 50 years after Gutenberg disintermediated knowledge away from the, you know, the church. And what disintermediation really means is the root word is intermediary. So disintermediation is removal of the intermediary from a transaction. So in the first wave of the internet, you saw the disintermediation of the stock brokerage industry or the travel industry. And now that we have high-speed bandwidth, it's everything else. So that's part of it. And I've spoken to 3,000 plus CEOs and as business owners. And anyone who is a middleman who is a salesperson, I say either have to add value or provide intellectual property, knowledge, research to your client base, or you have to go to your lowest price and become a commodity, and you don't want to do that. And the second part relative to healthcare is that in this disintermediation age, what healthcare was up until a few years ago was the 17% of the American GDP that was not connected, that was not open free market. If you believe as I do in free markets and you believe in open competition, you know, the simple thing, and I think you saw me do it in a speech I gave in Washington, I said, raise your hands to an audience of about a thousand. If you've ever gone online to do a price-oriented search before making a big purchase, like a flat screen TV or a car, and everybody raised their hand. And then I said, okay, so raise your hands if you've ever gone online to do a price competition, quality outcome measurement before major medical procedure, and three people raised their hands. So what that means is everything that we expect in the rest of our world that we have a say, we get to choose what we want to watch, when we want to watch it, the car we want to buy it, the price we want to buy, where we want to live, how we want to conduct our lives. When it came over to healthcare, oh, sorry, it's paper records, and we can't disclose it to you, and you're gonna have to buy our services and not know how much it costs. So it's it's inevitable that, regardless of the ACA, that healthcare was gonna have to go with the rest of society.
DavidWell, it's interesting. I mean, one of the things that ACA, I think, did, and it was probably an unintended consequence. As a matter of fact, I could be relatively sure that it was an unintended consequence, is that for the first time since World War II, arguably, it's really pushed a lot of people into the market, albeit in that walled garden called a marketplace, but it's pushed them into a market as consumers that they've never really been before. It was, okay, my employer offers X plan, that's what I take. Do you see that accelerating this trend?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I see that the future of healthcare, certainly in the United States, is at the center is the patient and the primary care physician. It is those two people standing together to manage the health of, and I don't even like the word patient, customer, because a patient implies they're they're sick or they need treatment. And before ACA, there were some 140,000 numbers that triggered a billing of some sort for doctors. There wasn't a single number that paid a doctor for keeping patients well. Now that is completely flipping. And the customer and the primary care physician are going to drive the whole interaction together. And anybody who doesn't believe that is wanting to hold on to some view of the way it was when it was comfortable for them.
DavidAnd yet, people do tend to hold on to the view of what was comfortable for them. Part of the reason why I think we we've had this notion, and you you sum it up really well. You say that you believe payers, patients, and suppliers are at war. In large measure, isn't that because nobody wants to let go of the paradigm they help build to move into the new one?
SPEAKER_01Well, that's right. Confusion serves those that maintain confusion. And disinformation is provided by those that don't want to educate. So you had the triangle where the patient was in conflict with the payer, usually the insurance company, and the insurance company was in conflict with the provider, the doctor, and the doctor was in conflict with the patient in the sense that they couldn't be open to them about how much things cost. So absolutely it's all going to change in the sense that it's going to be a payer-driven, and payer means more than just insurance company now. With high deductibles, it means the individual has to pay more. So whenever an individual has to make a major purchase, they pay more attention to the purchase. You go out and you buy a muffin, you buy a muffin and it costs you $2. You buy a $20,000 car, you're going to pay attention to what you get for that $20,000. So now the insurance company, the employer who to some greater or lesser degree is footing the bill, and the client or the customer, the individual, are all going to be in consort to say this is too expensive. And whenever there's a market that has never been price competitive, then it's an inefficient market. The study that was done in 2012, right after the new health age book came out, an internist from the University of Iowa, I believe, called 100 hospitals in the United States and asked them a one-sentence question. How much does it cost for a hip replacement surgery in your hospital? Out of the 100 people who 100 hospitals, excuse me, that were asked that question, 50 could not answer the question. And of the 50 that did, the price ranged from 110,000 to 11,000. Now, when that becomes open market knowledge, the consumer is going to drive that train.
DavidNo question. No, and in point of fact, uh, we've had guests on who've looked at these quality metrics against cost metrics. And in almost every case, almost unfailingly, the most expensive procedure is rarely the best in terms of outcomes. It's kind of an inverse factor of what you'd expect in any other market.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so it drives me nuts when I see these ads. We are the rated the number one hospital, or come to us for cancer, you know, and it's a pretty picture of a building and a couple of gray-haired physicians, and they don't have any statistics. What do you mean you're the best? You know, what does best mean, other than your peers who are playing the same game as you rating you? I think that what we have here is a huge transformation around the world in almost every market, and in healthcare, it's certainly in the United States, because it's the only part of the GDP that has not been changing over the last 20 years. So if you are a supplier of benefits, you make your living by selling benefits, you no longer sell a product, you provide a service. You no longer try to persuade people to pay for something, you ask them what they need. Because if you are selling benefits, you have to understand that other people are doing the same thing. And now, as the power goes to the consumer, the consumer is going to ask more questions. Why is your plan more expensive? What does your plan do? Before I buy it, I want my internists to take a look at it. So all of a sudden the game has changed. Just like everything else. The individual, as I said in the shift age, one of the flows is the flow to global. We're getting all connected. The flow to the individual, the individual has more power now because of the explosion of choice. One of the things, by the way, David, is that I do think that ultimately healthcare is going to go global, that it's not state by state, country by country. There's too many of us like myself that travel the world. Everything is going global. There's a global economy, and the economy leads, right? I mean, so so it healthcare will be going global. And one of the interesting things there is at the same time, practices are being broken down. It's not just the economics. There's a doctor that you and I've talked about, Dr. Devi Shetty, who operates out of India and Bangalore, and he is the most transformative physician in the world today. Forbes calls him the Henry Ford of surgery. The reason they do is he's bringing scale to a craft business. In other words, the healthcare profession, or certainly the surgical part of it, is a craft business. You ask an open heart surgeon how many surgeries they do in a day, and they'll say one or two. You ask any of the doctors working for Dr. Devi Shetty in India, and they say five or six. So because of volume, they can drive down price. Volume has always driven down price. So we're taking a non-scale craft, opaque industry, and making it transparent and scaling it up. And the interesting thing is that Dr. Shetty, and now he's Devi to me and I'm David to him, he set up healthcare in India at $6 a month for tens of thousands of people. And he realizes that he can't transform the world unless he transforms the United States. So I was fortunate to be the closing speaker at the opening in February of 2014 of Health City Cayman Islands, where one hour away from Miami, you can get quality surgery that outperforms the Cleveland Clinic or the Mayo Clinic at a price that is a fraction of the cost. So things like that are happening as well.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor. In today's market, you need a competitive edge, and HR 360 delivers with their special program for brokers called the 750 solution, loaded with every major compliance tool your clients need, and it's great for prospecting too. HR360's all-in-one program includes 750 subscriptions to HR 360's attorney-reviewed online HR library that acts like an HR department for your clients, so you can provide a subscription to all your clients and prospects. You'll keep your clients current and compliant with ACA news alerts, checklists, and guides branded with your logo, in addition to customizable monthly benefits newsletters and a free emailing system to send those newsletters and ACA alerts. And best of all, this entire popular program, including all of the tools I just mentioned, is only $899 a year. That's a special 30% discount just for Shift Shapers listeners. You really have to try it to fully understand the value in these attorney-reviewed customizable compliance tools. For a free trial access to HR360's tools, just click on the sponsor link at ShiftShapersOnline.com or email sales at hr360.com and mention Shift Shapers to take advantage of that special 30% discount. You say that volume drives prices, but that's really part of a big part of Dr. Shetty's story is that volume also drives expertise and technique and therefore drives outcome. It isn't just that he's delivering a lower price point. All of the metrics by which we measure quality and outcomes in surgical, whether it's length of stay, post-surgical infection rate, any of those others, are terrific numbers in his practice, aren't they?
SPEAKER_01They are. He has a, as I wrote in my book, and this was data from say 2010, but I, you know, we wrote the book in 2011, he has a lower mortality rate than the Cleveland Clinic, which is regarded as the number one cardio center in the United States. And a friend of mine, who is his partner in Health City, he would not reveal the name. He said he was sitting there, and Dr. Shetty was talking with one of the top heart surgeons in the United States. And the U.S. surgeon said, So what does your post-operative care look like? And accordingly to my friend, Dr. Shetty had a total puzzled look on his face. He says, I don't understand. And the American doctor said, Well, you know, after the surgery, how many times do you haven't come back? You know, all billable visits, right? And he said, We don't let them leave after the surgery until we know that they're fine. We have no post-operative care. The care isn't doing the surgery right.
DavidIsn't that amazing?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. How simple is that? You know, it's like you get your oil, the 30,000 mile on the car, and they say, well, come back in a thousand miles and we'll check and see if we did it right.
DavidAbsolutely. Absolutely. I mean, there are loads of things to talk about. One of the things I want to touch on in the five minutes or so that we have left is a concept you talk about that I don't think is really familiar to a lot of our listeners yet. I mean, I our listeners are familiar with ACOs, but you spend a decent amount of time in the book talking about something called EACOs. Can you talk about those and explain what they are and why you think they're going to be significant?
SPEAKER_01Thank you for that question. It's something that has not come up much since we wrote the book. EACO is, everybody knows, if you know what an ACO is, an E is just an employer EACO. So if you're an employer with a lot of employees, you have a critical mass to negotiate better coverage from a network of doctors. And it doesn't just have to be in one area. Boeing has tested this out in Washington with great success. They've driven down their cost by 20% a year or something like that, the first three years they did it, because they went into the marketplace and they said, okay, so we've got 50,000 employees. What are you going to do? And you can scale that up using Boeing or McDonald's or Starbucks or anything. You can go, we're going to create a national network and you can participate, but here's the deal. And that's where the scale drives down. So I don't think it will work with smaller companies as well, because they won't have the scale, but they can certainly do that. And then the other thing that happens is that the information sits with the company. So the company can see what works. And the company can also learn more about its workforce. If you're on the factory floor, you have different health issues than if you're in the corner office. And therefore, you can customize internally what the healthcare coverage should be based on the unique needs of your workforce. So I think that's going to be something that large companies are going to embrace because they're going to realize that it serves them, it serves the health and well-being of their employees and their bottom line. And there were a number of medium, you know, 10 million to 500 million size companies of CEOs who said, well, you know, I'll just pay the penalty and let them, you know, get healthcare on their own. And I pointed out to them very aggressively that that sends the wrong message. Now that we have more of a competitive hiring workplace, there's companies that will say, oh, well, you're on your own in terms of healthcare. And then there's another company that they go say, oh, we're really concerned about your well-being. We have this good EACO for you, and we want to make you healthy. Where do you want to work? For a company that doesn't care about your health or a company that cares about your health?
DavidSure. One of the things that that's been in the news an awful lot, both on the pro and the con side, especially in in Texas recently, is telehealth. But telehealth has the opportunity to be really transformative, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_01It absolutely does. My wife is a relationship therapist. So what she wants to do, if she has a couple that's coming into her office, meet them the first time, or one part of a couple, then she's totally happy to Skype with them because you see the facial expressions, you hear the emotion coming up. Unfortunately, uh, you know, the healthcare profession is so far behind on that. They're just the healthcare profession, other than the technological innovations that cost tens of millions of dollars for this robotic surgical thing or something, is terribly behind in the way that we would expect it. You and I are doing this interview over Skype, and I get a sense of you, and you get a sense of me. That would work with a lot of healthcare. For example, the example I give is you wake up, you're real sick, you can't get out of bed, you're not sure what it is, you call the doctor, the person says, Oh, she's really busy, and maybe she'll fit you in. So you get dressed, you don't know if you're infectious, you drive down, you look at old magazines, you may get picked up a disease, she asks you if you're allergic to something. No, she writes your prescription. Telehealth, you dial in, don't even need to speak to a doctor, just an empathetic healthcare practitioner who says, What are your symptoms? Oh, your symptoms are this. Well, last year 175,000 people in the United States had these symptoms, and two-thirds of them are treated with this medicine. Are you allergic to it? No, fine. Okay, we just placed the order and it will be delivered to your house. Telehealth will totally lower costs and increase efficiency of healthcare.
DavidYou know, David, we in the minute or two that we have left, we always like to ask our guests what they see about the future, and of course, that's all we've talked about. So let me let me reframe the question a little bit for you. Who's going to be responsible for driving the future here?
SPEAKER_01It's the individual. It's the what is currently being called the patient. We're moving from cure to prevention. So I say to anybody who's any age, but certainly if you're over 40, stay in great shape because in the next 10 years, and certainly by 2025, there will be medical miracles that will literally add decades onto your life. So we're by 2020, we don't, we're not going to call it health care, we're going to call it health management. So it is up to the individual to manage their health, to manage how long they want to live. And I truly believe that the generations, probably starting with the millennials, will have the opportunity to manage their lifespan to increase it beyond 120 years. And that's where we're going. We're going to an incredibly lengthening, healthier lives for those that want to take it on themselves to be responsible for it.
DavidA great positive note to end our time together. David, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience today.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's my pleasure to talk to anybody that has shifted the name. And David, you're really smart in this stuff. And I hope that uh your listeners enjoy this and thank you very much for having me.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you, to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Shift Shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the Ship Shapers to work in your business.